Managing chronic excuse-making behaviors of faculty can be difficult and challenging
for college administrators. In this article, Schlenker's responsibility triangle is
applied in the higher education forum to better understand the underpinnings of
responsibility and accountability in faculty jobs. Using this framework, attention
is given to strategies for preventing excuses from becoming a chronic and unwanted
behavior for faculty to use when justifying performance shortcomings.
ASHE-ERIC Higher Education Report
(2001) What Challenges to Deans Face?
28(1):
27—41
.
2.
Black, H.T.
and
Duhon, D.L.
(2003) `
Evaluating and Improving Student Achievement in Business Programs: The
Effective Use of Standardized Assessment Tests
', Journal of Education for Business79(2):
90—9
.
3.
Brem, R.
(2004) `
Excuses, Excuses: Students' Sad, Endless Stories'
, Chronicle of Higher Education50(23):
B15—16
.
4.
Brooks, S.
(1993) `
Shape Up or Ship Out'
, Restaurant Business92(2):
40—3
.
5.
Cote, J.E.
and
Levine, C.G.
(1992) `
The Genesis of the Humanistic Academic: A Second Test of Erikson's Theory
of Ego Identity Formation
', Youth and Society23(4):
387—410
.
6.
Dilts, D.A.
,
Haber, L.J.
and
Bialik, D.
(1994) Assessing What Professors Do: An Introduction to
Academic Performance Appraisal in Higher Education.
Westport, CN: Greenwood Press
.
7.
Feig, N.
(2005) `
Working Sick, or Playing Sick
?', Community Banker14(1):
50
.
8.
Graham, J.R.
(2003) `
The Dog Ate My Home-work'
, Industrial Distribution September:
59—62
.
9.
Hamilton, J.B.
,
Smith, M.
,
Heady, R.B.
and
Carson, P.P.
(1997) `
Using Open-ended Questions on Senior Exit Surveys to Evaluate and Improve
Faculty Performance: Results from a School of Business Administration',
Journal on Excellence
in College Teaching8(1):
23—48
.
10.
International Science, Technology, & Environmental Education Newsletter
(2004)
Investment in Education, Science & Technology: Economists' and Entrepreneurs
' Views29(3/4):
7—9
.
11.
Johnson, T.D.
(2000) `
A Comprehensive Approach to the Evaluation of College Teaching
', New Directions for Teaching and Learning83:
109—24
.
12.
Kerr, C.
(1994)
`Knowledge Ethics and the New Academic Culture'
, Change26:
8—16
.
13.
Latham, G.
and
Locke, E.
(1991) `Goal Setting: A Motivational Techniques That
Work' , in
R.M. Steers
and
L.W. Porter
(eds) Motivation and Work Behavior , pp.
357—69.
New York: McGraw-Hill
.
14.
Locke, E.A.
(1968) `
Toward a Theory of Task Motivation and Incentives
', Organization Behavior and Human Performance3:
157—89
.
15.
Marang, T.
(2001) `
We Had to Ask'
, The Wenatchee Business Journal February:
B—B2
.
16.
Miller, J.I.
(1967) `
A New Partnership: Business, Education, and Society
', Business Horizons10(1):
21—31
.
17.
Mottet, T.P.
,
Martin, M.M.
and
Myers, S.A.
(2004) `
Relationships among Perceived Instructor Verbal Approach and Avoidance
Relational Strategies and Students' Motives for Communicating with their Instructors
', Communication Education53(1):
116—22
.
18.
Pontari, B.A.
,
Schlenker, B.R.
and
Christopher, A.N.
(2002) `
Excuses and Character: Identifying the Problematic Aspects of Excuses
', Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology21(5):
497—516
.
19.
Rao, A.
,
Schmidt, S.M.
and
Murray, L.H.
(1995) `
Upward Impression Management: Goals, Influence Strategies, and Consequences
', Human Relations48(2):
147—69
.
20.
Rivkin, J.
(1993) `
Beyond the Prestige Economy of Graduate Education'
, Liberal Education79(2):
16—20
.
21.
Sandberg, J.
(2003) `
Why the Truth can be the Work Excuse for Taking a Day Off
. Wall Street Journal241(123):
B1
.
22.
Sanna, L.J.
and
Mark, M.M.
(1995) `
Self-handicapping, Expected Evaluation, and Performance: Accentuating the
Positive and Attenuating the Negative
', Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes645:
84—102
.
23.
Schlenker, B.R.
(1980) Impression Management: The Self Concept, Social
Identity, and Interpesonal Relations.
Monterey, CA: Brooks-Cole
.
24.
Schlenker, B.R.
(1997) `
Personal Responsibility: Applications of the Triangle Model
', Research in Organizational Behavior19:
241—301
.
25.
Schlenker, B.R.
,
Britt, T.W.
,
Pennington, J.W.
,
Murphy, R.
and
Doherty, K.J.
(1994) `
The Triangle Model of Responsibility'
, Psychological Review101:
632—52
.
26.
Schlenker, B.R.
,
Pontari, B.A.
and
Christopher, A.N.
(2001) `
Excuses and Character: Personal and Social Implications of Excuses
', Personality and Social Psychology5(1):
15—32
.
Scully, M.G.
(1984) `
US Colleges not Realizing their Full Potential
', Chronicle of Higher Education29(9):
1
,
34
.
29.
Segal, C.B.
(2000) `
The Dog Ate my Disk, and Other Tales of Woe
', Chronicle of Higher Education46(49):
A64
.
30.
Shelley-Sireci, L.M.
and
Leary, T.A.
(1996) `
Students' Identity Status and Mentorship from College Faculty'
. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Northwest
Educational Research Association, Ellenville, NY, 24
October 1996.
31.
Snyder, C.R.
and
Higgins, R.L.
(1988) `
Excuses: Their Effective Role in the Negotiation of Reality
', Psychological Bulletin104:
23—35
.
32.
Taylor, S.E.
and
Brown, J.D.
(1988) `
Illusion and Well-being: A Social Psychological Perspective on Mental Health'
, Psychological Bulletin103:
193—210
.
33.
Taylor, S.E.
and
Brown, J.D.
(1994) `
Positive Illusions and Well-being Revisited: Separating Fact from Fiction
', Psychological Bulletin116:
21—7
.
34.
Tobin, T.J.
(2004) `
Best Practices for Administrative Evaluation of Online Faculty', Online
Journal for Distance LearningAdministrationVII, II.
35.
Vrij, A.
,
Akehurst, L.
,
Soukara, S.
and
Bull, R.
(2004) `
Detecting Deceit via Analyses of Verbal and Nonverbal Behavior in Children
and Adults'
, Human Communication Research30(1):
34—41
.
36.
Vroom, V.
(1964) Work and Motivation.
New York : Wiley
.
