Reflecting on research following formerly incarcerated Massachusetts women for more than a decade, this paper questions whether conventional understandings of recidivism and desistance are meaningful frames for understanding women’s life trajectories. Drawing on our ongoing ethnographic work we argue that conventional measures of recidivism and desistance tend to (1) overstate the significance of distinctions between licit and illicit behavior—especially for women, (2) undervalue macro/structural and institutionalized barriers to stable housing and employment, (3) overly focus on individual choices and narratives in contexts where freedoms are constrained by structural and institutional policies and practices, (4) overlook the risks and erratic nature of daily and family life for women and other vulnerable, marginalized and poorly-resourced populations.
AbellL. (2018). Exploring the transition to parenthood as a pathway to desistance. Journal of Developmental and Life-Course Criminology, 4(4), 395–426.
2.
AbramsL. S.TerryD. (2017). Everyday desistance: The transition to adulthood among formerly incarcerated youth. Rutgers University Press.
3.
AlexanderM. (2010). The new Jim Crow: Mass incarceration in the age of colorblindness. The New Press.
4.
BakerW. (2005). America’s crisis of values. Princeton University Press.
5.
BaschN. (1986). The emerging legal history of women in the United States: Property, divorce, and constitution. Signs, 12(10), 97–117.
6.
BeckerM. A.AndelR.BoazT.ConstantineR. (2011). Gender differences and risk of arrest among offenders with serious mental illness. The Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research, 38(1), 16–28.
7.
BersaniB. E.DohertyE. E. (2018). Desistance from offending in the twenty-first century. Annual Review of Criminology, 1(1), 311–334.
8.
BlackburnA. G.PfefferR. D.HarrisJ. A. (2016). Serious about change: A gendered examination of the impact of offense type on parole success. Women & Criminal Justice, 26(5), 340–353.
9.
BurkeL.CollettS.McNeillF. (2018). Reimagining rehabilitation: Beyond the individual. Routledge.
10.
ButtsJ. A.SchiraldiV. (2018). Recidivism reconsidered: Preserving the community justice mission of community corrections. Program in Criminal Justice Policy and Management, Harvard Kennedy School, March2018.
11.
CalverleyA. (2013). Cultures of desistance: Rehabilitation, reintegration and ethnic minorities. Routledge.
12.
DeckerS. H.SpohnC.Ortiz NatalieR.HedbergE. (2014). Criminal stigma, race, gender, and employment: An expanded assessment of the consequences of imprisonment for employment. Department of Justice. https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/244756.pdf
13.
DeweyS.WeselyJ.EplarR.ConnollyC.ZareB.BrattonR. (2018). Ontologies of blame and the cultural value of accountability: Formerly incarcerated women’s narratives. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 42(1), 88–104.
14.
DohertyE. E.BersaniB. E. (2016). Understanding the mechanisms of desistance at the intersection of race, gender, and neighborhood context. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 53(5), 681–710.
15.
DohertyE. E.BersaniB. E. (2018). Mapping the age of official desistance for adult offenders: Implications for research and policy. Journal of Developmental and Life-Course Criminology, 4(4), 516–551.
16.
DohertyE. E.EnsmingerM. E. (2013). Marriage and offending among a cohort of disadvantaged African Americans. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 50(1), 104–131.
17.
DurnescuI. (2019). Pains of re-entry revisited. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 63(8), 1482–1498.
18.
EnnsP. K.YiY.ComfortM.GoldmanA. W.LeeH.MullerC.WakefieldS.WangE. A.WildemanC. (2019) What percentage of Americans have ever had a family member incarcerated?: Evidence from the Family History of Incarceration Survey (FamHIS). Socius: Sociological Research for a Dynamic World, 5, 237802311982933.
19.
EricksonP.E.EricksonS. K. (2008). Crime, punishment, and mental illness: Law and the behavioral sciences in conflict. Rutgers University Press.
20.
FarrallS.BottomsA.ShaplandJ. (2010). Social structures and desistance from crime. European Journal of Criminology, 7(6), 546–570.
21.
FarrallS.HunterB.SharpeG.CalverleyA. (2014). Criminal careers in transition: The social context of desistance from crime. Oxford University Press.
22.
