Restricted accessReview articleFirst published online 2024
Safety and efficacy of dynamic catheter-directed cerebral digital subtraction angiography for diagnosis of bowhunter syndrome spectrum disorders: A systematic review of the literature
Dynamic catheter-directed cerebral digital subtraction angiography (dcDSA) is the gold standard for diagnosing dynamic vascular occlusion syndromes such as bowhunter syndrome (BHS). Nonetheless, concerns about its safety exist and no standardized protocols have been published to date.
Methods
We describe our methodology and insights regarding the use of dcDSA in patients with BHS. We also perform a systematic literature review to identify cases of typical and atypical presentations of BHS wherein dcDSA was utilized and report on any procedural complications related to dcDSA.
Results
Our study included 104 cases wherein dcDSA was used for the diagnosis of BHS. There were 0 reported complications of dcDSA. DcDSA successfully established diagnosis in 102 of these cases. Thirty-eight cases were deemed atypical presentations of BHS. Fourteen patients endorsed symptoms during neck flexion/extension. In eight cases, there was dynamic occlusion of bilateral vertebral arteries during a single maneuver. Three patients had multiple areas of occlusion along a single vertebral artery (VA). An anomalous entry of the VA above the C6 transverse foramen was observed in four patients. One patient had VA occlusion with neutral head position and recanalization upon contralateral lateral head tilt.
Conclusion
Our study highlights the safety and diagnostic benefits of dcDSA in characterizing the broad spectrum of BHS pathology encountered in clinical practice. This technique offers a powerful means to evaluate changes in cerebral blood flow and cervical arterial morphology in real time, overcoming the constraints of static imaging methods. Our findings pave the way for further studies on dcDSA to enhance cross-sectional imaging methods for the characterization of BHS and other dynamic vascular occlusion syndromes.
ShabanSHuasenBHaridasA, et al.Digital subtraction angiography in cerebrovascular disease: current practice and perspectives on diagnosis, acute treatment and prognosis. Acta Neurol Belg2022; 122: 763–780.
2.
BaranoskiJFWhiteACChungCY, et al.Mechanical disorders of the cervicocerebral circulation in children and young adults. J NeuroIntervent Surg.2023: 1–8.
JongbloedWGertelAKashatL, et al.Vertebral artery compression by the greater cornu of the thyroid cartilage. Ear Nose Throat J2023; 102: 301–303.
5.
RollinsNBoothTShapiroK. The use of gated cine phase contrast and MR venography in achondroplasia. Childs Nerv Syst2000; 16: 569–575. discussion 575–577.
6.
PageMJMcKenzieJEBossuytPM, et al.The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. Br Med J2021; 372: n71.
7.
JostGFDaileyAT. Bow hunter’s syndrome revisited: 2 new cases and literature review of 124 cases. Neurosurg Focus2015; 38: E7.
8.
MatsuokaHOhashiSNarikiyoM, et al.A surgical case of bow hunter’s syndrome diagnosed by cervical rotational MRA. Case Rep Orthop2022; 2022: 6091597.
VatesGEWangKCBonovichD, et al.Bow hunter stroke caused by cervical disc herniation: case report. J Neurosurg Spine2002; 96: 90–93.
11.
MatsuyamaTMorimotoTSakakiT. Bow hunter’s stroke caused by a nondominant vertebral artery occlusion: case report. Neurosurgery1997; 41: 1393–1395.
12.
IidaYMurataHJohkuraK, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome by nondominant vertebral artery compression: a case report, literature review, and significance of downbeat nystagmus as the diagnostic clue. World Neurosurg2018; 111: 367–372.
13.
CorneliusJFPopRFriciaM, et al.Compression syndromes of the vertebral artery at the craniocervical junction. Acta Neurochir Suppl2019; 125: 151–158.
14.
SarkarJWolfeSQChingBH, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome causing vertebrobasilar insufficiency in a young man with neck muscle hypertrophy. Ann Vasc Surg2014; 28: 1032.e1–1032.e10.
15.
Motiei-LangroudiRGriessenauerCJAlturkiA, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome from a tortuous V1 segment vertebral artery treated with stent placement. World Neurosurg2017; 98: 878.e11–878.e15.
16.
HorowitzMJovinTBalzarJ, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome in the setting of contralateral vertebral artery stenosis: evaluation and treatment options. Spine (Phila Pa 1976)2002; 27: E495–E498.
17.
HealyATLeeBSWalshK, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome secondary to bilateral dynamic vertebral artery compression. J Clin Neurosci2015; 22: 209–212.
18.
