How do principals’ practices reflect democratic leadership for inclusion in diverse school settings? A Hong Kong case study

Abstract

Research on principals’ practice of democratic leadership for inclusion in schools has been undertaken in many parts of the world. This paper explores four principals’ leadership journeys in response to social justice issues in increasingly diverse settings within public schools, in relation to demographic and cultural changes in Hong Kong. This research aims at exploring the issues in schools arising from contextual changes in the society, contextualising characteristics of principals’ practices in relation to an emergent conception of democratic leadership practice in addressing the issues and identifying practical roles of democratic principal leadership in school transformation for diverse students’ learning development. I adopted a cross-case study of the principals’ leadership journeys through a theoretical lens of democratic leadership. The changes of demographic structure and cultural context and pressure from the central administration were the conditions of facilitating alternative practices of democratic principal leadership in a multicultural school context which evolved from the hybrid of Western and Confucian cultures in the city. These findings contribute to an international account of contextualising democratic leadership practices in a diverse Chinese school community.

Keywords

Chinese principals democratic leadership practice inclusion for social justice leadership problems multicultural contexts uncontrollable forces

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abowitz

(2019) The school principal as democratic leader: a critique of the Wallace foundation’s vision of the principalship. International Journal of Leadership in Education, 1–7. EPub ahead of print 3 July. DOI: 10.1080/13603124.2019.1637545.

Angelle

Beycioglu

Cheng

AYN

Kerry

Kondakci

Roberts

Potter

Szeto

Sun

Woods

(2017) Democratic leadership practices in the enactment of social justice in schools: cases from four countries. Paper presented at UCEA Annual Meeting 2017, Denver, USA.

Berkovich

(2014) A socio-ecological framework of social justice leadership in education. Journal of Educational Administration 52(3): 282–309.

CDC (2001) Learning to Learn: The way Forward in Curriculum Development. HKSAR, China: Curriculum Development Council.

Census and Statistics Department (2017) Hong Kong population estimates. Available at: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/so150.jsp (accessed 11 March 2018).

Chee

(2018) Opportunities, challenges, and transitions: educational aspirations of Pakistani migrant youth in Hong Kong. Children’s Geographies 16(1): 92–104.

Cheng

AYN

Szeto

(2019) Changing Hong Kong university students’ national identity through studying broad. Asian Education and Development Studies 8(2): 233–247.

Cheung

FCH

Kwok

DWH

(2019) Supporting Students With Special Educational Needs Policy Recommendations, 3rd draft. LC Paper No. CB(4)810/18-19(04). Hong Kong SAR: The Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.

Cohen

(1960) A coefficient of agreement for nominal scales. Educational and Psychological Measurement 20(1): 37–46.

10.

Corbin

Strauss

(2015) Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. Thousand Oaks: Sage.

11.

Creswell

(2012) Educational Research: Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating Quantitative and Qualitative Research. Boston: Pearson.

12.

Cribb

Gewirtz

(2003) Towards a sociology of just practices: an analysis of plural conceptions of justice. In: Vincent

(ed) Social Justice Education and Identity. London: RoutledgeFalmer, pp. 15–29.

13.

Dewey

(1997) Democracy and Education. New York: The Free Press.

14.

EDB (Education Bureau) (2017) For Discussion on Legislative Council Panel on Education: Priority Measures to Support Quality Education. Hong Kong SAR: The Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.

15.

EDB (2015) Medium of instruction. www.edb.gov.hk/en/edu-system/primary-secondary/applicable-to-secondary/moi/index.html (accessed 27 September 2015).

16.

EDB (2008) Operation Guide on the Whole School Approach to Integrated Education, 1st ed. Hong Kong SAR: The Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.

17.

Education Commission (2000) Reform Proposal for the Education System in Hong Kong. HKSAR, China: The Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.

18.

Furman

Shields

(2008) How can educational leaders promote and support social justice and democratic community in schools? In: Firestone

Riehl

(eds) A new Agenda for Research in Educational Leadership. Charlotte: Information Age Publishing, pp. 119–137.

19.

Gross

(2008) (Re-)Constructing a movement for social justice in our profession. In: Normore

(Ed.), Leadership for Social Justice: Promoting Equity and Excellence Through Inquiry and Reflective Practice. Charlotte: Information Age Publishing, pp. 257–266.

20.

Harris

Chapman

(2002) Democratic leadership for school improvement in challenging contexts. International Electronic Journal for Leadership in Learning 6(9): 1–13.

21.

HKEJ (2019) Editorial: government must take mounting grievances in society seriously. Hong Kong Economic Journal Available at: https://www2.hkej.com/landing/index (accessed 3 Jun 2019).

22.

Jean-Marie

Normore

Brooks

(2009) Leadership for social justice: preparing 21st century school leaders for a new social order. Journal of Research on Leadership Education 4(1): 1–31.

23.

Katyal

King

(2011) “Outsiderness” and “insiderness” in a Confucian society: Complexity of contexts. Comparative Education 47(3): 327–341.

24.

Kwan

BYM

(2015) Empowerment or impediment? School governance in the school-based management era in Hong Kong. Asia Pacific Journal of Education 35(3): 319–330.

25.

LCPoE (2014) Report of Subcommittee on Integrated Education. LC Paper No. CB(4)1087/13-14(01).

26.

Liu

Feng

(2015) How culture matters in educational borrowing? Chinese teachers’ dilemmas in a global era. Cogent Engineering 2(1): 1–24.

27.

Lugg

Shoho

(2006) Dare public school administrators build a new social order? Social justice and the possibly perilous politics of educational leadership. Journal of Educational Administration 44(3): 196–208.

