In the face of globalization, states around the world have tried to regain legitimacy by using a policy framework known as new public management (NPM). In education, it promises to improve quality and competitiveness, by means of increasing control over educational institutions, implementing managerial techniques and submitting educational institutions to increased competitiveness. This article presents evidence from an exploratory study comparing senior college administrators' attitudes in the Canadian province of British Columbia and those of vocational school administrators in two German subjurisdictions toward NPM. Questions addressed include: (1) how NPM-related measures were perceived by those administrators; and (2) how differences in the way reform discourses are framed in the different subjurisdictions impact the administrators' attitudes towards NPM. Findings show that the level of agreement on different aspects of NPM was comparatively similar across countries and subjurisdictions. Correlational analysis, however, revealed differences between the administrators' semantic constructions of the reform policy. Interpretive analysis indicated that semantic constructions were linked to the varying policy discourses of the subjurisdictions. The article concludes that discourse is an important aspect when introducing NPM in educational institutions, since it lays the groundwork for the conceptualization of future policy discourses.
Ball, S. (1998) `Big Policies/Small World: An Introduction to International Perspectives in Education Policy', Comparative Education34(2): 119—30.
2.
Bortz, J. (1989) Statistik für Sozialwissenschaftler, 2nd edn. Berlin: Springer .
3.
Bottery, M. and Barnett, R. (1996) `The Challenge of Professionals from the New Public Management: Implications for the Teaching Profession', Oxford Review of Education22(2). (Electronic resource, Academic Search Elite).
4.
Chandler, J.A. (2000) `Introduction', in J.A. Chandler (ed.) Comparative Public Administration, pp. 1—13. London: Routledge.
5.
College Institute Educators' Association of BC (CIEA) (2004) `Dismantling and Deregulating: The BC Liberal Record on Post-Secondary Education (April 2004)'. Available at: http://www.ciea.bc.ca/resources/librecord0404.pdf. Accessed 10 August 2004.
6.
Confederation of University Faculty Associations of British Columbia (CUFA BC) (2003) `Knowledge and Opportunity: The Role of BC's Public Post-Secondary Institutions'. Submission to the Ministry of Advanced Education in Response to the `Mandates, Roles and Responsibilities', Working Paper, Vancouver, 22 September.
7.
Deem, R. (1998) `“New Managerialism” and Higher Education: The Management of Performance and Culture in Universities in the United Kingdom', International Studies in theSociology of Education8(1): 47—69.
8.
Deissinger, Thomas (1994) `The Evolution of the Modern Vocational Training Systems in England and Germany: A Comparative View, Compare', Journal of Comparative Education24(1): 17—36.
9.
Deissinger, T. (2002) `Different Approaches to Lifelong Learning in Britain and Germany: A Comparative View with Regard to Qualifications and Certification Frameworks', in K. Harney, A. Heikkinen, S. Rahn and M. Scheman (eds) Lifelong Learning: One Focus, Different Systems, pp. 183—94. Frankfurt AM: Peter Lang.
10.
Deissinger, T. (2004). `Apprenticeship Cultures—A Comparative View ', in S. Roodhouse and D. Hemsworth (eds) Apprenticeship: A Historical Re-Invention for a Post Industrial World, pp. 43—58. Bolton, MA: University Vocational Awards Council.
11.
Dempster, N., Freakley, M. and Parry, L. (2001) `The Ethical Climate of Public Schooling under NPM', International Journal of Leadership in Education4(1): 1—12.
12.
Education Server for the State of Schleswig-Holstein (2002) `Konzeptstudie zur Weiterentwicklung der beruflichen Schulen zu Berufsbildungszentren'. Available at: http://www.lernnetz-sh.de/rbz/docs/Konzeptstudie.doc. Accessed 2 October 2002.
13.
Erdsiek-Rave, Ute (2002) `Berufliche Schulen als eigenständige regionale Berufsbildungszentren' in Federation-States Commission on Educational Planning and Research Funding (BLK) (ed.) Kompetenzzentren.Kompetenzzentren in regionalen Berufsbildungsnetzwerken—Rolle und Beitrag der beruflichen Schulen. BLK-Fachtagung, 3/4 December, 2001, Lübeck, pp. 14—21. Bonn: BLK.
14.
Federal Ministry of Education and Research ( 2005) Berufsbildungsbericht 2005. Bonn: BMBF.
15.
Federation-StatesCommissiononEducationalPlanningandResearchFunding(BLK), ed. (2002) Kompetenzzentren. Kompetenzzentren in regionalen Berufsbildungsnetzwerken—Rolle und Beitrag der beruflichen Schulen. BLK-Fachtagung, 3/4 December 2001, Lübeck. Bonn : BLK.
16.
Fishbein, M. and Ajzen, I. (1975) Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior: an Introduction to Theory and Research. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
17.
Hood, C. (1996) `Exploring Variations in Public Management Reform ', in H.A.G.M. Bekke, J.L. Perry and T.A.J. Toonen (eds) Civil Service Systems in Comparative Perspective , pp. 268—87. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
18.
Hubert, L. and Baker, F.B. (1977) `The Comparison and Fitting of Given Classification Schemes', Journal of MathematicalPsychology16(2): 233—53.
19.
Jaccard, J. and Wan, C.K. (1996) LISREL Approaches to Interaction Effects in Multiple Regression. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
20.
Johannesson, I.A., Lindblad, S. and Simola, H. (2002) `An Inevitable Progress? Educational Restructuring in Finland, Iceland and Sweden at the Turn of the Millennium', Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research46(3): 325—39.
21.
König, K. (1997) `Entrepreneurial Management or Executive Administration: The Perspective of Classical Administration', in W.J.M. Kickert (ed.) Public Management and Administrative Reform in Western Europe, pp. 217—36. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
22.
