Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This article deals with incipient fault of insulated-gate bipolar transistors to improve the safety of traction systems of China Railway High-speed 5. Combining with the pulse width modulated strategy which makes signals variate periodically, the multi-mode kernel principal component analysis algorithm is proposed. It can effectively not only capture the tiny changes caused by incipient faults but also detect short-faults of insulated-gate bipolar transistors in electrical systems. In feature space of every mode, different thresholds will be formed corresponding to defined modes. The proposed scheme is tested in experimental setup of traction system of China Railway High-speed 5 with incipient fault and short-circuit fault, and experimental results show that the multi-mode kernel principal component analysis has superior monitoring performance compared to other five methods.

Keywords

Multi-mode kernel principal component analysis incipient fault fault detection pulse width modulated inverter electronic engineering railway vehicles

Introduction

Three-phase pulse width modulated (PWM) voltage source inverter is one of the most important equipments in the traction system of high-speed railway trains.^1,2 Due to performance degradation of components in the inverter such as insulated-gate bipolar transistor (IGBT), it is possible that some faults of IGBTs may deteriorate the whole operating condition^1,3 and even lead to emergency power shutdown or unplanned standstill.⁴ Thus, the real-time fault detection and diagnosis (FDD) that can explore fault features and types is urgently needed for the inverters in high-speed railway trains to improve their stability and reliability.

For the inverters in variable speed drives, there are many components that should be diagnosed and many types of faults that need to be determined. With a rough classification, around 38% of faults are due to failures of IGBTs.^3,4 Faults in IGBTs are usually divided into three types,⁵ namely short-circuit faults, open-circuit faults, and intermittent faults. Lots of methods have been proposed to deal with the open-circuit faults and short-circuit faults of IGBTs. For example, sliding mode observer,⁶ wavelet neural networks,⁷ and model reference adaptive system⁸ were used to detect open-circuit faults; de-saturation detection,⁹ snubbers and clamp circuits,¹⁰ and vector composition of inverter output voltage¹¹ were used to handle short-circuit faults; for intermittent fault detection, time domain methods are more popular, because the fault features are insignificant in steady state. Besides that, graph theoretic approach, pattern recognition, and intelligent algorithms are usually considered.^12–16 Although the above-mentioned methods can be useful for detecting and locating some inverter faults, they are difficult to be implemented in real systems because of unavailable information, such as the accurate stray inductance and external noises. In addition, most of the common methods are model-based or knowledge-based, which may be less powerful for the systems with complicated working environments and faults with various types. For the model-based methods, it is hard to set up exact mathematical models of three-phase inverter as complex structure of inverter in high-speed railway trains. And the main challenge for the knowledge-based methods is that expertise may be difficult to acquire. Therefore, traditional FDD is difficult to perform well.

With the development of sensor technology, data storage, and analysis technologies, many advanced data-driven FDD algorithms^17–21 have been developed in the past 20 years, which provide new ways to solve FDD problems in complex electrical systems, such as the traction system of China Railway High-speed 5 (CRH5).

Different from traditional schemes,^1–16 data-driven methods have also been broadly investigated in FDD of industrial processes.^17–23 As pointed in Yin et al.,²⁴ many multivariate statistical methods, such as principal component analysis (PCA), and its variants are developed in terms of being monitored systems. In Lee et al.,¹⁷ a kernel principal component analysis (KPCA) was suggested to monitor nonlinear biological wastewater treatment process. In semiconductor manufacturing, multiblock PCA was proposed to detect abnormal process operations. Likewise, multiblock PCA with adaptive strategy was developed for FDD in a sequencing batch reactor. Aiming at the applications of nonlinear and multi-model features, a multi-mode FDD scheme based on similarities was presented in Zhang et al.²¹ Besides that, some improved methods were motivated by the other aspects, for example, a detailed fault-relevant PCA was proposed by the available fault information;²⁰ the multivariate exponentially weighted moving average (MEWMA) PCA keeping memory effect of variation trend was investigated for incipient abnormalities.

For traction system of CRH5, signals are usually periodic, highly correlated, and nonlinear, which make the existing data-driven FDD methods not applicable. And the data-driven FDD methods for common faults in inverter of electrical traction system have not been intensively investigated yet. For the incipient fault of IGBT, it is usually unnoticed at their early stage but may evolve to serious faults and increase the risk of possible hazards and rarely considered in existing literatures. These issues motivate us to focus on the study of data-based incipient FDD for inverter of CRH5.

An effective fault detection scheme is proposed based on multi-mode KPCA in this article. First, the multi-mode feature of PWM inverter is analyzed in detail, based on which a multi-mode KPCA algorithm is proposed. The proposed fault detection method consists of off-line analysis and on-line detection. For the off-line part, the collected data set is divided into six modes according to the gate trigger pulses of IGBTs, and then the off-line model of six modes’ data should be established. For the on-line part, the real-time collected data are assigned to the corresponding modes based on gate trigger signals, and the evaluation functions are then calculated to determine whether or not the inverter is running healthy finally. To illustrate its better effectiveness than other data-driven methods, PCA,²⁵ KPCA,¹⁷ multiblock PCA,¹⁸ and MEWMA PCA²⁶ are considered; besides that, a graph theoretic approach, bond graph,¹⁴ is adopted. The experimental results show that the proposed multi-mode KPCA is capable of detecting the incipient and common faults efficiently.

