The constrained evidence base of food and nutrition policy-making compromises nutrition programs. Nutrition policy-making must do better than relying exclusively on Food and Agriculture Organization Food Balance Sheets. The strategy of relying on observed-weighed food record or 24-hour recall surveys has not proven practical either; they remain few in number, generally not nationally representative, and of dubious external validity. Although Household Consumption and Expenditures Surveys (HCES) have shortcomings, they are increasingly being used to address this information gap.
Objective
To promote dialog within the nutrition community, and between it and the greater community of HCES stakeholders, in order to identify their shared agenda and develop a strategy to improve HCES for analyzing food and nutrition issues.
Methods
The diverse origins and objectives of HCES are described, the evolution of their use in addressing food and nutrition issues is traced, and their shortcomings are identified.
Results
The causes, relative importance, some potential solutions, and the strategic implications of three distinct categories of shortcomings are discussed. Elements of a possible approach and process for strengthening the surveys are outlined, including identifying best practices, developing guidelines and more rigorously analyzing the tradeoffs involved in common, key survey design and implementation decisions.
Conclusions
To date, the nutrition community's role in most HCES has been as a passive user of secondary data. The nutrition community must become more involved in the design, implementation, and analysis of HCES by identifying criteria for prioritizing countries, establishing assessment criteria, applying the criteria in retrospective assessments, identifying key shortcomings, and recommending alternatives to ameliorate the short-comings. Several trends suggest that this is a propitious time for improving the relevance and reliability of HCES.
RileyFMockNCogillBBaileyLKenefickE. Food security indicators and framework for use in the monitoring and evaluation of food aid programs. Food and Nutrition Technical Assistance (FANTA) Project document. Washington, DC: Academy for Educational Development, 1999. Available at: www.fantaproject.org. Accessed 7 May 2012.
2.
GibsonRS. Principles of nutritional assessment, 2nd ed.New York: Oxford University Press, 2005.
3.
FiedlerJLMartin-PrévelYMoursiM. Comparing the costs of 24-hour recall Surveys and Household Consumption & Expenditures Surveys (HCES): a nutrition analysis perspective. HarvestPlus Working Paper. Washington, DC: HarvestPlus/International Food Policy Research Institute and International Relief and Development, 2011.
4.
CoatesJColaiezziBFiedlerJLWirthJLividiniKRogersB. A program needs-driven approach to selecting dietary assessment methods for decision-making in food fortification programs. Food Nutr Bull2012;33:S146–56.
5.
SteinAJNestelPMeenakshiJVQaimMSachdevHPSBhuttaZA. Plant breeding to control zinc deficiency in India: how cost-effective is biofortification?Public Health Nutr2007;10:492–501.
6.
Imhoff-KunschBFloresRDaryOMartorellR. Wheat flour fortification is unlikely to benefit the most needy in Guatemala. J Nutr2007;137:1017–22.
7.
SteinAJMenakshiJVQaimMNestelPSachdevHPSBhuttaZA. Potential impacts of iron biofortification in India. Soc Sci Med2008;66:1797–808.
8.
MeenakshiJVJohnsonNLManyongVMDeGrooteHJavelosaJYanggenDRNaherFGonzalezCGarcíaJMengE. How cost-effective is biofortification in combatting micronutrient malnutrition? An ex ante assessment. World Dev2010;38:64–75.
9.
SteinAJSachdevHPSQaimM. Genetic engineering for the poor: golden rice and public health in India. World Dev2008;36:144–58.
10.
FiedlerJLSmitzMFDupriezOFriedmanJ. Household income and expenditure surveys: a tool for accelerating the development of evidence-based fortification programs. Food Nutr Bull2008;29:319–32.
11.
FiedlerJLMacdonaldBA. A strategic approach to the unfinished fortification agenda: feasibility, costs and cost-effectiveness analysis of fortification programs in 48 countries. Food Nutr Bull2009;30:283–316.
FiedlerJLHellerantaM. Recommendations for improving Guatemala's food fortification program based on household income and expenditure survey (HIES) data. Food Nutr Bull2010;31:251–69.
14.
FiedlerJLAfidraR. Vitamin A fortification in Uganda: comparing the feasibility, coverage and cost-effectiveness of vegetable oil and sugar. Food Nutr Bull2010;31:193–205.
15.
FiedlerJLBabuSSmitzMFLividiniKBermudezO. Indian social safety net programs as platforms for introducing wheat flour fortification: a case study of Gujarat, India. Food Nutr Bull2012;33:11–30.
16.
TrichopoulouALagiouL, eds. Methodology for the exploitation of HBS food data and results on food availability for five European countries. Data Food Networking (DAFNE I), Directorate-General, Science, Research and Development, European Commission, Athens, 1997. Available at: http://www.nut.uoa.gr/downloadsENG.html. Accessed 7 May 2012.
17.
Lagiou P, Trichopoulou A, the DAFNE Contributors. The DAFNE initiative: the methodology for assessing dietary patterns across Europe using household budget survey data. Public Health Nutr2001;4:1135–42.
18.
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, School of Medicine, Department of Hygiene, Epidemiology and Medical Statistics. DAFNE-DAta Food NEtworking. Available at: http://www.nut.uoa.gr/dafneENG.html. Accessed 7 May 2012.
WeisellRDopMC. The Adult Male Equivalent concept and its application to Household Consumption and Expenditures Surveys (HCES). Food Nutr Bull2012;33:S157–62.
