Debate continues on development priorities between urban and rural populations in emerging nations. A review of 33 papers on nutrition status and dietary intakes from different continents and countries found comparisons of poor urban and rural populations inconclusive. It is proposed that the two populations can never be truly comparable, and that urban-rural competition for resources is not useful. Several kinds of health and nutrition surveys could be useful for identifying priority groups and issues within the urban context.
References
1.
World Bank.Urban policy and economic development: an agenda for the 1990s.Washington, DC: World Bank, 1991.
2.
WHO.Strategies for health for all in the face of rapid urbanization: background documents.Geneva: WHO, 1991.
BastaS.S.Nutrition and health in low income urban areas of the third world. Ecol Food Nutr1977; 6: 113–24.
5.
WrayI.D.Child health interventions in urban slums: Are we neglecting the importance of nutrition?Health Pol Plan1986; (4): 299–308.
6.
LiptonM.Why poor people stay poor: a study of urban bias in world development.Cambridge, Mass, USA: Temple Smith/Harvard University Press, 1977.
7.
ChambersR.Rural development: putting the last first.London: Longman, 1983.
8.
HarphamT., LustyT., VaughanP.In the shadow of the city.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988.
9.
SudhartoP.Experiences in the field of primary health care in Jakarta. Report of the Joint UNICEF/WHO Meeting on Primary Health Care in Urban Areas, 2529 July.Geneva: WHO, 1983.
10.
MorellS., MorellD.Six slums in Bangkok: problems of life and options for actions.Bangkok: UNICEF, 1972.
11.
AustinJ.E.Confronting urban malnutrition: the design of nutrition programmer. 23rd ed.Washington, DC: World Bank, 1980.
12.
Prasada RaoT.M.V., Gowrinath SastryJ., VijayaraghavenK.Nutritional status of children in urban slums around Hyderabad city. Ind J Med Res1974; 62(10): 1492–98.
13.
Rossi-EspagnetA.Health services and environmental factors in urban slums and shanty towns of the developing world. Food Nutr Bull1987; 9(4): 4–20.
14.
ClarkW.F.The rural to urban nutritional gradient: application and interpretation in a developing nation and urban situation. Soc Sci Med1980; 14D: 31–36.
15.
GrahamG.G., MacleanW.C., KallmanC.H., RaboldJ., MellitsE.D.Urban-rural differences in the growth of Peruvian children. Am J Clin Nutr1980; 33: 338–44.
16.
LeonM.E., SerdulaM., WilliamsonD.F., NieburgP., SullivanK., BoringJ.R.Identifying the malnourished within Peru: regional variation in the performance of a nutrition indicator. Int J Epidem1990; 19: 214–16.
17.
ValverdeV., NievesI., SloanNLifestyles and nutritional status of children from different ecological areas of El Salvador. Ecol Food Nutr1980; 9: 167–77.
18.
WolfeB.L., BehrmanJ.R.Determinants of child mortality, health and nutrition in a developing country. J Dev Econ1982; 11: 163–93.
19.
IBGE/UNICEF.Perfil estatístico de crianças e mäes no Brasil: situação nutricional.Rio de Janeiro: IBGE, 1982.
20.
PickeringH., LambW.H.Urban and rural differences in seasonal stress in the Gambia. In: TaylorT.G., JenkinsN.K., eds. Proceedings of 13th International Congress of Nutrition.London: John Libbey, 1986.
21.
NnanyelugoD.O.Urbanization and nutrition. Afr Health1980; 2: 15–16.
22.
MatheS., MatovuH.L., MossopR.T.Nutritional status of an urban community in Zimbabwe. Centr Afr J Med1985; 31: 5962.
23.
MartinsMH de S., TeixeiraS.G.Hyporiboflavinosis in rural and urban pre-school age children in northeast Brazil. Ecol Food Nutr1976; 5: 101–05.
24.
FashakinJ.B., OyckanmiM.A.Evaluation of some vitamin B complex nutriture in lle-lfe and environs (Nigeria). Int J Nutr Res1986; 56: 79–84.
25.
KhanjanasthitiP., WrayJ.D.Early protein-calorie malnutrition in slum areas of Bangkok municipality 19701971. J Med Assoc Tai1974; 57: 357–66.
GrimbleR.F.A study of the pattern of clinical protein energy malnutrition in Accra from 1970 to 1978. J Trop Pediatr1981; 27: 12–14.
28.
PrimhakR.A., ChojnowskaE., PongapA.Trends in infant feeding in Port Moresby. Papua New Guinea Med J1989; 32: 113–16.
29.
ClavanoN.R.Mode of feeding and its effect on infant mortality and morbidity. J Trop Pediatr1982; 28: 28793.
30.
ShawqiA.M., El SharifA.S., LatifA.A., RuckN.F.A study of food habits of mothers and children attending rural and urban health centres in Minya, Egypt. J Trop Pediatr1985; 31: 11217.
31.
GrossR., MonteiroC.A.Urban nutrition in developing countries: some lessons to learn. Food Nutr Bull1989; 11(2): 14–20.
32.
CreanJ.T.G., LingS.C., PearsonD.J., ShawS.N., StewartR.J., WilsonJ.H.Dharavi project, 1985: an investigation into patterns of infant feeding and malnutrition in the urban slum of Dharavi in Bombay. J Trop Pediatr1987; 33(suppl. 2).
33.
SinghalP.K., MathurG.P., MathurS.Singh YD. Mortality pattems in under six children in ICDS urban slums. Ind Pediatr1986; 23: 617–22.
34.
TaverI.H., EbrahimG.J., RichardsonR.Infant mortality and undernutrition in the squatter settlements of Karachi. J Trop Pediatr1990; 36: 135–40.
35.
FloresM., Aranda-PastorJ.Evaluación dietética a nivel nacional en Costa Rica: cambios de una decade. Arch Latinoam Nutr1980; 30: 432–50.
36.
Van Ginneken. Rural and urban income inequalities.Geneva: ILO, 1976.
37.
JansenG.R., JansenN.B., ShigetomiC.T., HarperJ.M.Effect of income and geographic region on the nutritional value of diets in Brazil. Am J Clin Nutr1977; 30: 955–64.
38.
HomerM.R., DoreaJ.G., PerreiraM.G., BezerraV.L., SalomonJ.B.Inquérito dietético com base do consumo familiar: o cave de Ilhéus, Bahia, Brasil em 1979. Arch Latinoam Nutr1981; 31: 721–39.
39.
FinauS.A., PriorJ.A.M., SalmondC.E.Hypertension among urban and rural Tongans. Med J Aust1986; 144: 16–19.
40.
GilbertA., GuglerJ.Cities, poverty and development: urbanization in the third world.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1981.