This article is organized as follows: section “PWM inverter of CRH5” gives a brief introduction on the traction system of CRH5, the modeling of a three-phase PWM voltage source inverter, and IGBT short-circuit faults and incipient faults. In section “Fault detection based on multi-mode KPCA,” a traditional algorithm KPCA is introduced, followed by a novel multi-mode KPCA algorithm; on-line fault detection strategy is also given in this section. Experimental results for several faults using six different methods are presented in section “Experimental results and analysis.” Finally, the conclusion is given in section “Conclusion.”

PWM inverter of CRH5

A three-phase PWM voltage source inverter

The traction drive system of CRH5 has eight major parts: vacuum circuit beaker, transformer, pulse rectifier, intermediate links, inverter, motor, gear box, and controller. The input voltage of the transformer is about single phase 25 kV/50 Hz from high-voltage power supply network. Through the pulse rectifier and intermediate links, a single-phase 3600-V direct current (DC) is obtained and transformed to the three-phase PWM voltage inverter. The output of inverter voltage is 0–2.3 kV/0–220 Hz for the three-phase squirrel cage induction motor. The motor is adjusted by variable velocity variable frequency (VVVF) direct vector control.

The inverter in traction drive system of CRH5 has four modulation types, namely asynchronous modulation, subsection and synchronization modulation, calculation in advance angle modulation, and square modulation. Modulation mode changes with the stator voltage frequency f_s. When 90 Hz ≤ f_s < 110 Hz, the inverter works under square modulation. All data sets for fault diagnosis in this article are obtained under this modulation condition. A three-phase PWM voltage source inverter system of CRH5 is mainly composed of a DC supply, a PWM inverter, a filter circuit, and four squirrel cage induction motors.

As shown in Figure 1, where S₁ to S₆ are IGBT switches, L_f is the filter inductor and C_f is the filter capacitor. The three-phase alternating current (AC) $i_{di}$ is generated from the $V_{dc}$ by the controlled IGBT switches alternately. Three-phase output voltages, $v_{ab}$ , $v_{bc}$ , and $v_{ca}$ , consist of a sequence of varied width pulses. Note that the subscript $i$ in the voltage and current variables is a, b, and c.

Figure 1.

Main circuit of three-phase PWM voltage source inverter.

According to Kirchoff’s laws, the following relationships can be obtained

i_{La} + i_{Lb} + i_{Lc} = 0

(1)

L_{f} \frac{d i_{Li}}{dt} + r i_{Li} + v_{oi} - v_{iN} - v_{in} = 0

(2)

C_{f} \frac{d v_{oi}}{dt} - i_{Li} + i_{di} = 0

(3)

For the variables in equations (1)–(3), many are highly nonlinear, such as $i_{Li}$ , where $v_{iN}$ is the neutral point voltage.

As shown in Figure 1 and Table 1, 15 variables, 9 current and 6 voltage variables, are selected which are named as $i_{s 1}$ to $i_{s 6}$ , $i_{di}$ , $v_{in}$ , $v_{ab}$ , $v_{bc}$ , and $v_{ca}$ . As IGBT works in periodic turn-on and turn-off conditions alternately, the signals in three-phase PWM inverter show periodicity naturally, as presented in the second column of Table 1, for example, the line voltage $v_{ab}$ in Figure 3. Aiming at such periodic signals in industrial processes, multiblock PCA was proposed and used for FDD for semiconductor,¹⁸ biological wastewater treatment,¹⁹ and so on. Because there exist energy storage devices, charging and discharging in every period, many electrical signals are changing in high frequency under fault-free condition. This leads, predominantly, to that the existing statistical methods cannot be directly applied to monitor the three-phase inverter condition because of the non-Gaussian feature. Aiming at this characteristic, the improved solution will be presented in section “Fault detection based on multi-mode KPCA.”

Table 1.

The selected variables in inverter.

No.	Variable name	Min.	Max.	Lag degree
1	$i_{s 1}$	−48.87	55.86	$0 \circ$
2	$i_{s 2}$	−48.22	55.50	$60 \circ$
3	$i_{s 3}$	−48.31	55.70	$120 \circ$
4	$i_{s 4}$	−48.46	55.86	$180 \circ$
5	$i_{s 5}$	−48.24	55.44	$240 \circ$
6	$i_{s 6}$	−48.32	55.67	$300 \circ$
7	$i_{da}$	−55.75	55.74	$60 \circ$
8	$i_{db}$	−55.56	55.60	$120 \circ$
9	$i_{dc}$	−55.39	55.33	$180 \circ$
10	$u_{an}$	−2401	2401	$0 \circ$
11	$u_{bn}$	−2401	2402	$120 \circ$
12	$u_{cn}$	−2402	2402	$240 \circ$
13	$u_{ab}$	−2821	2821	$0 \circ$
14	$u_{bc}$	−2813	2815	$120 \circ$
15	$u_{ca}$	−2814	2813	$240 \circ$

IGBT short-circuit fault and incipient fault

In the traction system of CRH5, faults can be classified into three types:⁴ faults with drive breakdown, faults with emergency operation or performance reduction, and incipient faults with unnoticed effects. IGBT short-circuit faults belong to the second type and may happen due to an intrinsic failure or wrong gate trigger voltages.⁵ These kinds of faults are difficult to deal with, as the time span between the alarming time $t_{2}$ and failure time or fusing time $t_{3}$ is very short, as illustrated in Figure 2, where $i_{g}$ is the current across the IGBT. Frequently, overheat, overcurrent, or overvoltage of IGBTs will cause the degradation of internal resistor and PN junctions and finally result in the breakdown of IGBTs. It is well known that after the fusing time $t_{3}$ , IGBT will fuse and trigger the fusing mechanism to protect the whole inverter. In the meantime, the PWM inverter will lose partial efficacy.

