Case study data from six primary schools are drawn upon to examine the reality of
primary headteacher leadership. Three alternative theoretical models of leadership
are used to analyse the ways in which it has changed since the Education Reform Act
(1988) and the implications of these changes for leading teaching and learning.
Prior to 1988 primary headteachers as ‘educative leaders’ were
involved in teaching and direct working relations with children and classteachers.
However, in the current educational climate ‘educative
leadership’ appears unsustainable. Although ‘instructional
leadership’ is an effective model for achieving compliance with government
reforms and achieving a narrow standards agenda, it stifles teachers’
creativity and constrains school innovation. It is argued that
‘pedagogical leadership’, as exemplified by two headteachers in
the study, appears to offer much greater possibilities for developing teaching and
promoting both pupil and teacher learning. While the practice of
‘pedagogical leadership’ is viewed as conflicting with aspects
of ‘instructional leadership’, it has value congruence with
‘educative leadership’ and can therefore develop from it.
Alexander, R.
,
Rose, J.
and
Woodhead, C.
(1992) Curriculum Organisation and ClassroomPractice in Primary Schools: A Discussion Paper.
London: DES
.
2.
Bassey, M.
(1984) ‘Pedagogic Research: On the Relative
Merits of Search for Generalization and Study of Single
Events’, in
J. Bell
,
T. Bush
,
A. Fox
,
J. Goodey
and
S. Goulding
(eds) Conducting Small-Scale Investigations in Educational
Management, pp. 103–122.
London: Harper & Row
.
3.
Bell, L.
,
Bolam, R.
and
Cubillo, L.
(2003) A Systematic Review of the Impactof School
Headteachers and Principals on Student Outcomes, Review conducted bythe School
Leadership Review Group.
London: EPPI-Centre, University of London
.
4.
Broadfoot, P.
(2001) ‘Empowerment or Performativity?
Assessment Policy in the Late Twentieth Century’, in
R. Phillips
and
J. Furlong
(eds) Education, Reform and the State.
London: RoutledgeFalmer
.
5.
CACE
(1967) Children and their Primary Schools: A Report of the
Central Advisory Council for Education (England), vol. 1.
London: HMSO
.
6.
Chaplain, R.P.
(2001)
‘Stress and Job Satisfaction among Primary Headteachers: A
Question of Balance?’
, Educational Management & Administration29(2):
197–215
.
7.
Coulson, A.
(1985)
‘The Managerial Behaviour of Primary School Heads’
, CORE9:
2-2
.
8.
Day, C.
,
Harris, A.
,
Hadfield, M.
,
Tolley, H.
and
Beresford, J.
(2000) Leading Schools in Times of Change.
Buckingham: Open University Press
.
9.
DfEE
(2001) Learning and Teaching: A Strategy for Professional
Development.
London: DfEE
.
10.
DfES
(2003) Excellence and Enjoyment: A Strategy for Primary
Schools.
Nottingham: DfES Publications
.
11.
Duignan, P.A.
and
Macpherson, R.J.S.
, eds (1992) Educative Leadership: A Practical Theory for New
Administrators and Managers.
London: Falmer Press
.
12.
Fullan, M.
(1993) Change Forces Probing the Depths of Educational
Reform.
London: Falmer
.
13.
Fullan, M.
(2001) Leading in a Culture of Change.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
14.
Galton, M.
,
MacBeath, J.
,
Page, C.
and
Steward, S.
(2002) A Life in Teaching? The Impact of Change on Primary
Teachers’ Working Lives.
London: NUT
.
15.
Glaser, B.
and
Strauss, A.
(1967) The Discovery of Grounded Theory.
Chicago: Aldine
.
16.
Grace, G.
(1995) School Leadership: Beyond Education Management.
London: Falmer Press
.
17.
Hallinger, P.
(1992)
‘The Evolving Role of American Principals: From Managerial to
Instructional to Transformational Leaders’
, Journal of Educational Administration30(3):
35–48
.