OrlandiNCavallieriFGrisendiI, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome successfully treated with a posterior surgical decompression approach: a case report and review of literature. World J Clin Cases2022; 10: 4494–4501.
19.
IkedaDSVillelliNShawA, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome unmasked after contralateral vertebral artery sacrifice for aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. J Clin Neurosci2014; 21: 1044–1046.
20.
MontanoMAlmanKSmithMJ, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome: a rare cause of vertebrobasilar insufficiency. Radiol Case Rep2021; 16: 867–870.
21.
ToluianTVolterraDGioppoA, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome: an unusual case of bilateral dynamic occlusion of vertebral arteries. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry2021; 92: 1131–1132.
22.
NgSBoettoJFavierV, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome: surgical vertebral artery decompression guided by dynamic intraoperative angiography. World Neurosurg2018; 118: 290–295.
23.
YoshimuraKIwatsukiKIshiharaM, et al.Bow hunter’s stroke due to instability at the uncovertebral C3/4 joint. Eur Spine J2011; 20: 266–270.
24.
Taylor 3rdWBVandergriffCLOpatowskyMJ, et al.Bow hunter’s syndrome diagnosed with provocative digital subtraction cerebral angiography. Proc (Bayl Univ Med Cent)2012; 25: 26–27.
25.
SchunemannVKimJDornbos 3rdD, et al.C2-C3 anterior cervical arthrodesis in the treatment of bow hunter’s syndrome: case report and review of the literature. World Neurosurg2018; 118: 284–289.
26.
ChaudhryNGaynorBGAmbekarS, et al.Combined use of intraoperative indocyanine green and dynamic angiography in rotational vertebral artery occlusion. Asian J Neurosurg2017; 12: 763–765.
27.
de la RivaPMartínez-ZabaletaMTPardoE, et al.Congenital spinal malformation and stroke: aneurysmal dilatations and bilateral rotational vertebral artery occlusion. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2016; 25: e23–e24.
28.
ZaidiHAAlbuquerqueFCChowdhrySA, et al.Diagnosis and management of bow hunter’s syndrome: 15-year experience at barrow neurological institute. World Neurosurg2014; 82: 733–738.
29.
KutsunaFMorofujiYShiozakiE, et al.Endovascular coil embolization for recurrent bow hunter’s stroke. Intern Med2022; 61: 3595–3598.
30.
IkedaDSMillerCARavindraVM. Fusion for subaxial bow hunter’s syndrome results in remote osseous remodeling of the hyperostotic growth responsible for vertebral artery compression. Surg Neurol Int2021; 12: 104.
31.
MiyamotoSHayakawaMOkuneS, et al. Hidden bow hunter’s syndrome diagnosed using dynamic cerebral angiography and successfully treated with spinal surgery: a case report and review of the literature. Internal Medicine2024; 63: 327–331.
32.
VelatGJReavey-CantwellJFUlmAJ, et al.Intraoperative dynamic angiography to detect resolution of bow hunter’s syndrome: technical case report. Surg Neurol2006; 66: 420–423. discussion 423.
33.
RavindraVMNeilJAMazurMD, et al.Motion-related vascular abnormalities at the craniocervical junction: illustrative case series and literature review. Neurosurg Focus2015; 38: E6.
34.
NishikawaHMiyaFKitanoY, et al.Positional occlusion of vertebral artery due to cervical spondylosis as rare cause of wake-up stroke: report of two cases. World Neurosurg2017; 98: 877.e13–877.e21.
35.
UjifukuKHayashiKTsunodaK, et al.Positional vertebral artery compression and vertebrobasilar insufficiency due to a herniated cervical disc. J Neurosurg Spine2009; 11: 326–329.
36.
KanPYasharPLangerDJ, et al.Posterior inferior cerebellar artery to posterior inferior cerebellar artery in situ bypass for the treatment of bow hunter’s-type dynamic ischemia in holovertebral dissection. World Neurosurg2012; 78: 553.e15–17.
37.
FlemingJBVoraTKHarriganMR. Rare case of bilateral vertebral artery stenosis caused by C4–5 spondylotic changes manifesting with bilateral bow hunter’s syndrome. World Neurosurg2013; 79: 799.e1–799.e5.
38.
TanakaKSteinfortB. Rare cause of bow hunter’s syndrome due to an aberrant course of a vertebral artery. BMJ Case Rep2019; 12: 1–4.
39.
NozawaTOkamotoKNakazatoS, et al.Repeated cerebellar infarction in the affected nondominant vertebral artery distribution with reversible vertebral artery occlusion elicited by head tilt: illustrative case. J Neurosurg Case Lessons2021; 1: CASE2061.