Figure 2.

Illustration of an incipient fault evolving.

For IGBT fault signal, its deterioration, as shown in Figure 2, has two stages: incipient fault and short-circuit fault. In traction system, its current curve is under normal condition between 0 and $t_{1}$ . IGBT incipient fault can be defined as the small shifts in the internal structure that lead to insignificant performance reduction in the traction system. When incipient fault occurs at $t_{1}$ , there should exist some symptoms which are different from the healthy case but do not trigger an alarm using the traditional threshold-based FDD method in CRH5. If incipient faults can be quickly detected and diagnosed as soon as possible between time $t_{1}$ and $t_{2}$ , the short-circuit fault, which is harmful to the traction system, may be avoided effectively by replacing the components. After $t_{2}$ , the unexpected shift can be defined as a short fault as $i_{g}$ exceeds the fault threshold. The short-circuit fault turns out an open-circuit fault in moment, so it leaves very narrow time window for diagnosing such short-circuit faults.

The incipient faults and short-circuit faults had not been considered sufficiently in the design of traction system; therefore both the faults should be focused on in the real traction system of CRH5.

Multi-mode feature of PWM inverter

Figure 3 shows the current curve $v_{ab}$ , which fluctuates up and down in normal operation, and has obvious periodicity. In every period, the points of variation trend are noted by data cursors. The condition of charging and discharging is changed as the turn-on and turn-off of the controlled IGBTs in three-phase PWM voltage source inverter. From the gate trigger pulses of IGBTs in Figure 4, one can draw the same conclusion that there exist six modes in the process data set. Figure 4 presents the six periodic gate trigger pulses of IGBT in a three-phase PWM inverter, and every signal can be divided into six parts as Mode 1 to Mode 6 based on the lag degree of the gate trigger pulse.

Figure 3.

Line voltage $v_{ab}$ in every period.

Figure 4.

Six modes based on gate trigger pulse.

In Table 1, the lag degrees of 15 selected measurement signals in inverter are present in the last column. It can be seen that the measurements do not obey the Gaussian distribution. Therefore, the existing multivariate statistical methods cannot be used directly, such as the most popular PCA and its numerous variants.^17–19 In this article, the proposed method that can handle the multi-mode feature is desirable for a PWM inverter.

From Figures 3 and 4, it is obvious that all the signals can be split into segments based on six modes in every period, even though they are irregular in every period. The existing algorithm can be directly used to process the collected nonlinear data. In different modes, the signals obey different distributions, but different statistical models can be developed for fault detection. Therefore, higher performance can be achieved, especially for detecting the incipient faults.

Fault detection based on multi-mode KPCA

KPCA

PCA is a popular data-driven technique which can deal with high-dimensional and high-correlated data by projecting the original data onto a new lower dimensional subspace which contains most of the original features.^25,27 It has been widely applied in data-driven on-line fault diagnosis.^22,24 However, as is well known, PCA can only be effectively used when the variables are correlated linearly and subject to normal distribution.

The KPCA method, an extension of PCA,²⁸ has been proposed to deal with the nonlinear data. Through some simple kernel functions, the original data set is mapped into a higher dimensional space with linear characteristics. And its applications can be found in Hu et al.²⁹

Considering that the collected data from a PWM inverter are non-Gaussian and nonlinearly correlated, KPCA is adopted in this article. Assume that all time series of signals in a PWM inverter are arranged in the data matrix $X = [x_{1}, x_{2}, \dots, x_{N}]^{T} \in R^{N \times m}$ , where N and m are the numbers of samples and chosen variables, respectively. X should be normalized so that all signals have zero means and unit variances to eliminate the influence of different scales.

With $x_{k} \in R^{m}, k = 1, \dots, N$ , the covariance matrix $C^{F}$ in a linear feature space $F$ through nonlinear mapping can be given by

C^{F} = \frac{1}{N} \sum_{k = 1}^{N} Φ (x_{k}) Φ {(x_{k})}^{T}

(4)

where $Φ (\cdot)$ is a nonlinear function that projects the original input vectors $x_{k}$ to the new feature space F under the condition that $\sum_{k = 1}^{N} Φ (x_{k}) = 0$ . The eigenvalues $λ$ and the corresponding eigenvectors $v$ in the new space $F$ can be calculated by

λ v = C^{F} v

(5)

The eigenvectors $v$ are expanded by

v = \sum_{k = 1}^{N} α_{k} Φ (x_{k})

