Addressing the Small Market Problem for Canadian NHL Franchises: On-site Gaming as a New Revenue Stream

Abstract

This paper identifies the unique problems faced by Canadian small market (CSM) franchises in the National Hockey League (NHL). While featuring characteristics similar to other major leagues in North America, CSM franchises are also burdened by currency and taxation issues that favor US-based teams, as well as a reliance on gate revenues, which have exacerbated the problem for NHL teams. Three general alternatives devised to address the small market problem are introduced in this paper: (1) allow other stakeholders, such as levels of government, to subsidize weaker teams; (2) create revenue sharing agreements among teams to distribute money to weaker franchises; and (3) create artificial restraints on player salaries in order to reduce the ability of large market teams to stockpile talent (Cocco & Jones, 1997). These are reviewed in the context of the NHL and include the Mills Report and Manley proposals, the Alberta Players Tax, lotteries, revenue sharing, and salary caps. A proposal is put forward to explore the use of on-site gaming in arenas in order to provide additional revenues for Canadian-based NHL teams. The benefits of such a proposal are then reviewed, which include: (1) acting as a less regressive tax than other government subsidies by targeting game attendees; (2) having fans who already support the team provide the subsidization, eliminating those who are not followers of hockey from bearing the financial burden; and (3) enhancing the viewing experience of fans. In doing so, it is hoped that an alternative way of assisting small market Canadian teams can be achieved that does not require substantial legal or labor negotiations, while not altering the structural characteristics of the league as a whole.

Keywords

hockey gaming arena government subsidies Canada

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Azmier

J. J.

, & Roach

(2000). The ethics of charitable gaming: A survey. Gambling in Canada Research Report No. 10. December.

Bacon

(2000). Initial public offerings and professional sports teams: The regulations work, but are owners and investors listening? Seton Hall Journal of Sport Law, 10, 139-166.

Brean

D. J. S.

, & Forgione

(2003). Missing the net: The law and economics of Alberta's NHL players tax. Alberta Law Review, 41, 425-448.

Campbell

C. S.

, & Smith

G. J.

(1998). Canadian gambling: Trends and public policy issues. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 556, 22-35.

Canton

(2004, April 16). Deerfoot casino hits jackpot. Calgary Herald, p. B1.

Cocco

, & Jones

J. C. H.

(1997). On going south: The economics of survival and relocation of small market NHL franchises in Canada. Applied Economics, 29, 1537-1552.

Cohen

(2002). Sharing the wealth: Don't call us. We'll call you: Why revenue sharing is a permissive subject and therefore the labor exemption does not apply. Fordham Intellectual Property, Media and Entertainment Law Journal, 12, 609–645.

De Schriver

T. D.

, & Jensen

P. E.

(2003). What's in a name? Price variation in sport facility naming rights. Eastern Economic Journal, 29, 359–376.

Forrest

, & Simmons

(2003). Sport and gambling. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 19, 598-611.

10.

Fort

, & Quirk

(1995). Cross-subsidization, incentives, and outcomes in professional team sports leagues. Journal of Economic Literature, 33, 1265-1299.

11.

Gratton

, & Taylor

(2000). Economics of $ports and recreation. London: Taylor and Francis.

12.

Greenberg

M. J.

, & Gray

J. T.

(1996). The stadium game. Milwaukee: National Sports Law Institute.

13.

Howard

D. R.

, & Crompton

J. L.

(2004). Financing sport, 2nd edition. Morgantown, WV: Fitness Information Technology.

14.

Lavitt

(2004). The Alberta NHL players tax: The jock tax comes to Alberta—or does it? Canadian Tax Journal, 52, 514–542.

15.

Lavoie

(2000). Economics and sport. In J. Coakley & E. Dunning (Eds.), Handbook of sport studies (pp. 157–170. London: Sage.

16.

Macnaughton

, & Wood

(2004). Should provinces tax nonresident athletes? Canadian Tax Law Journal, 52, 428-485.

17.

Mason

D. S.

(1999). What is the sports product and who buys it? The marketing of professional sports leagues. European Journal of Marketing, 33, 402–418.

18.

Mason

D. S.

(2006). Expanding the footprint? Questioning the NHL's expansion and relocation strategy. In Whitson

, & Gruneau

, (Eds.), Artificial ice: Hockey, culture, and commerce pp. 181–199). Toronto: Garamond Press.

19.

McKelvey

S. M.

(2004). US professional sport organization policies shift to embrace legalized gambling entities: A roll of the dice? Journal of Legal Aspects of Sport, 14, 23–45.

20.

Moag & Company (2004, June 8). National Hockey League: Review & outlook. Baltimore: Author.

21.

National Hockey League (1999, September 14). Professional Hockey in Canada: NHL Self-Help Initiatives and Proposed Stakeholder Contributions.

22.

Neale

W. C.

(1964). The peculiar economics of professional sports. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 78, 1-14.

23.

Noll

R. G.

, & Zimbalist

(1997). Build the stadium—Create the jobs! In R. G. Noll & A. Zimbalist (Eds.) Sports, jobs, and taxes: The economic impact of sports teams and stadiums (pp. 1–54). Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

24.

Petersen

D. C.

(2001). Developing sports, convention, and performing arts centers (3rd ed.). Washington DC: Urban Land Institute.

25.

Pogroszewski

(2004). Is Canada overstepping its borders? The Alberta province tax specifically targets professional hockey players in order to help finance its professional hockey franchises. Marquette Sports Law Review, 14, 509–524.

26.

Public Policy Forum (1999, October). The National Hockey League in Canada.

27.

Scherer

, & Jackson

S. J.

(2004). From corporate welfare to national interest: Newspaper analysis of the public subsidization of NHL hockey debate in Canada. Sociology of Sport Journal, 21, 36–60.

28.

Schmoll

R. A.

(2003). NAFTA Chapter 11 and professional sports in Canada. Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, 36, 1027-1072.

29.

Silver

(1996). Thin ice: Money, politics, and the demise of an NHL franchise. Halifax, NS: Fernwood Publishing.

30.

Sloane

P. J.

(2002). The regulation of professional team sports. In Barros

C. P.

, Ibrahimo

, & S. Szymanski (Eds.) Transatlantic sport: The comparative economics of North American and European Sports (pp. 50–68). Cheltenham, UK: Edward Algar.

31.

Smith

G. J.

(1990). Pools, parlays, and point spreads: A sociological consideration of the legalization of sports gambling. Sociology of Sport Journal, 8, 271-286.

32.

Smith

G. J.

(1992). Sucker bet or sure thing: A critical analysis of sports lotteries. Journal of Gambling Studies, 8, 331-349.

33.

Staudohar

P. D.

(2005). The hockey lockout of 2004-05. Monthly Labor Review, December, 23–29.

34.

Szymanski

(2003). The assessment: The economics of sport. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 19, 467-477.

35.

Tychkowski

(2004, September 24). NHL shutdown may cut $75M swath through gaming industry. Edmonton Sun.

36.

Whitson

, Harvey

, & Lavoie

(2004). Government subsidization of professional sports franchises: A risky business. In T. Slack (Ed.), The commercialization of sport (pp. 75–100). London: Routledge.