28.

MacBeath

(2014) Report of the Impact Study on the Implementation of the 2nd Cycle of the School Development and Accountability Framework on Enhancing School Development in Hong Kong. HKSAR, China: Quality Assurance, Education Bureau.

29.

Marri

(2003) Multicultural democracy. Intercultural Education 14(3): 263–277.

30.

McMahon

(2007) Educational administrators’ conceptions of whiteness, anti-racism and social justice. Journal of Educational Administration 45(6): 684–696.

31.

Mahony

Moos

(1998) Democracy and school leadership in England and Denmark. British Journal of Educational Studies 46(3): 302–317.

32.

Marshall

(2004) Social justice challenges to educational administration: introduction to a special issue. Educational Administration Quarterly 40(1): 3–13.

33.

Muna

Zennie

(2011) Developing Multicultural Leaders: the Journey to Leadership Success. London: Palgrave and Macmillan.

34.

Postiglione

(2017) Education, Ethnicity, Society and Global Change in Asia: The Selected Works of Gerard A. Postiglione. London: Routledge.

35.

Riehl

(2000) The principal’s role in creating inclusive schools for diverse students: a review of normative, empirical, and critical literature on the practice of educational administration. Review of Educational Research 70(1): 55–81.

36.

Riley

(2003) ‘Democratic leadership’ – a contradiction in terms? Leadership and Policy in Schools 2(2): 125–139.

37.

RTHK (2019) Clashes spread to different Hong Kong universities. Available at: https://news.rthk/en/component/k2/1491306-20191111.htm (accessed 4 December 2019).

38.

Seashore Louis

(2003) Democratic schools, democratic communities: reflections in an international context. Leadership and Policy in Schools 2: 93–108.

39.

Sinn

(2008) Lesson in openness: creating a space of flow in Hong Kong. In: Siu

(eds) Hong Kong Mobile: Making a Global Population. Hong Kong, China: Hong Kong University Press, pp. 13–44.

40.

Spangler

(2016) Chinese education models in a global age: myth or reality? In: Chou

Spangler

(eds) Chinese Education Models in a Global Age, Vol. 31. Singapore: Springer, pp. 337–354.

41.

Steiner-Khamsi

(2014) Cross-national policy borrowing: understanding reception and translation. Asia Pacific Journal of Education 34(2): 153–167.

42.

Stokes

(2002) Democracy and citizenship. In: Carter

Stokes

(eds) Democratic Theory Today. Cambridge: Polity Press.

43.

Szeto

(2017) Equal educational opportunity? Global policy development and local practices in diverse school contexts. Hong Kong Journal of Special Education 18: 1–13.

44.

Szeto

(2019) School leadership in the reforms of the Hong Kong education system: insights into school-based development in policy borrowing and indigenising. School Leadership & Management, 1–22. EPub ahead of print 21 May. DOI: 10.1080/13632434.2019.1616172.

45.

Szeto

Cheng

AYN

(2018) How do principals practise leadership for social justice in diverse school settings? A Hong Kong case study. Journal of Educational Administration 56(1): 50–68.

46.

Szeto

Cheng

AYN

Sin

KKF

(2019) Challenges of difference and difficulty: how do principals enact different leadership for diverse student population in a changing Chinese school context? International Journal of Leadership in Education 22(5): 519–535.

47.

Tan

Chua

CSK

(2015) Education policy borrowing in China: has the west wind overpowered the east wind? Compare 45: 686–704.

48.

Taysum

Gunter

(2008) A critical approach to researching social justice and school leadership in England. Education, Citizenship and Social Justice 3(2): 183–199.

49.

The Financial Times (2019) Hong Kong police under fire after ‘triads’ beat protesters. The Financial Times. Available at: https://www.ft.com/content/0a497d3c-ac2e-11e9-8030-530adfa879c2 (accessed 22 July 2019).

50.

The Guardian (2019) Hong Kong police claim university has become ‘refuge for criminals’. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/nov/13/ (accessed 4 December 2019).

51.

The Guardian (2019). ‘Where were the police?’ Hong Kong outcry after masked thugs launch attack. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/22/ (accessed 22 July 2019).

52.

Theoharis

(2007) Social justice educational leaders and resistance: toward a theory of social justice leadership. Educational Administration Quarterly 43(2): 221–258.

53.

Vedøy

Møller

(2007) Successful school leadership for diversity? Examining two contrasting examples of working for democracy in Norway. International Studies of Educational Administration 35(3): 58–66.

54.

Ward

Bagley

Lumby

Woods

Hamilton

Roberts

(2015) School leadership for equity: lessons from the literature. International Journal of Inclusive Education 19(4): 333–346.

55.

Winton

(2010) Character development and critical democratic education in Ontario, Canada. Leadership and Policy in Schools 9(2): 220–237.

56.

Woods

(2004) Democratic leadership: drawing distinctions with distributed leadership. International Journal of Leadership in Education 7(1): 3–26.

57.

Woods

(2005) Democratic Leadership in Education. London: Paul Chapman Publishing.

58.

Woods

Gronn

(2009) Nurturing democracy: the contribution of distributed leadership to a democratic organizational landscape. Educational Management Administration & Leadership 37(4): 430–415.

59.

Woods

(2013) Deepening distributed leadership: a democratic perspective on power, purpose, and the concept of the self. Vodenjev Vzgoji in Izobraževanju (Leadership in Education) 2: 17–39.

60.

Yin

(2014) Case Study Research: Design and Methods, 5 ed. Los Angeles: SAGE.