GålnanderR. (2020). Desistance from crime—to what? Exploring future aspirations and their implications for processes of desistance. Feminist Criminology, 15(3), 255–277.
23.
GiordanoP. C. (2016). Mechanisms underlying the desistance process: reflections on ‘A theory of cognitive transformation’. In ShaplandJ.FarrallS.BottomsA. (Eds.), Global perspectives on desistance: Reviewing what we know and looking to the future (pp. 11–27). Routledge.
24.
GiordanoP. C.CernkovichS.A.RudolphJ. L. (2002). Gender, crime, and desistance: Toward a theory of cognitive transformation. American Journal of Sociology, 107(4), 990–1064.
25.
GrattetR.LinJ.PetersiliaJ. (2011). Supervision regimes, risk, and official reactions to parolee deviance. Criminology, 49(2), 371–399.
26.
GuetaK.ChenG. (2019). Missed opportunities: Perspectives of incarcerated Israeli women and men on their unsuccessful desistance. Feminist Criminology, 14(2), 241–262.
27.
GurusamiS. (2019). Motherwork under the state: The maternal labor of formerly incarcerated Black women. Social Problems, 66(1), 128–143.
28.
HalseyM.ArmstrongR.WrightS. (2017). ‘F*ck it!’: Matza and the mood of fatalism in the desistance process. British Journal of Criminology, 57(5), 1041–1060.
29.
HannonL.DeFinaR. (2010). The state of the economy and the relationship between prisoner reentry and crime. Social Problems, 57(4), 611–629.
JonesS. (2011). Under pressure: Women who plead guilty to crimes they have not committed. Criminology & Criminal Justice, 11(1), 77–90.
32.
KingS. (2013). Transformative agency and desistance from crime. Criminology & Criminal Justice, 13(3), 317–335.
33.
LeverentzA. M. (2011). Being a good daughter and sister: Families of origin in the reentry of African American female ex-prisoners. Feminist Criminology, 6(4), 239–267.
34.
LeverentzA. M. (2014). The ex-prisoner’s dilemma: How women negotiate competing narratives of reentry and desistance. Rutgers University Press.
35.
MartinezD. J. (2013). Former prisoners, their family members, and the transformative potential of support. In VeyseyB.ChristianJ.MartinezD. (Eds.), How offenders transform their lives (pp. 56–71). Willan.
36.
MarunaS. (2001). Making good: How ex-convicts reform and rebuild their lives. American Psychological Association Washington.
37.
MarunaS. (2017). Desistance as a social movement. Irish Probation Journal, 14(1), 5–20.
MillerJ.Carbone-LopezK.GundermanM. V. (2015). Gendered narratives of self, addiction, and recovery among women methamphetamine users. In PresserL.SandbergS. (Eds.), Narrative criminology: Understanding stories of crime (pp. 69–95). New York University Press.
42.
MorashM. (2009). Parole supervision, change in the self, and desistance from substance use and crime. In VeyseyB. M.ChristianJ.MartinezD. J. (Eds.), How offenders transform their lives (pp. 124–143). Willan.
NguyenH.LoughranT. A. (2018). On the measurement and identification of turning points in criminology. Annual Review of Criminology, 1(1), 335–358.
45.
NugentB.SchinkelM. (2016). The pains of desistance. Criminology and Criminal Justice, 16(5), 568–584.
46.
O’BrienP. (2001). Making it in the free world: Women in transition from prison. SUNY Press.
47.
OpsalT. (2012). ‘Livin’ on the straights’: Identity, desistance, and work among women post-incarceration. Sociological Inquiry, 82(3), 378–403.
48.
OpsalT. (2014). It’s their world, so you’ve just got to get through”: Women’s experiences of parole governance. Feminist Criminology, 10(2), 188–207.
49.
OwenB. (2009). Accounts of change and resistance among women prisoners. In VeyseyB. M.ChristianJ.MartinezD. J. (Eds.), How offenders transform their lives (pp. 117–136). Willan.
50.
PollackS. (2005). Taming the shrew: Regulating prisoners through women-centered mental health programming. Critical Criminology, 13(1), 71–87.
51.
PrescottJ. J.StarrS. B. (2019). Expungement of criminal convictions: An empirical study. University of Michigan Law & Economics Research Paper, (19-001).
52.