(6)

where $α_{k}$ is the coefficient to be determined later. A kernel matrix $K \in R^{N \times N}$ is then defined with the form $K_{ij} = 〈 Φ (x_{i}), Φ (x_{j}) 〉 = k (x_{i}, x_{j})$ , where $〈 a, b 〉$ denotes dot product of a and b. Representative kernel functions include polynomial kernel, sigmoid kernel, and radial basis kernel. In this article, radial basis kernel function is used, which is written as

k (a, b) = \exp (- \frac{{‖ a - b ‖}^{2}}{c})

(7)

where ∥·∥ means matrix two-norms. In addition, all kernel functions should be subject to Mercer’s condition. Preliminary studies²⁹ pointed that the keys to choose the type of kernel function and the corresponding parameters are the amount of training data and the complexity of data space. Optimal selection of the kernel function is still a difficult issue.

Centralization of the kernel matrix K can be done by

\bar{K} = K - 1_{N} K - K 1_{N} + 1_{N} K 1_{N}

(8)

Assume that there are l principal components in the feature space; the matrices $C^{F}$ and $\bar{K}$ have the same eigenvalues $λ_{1}, λ_{2}, \dots, λ_{l}$ with the different eigenvectors; and the eigenvalues are ranked in descending order. Let vectors $α_{1}, α_{2}, \dots, α_{N}$ be the eigenvectors of $\bar{K}$ , the following relation can be obtained

〈 v_{k}, v_{k} 〉 = λ_{k} 〈 α_{k}, α_{k} 〉 = 1

(9)

For a new sample $x_{new}$ , $Φ (x_{new})$ is its mapping to feature space $F$ . Then the kth score t of new data $x_{new}$ extracted by projecting $Φ (x_{new})$ onto eigenvectors in the new feature space $F$ and $t_{k}$ can be calculated by

\begin{matrix} t_{k} = 〈 v_{k}, Φ (x_{new}) 〉 = \sum_{i = 1}^{N} α_{i}^{k} 〈 Φ (x_{i}), Φ (x_{new}) 〉 \\ = \sum_{i = 1}^{N} α_{i}^{k} [k (x_{1}, x_{new}), k (x_{2}, x_{new}), \dots, k (x_{N}, x_{new})] \end{matrix}

For on-line fault diagnosis based on KPCA, T²-test statistic and Q statistic are usually used. T²-test statistic is also called Hotelling’s T²-test statistic with l and $N - l$ degrees of freedom

T^{2} = X^{T} P Λ_{pc}^{- 1} P^{T} X

(11)

where $Λ_{pc} = diag (λ_{1}, \dots, λ_{l})$ . And its control limit can be calculated by

J_{t h, T^{2}} = \frac{l (N + 1) (N - 1)}{N (N - l)} F_{α} (l, N - l)

(12)

where $F_{α} (l, N - l)$ denotes $F$ distribution with $l$ and $N - l$ degrees of freedom, and $α$ is the significance level. In addition, $Q$ statistic, also called square prediction error (SPE), is the square of projection in the sample residual subspace defined by

SPE = ‖ ϕ (x) - \hat{ϕ} (x) ‖^{2}

(13)

Its control limit can be calculated by

SP E_{th} = θ_{1} {[\frac{C_{α} h_{0} \sqrt{2 θ_{2}}}{θ_{1}} + 1 + \frac{θ_{2} h_{0} (h_{0} - 1)}{θ_{1}^{2}}]}^{1 / h_{0}}

(14)

where $θ_{i} = \sum_{i = l + 1}^{m} λ_{j}^{i}, i = 1, 2, 3, h_{0} = 1 - 2 θ_{1} θ_{3} / 3 θ_{2}^{2}$ ; $C_{α}$ is the critical value of the normal distribution in the test level $α$ .

Except $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ , combined index or adaptive index was also defined in Cherry and Qin¹⁸ to ensure a better fault detection property. In this article, section “On-line fault detection of multi-mode KPCA” presents an adaptive method for index based on $SPE$ and Hotelling’s $T^{2}$ . Both control limits will change accordingly in different modes.

On-line fault detection of multi-mode KPCA

Preprocessing for data

As in section “Multi-mode feature of PWM inverter,” the electrical PWM inverter system contains six operation modes according to the gate trigger pulse in every period. So the data can be regarded to have two more dimensions than original data collected from inverter of CRH5. Signals can be described in four dimensions, samples, amplitudes, periods, and modes. Figure 5 shows a signal $i_{s 1}$ in six modes under the normal condition.

Figure 5.

IGBT1 circuit $i_{s 1}$ in three-dimensional space.

In every part, the data set, having the same characteristic or tendency, is different from every period. Therefore, a more effective fault detection method can be achieved if the signals of inverter in terms of different operation modes are sufficiently considered. In terms of the experiment in section ““Experimental results and analysis,” there are 400 samples in one period, and the six parts should be split as provided in Table 2, where $T = 0, \dots, \infty$ and the value of $T + 1$ is the sampling period.

Table 2.

Samples in every mode.

Mode	Sample
M-1	1∼67+T × 400
M-2	68∼134+T × 400
M-3	135∼200+T × 400
M-4	201∼267+T × 400
M-5	268∼334+T × 400
M-6	335∼400+T × 400

Data normalization is needed before multi-mode modeling and fault detection algorithms. The purpose is to simplify the algorithm and eliminate the influence of different scales. And normalization is formulated in Algorithm 1.