21.
SmithLCAldermanHAduayomD. Food insecurity in Sub-Saharan Africa: New estimates from household expenditure surveys. IFPRI Research Report 146. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute, 2006.
22.
SmithLCSubandoroA. Measuring food security using Household Expenditure Surveys. Food Security in Practice Series. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute, 2007. Available at: http://www.ifpri.org/sites/default/files/publications/sp3.pdf. Accessed 7 May 2012.
SibriánRSeevalingumRMerniesJ. Measuring hunger at sub-national levels from household surveys using the FAO approach. Statistics Division Working Paper Series, ESS 5. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization, 2008.
25.
Tanzania National Bureau of Statistics, Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs, European Community, Food and Agriculture Organization. Trends in food insecurity in mainland Tanzania. Food Security and Nutrition Analysis of Tanzania Household Budget Surveys 2000/1 and 2007. Dar es Salaam: Government of the United Republic of Tanzania, 2010.
26.
DopMCPereiraCMisturaLMartinezCCardosoE. Using Household Consumption and Expenditures Survey (HCES) data to assess dietary intake in relation to the nutrition transition: a case study from Cape Verde. Food Nutr Bull2012;33:S221–7.
27.
LambeJKearneyJBeckerWHulshofKDunneAGibneyMJ. Predicting percentage of individuals consuming foods from percentage of households purchasing foods to improve the use of household budgets in estimating food chemical intakes. Public Health Nutr1998;1:239–47.
28.
FrielSNelsonMMcCormackKKelleherCThriskosP. Methodological issues using household survey expenditure data for individual food availability estimation: Irish experience in the DAFNE pan-European project. Public Health Nutr2001;4:1143–7.
29.
NaskaAVasdekisVGSTrichopoulouA. A preliminary assessment of the use of household budget survey data for the prediction of individual food consumption. Public Health Nutr2001;4:1158–65.
30.
JarisetaRambeloson ZDaryOFiedlerJLFranklinN. Comparison of estimates of the nutrient density of the diet of women and children in Uganda by Household Consumption and Expenditures Surveys (HCES) and 24-hour recall. Food Nutr Bull2012;33:S199–207.
31.
NaskaAOikonomouETrichopoulousAWagnerKGedrichK. Estimations of daily energy and nutrient availability based on nationally representative household budget survey data. The Data Food Networking (DAFNE) project. Public Health Nutr2007;10:1422–9.
32.
NelsonMDysonPPaulAA. Family food purchases and home food consumption: comparison of nutrient contents. Br J Nutr1985;54:373–87.
33.
SekulaWNelsonMFigurskaKOltarzewskiMWeisellRSzponarL. Comparison between household budget survey and 24-hour recall data in a nationally representative sample of Polish households. Public Health Nutr2005;8:430–9.
34.
BeegleKDeWeerdtJFriedmanJGibsonJ. Methods of household consumption measurement through surveys: experimental results from Tanzania. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 5501. Washington, DC: World Bank, 2010.
35.
RavallionM. Global poverty measurement: Current practice and future challenges. PowerPoint presentation. National Academy of Sciences. A sustainability challenge: Food security for all. Workshop 2: measuring food insecurity and assessing the sustainability of global food systems. February 16, 2011. Venable LLP Conference Center, Washington, DC. Available at: http://sites.nationalacademies.org/PGA/sustainability/foodsecurity/PGA_060826. Accessed 7 May 2012.
36.
FiedlerJLLividiniKBermudezOISmitzM-F. Household Consumption and Expenditures Surveys (HCES): a primer for food and nutrition analysts in low- and middle-income countries. Food Nutr Bull2012;33:S170–84.
37.
International Labor Organization. Household income and expenditure statistics. Report II of the Seventeenth International Conference of Labor Statisticians. Geneva: International Labor Organization, 2003.
38.
GroshMGlewweP, eds. Designing household survey questionnaires for developing countries: lessons from 15 years of the Living Standards Measurement Study. Volumes 1, 2, and 3. Washington, DC: World Bank, 2000.
39.
United Nations. Handbook of household surveys. New York: United Nations, 1984.
40.
CoatesJColaiezziBFiedlerJWirthJLividiniKRogersB. Food consumption measurement methods for decision-making in food fortification and other nutrition programs: a Joint GAIN/HarvestPlus/Tufts Working Paper. Geneva: Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition, 2012.
41.
MartirosovaD. Food data collected using acquisition and consumption approaches with daily diaries in Armenia's ILCS 2004. In: SibrianR, ed. Deriving food security information from national household budget surveys: experiences, achievements, challenges. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization, 2008:59–68.
42.
PereiraCTroubatNSibrianR. Food data collected using acquisition and intake approaches in Cape Verde's IDRF 2001/2002. In: SibrianR, ed. Deriving food security information from national household budget surveys: experiences, achievements, challenges. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization, 2008:81–90.
43.
KaaraJRamasawmyS. Food data collected using acquisition and consumption approaches with a seven-day recall method in Kenya's KIHBS 2005/2006. In: SibrianR, ed. Deriving food security information from national household budget surveys: experiences, achievements, challenges. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization, 2008: 69–80.
44.
RuelMTDeitchlerMArimondM. Developing simple measures of women's diet quality in developing countries: overview. J Nutr2010;140:2048–50.
