Flexible lateral isocenter: A novel mechanical functionality contributing to dose reduction in neurointerventional procedures

Abstract

Aim of the study

A new functionality that enables vertical mobility of the lateral arm of a biplane angiographic machine is referred to as the flexible lateral isocenter. The aim of this study was to analyze the impact of the flexible lateral isocenter on the air-kerma rate under experimental conditions.

Material and methods

An anthropomorphic head-and-chest phantom with anteroposterior (AP) diameter of the chest varying from 22 cm to 30 cm simulated human bodies of different body constitutions. The angulation of the AP arm in the sagittal plane varied from 35 degrees to 55 degrees for each AP diameter. The air-kerma rate (mGy/min) values were read from the system dose display in two settings for each angle: flexible lateral isocenter and fixed lateral isocenter.

Results

The air-kerma rate was significantly lower for all AP diameters of the chest of the phantom when the flexible lateral isocenter was used: (a) For 22 cm, the p value was 0.028; (b) For 25 cm, the p value was 0.0169; (c) For 28 cm, the p value was 0.01005 and (d) For 30 cm, the p value was 0.01703.

Conclusion

Our results show that the flexible lateral isocenter contributes significantly to the reduction of the air-kerma rate, and thus to a safer environment in terms of dose lowering both for patients and staff.

Keywords

Lateral isocenter biplane angiographic machine dose saving

Introduction

The treatment of cerebral aneurysms, arteriovenous malformations and fistulas is always very challenging for many reasons. An inappropriate approach to the target, suboptimal catheterization of vascular structures, with subsequent erroneous injection of various embolic materials; or deployment of implants may lead to the unsatisfactory treatment of vascular pathology or even to vascular catastrophes. The main prerequisite for optimal treatment is optimal visualization of the target in two projections.^1–4 All state-of-the-art angiographic machines possess two arms intended for simultaneous visualization of the target in two planes, anteroposterior (AP) and lateral. Extreme angulations of both arms are often necessary to obtain optimal visualization of a vascular structure. The table and the patient on it, as well as all anesthetic and neurosurgical instruments necessary for a neurointervention, limit angulations of both arms. This problem can partially be solved by changing the position of the table, since the position of the table is adjustable in all three planes, regardless of the model of angiographic machine used. An appropriate combination of table position, angulations of both arms, as well as distances between detector panels and X-ray tubes in both projections is therefore currently being used for optimal visualization of the target.

A new functionality, described in this study, that enables mobility of the lateral arm in the vertical direction additionally contributes to the adjustability of the lateral arm and thus to better visualization of vascular structures regardless of their position, size or shape. This functionality is referred to as the flexible lateral isocenter (FLIC). Thanks to this novel functionality, it is also possible to obtain the desired projections with the minimal possible distance between the detector plate and X-ray tube.

The aim of this study was to show the impact of this new functionality on the radiation dose, since one of the factors on which the dose is dependent is the distance between the detector panel and X-ray tube.

Material and methods

The biplane machine used in this study was the Toshiba Infinix-i/BP (Toshiba Medical Systems, Shimoishigami, Otawara-shi, Tochigi, Japan). The technical characteristics of the fluoroscopy used for the measurements were detector input dose of 0.45 µGy/s for a reference field of view (FOV) of 20 × 20 cm, which was used for all measurements. The X-ray factors were voltage, 80 kV; range of current, 50–200 mA; and filtration, 0.3 mm copper. Current (mA) and time (ms) are not constant in fluoroscopy as they vary according to the automatic brightness control (ABC) response.

FLIC enables adjustment of the lateral arm ±7 cm in the vertical direction.

The air-kerma rate (mGy/min) values were read from the system dose display.

The head of an anthropomorphic head-and-chest phantom with AP diameters of the chest measuring 22 cm, 25 cm, 28 cm and 30 cm for each dose measurement was used as a target. The AP diameter of the thorax was extended by adding 1 or 2 cm thick Plexiglas plates. The distance between the detector plate of the AP arm and the thorax was always 2cm. The caudo-cranial angulation of the AP arm varied from 35 degrees to 55 degrees, with a 5-degree increment between measurements.

To achieve the needed caudo-cranial angulation, to keep lateral projection of the target, and to avoid collision between the AP arm and the chest of the phantom, the distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate increased for each angulation when the non-flexible isocenter (non-FLIC) was used (Figure 1). When the FLIC was used, the same aim was achieved by vertical adjustment of the lateral arm and a marginal increase of the distance between X-ray tube and detector plate (Figure 2). For both FLIC and non-FLIC setups the exposed anatomical area and volume (head of the head-and-chest phantom) were the same for each measurement. This ensured the air-kerma values for both setups were comparable and dependent only on the distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate.