Kreysing, M. (2002) `Autonomy, Accountability, and Organizational Complexity in Higher Education: the Goettingen Model of University Reform', Journal of Educational Administration40(6): 552—60.
23.
Kurz, S. (2003) `Developing Vocational Schools into Regional Vocational Training Centers', in ITB (ed.) ITB Info (No. 1, Sept 2003 ), p. 5. Bremen: ITB.
Levin, J.S. (1999) `Missions and Structures: Bringing Clarity to Perceptions about Higher Education in Canada', Higher Education37(4): 377—99.
27.
Levin, J.S. (2001) `Public Policy, Community Colleges, and the Path to Globalization', Higher Education42(2): 237—62.
28.
Lower Saxon Ministry of Culture (2002) `Schulversuch Berufsbildende Schulen in Niedersachsen als regionale Kompetenzzentren'. Project description, June 2002. Available at: http://www.mk.niedersachsen.de/functions/downloadObject/0,,c682860_s20,00.pdf. Accessed 24 November 2002.
29.
Macpherson, R.J.S. (1996) Educative Accountability: Theory, Practice, Policy and Research in Educational Administration. Oxford: Pergamon.
30.
Ministry of Advanced Education (MAVED) (2003 a) `An Accountability Framework for British Columbia's Public Post-Secondary Education System'. Victoria: Ministry of Advanced Education. Available at: http://www.aved.gov.bc.ca/accountability/policy_paper.pdf. Accessed 10 August 2004.
31.
Ministry of Advanced Education (MAVED) (2003 b) `Annual Service Plan Report'. Victoria : Ministry of Advanced Education. Available at: http://www.bcbudget.gov.bc.ca/annualreports/aved/aved_performance_link1.htm . Accessed 10 August 2004.
32.
Ministry of Education, Science, Research and Culture of Schleswig-Holstein (2002) Enactment III 51, 23 September 2002.
33.
Oecd (1999) Manual for ISCED-97 Implementation in OECD countries. Paris: OECD.
34.
Osborne, D. and Plastrik, P. (1997) Banishing Bureaucracy. The Five Strategies for Reinventing Government. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
35.
Parliament of BC (2002) Degree Authorization Act (Bill 15—2002. 3rd Sess., 37th Parliament, 1 May 2002).
36.
Parliament of Lower Saxony (2001) Berufsbildende Schulen in Niedersachsen als regionale Kompetenzzentren (Landtagsdrucksache 14/2701, Parliamentary Resolution 17 September 2001).
37.
Samier, E. (2001) `Demandarinisation in the NPM: Examining Changing Administrative Authority from a Weberian Perspective', in E. Hanke and W.J. Mommsen (eds) Max Webers Herrschaftssoziologie, pp. 235—63. Tübingen: Mohr und Siebeck.
38.
Samier, E. (2002) `Managerial Rationalisation and the Ethical Disenchantment of Education', Journal of Educational Administration40(6): 589—603.
39.
Samier (forthcoming) `Leadership and the New Public Management: between Guru and the Market Model in Canadian Schools', in J. van Buer and C. Wagner (eds) Qualität von Schule—zwischen erweiterter Autonomie und kontrollierter Outputproduktion. Frankfurt : Peter Lang.
40.
Schlegel, Jürgen (2002) `Eröffnung der BLK-Fachtagung', in Federation-States Commission on Educational Planning and Research Funding (BLK) (ed.) Kompetenzzentren.Kompetenzzentren in regionalen Berufsbildungsnetzwerken—Rolle und Beitrag der beruflichen Schulen. BLK-Fachtagung, 3/4 December 2001, Lübeck, pp. 11—13. Bonn: BLK.
41.
Shacklock, G., Hattam, R. and Smyth, J. (2000) `Enterprise Education and Teachers' Work: Exploring the Links', Journal of Education and Work13(1): 41—60.
42.
Shain, F. and Gleeson, D. (1999) `Under New Management: Changing Conceptions of Teacher Professionalism and Policy in the Further Education Sector', Journal of Education Policy14(4): 445—62.
43.
Shore, C. and Wright, S. (1999) `Audit Culture and Anthropology: Neo-Liberalism in British Higher Education', Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute5(4): 557—75.
44.
Statistisches Bundesamt (2005) `Bildung und Kultur'. Berufliche Schulen. Schuljahr 2003/04. Series 11/Reihe 2. Wiesbaden: Statistisches Bundesamt .
45.
Stephan, W., Gruner, W. and Lauterbach, U. (2002) `Kanada', in: Lauterbach, U. (ed.) Internationales Handbuch der Berufsbildun: Loose-leaf Collection. Nomos: Baden-Baden .
46.
Stronach, I. (1993) `Education, Vocationalism and Economic Recovery: The Case Against Witchcraft', British Journal of Education and Work2(1): 5—31.
47.
Velleman, P.F. and Wilkinson, L. (1993) `Nominal, Ordinal Interval, and Ratio Typologies are Misleading', The American Statistician47(1): 65—72.
48.
Wittmann, E. (2003) `Leiten von Schule als Balanceakt zwischen alternativen Administrativen Philosophien? Zur Bedeutung des `New Public Managements' für die Implementation von Kompetenzzentren und Regionalen Berufsbildungszentren ', in J.v. Buer and O. Zlatkin-Troitschanskaia (eds) Berufliche Bildung auf dem Prüfstand: Entwicklung zwischen systemischer Steuerung, Transformation durch Modellversuche und unterrichtliche Innovation, pp. 343—73. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.
49.
Wright, N. (2003) `Principled `Bastard' Leadership? A Rejoinder to Gold, Evans, Earley, Halph and Colloborne', Educational Management and Administration31(2): 139—43.