40.
AkarZKafadarAMTanrioverN, et al.Rotational compression of the vertebral artery at the point of dural penetration. Case report. J Neurosurg2000; 93: 300–303.
41.
JohnsonSADucruetAFBellotteJB, et al.Rotational vertebral artery dissection secondary to anomalous entrance into transverse foramen. World Neurosurg2017; 108: 998.e1–998.e5.
42.
BulsaraKRVelezDAVillavicencioA. Rotational vertebral artery insufficiency resulting from cervical spondylosis: case report and review of the literature. Surg Neurol2006; 65: 625–627.
43.
TominagaTTakahashiTShimizuH, et al.Rotational vertebral artery occlusion from occipital bone anomaly: a rare cause of embolic stroke. Case report. J Neurosurg2002; 97: 1456–1459.
44.
YangHZhongSHuY, et al.Rotational vertebral artery occlusion in a patient with basilar invagination. Br J Neurosurg2023; 37: 650–652.
45.
BuchananCCMcLaughlinNLuDC, et al.Rotational vertebral artery occlusion secondary to adjacent-level degeneration following anterior cervical discectomy and fusion: case report. SPI2014; 20: 714–721.
46.
LuDCZadorZMummaneniPV, et al.Rotational vertebral artery occlusion—series of 9 cases. Neurosurgery2010; 67: 1066–1072.
47.
KuetherTANesbitGMClarkWM, et al.Rotational vertebral artery occlusion: a mechanism of vertebrobasilar insufficiency. Neurosurgery1997; 41: 427–433.
48.
BuchVPMadsenPJVaughanKA, et al.Rotational vertebrobasilar insufficiency due to compression of a persistent first intersegmental vertebral artery variant: case report. J Neurosurg Spine2017; 26: 199–202.
49.
DabusGGerstleRJParsonsM, et al.Rotational vertebrobasilar insufficiency due to dynamic compression of the dominant vertebral artery by the thyroid cartilage and occlusion of the contralateral vertebral artery at C1-2 level. J Neuroimaging2008; 18: 184–187.
50.
DadsetanMRSkerhutHEI. Rotational vertebrobasilar insufficiency secondary to vertebral artery occlusion from fibrous band of the longus coli muscle. Neuroradiology1990; 32: 514–515.
51.
NatelloGWCarrollCMKatwalAB. Rotational vertebrobasilar ischemia due to vertebral artery dynamic stenoses complicated by an ostial atherosclerotic stenosis. Vasc Med2009; 14: 265–269.
52.
VilelaMDGoodkinRLundinDA, et al.Rotational vertebrobasilar ischemia: hemodynamic assessment and surgical treatment. Neurosurgery2005; 56: 36–43. discussion 43–45.
53.
TsutsumiSItoMYasumotoY. Simultaneous bilateral vertebral artery occlusion in the lower cervical spine manifesting as bow hunter’s syndrome -case report-Neurol Med Chir(Tokyo)2008; 48: 90–94.
54.
SafainMGTalanJMalekAM, et al.Spontaneous atraumatic vertebral artery occlusion due to physiological cervical extension: case report. J Neurosurg Spine2014; 20: 278–282.
55.
MieleVJFranceJCRosenCL. Subaxial positional vertebral artery occlusion corrected by decompression and fusion. Spine2008; 33: E366–E370.
56.
LuzziSGragnanielloCMarascoS, et al.Subaxial vertebral artery rotational occlusion syndrome: an overview of clinical aspects, diagnostic work-up, and surgical management. Asian Spine J2021; 15: 392–407.
57.
NguyenHSDoanNEckardtG, et al.Surgical decompression coupled with diagnostic dynamic intraoperative angiography for bow hunter’s syndrome. Surg Neurol Int2015; 6: 147.
58.
HaimotoSNishimuraYHaraM, et al.Surgical treatment of rotational vertebral artery syndrome induced by spinal tumor: a case report and literature review. NMC Case Rep J2017; 4: 101–105.
59.
PiñolIRamirezMSalóG, et al.Symptomatic vertebral artery stenosis secondary to cervical spondylolisthesis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976)2013; 38: E1503–E1505.
60.
KarleWEBunielMCLutsepHL, et al.Thyroid cartilage compression causing stroke. Laryngoscope2019; 129: E445–E448.
61.
IguchiYKimuraKShibazakiK, et al.Transcranial Doppler and carotid duplex ultrasonography findings in bow hunter’s syndrome. J Neuroimaging2006; 16: 278–280.
