Using a prediction model for National Football League (NFL) regular season games, we find that awarding bonuses for certain outcomes improves the ability of league standings to capture differences in team strength. Our preferred specification awards six points for a win, four points for a tie, two bonus points for losing by seven or fewer points, and one bonus point for scoring four or more touchdowns. Testing the out-of-sample performance of rankings based on this system, we find that teams advantaged by bonuses won 75% of their playoff matches, despite playing nearly all of these games on the road, and disadvantaged teams won 41% of their playoff matches. We conclude that there is significant scope for bonus points to improve the accuracy of NFL standings.
BanerjeeA. N., SwinnenJ. F. M., & WeersinkA. (2007). Skating on thin ice: Rule changes and team strategies in the NHL. Canadian Journal of Economics, 40, 493–514.
2.
BeckmanE. M., CaiW., EsrockR. M., & LemkeR. J. (2012). Explaining game-to-game ticket sales for Major League Baseball games over time. Journal of Sports Economics, 13, 536–553.
3.
BorlandJ., & MacDonaldR. (2003). Demand for sport. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 19, 478–502.
4.
BringJ., & ThuressonM. (2011). Three points for a win in soccer: Is it fair?Chance, 24(3), 47–53.
5.
BrocasI., & CarrilloJ.D. (2004). Do the three-point victory and golden goal rules make soccer more exciting?Journal of Sports Economics, 5, 169–185.
6.
DilgerΑ., & GeyerΗ. (2009). Are three points for a win really better than two?A comparison of German soccer league and cup games. Journal of Sports Economics, 10, 305–318.
7.
GuedesC. J., & MachadoF. S. (2002). Changing rewards in contest: Has the three-point rule brought more offense to soccer?Empirical Economics, 27, 607–630.
8.
KappeE., BlankA. S., & DeSarboW. S. (2014). A general multiple distributed lag framework for estimating the dynamic effects of promotions. Management Science, 60(6), 1–22.
9.
JaneW. J. (2014). The relationship between outcome uncertainties and match attendance: New evidence in the National Basketball Association. Review of Industrial Organization, 45,177–200.
MoschiniG. (2010). Incentives and outcomes in a strategic setting: The 3-points-for-a-win system in soccer. Economic Inquiry, 48, 65–79.
12.
PaulR. J., & WeinbachA. P. (2007). The uncertainty of outcome and scoring effects on Nielsen ratings for Monday night football. Journal of Economics and Business, 59, 199–211.
13.
QuinnK. G. (Ed.). (2012). The economics of the National Football League: The state of the art, New York, NY: Springer.
14.
ScarfP., YusofM. M., & BilbaoM. (2009). A numerical study of designs for sporting contests. European Journal of Operations Research, 198, 190–198.
15.
StefaniR. T. (1997). Survey of the major world sports rating systems. Journal of Applied Statistics, 24, 636–646.
16.
StefaniR. T. (2011). The methodology of officially recognized international sports rating systems. Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sport, 7(4), Article 10.
17.
SzymanskiS. (2003). The economic design of sporting contests. Journal of Economic Literature, 41, 1137–1187.
18.
TainskyS., & McEvoyC. D. (2012). Television broadcast demand in markets without local teams. Journal of Sports Economic, 13, 250–265.
19.
TainskyS., XuJ., & ZhouY. (2014). Qualifying the game uncertain effect: A game-level analysis of NFL postseason broadcast ratings. Journal of Sports Economics, 15, 219–236.
20.
VroomanJ. (2012). The economic structure of the NFL. In QuinnK. G. (Ed.), The economics of the National Football League: The state of the art (pp. 7–32). New York, NY: Springer.
21.
WinchesterN. (2008). Shifting the 'goal posts': Optimizing the allocation of competition points for sporting contests. Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports, 4(4), Article 1.
22.
WinchesterN. (2016). Scoring points: How statistics helped change a rugby competition. Significance, 13(5), 38–41.
23.
WinchesterN, & StefaniR. (2013). An innovative approach to National Football League standings using bonus points. Applied Economics, 45, 123–134.
24.
WinfreeJ. (2012). NFL franchise values, locations, and stadium economics. In QuinnK. G. (Ed.), The economics of the National Football League: The state of the art (pp. 33–54). New York, NY: Springer.