Algorithm 1. (Data normalization)

Step 1: Define $X = [x_{k} (1), \dots, x_{k} (i), \dots, x_{k} (m)] \in R^{N \times m}$ and calculate

\bar{x} (i) = \frac{1}{N} \sum_{k = 1}^{N} x_{k} (i)

(15)

σ^{2} (i) = \frac{1}{N - 1} \sum_{k = 1}^{N} {(x_{k} (i) - \bar{x} (i))}^{2}

(16)

where $k \in [1, N]$ and $i \in [1, m]$ .

Step 2: With $\bar{x} (i)$ and $σ^{2} (i)$ from equations (15) and (16), $x_{k} (i)$ can be obtained as follows

x (i) = [\begin{matrix} \frac{x_{1} (i) - \bar{x} (i)}{σ (i)} \\ ⋮ \\ \frac{x_{N} (i) - \bar{x} (i)}{σ (i)} \end{matrix}]

(17)

Off-line modeling for fault detection

Algorithm 2. Off-line computation steps for fault detection.

Step 1: Collect normal operating data and assign them to corresponding mode based on the sample number. The obtained data can be denoted as $X_{off} = [x_{1}, \dots, x_{N}]^{T} \in R^{N \times m}$ . Considering six modes in inverter, the off-line data set can be written as $X_{off} = [\hat{X} (1), \dots, \hat{X} (j), \dots, \hat{X} (6)]$ , where $X (j) \in R^{N (j) \times m}$ is the corresponding mode data, $j = 1, \dots, 6$ , and $\sum_{j = 1}^{6} N (j) = N$ . $j$ can be determined according to Table 2, and $N (j)$ can be obtained on the basis of Table 2 and the number of sample period.

Step 2:

Initialize j = 1.

Data normalization for $\hat{X} (j)$ using Algorithm 1.

Calculate the kernel matrix $K (j) \in R^{N (j) \times N (j)}$ by

K_{mn} (j) = 〈 Φ (x_{m}), Φ (x_{n}) 〉 = k (x_{m}, x_{n})

(18)

where $m$ and $n = 1, \dots, N$ .

Centralize $K (j)$ by

\bar{K} (j) = K (j) - 1_{N} K (j) - K (j) 1_{N} + 1_{N} K (j) 1_{N}

(19)

where matrix $1_{N} = (1 / N (j))_{N (j) \times N (j)}$ .

Compute $λ_{k} (j)$ and $α_{k} (j)$ by solving the following equation

λ_{k} (j) α_{k} (j) = 1 / N \bar{K} (j) α_{k} (j)

(20)

Compute the component through

\begin{matrix} t_{k} (j) = 〈 v_{k} (j), Φ (x) 〉 \\ = \sum_{i = 1}^{N (j)} α_{k} (j) [k (x_{1}, x), k (x_{2}, x), \dots, k (x_{N (j)} (j), x)] \end{matrix}

(21)

Compute $J_{th, T^{2}} (j)$ and $SP E_{th} (j)$ by equations (12) and (14).

Save $\bar{x} (i)$ , $σ (i)$ , $x$ , $Φ (x)$ of $\hat{X} (j)$ and the control limits $J_{th, T^{2}} (j)$ and $SP E_{th} (j)$ .

If $j \leq 5, j = j + 1$ , repeat Steps (2)–(8). Otherwise, break.

Step 3: Establish the normal operating condition models.

On-line computation for fault detection

Algorithm 3. On-line computation steps for fault detection.

Step 1: Obtain a new data $x_{new}$ from a running inverter device.

Step 2:

Determine the current operation mode by Table 2 according to the sample number.

Call the model parameters of the corresponding mode.

Normalize $x_{new}$ using Algorithm 1.

Calculate kernel matrix $K_{new}$ by

K_{new} = 〈 Φ (x_{new}), Φ (x_{n}) 〉 = k (x_{new}, x_{n})

(22)

where $x_{n}$ is the nth step data in normal operating.

Centralize $K_{new}$ by

{\bar{K}}_{new} = K_{new} - 1_{N} K_{new} - K_{new} 1_{N} + 1_{N} K_{new} 1_{N}

(23)

where matrix $1_{N} = (1 / N (j))_{N (j) \times N (j)}$ .

Obtain $t_{k}$ by

\begin{matrix} t_{k} & = 〈 v_{k}, Φ (x_{new}) 〉 \\ = \sum_{i = 1}^{N (j)} α_{k} [k (x_{1}, x_{new}), k (x_{2}, x_{new}), \dots, k (x_{N (j)}, x_{new})] \end{matrix}

(24)

Compute the monitoring statistics $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ by the following equations

T^{2} = [t_{1}, \dots, t_{l}] Λ_{pc}^{- 1} [t_{1}, \dots, t_{l}]^{T}

(25)

SPE = \sum_{k = 1}^{m} t_{k}^{2} - \sum_{k = 1}^{l} t_{k}^{2}

(26)

where m and l are the number of variables and principal components.