Figure 1.

Use of the non-flexible lateral isocenter. To get the desired working anteroposterior projection and to keep the lateral projection by keeping the height of the table unchanged, the source-to-image distance has been extended (blue arrow).

Figure 2.

Use of the flexible lateral isocenter. The same angulation as in Figure 1 with kept lateral view is achieved using the flexible lateral isocenter that compensates for table lowering (red arrows). The source-to-image distance is shorter compared to the non-flexible lateral isocenter (blue arrow).

The Excel T test was used for statistical analysis of the results. For the difference between air-kerma values, a p value <0.05 was considered significant.

Results

(a) Thorax AP diameter: 22 cm

When the non-FLIC was used, the distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate increased from 97 cm to 118 cm as the angulation in caudo-cranial direction increased from 35 degrees to 55 degrees. Thus the lateral projection was not lost regardless of angulation, and the detector plate did not collide with the thorax of the phantom. The increase of distance caused an increase of dose from 16.3 mGy/min to 39.7 mGy/min (Figure 3). When the FLIC was used, the lowering of the table was compensated for by vertical adjustment of the lateral arm and a marginal increase of distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate: from 95 cm for 35 degrees to 105 cm for 55 degrees. This increase in distance caused an increase in dose from 14 mGy/min to 19.2 mGy/min (Figure 3).

Figure 3.

Air-kerma rate is significantly lower for thorax anteroposterior diameter of 22 cm when the flexible lateral isocenter was used, p value = 0.0280.

(b) Thorax AP diameter: 25 cm

When the FLIC was used, the increase of angulation from 35 degrees to 55 degrees was compensated for by vertical adjustment of the lateral arm and an increase in the distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate from 95 cm to 108 cm, which was followed by a dose increase from 15.9 mGy/min to 29.8 mGy/min (Figure 4). For the same angulations, the distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate increased from 101 cm to 123 cm when the non-FLIC was used. This increase of distance caused an increase of the dose from 17.9 mGy/min to 40.6 mGy/min (Figure 4).

Figure 4.

Air-kerma rate is significantly lower for thorax anteroposterior diameter of 25 cm when the flexible lateral isocenter was used, p value = 0.0169.

(c) Thorax AP diameter: 28 cm and 30 cm

For these two AP diameters, the angulation of 55 degrees could not be reached when the non-FLIC was used. For an AP thorax diameter of 28 cm, the distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate increased from 103 cm to 125 cm and an angulation of 54 degrees was reached. This was followed by a dose increase from 18.7 mGy/min to 44.2 mGy/min (Figure 5). Similarly, for the AP thorax diameter of 30 cm, the distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate increased from 106 cm to 124 cm and an angulation of 50 degrees was reached. This increase in distance led to a dose increase from 19.9 mGy/min to 40.2 mGy/min (Figure 6). The angulation of 55 degrees was reached for both AP thorax diameters when the FLIC was used. For these two diameters, the distance between the X-ray tube and detector plate increased from 95 cm to 113 cm and from 96 cm to 116 cm, respectively. This was followed by a dose increase from 15.6 mGy/min to 34.9 mGy/min and 16.8 mGy/min to 41.5 mGy/min, respectively (Figures 5 and 6).

Figure 5.

Air-kerma rate is significantly lower for thorax anteroposterior diameter of 28 cm when the flexible lateral isocenter was used, p value = 0.01005. When the non-flexible lateral isocenter was used, the maximum achieved angulation was 54 degrees.

Figure 6.

Air-kerma rate is significantly lower for thorax anteroposterior diameter of 30 cm when the flexible lateral isocenter was used, p value = 0.01703. When the non-flexible lateral isocenter was used, the maximum achieved angulation was 50 degrees.

The Excel T Test showed that the dose when the FLIC was used was significantly lower (0.001 < p value < 0.05) than the dose when the non-FLIC was used for each thorax diameter (Figures 3 –6):

(e) For 22 cm, the p value was 0.028;

(f) For 25 cm, the p value was 0.0169;

(g) For 28 cm, the p value was 0.01005 and

(h) For 30 cm, the p value was 0.01703.

