Simultaneous Carpal Tunnel Release With Forearm Fasciotomy: Are We Doing Enough?

Abstract

Background:

Simultaneous carpal tunnel release (sCTR) with emergent forearm fasciotomy in the setting of acute compartment syndrome (ACS) has been reported, but the national incidence and cost of delayed carpal tunnel release (CTR) remain unknown. This large database study aims to evaluate how often sCTR is performed, the frequency of delayed CTR when not performed simultaneously, and the associated costs.

Methods:

The PearlDiver Mariner database was queried for patients who underwent forearm fasciotomies between January 1, 2015, and October 31, 2022. Patients were grouped based on CTR timing: simultaneous, within 2 weeks, 2 weeks to 1 year, 1 to 5 years, or no CTR. Reimbursement data were collected, and patient numbers and costs were analyzed across cohorts.

Results:

More than half of patients undergoing emergent forearm fasciotomy received sCTR. Among those who did not, 31% required CTR within 1 year and 35% within 5 years. The total cost was highest when CTR was performed within 1 year but not on the same day as fasciotomy. After 1 year, the additional cost of CTR was similar to that of patients who never underwent fasciotomy.

Conclusions:

This large database study shows that over one-third of patients who did not undergo sCTR at the time of emergent forearm fasciotomy required it within 1 year, incurring significantly higher costs. Including sCTR during initial fasciotomy may reduce delayed care and associated expenses. While these findings suggest that including sCTR during initial fasciotomy may reduce delayed care and expenses, the retrospective design precludes definitive recommendations, and clinical judgment remains essential

Level of Evidence:

4