Make a decision for fault detection according to the following criterion

{\begin{matrix} Fault - free, & T^{2} \leq T_{th, T^{2}} and SPE \leq J_{th, SPE} \\ Faulty, & in other cases \end{matrix}

(27)

Back to Step 1.

Experimental results and analysis

To verify the effectiveness of the proposed multi-mode KPCA-based incipient fault detection algorithm for PWM inverter, an IGBT short-circuit fault and an IGBT incipient fault are injected into a CRH traction system simulation platform;^30,31 the experimental setup is shown in Figure 6.

Figure 6.

The experimental setup used for data generation.

This platform allows easy setting and generation of different types of faults in PWM inverter by upper computer. The IGBT short-circuit fault and incipient fault are injected by changing the turn-on resistance $R_{on}$ and turn-off resistance $R_{off}$ of IGBT in the following equations

i_{s 1 - on} = \frac{V_{dc}}{R_{on} + R_{eq}}

(28)

i_{s 1 - off} = \frac{V_{dc}}{R_{off} + R_{eq}}

(29)

where $R_{eq}$ is the equivalent resistance of the remaining components in Figure 1.

Some popular data-driven FDD methods, such as PCA,²⁵ KPCA,¹⁷ multiblock PCA,¹⁸ and MEWMA PCA,²⁶ are simulated and compared with the proposed method. Besides that, a bond graph–based method proposed in our research group is also considered. In the following parts, we concentrate on incipient fault and short-circuit fault to illustrate the superiority of the proposed algorithm over the other five approaches.

Fault detection

For simplification without losing generality, the IGBT1 is chosen as a degrading IGBT in this article. And its historical data are generated in three-phase PWM inverter of CRH5 under normal condition. Before the on-line test, the historical collected data are input into the off-line modeling. For the on-line signals, they can be analyzed in real-time. To obtain the on-line data, first an incipient fault is injected by changing turn-on and turn-off resistance of IGBT1 between samples 400 and 1000. After sample 1000, the incipient fault developed to be a short-circuit fault.

As shown in Figure 7, 15 selected signals in inverter, as listed in Table 1, are described in three-dimensional space. There are five periods in the on-line test data set, and every period has 400 samples. The data under normal and incipient fault conditions have no significant changes before 1000th step. But after 1000th step, the IGBT switches $S_{1}$ always work on turn-on condition, and there must exist short-current fault in M-4 to M-6. In this case, both the mean and variance of data change significantly after 1000th step.

Figure 7.

The on-line data set in three-dimensional space.

Figure 8 shows the results using a PCA-based fault detection method. It is clear that the short-current fault can be detected, but the $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ indices in the charts cannot detect incipient fault which is injected in sampling instant 400. Besides, the missed alarming rate is very high between the 1200th and 1400th steps.

Figure 8.

Fault detection using $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ through PCA.

In the implementation of KPCA, we choose $c = 10, 000$ . Similarly, KPCA can only detect the short-circuit fault from 1000th step; the missing alarm is zero between 1200 and 1400, as shown in Figure 9. In theory, KPCA can capture more features than PCA with the same number of retained principal components. Although PCA and KPCA are widely used in many industry processes, they are invalid for the PWM inverter unless serious faults.

Figure 9.

Fault detection using $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ through KPCA.

By regarding a period as a batch or a block in this application, multiblock PCA-based method is conducted, which shows similar results as shown in Figure 10. The reason for this phenomenon is that the score and loading matrices of both methods in principal and residual space are the same when the samples’ number $N \to \infty$ .

Figure 10.

Fault detection using $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ through multiblock PCA.

As pointed in Zhang et al.,²⁶ MEWMA and PCA can be combined for fault detection to enhance the detect ability of incipient faults. When this MEWMA PCA-based method is implemented in this article, a scalar constant $λ$ is added, which can keep the memory effect of process trend and can make it more sensitive to tiny shifts. Then two statistical values will be changed in the case of different $λ$ . But for the incipient fault detection in PWM inverter, this method cannot work well as shown in Figure 11. The performance is similar to KPCA-based method from Figures 9 and 11.

Figure 11.

Fault detection using $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ through MEWMA PCA.

The results using bond graph–based FDD are shown in Figure 12. Based on the global analytical redundancy relations of three-phase PWM inverter, the residuals can be obtained for FDD, as shown in Figure 12. It can be observed that the incipient fault can be detected after 400 to some degree. Meanwhile, the false alarm rate is 0.225, which is actually unacceptable for practical application.

Figure 12.

Fault detection using $r 1$ and $r 2$ through bond graph.

Finally, the results using the proposed multi-mode KPCA-based method are shown in Figure 13. SPE statistic values exceed the control limits between 400 and 1000, the missing alarm rate is 0.1083, and the false alarm rate is 0.0075 for incipient fault. The proposed method can successfully detect both the incipient fault and the short-circuit fault. The missing alarm rates and false alarm rates are summarized in Tables 3 and 4. The superiority of the proposed method is obvious compared to traditional algorithms.

Figure 13.

Fault detection using $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ through the proposed algorithm.

Table 3.

Missing alarm rates for the six methods.