Discussion

Since the beginning of the era of endovascular treatment of cerebral aneurysms, arteriovenous malformations and fistulas, optimal visualization of these targets has been the main prerequisite for a successful treatment and the object of numerous studies.^1–3 The visualization of these vascular structures has evolved from monoplane and biplane fluoroscopy to three-dimensional (3D) rotational angiography.^4,5 Moreover, the evolution of computerized tomographic angiography as well as magnetic resonance tomographic angiography enabled almost noninvasive visualization of the angioarchitecture of cerebral aneurysms, arteriovenous malformations and fistulas without exposing patients to the risks related to trans-catheter angiography.^6–8 The preoperative, 3D visualization of cerebral vascular structures is the first and very important step in the planning of the treatment of these conditions. Since the consequences of complications that sometimes occur during endovascular intervention are often disastrous, an adequate visualization of the vascular target during treatment is essential for the appropriate choice of devices and techniques. The biplane systems have become an obligatory part of the equipment of an angiographic theater intended for neurointerventional procedures. The superiority of a biplane system compared to a monoplane system cannot be scientifically proven based on existing data in the scientific literature, but this system can definitely improve operators confidence, which should provide a better treatment in terms of reduced risk of complications and better radiological and clinical result of the intervention.⁹

All state-of-the-art biplane machines possess two arms intended for visualization of vascular structures in two planes, which are, in the neutral position, perpendicular to each other. During the intervention, the angulation of these arms is changed in order to obtain the optimal visualization of a vascular target. Both arms are constructed so that the angle between the axis of the X-rays and the detector plate is 90 degrees, and this axis always hits the intersection of the diagonals of the detector plate. This intersection, which is the geometric center of the detector plate, is referred to as the isocenter. The distance between the X-ray source and the detector plate is flexible and referred to as the source-to-image distance (SID). Beside the angulations, the only possible mobility of the lateral isocenter of all state-of-the-art biplane machines, except the Toshiba Infinix-i/BP, is the mobility in the horizontal direction. The FLIC, which enables additional mobility in the vertical direction of the lateral isocenter, is integrated in all commercially available Infinix-i/BP machines.

The amplitude of the angulation of both arms is very high regardless of the model of the bi-plane system because of the specific demands for optimal visualization of cerebral vascular structures. A factor that limits the full capacity of the angulation is the table that carries the body of the patient connected by tubes and cables with anesthetic and neurosurgical systems for monitoring and maintenance of vital functions. The amplitude of vertical movement of the FLIC is 14 cm, which corresponds to approximately 75% of a mean AP diameter of the head of an adult human.¹⁰ This means that the FLIC markedly expands the capacity of angulation of both arms and in this way contributes to easier achievement of the optimal visualization of vascular targets with challenging angioarchitecture. Our experimental work has shown that the FLIC enables such visualization with a marginal increase of SID, at least in the AP projection.

Since the beginning of the era of neurointervention, X-ray equipment has evolved tremendously in terms of improved image quality and decreased fluoroscopic and angiographic doses. This development is based on technical improvements of X-ray generators, hardware and software for acquisition of data and generation of images, as well as on the improvements in radiation-protection systems integrated into the biplane machines.^11–15 The biggest challenge to the improvement of dose-saving systems is that the image quality must be kept on an optimal level regardless of the dose reduction.¹⁶ The most frequent and the easiest way of reducing the dose is optimization of existing parameters of fluoroscopy and angiography.^16–19 Spot fluoroscopy, a qualitatively new type of asymmetric collimation, represents a breakthrough in the technology of dose-reduction systems.²⁰

The FLIC is also a qualitatively new technical solution that originally was aimed at improvement of the amplitude of angulation of both arms. Thanks to the FLIC, even extreme angulations can be achieved without or with marginal extension of the SID. Thus the FLIC also prevents the dose increase caused by the SID increase, which is inevitable if a non-FLIC system is used for achieving these angulations. This was clearly shown by our experiment.

This experimental study has certain limitations. The effect of the FLIC on the amplitude of angulation has been described only briefly and not elaborated on in detail since we assumed that this issue is comprehensible “per se.” The measurements of the dose were carried out in only the sagittal plane because measurements in several planes of both arms would involve a much more complex study design, with the same or very similar results. Finally, the only parameter we measured in this experiment was the air kerma rate.

