Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Acting in the best interests of students is central to the moral and ethical work of schools. Yet tensions can arise between principals and school counsellors as they work from at times opposing professional paradigms. In this article we report on principals’ and counsellors’ responses to scenarios covering confidentiality and the law, student/teacher relationships, student welfare and psychological testing of students. This discussion takes place against an examination of ethics, ethical dilemmas and professional codes of ethics. While there were a number of commonalities among principals and school counsellors that arose from their common belief in education as a moral venture, there were also some key differences among them. These differences centred on the principals’ focus on the school as a whole and counsellors’ focus on the welfare of the individual student. A series of recommendations is offered to assist principals to navigate ethical dilemmas such as those considered in this article.

Keywords

Ethical dilemma school principals school counsellors

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aronson

(1994) A pragmatic view of thematic analysis. The Qualitative Report 2(1). Available at: http://www.nova.edu/ssss/QR/BackIssues/QR2-1/aronson.html.

Association of American Educators (n.d.) AAE code of ethics for educators. Available at: http://aaeteachers.org/images/pdfs/aaecodeofethicsforeducators.pdf (accessed 16 December 2011).

Australian Psychological Society (2007) Code of ethics. Available at: http://www.psychology.org.au/Assets/Files/Code_Ethics_2007.pdf (accessed 16 December 2011).

Berg

(2009) Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences. 7th edn. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.

Bodenhorn

(2006) Exploratory study of common and challenging ethical dilemmas experienced by professional school counsellors. Professional School Counseling 10(2): 195–202.

Bond

(2000) Standards and Ethics for Counselling in Action. London: Sage.

British Psychological Society (2009) Code of ethics and conduct. Available at: http://www.bps.org.uk/sites/default/files/documents/code_of_ethics_and_conduct.pdf (accessed 16 December 2011).

Bruhn

(2009) The functionality of gray area ethics in organizations. Journal of Business Ethics 89(2): 205–214.

Campbell

(1997) Administrators’ decisions and teachers’ ethical dilemmas: Implications for moral agency. Leading and Managing 3(4): 245–257.

10.

Campbell

(2001) Let right be done: Trying to put ethical standards into practice. Journal of Educational Policy 16(5): 395–411.

11.

Campbell

(2003) Let right be done: Trying to put ethical standards into practice. In: Begley

Johansson

(eds) The Ethical Dimensions of School Leadership. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp.107–125.

12.

Campbell

(2004) What to do? An exploration of ethical issues for principals and school counsellors. Principia: Journal of the Queensland Secondary Principals’ Association 1: 7–9.

13.

Campbell

(2010) Justice, humanity and prudence. In: Boston

Bradstock

Eng

(eds) Public Policy: Why Ethics Matters. Canberra: ANU E-Press, pp.21–36.

14.

Christenbury

(2008) A consideration of the ethics of teaching English. English Journal 97(6): 32–38.

15.

Collins

Knowles

(1995) Adolescents’ attitudes towards confidentiality between the school counsellor and the adolescent client. Australian Psychologist 30(3): 179–182.

16.

Cranston

Ehrich

Kimber

(2006) Ethical dilemmas: The ‘bread and butter’ of educational leaders lives. Journal of Educational Administration 44(2): 106–121.

17.

Davis

Mickelson

(1994) School counsellors: Are you aware of ethical and legal aspects of counselling? The School Counsellor 42(1): 5–12.

18.

Day

Harris

Hadfield

(1999) Leading schools in times of change. In: European conference on educational research, Lahti, 22–25 September 1999.

19.

Dempster

Berry

(2003) Blindfolded in a minefield: Ethical decision-making. Cambridge Journal of Education 33(3): 457–477.

20.

Duignan

Collins

(2003) Leadership challenges and ethical dilemmas in front line organisations. In: Bennett

Crawford

Cartwright

(eds) Effective Educational Leadership. London: Open University, pp.281–294.

21.

Duignan

Burford

Collins

. (2003) Contemporary Challenges and Implications for Leaders in Frontline Human Service Organisations. Brisbane: Australian Catholic University.

22.

Ehrich

Kimber

Millwater

. (2011) Ethical dilemmas: A model to understand teacher practice. Teachers and Teaching 17(2): 173–185.

23.

Eyal

Berkovich

Schwartz

(2010) Making the right choices: Ethical judgments among educational leaders. Journal of Educational Administration 49(4): 396–413.

24.

Fook

(2002) Theorizing from practice: Towards an inclusive approach for social work research. Journal of Qualitative Social Work 1(1): 79–95. doi: 10.1177/147332500200100106.

25.

Francis

Armstrong

(2003) Ethics as a risk management strategy: The Australian experience. Journal of Business Ethics 45(4): 375–385.

26.

Gilman

Gabriel

(2004) Perceptions of school psychological services by education professionals: Results from a multi-state survey pilot study. School Psychology Review 33(2): 271–286.

27.

Isaacs

Stone

(1999) School counsellors and confidentiality: Factors affecting professional choices. Professional School Counselling 2(4): 258–268.

28.

Jacob-Timm

(1999) Ethically challenging situations encountered by school psychologists. Psychology in the Schools 36(3): 205–217.

29.

Kakabadse

Korac-Kakabadse

Kouzmin

(2003) Ethics, values and behaviours: Comparison of three case studies examining the paucity of leadership in government. Public Administration 81(3): 477–508.

30.

Kane

Patapan

(2006) In search of prudence: The hidden problem of managerial reform. Public Administration Review 66(5): 711–724.

31.

Kaplan

(1995) Principals versus counselors: Resolving tensions between different practice models. School Counselor 42(4): 261–268.

32.