18.
Hallinger, P.
and
Murphy, J.
(1985)
‘Assessing the Instructional Management Behaviour of Principals’
, Elementary School Journal86(2):
217–247
.
19.
Harris, A.
(2003a) ‘The Changing Context of Leadership:
Research, Theory and Practice’, in
A. Harris
,
C. Day
,
D. Hopkins
,
M. Hadfield
,
A. Hargreaves
and
C. ChapmanEffective Leadership for School Improvement, pp.
9–25.
London: Routledge Falmer
.
20.
Harris, A.
(2003b) ‘Teacher Leadership and School
Improvement’, in
A. Harris
,
C. Day
,
D. Hopkins
,
M. Hadfield
,
A. Hargreaves
and
C. ChapmanEffective Leadership for School Improvement, pp.
72–83.
London: Routledge Falmer
.
21.
Hayes, D.
(1995)
‘The Primary Heads’ Tale: Collaborative Relationships
in a Time of Rapid Change’
, Educational Management & Administration23(4):
233–244
.
22.
Hopkins, D.
(2003) ‘Instructional Leadership and School
Improvement’, in
A. Harris
,
C. Day
,
D. Hopkins
,
M. Hadfield
,
A. Hargreaves
and
C. ChapmanEffective Leadership for School Improvement, pp.
55–71.
London: Routledge Falmer
.
23.
Hughes, M.
(1988) ‘Leadership in Professionally Staffed
Organisations’, in
R. Glatter
,
M. Preedy
,
C. Riches
and
M. MastertonUnderstanding School Management.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
24.
Jones, N.
(1999)
‘The Changing Management Agenda for Primary Heads’
, International Journal of Public Sector Management12(4):
324–337
.
25.
Lawlor, H.
and
Sills, P.
(1999)
‘Successful Leadership – Evidence from Highly Effective Headteachers’
, Improving Schools2(2):
53–60
.
26.
Leithwood, K.
(1992)
‘The Move towards Transformational Leadership’
, Educational Leadership45(5):
8–12
.
27.
Leithwood, K.
,
Jantzi, D.
and
Seinbach, R.
(1999) Changing Leadership for Changing Times.
Buckingham: Open University Press
.
28.
MacBeath, J.
, ed. (1998) Effective School Leadership: Responding to
Change.
London: Paul Chapman
.
29.
Mortimore, P.
,
Sammons, P.
,
Stoll, L.
,
Lewis, D.
and
Ecob, R.
(1988) School Matters: The Junior Years.
Somerset: Open Books
.
30.
National College for School Leadership
(2003) Sustaining Improvement in the Primary School:
Leadership Programme for Primary School Leaders.
Nottingham: NCSL
.
31.
Ofsted
(1994) Primary Matters.
London: HMSO
.
32.
Ofsted
(1999) Primary Education 1994–98: A Review of
Primary Schools in England.
London: Stationery Office
.
33.
Osborn, M.
,
McNess, E.
,
Broadfoot, P.
,
Pollard, A.
and
Triggs, P.
(2000) What Teachers Do: Changing Policy and Practice in
Primary Education.
London: Continuum
.
34.
Pascal, C.
and
Ribbins, P.
(1998) Understanding Primary Headteachers.
London: Cassell
.
35.
Sachs, J.
(2003) The Activist Teaching Profession.
Buckingham: Open University Press
.
36.
Sammons, P.
,
Hillman, J.
and
Mortimore, P.
(1995) Key Characteristics of Effective Schools: A Review of
School Effectiveness.
London: Ofsted
.
37.
Sergiovanni, T.J.
(1998)
‘Leadership as Pedagogy, Capital Development and School Effectiveness’
, International Journal of Leadership in Education1(1):
37–46
.
38.
Smyth, J.
(2001) Critical Politics of Teachers’ Work: An
Australian Perspective.