Approaches	Incipient fault	Fault
PCA²⁵	0.9833	0.28
KPCA¹⁷	1	0
Multiblock PCA¹⁸	0.9833	0.28
MEWMA PCA²⁶	1	0
Bond graph¹⁴	0.46	0
Multi-mode KPCA	0.1083	0

PCA: principal component analysis; KPCA: kernel principal component analysis; MEWMA: multivariate exponentially weighted moving average.

Table 4.

False alarm rates for the six methods.

Approaches	Normal
PCA²⁵	0.015
KPCA¹⁷	0
Multiblock PCA¹⁸	0.015
MEWMA PCA²⁶	0
Bond graph¹⁴	0.0225
Multi-mode KPCA	0.0075

PCA: principal component analysis; KPCA: kernel principal component analysis; MEWMA: multivariate exponentially weighted moving average.

Discussions

Those traditional PCA-based FDD methods have poor missing and false alarming rates for detection of the incipient fault. The key reason is those methods do not consider the characteristic of electrical systems. In equations (28) and (29), it should be pointed that $R_{on}$ is far smaller than $R_{eq}$ and $R_{off}$ is far bigger than $R_{eq}$ , respectively. Changing the turn-on resistance and turn-off resistance causes nonsignificant influence. The current $i_{s 1}$ shows tiny varied mean value and variance with changing turn-on and turn-off resistances of IGBT. Then both statistic values will be below the control limits, as shown in Figures 8 –12.

Besides that, the short-current fault of IGBT appears from 1000th step; all the six methods can detect fault quickly. But if this fault happened in between 800th and 1000th steps, PCA, KPCA, multiblock PCA, and MEWMA PCA will lose these rapidity. The reason for this phenomenon is which IGBT1 and IGBT4 should work on turn-on and turn-off conditions, respectively, between 800th and 1000th steps. In other words, although the IGBT switches $S_{1}$ always work on turn-on condition after 1000th step, the inverter works under incipient fault in sampling steps 800–1000, not short-circuit fault. But there is no influence of the proposed method in this article. Although this cannot influence the detection performance of bond graph, the biggest false alarm rate and the bigger missing alarm rate are still not changed.

It should be pointed that $SPE$ is a kind of measure of model variation as mentioned in section “Fault detection based on multi-mode KPCA” and has better ability of capturing the tiny changes than $T^{2}$ . Because tiny shifts might not change significant deviations in the axes of principal direction, FDD in the principal space cannot get enough information when compared to $SPE$ . So most of the data-driven fault diagnosis researches adopt either $SPE$ or both $T^{2}$ and $SPE$ statistics. The simulation results and its definition show that $SPE$ is a more significant index for incipient fault detection.

Therefore, based on Algorithm 2 and Algorithm 3, the incipient fault can be detected correctly. Moreover, application of all other five methods from incipient fault detection results in an erroneous detection which has been confirmed through experimental results. If an algorithm can detect incipient fault, fault must be detected obviously. In real traction systems of CRH5, the proposed algorithm can play satisfied effects in the case that some monitoring variables have a tiny irregular deviation.

Conclusion

The real-time incipient fault detection for PWM inverter of CRH5 is investigated in this article. An improved approach based on KPCA is first proposed. In this proposed method, original data will have two more dimensions, as period and mode. In this way, it can capture the characters of electrical system so that the proposed algorithm detects both incipient faults and common faults of IGBT quickly and correctly. Many parameters using the proposed algorithm are changed by switching modes, so the fault detection can be updated adaptively. The proposed method is effective to detect faults for nonlinear electrical systems such as three-phase PWM voltage source inverter system of CRH5. Moreover, the method can be applied in traction system of high-speed railway with no more designs of hardware and controller. This study is proposed under a multivariate statistical analysis framework. For electrical systems, based on the multi-mode idea, the proposed data-driven method can be extended to handle other fault types and to other electrical systems both from theoretical and practical viewpoints.

Footnotes

Handling Editor: Chenguang Yang

Declaration of conflicting interests

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Funding

The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: This work was partially supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant no. 61490703) and Funding of Jiangsu Innovation Program for Graduate Education (grant no. KYLX16_0378).

References

Gou

Wang

et al . An open-switch fault diagnosis method for single-phase PWM rectifier using a model-based approach in high-speed railway electrical traction drive system. IEEE T Power Electr 2016; 31: 3816–3826.

Mao

Zhan

Tao

et al . Sensor fault detection for rail vehicle suspension systems with disturbances and stochastic noises. IEEE T Veh Technol 2016; 66: 4961–4705.

Yang

Xiang

Bryant

et al . Condition monitoring for device reliability in power electronic converters: a review. IEEE T Power Electr 2010; 25: 2734–2752.

Fuchs

. Some diagnosis methods for voltage source inverters in variable speed drives with induction machines—a survey. In: Proceedings of the 29th annual conference of the IEEE industrial electronics society, Roanoke, VA, 2–6 November 2003, vol. 2, pp.1378–1385. New York: IEEE.

Sharma

. A literature review of IGBT fault diagnostic and protection methods for power inverters. IEEE T Ind Appl 2009; 45: 1770–1777.

Shao

Wheeler

Clare

et al . Fault detection for modular multilevel converters based on sliding mode observer. IEEE T Power Electr 2013; 28: 4867–4872.

Khomfoi

Tolbert

. Fault diagnosis and reconfiguration for multilevel inverter drive using AI-based techniques. IEEE T Ind Electron 2007; 54: 2954–2968.

