Abstract
This article analyzes coverage of the Stanford, California rape case, using a qualitative thematic press analysis to demonstrate how “rape culture” and penal populist framing intersected. Pulling from national newspapers, as well as diverse online fora, we show how characteristics of the case such as the perceived leniency toward the accused were featured in rape culture and penal populist narratives. In addition, we document a counternarrative that critiqued feminism to pit antirape activists against justice reformers, framing the case as exemplifying a “culture of mass incarceration.” We discuss the significance of this in the context of broader justice reform.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.Alliance for Safety and Justice . (2016 ). Crime survivor’s speak: The first national survey of victims’ views on safety and justice . Oakland : Author . Retrieved from https://www.allianceforsafetyandjustice.org/wp-content/uploads/documents/Crime%20Survivors%20Speak%20Report.pdf
2.
Baker
C. N.
Bevacqua
M.
(2017 ). Challenging narratives of the anti-rape movement’s decline . Violence Against Women , 35 , 1 -27 .
3.
Baker
K. M.
(2016 , June 3 ). Here is the powerful letter the Stanford victim read aloud to her attacker . BuzzFeed News . Retrieved from https://www.buzzfeed.com/katiejmbaker/heres-the-powerful-letter-the-stanford-victim-read-to-her-ra?utm_term=.vy2wkrkyg#.ji4olgVb
4.
Barchenger
S.
(2017 , May 4 ). Third player in Vanderbilt rape case headed to trial . The Tennessean . Retrieved from http://www.tennessean.com/story/news/crime/2017/05/04/third-player-vanderbilt-rape-case-headed-trial-brandon-banks/100641602/
5.
Baysinger
T.
(2016 , June ). How BuzzFeed became the outlet that made the Stanford rape victim’s letter go viral . Adweek . Retrieved from http://www.adweek.com/digital/how-buzzfeed-became-outlet-make-stanford-rape-victims-letter-go-viral-171870/
6.
Bazelon
E.
(2016 , June 9 ). Why the Stanford rape conviction actually represents progress . New York Times Magazine . Retrieved from http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/06/09/magazine/why-the-stanford-rape-conviction-actually-represents-progress.html?emc=edit_tnt_20160610&nlid=73413358&tntemail0=y&_r=0&referer=
7.
Berlatsky
N.
(2016 , June 17 ). Why sex offender registries don’t work . Quartz . Retrieved from https://qz.com/708265/why-sex-offender-registries-dont-work/
8.
Bernstein
E.
(2012 ). Carceral politics as gender justice? The “traffic in women” and neoliberal circuits of crime, sex, and rights . Theory and Society , 41 , 233 -259 .
9.
Bever
L.
(2016 , September 1 ). After Brock Turner’s “soft” sentence, lawmakers approve stricter punishments for sexual assaults . Chicago Tribune . Retrieved from http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-california-sex-assault-legislation-20160901-story.html
10.
Bottoms
A.
(1995 ). The philosophy and politics of punishment and sentencing . In
Clarkson
C.
Morgan
R.
(Eds.), The politics of sentencing reform (pp. 17 -49 ). London, England : Clarendon Press .
11.
Braun
V.
Clarke
V.
(2006 ). Using thematic analysis in psychology . Qualitative Research in Psychology , 3 , 77 -101 . doi:10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
12.
Brennan
C.
(2016 , August 26 ). Brock Turner judge Aaron Persky accused of leniency against another athlete . Daily News . Retrieved from http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/judge-aaron-persky-accused-leniency-athlete-article-1.2767622
13.
Brodsky
A.
Simonich
C.
(2016 , August 11 ). Helping rape victims after the Brock Turner case . The New York Times . Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/11/opinion/rape-victims-deserve-better-mandatory-minimums-wont-help.html?_r=0
14.
Buchwald
E.
Fletcher
P. R.
Roth
M.
(Eds.). (2005 ). Transforming a rape culture . Minneapolis, MN : Milkweed Editions .
15.
Bumiller
K.
(2008 ). In an abusive state: How neoliberalism appropriated the feminist movement against sexual violence . Durham, NC : Duke University Press .
16.
Burgess-Proctor
A.
(2006 ). Intersections of race, class, gender, and crime future directions for feminist criminology . Feminist Criminology , 1 , 27 -47 . doi:10.1177/1557085105282899
17.
Calefati
J.
Murphy
K.
(2016 , December 19 ). D.A. Jeff Rosen introduces bill to send “next Brock Turner” to prison . The Mercury News . Retrieved from http://www.mercurynews.com/2016/06/22/d-a-jeff-rosen-introduces-bill-to-send-next-brock-turner-to-prison/
18.
Cate
S.
(2016 , July 8 ). Beyond panic and punishment: Brock Turner and the left response to sexual violence . Common Dreams . Retrieved from https://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/07/18/beyond-panic-and-punishment-brock-turner-and-left-response-sexual-violence
19.
Chammah
M.