PresserL.SandbergS. (2015). Introduction: What is the story. Narrative criminology: Understanding stories of crime (pp. 1–20). New York University Press.
53.
RodermondE.KruttschnittC.SlotboomA.BijleveldC. C. (2016). Female desistance: A review of the literature. European Journal of Criminology, 13(1), 3–28.
54.
RyanG. W.BernardH. R. (2000). Data management and analysis methods. In DensinN. K.LincolnY. S. (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research (2nd ed., pp. 769–802). Sage Publications.
55.
SampsonR. J.LaubJ. H. (1996). Socioeconomic achievement in the life course of disadvantaged men: Military service as a turning point, circa 1940-1965. American Sociological Review, 61, 347–367.
56.
SampsonR.J.LaubJ. H. (2003). Desistance from crime over the life course. In: MortimerJ. T.ShanahanM. J. (Eds.), Handbook of the life course. Springer.
SavitskyD. (2012). Is plea bargaining a rational choice? Plea bargaining as an engine of racial stratification and overcrowding in the United States prison system. Rationality and Society, 24(2), 131–167.
SchinkelM.AtkinsonC.AndersonS. (2010). ‘Well-kent faces’: Policing persistent offenders and the possibilities for desistance. The British Journal of Criminology, 59(3), 634–652.
61.
SchneiderV. (2018). The Prison to Homelessness Pipeline: Criminal Record Checks, Race, and Disparate Impact. Indiana Law Journal, 93(2), 421–455.
62.
SeredS.Norton-HawkM. (2011). Whose higher power?: Criminalized women confront the “Twelve Steps.”Feminist Criminology, 6(4), 308–332.
63.
SeredS.Norton-HawkM. (2014). Can’t catch a break: Gender, jail, drugs, and the limits of personal responsibility. University of California Press.
SeredS. (forthcoming). Diminished citizenship in the era of mass criminalization. Punishment and Society.
66.
SimpsonG. M.Lawrence-WebbC. (2009). Responsibility without community resources: Informal kinship care among low-income, African American grandmother caregivers. Journal of Black Studies, 39(6), 825–847.
67.
SkardhamarT.SavolainenJ. (2016). Timing of change: Are life course transitions causes or consequences of desistance? In ShaplandJ.FarrallS.BottomsA. (Eds.), Global perspectives on desistance (pp. 170–185). Routledge.
68.
SoyerM. (2014). The imagination of desistance: A juxtaposition of the construction of incarceration as a turning point and the reality of recidivism. British Journal of Criminology, 54(1), 91–108.
69.
StoneR.MorashM.GoodsonM.SmithS.CobbinaJ. (2018). Women on parole, identity processes, and primary desistance. Feminist Criminology, 13(4), 382–403.
70.
StraussA.CorbinJ. (2000). Grounded theory: An overview. In DenzinN. K.LincolnY. S. (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research (2nd ed., pp. 273–285). Sage.
71.
SugieN. F.TurneyK. (2018). Beyond incarceration: Criminal justice contact and mental health. American Sociological Review, 83(4), 719–743.
72.
TaxmanF. S.ByrneJ. M.PattavinaA. (2005). Racial disparity and the legitimacy of the criminal justice system: exploring consequences for deterrence. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 16(4 Suppl. 5), 57–77.
73.
UggenC.BlahnikL. (2016). The increasing stickiness of public labels. In ShaplandJ.FarrallS.BottomsA. (Eds.), Global perspectives on desistance (pp. 222–243). Routledge.
74.
UggenC.ManzaJ.ThompsonM. (2006). Citizenship, democracy, and the civic reintegration of criminal offenders. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 605(1), 281–310.
75.
Van RoeyenS.AndersonS.VanderplasschenW.ColmanC.Vander LaenenF. (2017). Desistance in drug-using offenders: A narrative review. European Journal of Criminology, 14(5), 605–625.
76.
WacquantL. (2010). Prisoner reentry as myth and ceremony. Dialectical Anthropology, 34(4), 605–620.
77.
WelshM. (2019). How formerly incarcerated women confront the limits of caring and the burdens of control amid California’s carceral realignment. Feminist Criminology, 14(1), 89–114.
78.
WesternB. (2018). Homeward: Life in the year after prison. Russell Sage Foundation.