Jung

Park

Kim

et al . An MRAS-based diagnosis of open-circuit fault in PWM voltage-source inverters for PM synchronous motor drive systems. IEEE T Power Electr 2013; 28: 2514–2526.

Huang

Flett

. IGBT fault protection based on di/dt feedback control. In: Proceedings of the IEEE power electronics specialists conferences, Orlando, FL, 17–21 June 2007, pp.1478–1484. New York: IEEE.

10.

Chokhawala

Sobhani

. Switching voltage transient protection schemes for high-current IGBT modules. IEEE T Ind Appl 1997; 33: 1601–1610.

11.

Richardeau

Baudesson

Meynard

. Failures-tolerance and remedial strategies of a PWM multicell inverter. IEEE T Power Electr 2002; 17: 905–912.

12.

Smith

Ran

Penman

. Real-time detection of intermittent misfiring in a voltage-fed PWM inverter induction-motor drive. IEEE T Ind Electron 1997; 44: 468–476.

13.

Perpiñà

Castellazzi

Piton

et al . Failure-relevant abnormal events in power inverters considering measured IGBT module temperature inhomogeneities. Microelectron Reliab 2007; 47: 1784–1785.

14.

Gonzàlez-Contreras

Rullàn-Lara

Vela-Valdés

et al . Modelling, simulation and fault diagnosis of the three-phase inverter using bond graph. In: Proceedings of the IEEE international symposium on industrial electronics, Vigo, 4–7 June 2007, pp.130–135. New York: IEEE.

15.

Diallo

Benbouzid

MEH

Hamad

et al . Fault detection and diagnosis in an induction machine drive: a pattern recognition approach based on concordia stator mean current vector. IEEE T Energy Conver 2005; 20: 512–519.

16.

Zidani

Diallo

Benbouzid

MEH

et al . A fuzzy-based approach for the diagnosis of fault modes in a voltage-fed PWM inverter induction motor drive. IEEE T Ind Electron 2008; 55: 586–593.

17.

Lee

Yoo

Choi

et al . Nonlinear process monitoring using kernel principal component analysis. Chem Eng Sci 2004; 59: 223–234.

18.

Cherry

Qin

. Multiblock principal component analysis based on a combined index for semiconductor fault detection and diagnosis. IEEE T Semiconduct M 2006; 19: 159–172.

19.

Lee

Vanrolleghem

. Monitoring of a sequencing batch reactor using adaptive multiblock principal component analysis. Biotechnol Bioeng 2003; 82: 489–497.

20.

Zhao

Gao

. Fault-relevant principal component analysis (FPCA) method for multivariate statistical modeling and process monitoring. Chemometr Intell Lab 2014; 133: 1–16.

21.

Zhang

Fan

Yang

. Fault diagnosis of multimode processes based on similarities. IEEE T Ind Electron 2016; 63: 2606–2614.

22.

Zhao

Sun

. Comprehensive subspace decomposition and isolation of principal reconstruction directions for online fault diagnosis. J Process Contr 2013; 23: 1515–1527.

23.

Gao

Yang

et al . PCA-based modeling and on-line monitoring strategy for uneven-length batch processes. Ind Eng Chem Res 2004; 43: 3343–3352.

24.

Yin

Ding

Xie

et al . A review on basic data-driven approaches for industrial process monitoring. IEEE Trans Ind Electron 2014; 61: 6418–6428.

25.

Ding

. Data-driven design of fault diagnosis and fault-tolerant control systems. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 2014.

26.

Zhang

. A modified multivariate EWMA control chart for monitoring process small shifts. In: Proceedings of the IEEE international conference on modelling, identification and control, Shanghai, China, 26–29 June 2011, pp.75–80. New York: IEEE.

27.

Wang

Chani

Ding

et al . Data driven fault diagnosis and fault tolerant control: some advances and possible new directions. Acta Autom Sinica 2009; 35: 739–747.

28.

Zhang

. Improved multi-scale kernel principal component analysis and its application for fault detection. Chem Eng Res Des 2012; 90: 1271–1280.

29.

Xie

Chen

et al . An aeroengine fault detection method based on kernel principal component analysis. J Propul Technol 2008; 29: 79–83.

30.

Yang

Peng

et al . A fault-injection strategy for traction drive control systems. IEEE T Ind Electron 2017; 64: 5719–5727.

31.

Zhang

Jiang

Yan

et al . Incipient voltage sensor fault isolation for rectifier in railway electrical traction systems. IEEE T Ind Electron 2017; 64: 6763–6774.

Multi-mode kernel principal component analysis–based incipient fault detection for pulse width modulated inverter of China Railway High-speed 5

Abstract

Keywords

Introduction

PWM inverter of CRH5

A three-phase PWM voltage source inverter

IGBT short-circuit fault and incipient fault

Multi-mode feature of PWM inverter

Fault detection based on multi-mode KPCA

KPCA

On-line fault detection of multi-mode KPCA

Preprocessing for data

Off-line modeling for fault detection

On-line computation for fault detection

Experimental results and analysis

Fault detection

Discussions

Conclusion

Footnotes

Declaration of conflicting interests

Funding

References