(2016 , June 16 ). Could removing Brock Turner’s judge hurt poor and minority defendants? The Marshall Project . Retrieved from https://www.themarshallproject.org/2016/06/16/could-removing-brock-turner-s-judge-hurt-poor-and-minority-defendants#.ium6nw9h3
20.
Charmaz
K.
(2006 ). Constructing Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide through Qualitative Analysis (1st ed .). Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage Publications Ltd .
21.
Chesney-Lind
M.
(2006 ). Patriarchy, crime, and justice: Feminist criminology in an era of backlash . Feminist Criminology , 1 , 6 -26 . doi:10.1177/1557085105282893
22.
Clark
M.
(2016 , August 2 ). The fight to recall the Stanford rape case judge is heating up . Glamour . Retrieved from http://www.glamour.com/story/the-fight-to-recall-the-stanford-rape-case-judge-is-heating-up
23.
Clear
T.
Frost
N. A.
(2014 ). The punishment imperative: The rise and fall of mass incarceration in America . New York : New York University Press .
24.
Corrigan
R.
(2013 ). Up Against a Wall: Rape Reform and the Failure of Success . New York : New York University Press .
25.
Crocker
L.
(2016 , December 15 ). Donald Trump, Roger Ailes, Bill Cosby, and the sex assault scandals of 2016 . Daily Beast . Retrieved from https://www.thedailybeast.com/donald-trump-roger-ailes-bill-cosby-and-the-sex-assault-scandals-of-2016
26.
Curtis-Fawley
S.
Daly
K.
(2005 ). Gendered violence and restorative justice . Violence Against Women , 11 , 603 -638 .
27.
Daly
K.
Bouhours
B.
(2010 ). Rape and attrition in the legal process: A comparative analysis of five countries . Crime and Justice , 39 , 565 -650 .
28.
DeKeseredy
W. S.
(2011 ). Violence against women: Myths, facts, controversies . Toronto, Ontario, Canada : University of Toronto Press, Higher Education Division .
29.
Dvorak
P.
(2016 ). The Stanford attacker’s smiling photo is far more telling than any mugshot . The Washington Post , p. B04 .
30.
Entman
R.
(1993 ). Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm . Journal of Communications , 43 (4 ), 51 -58 .
31.
Fantz
A.
Willis
A.
(2016 , June 9 ). Stanford rape case: Who is the judge who gave Brock Turner 6 months? CNN . Retrieved from http://www.cnn.com/2016/06/08/us/aaron-persky-brock-turner-stanford-rape/
32.FAQs . (n.d.). Retrieved from http://endrapeoncampus.org/faq/
33.
Ferrell
J.
Hayward
K.
Young
J.
(2008 ). Cultural Criminology: An Invitation (1st ed .). Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
34.
Ferrell
J.
Hayward
K.
Young
J.
(2015 ). Cultural criminology: An invitation (2nd ed. ). Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
35.
Garcia
C.
(2016 , September 16 ). California redefines rape . California State Assembly . Retrieved from https://a58.asmdc.org/press-release/california-redefines-rape
36.
Garland
D.
(2002 ). The culture of control: Crime and social order in contemporary society . Chicago, IL : The University Of Chicago Press .
37.
Gavey
N.
(2013 ). Just sex? The cultural scaffolding of rape . New York, NY : Routledge .
38.
Gersen
J. S.
(2016 , June 17 ). The unintended consequences of the Stanford rape-case recall . The New Yorker . Retrieved from http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-unintended-consequences-of-the-stanford-rape-case-recall
39.
Goffman
E.
(1961 ). Asylums: Essays on the social situation of mental patient and other inmates . New York, NY : Anchor Books .
40.
Golding
B.
(2016 , June 7 ). Rage at Stanford rapist pa Calls son’s attack “20 minuts of action .” New York Post , p. 17 .
41.
Goodwin-Smith
O.
(2016 , June 8 ). Twitter claps back at letter written by dad of Stanford student convicted of sexual assault . USA Today College . Retrieved from http://college.usatoday.com/2016/06/08/twitter-claps-back-at-letter-written-by-ex-stanford-students-dad/
42.
Gotell
L.
(2015 ). Reassessing the place of criminal law reform in the struggle against sexual violence: A critique of the critique of carceral feminism . In
Powell
A.
Henry
N.
Flynn
A.
(Eds.), Rape justice: Beyond the criminal law (pp. 53 -71 ). Hampshire, UK : Palgrave Macmillan .
43.
Gottschalk
M.
(2006 ). The prison and the gallows: The politics of mass incarceration in America . New York, NY : Cambridge University Press .
44.
Gottschalk
M.
(2014 ). Caught: The Prison State and the Lockdown of American Politics . Princeton : Princeton University Press .
45.
Greer
C.
McLaughlin
E.
(2013 ). The Sir Jimmy Savile scandal: Child sexual abuse and institutional denial at the BBC . Crime Media Culture , 9 , 243 -263 .