Kidder

(1995) How Good People Make Tough Choices: Resolving the Dilemmas of Ethical Living. New York: William Morrow.

33.

Kimber

Carrington

Mercer

Bland

(2011) Enhancing professional ethics: Service-learning in teacher education. In: Millwater

Ehrich

Beutel

(eds) Practical Experiences in Professional Education: A Transdisciplinary Approach. Brisbane: Post Pressed, pp. 115–134.

34.

Kirchner

Setchfield

(2005) School counselors’ and school principals’ perceptions of the school counselor’s role. Education 126(1): 10–16.

35.

Langlois

Lapointe

(2007) Ethical leadership in Canadian school organizations: Tensions and possibilities. Educational Management Administration and Leadership 32(5): 247–260.

36.

Lehr

Sumarch

(2007) Confidentiality and informed consent: School counsellors’ perceptions of ethical practices. Canadian Journal of Counselling 41(1): 16–30.

37.

Lindsey

Kalafat

(1998) Adolescents’ views of preferred helper characteristics and barriers to seeking help from school-based adults. Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation 9(2): 171–193.

38.

Lyons

(1990) Dilemmas of knowing: Ethical and epistemological dimensions of teacher’s work and development. Harvard Educational Review 60(2): 159–181.

39.

Maksić

Pavlović

(2011) Educational researchers’ personal explicit theories on creativity and its development: A qualitative study. High Ability Studies 22(2): 219–231.

40.

Mayer

(1986) A fall into the rabbit hole: The dual roles of English teacher/guidance counselor. The English Journal 75(1): 40–41.

41.

Minichiello

Aroni

Timewell

. (1990) In-Depth Interviewing: Researching People. Melbourne: Longman Cheshire.

42.

Mitchell

Disque

Robertson

(2002) When parents want to know: Responding to parental demands for confidential information. Professional School Counseling 6(2): 156–162.

43.

Moleski

Kiselica

(2005) Dual relationships: A continuum ranging from the destructive to the therapeutic. Journal of Counseling and Development 83(1): 3–11.

44.

New Zealand Teachers Council (n.d.) Registered teachers code of ethics. Available at: http://www.teacherscouncil.govt.nz/required/ethics/codeofethics.stm (accessed 16 December 2011).

45.

Norburg

Johansson

(2007) Ethical dilemmas of Swedish school leaders: Contrasts and common themes. Educational Management Administration and Leadership 35(2): 277–294.

46.

Queensland College of Teachers (2008) Code of ethics for teachers in Queensland. Available at: http://www.qct.edu.au/PDF/PCU/CodeOfEthicsPoster20081215.pdf (accessed 16 December 2011).

47.

Queensland Department of Education and Training (2005) Inclusive Education Statement. Brisbane: Queensland Department of Education and Training.

48.

Queensland Guidance and Counselling Association (QGCA) (2000) Code of ethics. Brisbane: Queensland Guidance and Counselling Association.

49.

Queensland Parliament (1994) Public Sector Ethics Act 1994. Brisbane: Queensland Parliament.

50.

Reid

(1996) School Counselling: A Client Centred Perspective. Red Hill, Brisbane: Kids Help Line.

51.

Stake

(2006) Multiple Case Study Analysis. New York: The Guilford Press.

52.

Stake

(2010) Qualitative Research: Studying How Things Work. New York: The Guilford Press.

53.

Starratt

(1996) Transforming Educational Administration: Meaning, Community and Excellence. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

54.

Starratt

(2003) Democratic leadership theory in late modernity: An oxymoron or ironic possibility? In: Begley

Johansson

(eds) The Ethical Dimensions of School Leadership. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp.13–31.

55.

Stefkovich

Begley

(2007) Ethical school leadership: Defining the best interests of students. Journal of Educational Administration 35(2): 205–224.

56.

Stefkovich

Poliner Shapiro

(2003) Deconstructing communities: Educational leaders and their ethical decision-making. In: Begley

Johansson

(eds) The Ethical Dimensions of School Leadership. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp.89–106.

57.

Stolle

(2001) Ethical and legal dimensions of counselling in schools. In: Flach

(ed.) Ethical Issues in Professional Counselling. Eric Document Reproduction Service No. ED 464293, pp.56–68.

58.

Strike

(2003) Community, coherence, and inclusiveness. In: Begley

Johansson

(eds) The Ethical Dimensions of School Leadership. Dorderect: Kleuwer Academic Publishers, pp.69–87.

59.

Sumsion

(2000) Caring and empowerment: A teacher educator’s reflection on an ethical dilemma. Teaching in Higher Education 5(2): 167–179.

60.

Taylor

Adelman

(1998) Confidentiality: Competing principles, inevitable dilemmas. Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation 9(3): 267–275.

61.

Thielking

Jimerson

(2006) Perspectives regarding the role of school psychologists: Perceptions of teachers, principals, and school psychologists in Victoria, Australia. Australian Journal of Guidance and Counselling 16(2): 211–223.

62.

Tirri

(1999) Teacher’s perceptions of moral dilemmas at school. Journal of Moral Education 28: 31–41.

63.

Uhr

(2005) Terms of Trust: Arguments Over Ethics in Australian Government. Sydney: UNSW Press.

64.

Uhr

(2010) Be careful what you wish for. In: Boston

Bradstock

Eng

(eds) Public Policy: Why Ethics Matters. Canberra: ANU E-Press, pp.79–100.

65.

Voskuijl

Evers

(2007) Tension between the prescriptive and descriptive ethics of psychologists. Journal of Business Ethics 72(3): 279–291.

66.

Yin

(2009) Case Study Research: Design and Methods. 4th edn. Thousand Oaks California: Sage.

Exploring ethical dilemmas for principals arising from role conflict with school counsellors

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References