Conclusion

The FLIC is a novel, original functionality intended for better exploitation of existing technical capabilities of the arms of a biplane angiographic machine. Our experimental work, in spite of certain methodological limitations, clearly shows that the FLIC also contributes to a significant dose reduction, at least in the AP plane. In other words, the FLIC is a functionality that effectively couples two independent but equally important functionalities of each angiographic machine.

Footnotes

Declaration of conflicting interests

The authors declared the following potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: The Unit for Neurointervention in our department is Toshiba’s reference site. AP is a Toshiba employee, an engineer, and International Clinical Development Manager.

Funding

The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

References

Wilson

Royston

Noble

et al.

Determining X-ray projections for coil treatments of intracranial aneurysms. IEEE Trans Med Imag 1999; 18: 973–980.

Guglielmi

Vinuela

Septka

et al.

Electrothrombosis of saccular aneurysms via endovascular approach: Electrochemical basis, technique and experimental. J Neurosurg 1991; 75: 1–7.

Wilson

Noble

. An adaptive segmentation algorithm for extracting arteries and aneurysms from time-of-flight MRA data. IEEE Trans Med Imag 1999; 18: 938–945.

Combaz

Levrier

Moritz

et al.

Three-dimensional rotational angiography in the assessment of the angioarchitecture of brain arteriovenous malformations. J Neuroradiol 2011; 38: 167–174.

Wong

Nawawi

Ramli

et al.

Benefits of 3D rotational DSA compared with 2D DSA in the evaluation of intracranial aneurysm. Acad Radiol 2012; 19: 701–707.

Leffers

Wagner . Neurologic complications of cerebral angiography—a retrospective study of complication rate and patient risk factors. Acta Radiol 2000; 41: 204–210.

Blanc

Seiler

Robert

et al.

Multimodal angiographic assessment of cerebral arteriovenous malformations: A pilot study. J Neurointervent Surg 2015; 7: 841–847.

Karamessini

Kagadis

Petsas

. CT angiography with three-dimensional techniques for the early diagnosis of intracranial aneurysms. Comparison with intra-arterial DSA and the surgical findings. Eur J Radiol 2004; 49: 212–223.

Bellemare

Poder

. Effectiveness of biplane angiography compared to monoplane angiography for vascular neuro-interventions: A systematic review of the literature. Clin Radiol 2017; 72: 612.e1–612.e5.

10.

Catapan MF, Okimoto ML and Boas MV. Anthropometric analysis of human head to identification of height in proper use of ballistic helmets. Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Applied Human Factors and Ergonomics AHFE 2014, Kraków, Poland, 19–23 July 2014.

11.

Kemerink

Franzen

Oei

et al.

Patient and occupational dose in neurointerventional procedures. Neuroradiology 2002; 44: 522–528.

12.

Urairat

Asavaphatiboon

Singhara Na Ayuthaya

et al.

Evaluation of radiation dose to patients undergoing interventional radiology procedures at Ramathibodi Hospital, Thailand. Biomed Imaging Interv J 2011; 7: e22.

13.

Han

Kwon

. Radiation dose reduction to the critical organ with bismuth shielding during endovascular coil embolization for cerebral aneurysms. Rad Protection Dosimetry 2013; 156: 364–371.

14.

Söderman

Mauti

Boon

et al.

Radiation dose in neuroradiography using image noise reduction technology: A population study based on 614 patients. Neuroradiology 2013; 55: 1365–1372.

15.

Theodorakou CD and Patel J. A study on patient skin doses in cerebral embolisation using radiochromic films. Poster number C-0621, Congress ECR, scientific exhibit, Vienna, Austria, 6–10 March 2014.

16.

Söderman

Holmin

Andersson

. Image noise reduction algorithm for digital subtraction angiography: Clinical results. Radiology 2013; 269: 553–560.

17.

Kahn

Gemmete

Chaudhary

et al.

Radiation dose reduction during neurointerventional procedures by modification of default settings on biplane angiography equipment. J Neurointerv Surg 2016; 8: 19–23.

18.

Pearl

Torok

Wang

et al.

Practical techniques for reducing radiation exposure during cerebral angiography procedures. J Neurointerv Surg 2015; 7: 141–145.

19.

Jang

Stidd

Schafer

. Monoplane 3D overlay roadmap versus conventional biplane 2D roadmap technique for neurointervenional procedures. Neurointervention 2016; 11: 105–113.

20.

Borota

Jangland

Åslund

et al.

Spot fluoroscopy: A novel innovative approach to reduce radiation dose in neurointerventional procedures. Acta Radiol 2017; 58: 600–608.