62.
NemecekANNewellDWGoodkinR. Transient rotational compression of the vertebral artery caused by herniated cervical disc: case report. J Neurosurg: Spine2003; 98: 80–83.
63.
LeeVRilesTSStablefordJ, et al.Two case presentations and surgical management of bow hunter’s syndrome associated with bony abnormalities of the C7 vertebra. J Vasc Surg2011; 53: 1381–1385.
64.
ShigekawaSInoueATagawaM, et al.Utility of O-arm navigation for atlantoaxial fusion with bow hunter’s syndrome. Surg Neurol Int2021; 12: 1–3.
65.
PetridisAKBarthHBuhlR, et al.Vertebral artery decompression in a patient with rotational occlusion. Acta Neurochir (Wien)2008; 150: 391–394; discussion 394.
66.
DarkhabaniMZThompsonMCLazzaroMA, et al.Vertebral artery stenting for the treatment of bow hunter’s syndrome: report of 4 cases. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2012; 21: e1–e5.
67.
MilevaNBVassilevDISerbezovaI, et al.Vertebral artery stenting in a patient with bow hunter’s syndrome. JACC Case Rep2019; 1: 73–74.
68.
OkawaMAmamotoTAbeH, et al.Wake-up stroke in a young woman with rotational vertebral artery occlusion due to far-lateral cervical disc herniation. J Neurosurg: SPine2015; 23: 166–169.
69.
ShingaiYSakataHEndoT, et al.Bow Hunter’s syndrome due to an embolic mechanism: illustrative case. J Neurosurg Case Lessons2021; 1: CASE20150.
70.
FelbaumDRRyanJEStemerAB, et al.Bilateral subaxial rotational vertebral artery occlusion in a setting of a prior cervical construct. World Neurosurg2017; 97: 762.e5–762.e10.
71.
GailloudP. The segmentation of the vertebral artery: an ambiguous anatomical concept. Interv Neuroradiol2022; 28: 765–772.
72.
SioutasGSSalemMMMuhammadN, et al.Feasibility and safety of transradial intraoperative angiography for neurosurgery: an institutional experience. Interv Neuroradiol2023: 1–7.
73.
HartRGDienerHCCouttsSB, et al.Embolic strokes of undetermined source: the case for a new clinical construct. Lancet Neurol2014; 13: 429–438.
74.
WWEAGLE. Elongated styloid process; further observations and a new syndrome. Arch Otolaryngol (1925)1948; 47: 630–640.
75.
SchleiferLVogelSArunA, et al.Stroke caused by arterial thoracic outlet syndrome in an adolescent. Child Neurol Open2022; 9: 2329048X221105743.
76.
CorreiaPNMeyerIAEskandariA, et al.Beauty parlor stroke revisited: an 11-year single-center consecutive series. Int J Stroke2016; 11: 356–360.
PrimianiCTLawtonMHillisAE, et al.Pearls & oy-sters: cerebral venous congestion associated with cognitive decline treated by jugular release. Neurology2022; 99: 577–580.
79.
FargenKMCoffmanSTorosianT, et al.“Idiopathic” intracranial hypertension: an update from neurointerventional research for clinicians. Cephalalgia2023; 43: 03331024231161323.
80.
MitchellJ. Vertebral artery blood flow velocity changes associated with cervical spine rotation: a meta-analysis of the evidence with implications for professional practice. J Man Manip Ther2009; 17: 46–57.
81.
CagnieBBarbaixEVinckE, et al.Atherosclerosis in the vertebral artery: an intrinsic risk factor in the use of spinal manipulation?Surg Radiol Anat2006; 28: 129–134.
82.
PrasadKCKamathMPReddyKJM, et al.Elongated styloid process (Eagle’s syndrome): a clinical study. J Oral Maxillofac Surg2002; 60: 171–175.
83.
CharbonnierGCancelliereNMRusticiA, et al.Venous balloon test occlusion for pulsatile tinnitus assessment: a clinical feasibility study. Interv Neuroradiol2023: 1–6.
84.
SimkaMMajewskiEFortunaM, et al.Internal jugular vein entrapment in a multiple sclerosis patient. Case Rep Surg2012; 2012: e293568.
85.
LiMSunYChanCC, et al.Internal jugular vein stenosis associated with elongated styloid process: five case reports and literature review. BMC Neurol2019; 19: 112.
86.
TuckerWDAroraYMahajanK. Anatomy, Blood Vessels. In: StatPearls. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing, 2023. Accessed September 23, 2023. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK470401/.
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