New York: Peter Lang
.
39.
Southworth, G.
(1987) ‘Primary School Headteachers and
Collegiality’, in
G. Southworth
(ed.) Readings in Primary School Management.
Lewes: Falmer Press
.
40.
Southworth, G.
(1988)
‘Looking at Leadership: English Primary School Headteachers at Work’
, Education 3–1316(2):
53–56
.
41.
Southworth, G.
(1995a) Looking into Primary Headship: A Research Based
Interpretation.
London: Falmer Press
.
42.
Southworth, G.
(1995b) Talking Heads: Voices of Experience.
Cambridge: University of Cambridge Institute of Education
.
43.
Southworth, G.
(1998a)
‘Change and Continuity in the Work of Primary Headteachers in England’
, International Journal of Educational Research29:
311–321
.
44.
Southworth, G.
(1998b) Leading Improving Primary Schools: The Work of Heads
and Deputy Headteachers.
London: Falmer Press
.
45.
Southworth, G.
(2002)
‘Instructional Leadership in Schools: Reflections and Empirical Evidence’
, School Leadership and Management22(1):
73–91
.
46.
Southworth, G.
(2004) Primary School Leadership in Context: Leading Small
Medium and Large Sized Schools.
London: Routledge Falmer
.
47.
Vulliamy, G.
,
Kimonen, E.
,
Nevalainen, R.
and
Webb, R.
(1997)
‘Teacher Identity and Curriculum Change: A Comparative Analysis
of Small Schools in England and Finland’
, Comparative Education33(1):
97–115
.
48.
Wallace, M.
(1992) ‘Flexible Planning: A Key to the
Management of Multiple Innovations’, in
N. Bennett
,
M. Crawford
and
C. Riches
(eds) Managing Change in Education, pp.
151–165.
London: Paul Chapman
.
49.
Webb, R.
(2002)
‘Delegation: Burden or Empowerment’
, Education 3–1330(3):
35–41
.
50.
Webb, R.
,
Häkkinen, K.
,
Hämäläinen, S.
and
Vulliamy, G.
(1998)
‘External Inspection or School Self-Evaluation? A Comparative
Analysis of Policy and Practice in Primary Schools in England and Finland’
, British Educational Research Journal24(5):
539–556
.
51.
Webb, R.
and
Vulliamy, J.
(1996) Roles and Responsibilities in the Primary School,
Changing Demands, Changing Practices.
Buckingham: Open University Press
.
52.
Webb, R.
and
Vulliamy, G.
(1999)
‘Managing Curriculum Policy Changes: A Comparative Analysis of
Primary Schools in England and Finland’
, Journal of Educational Policy14(2):
117–137
.
53.
Webb, R.
and
Vulliamy, G.
(2002)
‘The Social Work Dimension of the Primary School
Teacher’s Role’
, Research Papers in Education17(2):
165–184
.
54.
Webb, R.
,
Vulliamy, G.
,
Häkkinen, K.
,
Hämäläinen, S.
,
Kimonen, E.
,
Nevalainen, R.
and
Nikki, M.
(1997) A Comparative Analysis of Curriculum Change in Primary
Schools in England and Finland.
York: Department of Educational Studies,
University of York
.
55.
Webb, R.
,
Vulliamy, G.
,
Hämäläinen, S.
,
Sarja, A.
,
Kimonen, E.
and
Nevalainen, R.
(2004a)
‘A Comparative Analysis of Primary Teacher Professionalism in
England and Finland’
, Comparative Education40(1):
83–107
.
56.
Webb, R.
,
Vulliamy, G.
,
Hämäläinen, S.
,
Sarja, A.
,
Kimonen, E.
and
Nevalainen, R.
(2004b)
‘Pressures, Rewards and Teacher Retention: A Comparative Study of
Primary Teaching in England and Finland’
, Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research48(2) (in press).