46.
Griffin
S.
(1971 , September ). Rape: The all-American crime . Ramparts Magazine , pp. 26 -35 .
47.
Grigoriadis
V.
(2017 ). Blurred lines: Rethinking sex, power, and consent on campus . Boston, MA : Houghton Mifflin .
48.
Halley
J.
(2008 ). Rape at Rome: Feminist Interventions in the Criminalization of Sex-Related Violence in Positive International Criminal Law . Michigan Journal of International Law , 30 , 1 -124 .
49.
Handa
R.
(2016 , June 21 ). Bay area legal professionals oppose efforts to recall judge Aaron Persky . NBC . Retrieved from http://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/Bay-Area-Legal-Professionals-Oppose-Efforts-to-Recall-Judge-Aaron-Persky-383883831.html
50.
Henry
N.
Powell
A.
(Eds.). (2014 ). Preventing sexual violence: Interdisciplinary approaches to overcoming a rape culture . London, England : Palgrave Macmillan .
51.
Herman
J.
(2005 ). Justice from the victim’s perspective . Violence Against Women , 11 , 571 -602 .
52.
Hill
L.
(2017 , October 6 ). Trump’s “Access Hollywood” video playing on 12-hour loop at D.C.’s National Mall . LA Times . Retrieved from http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/la-et-entertainment-news-updates-trump-s-access-hollywood-video-gets-1507311329-htmlstory.html
53.
Horowitz
E.
(2014 ). Protecting our kids? How sex offender laws are failing us . New York, NY : Praeger .
54.
Iyengar
S.
(1994 ). Is anyone responsible? How television frames political issues (1st ed. ). Chicago, IL : The University of Chicago Press .
55.
Jewkes
Y.
(2010 ). Media & crime (2nd ed. ). London, UK : Sage .
56.
Johnson
K. C.
Taylor
S.
(2017 ). The Campus Rape Frenzy: The attack on due process at America’s universities . New York, NY : Encounter Books .
57.
Johnson-Cartee
K. S.
(2005 ). News narratives and news framing: Constructing political reality . Rowman & Littlefield .
58.
Kaplan
T.
(2016 , September 03 ). Brock Turner: A sex offender for life, he faces stringent rules . The Mercury News . Retrieved from http://www.mercurynews.com/2016/09/02/brock-turner-a-sex-offender-for-life-he-faces-stringent-rules/
59.
Kaplan
T.
(2017 , January 24 ). Judicial commission backs Judge Persky in Brock Turner sentence . The Mercury News . Retrieved from http://www.mercurynews.com/2016/12/19/judicial-commission-backs-judge-persky-in-brock-turner-sentence/
60.
Kaukinen
C.
Miller
M.
Powers
R.
(Eds.). (2017 ). Addressing violence against women on college campuses . Philadelphia, PA : Temple University Press .
61.
Khan
S.
(2016 a, June 7 ). Debriefing and defending the Brock Turner sentence . Closing Arguments . Retrieved from http://thesajidakhan.tumblr.com/post/145573169734/debriefing-and-defending-the-brock-turner-sentence
62.
Khan
S
. (2016 b). A letter in support of judge Aaron Persky and judicial discretion . Retrieved from https://www.change.org/p/california-commission-on-judicial-performance-a-letter-in-support-of-judge-aaron-persky-and-judicial-discretion
63.
Khan
S.
(2016 c, June 24 ). Op-Ed: In defense of Brock Turner’s “lenient” sentence . San Jose Inside . Retrieved from http://www.sanjoseinside.com/2016/06/24/op-ed-in-defense-of-brock-turners-lenient-sentence/
64.
Kingkade
T.
(2016 , June 6 ). Brock Turner’s dad gave tone-deaf plea for lenient sentence in son’s sexual assault case . Huffington Post . Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/brock-turner-dad-action-stanford-sexual-assault_us_57548e2fe4b0c3752dcdf574
65.
Kipnis
L.
(2017 ). Unwanted advances: Sexual paranoia comes to campus . New York, NY : Harper .
66.
Koss
M. P.
Wilgus
J. K.
Williamsen
K. M.
(2014 ). Campus sexual misconduct: Restorative justice approaches to enhance compliance with Title IX guidance . Trauma, Violence, & Abuse , 15 , 242 -257 .
67.
Larimer
S.
(2016 , September 30 ). In aftermath of Brock Turner case, California’s governor signs sex crime bill . The Washington Post . Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/grade-point/wp/2016/09/30/in-aftermath-of-brock-turner-case-californias-governor-signs-sex-crime-bill/?utm_term=.06bbf702b343
68.
Leon
C.
(2011 ). Sex fiends, perverts, and pedophiles: Understanding sex crime policy in America . New York : New York University Press .
69.
Levin
S.
Walters
J.
(2016 , June 6 ). Judge in Stanford sexual assault case faces recall effort over light sentence . The Guardian . Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jun/06/stanford-sexual-assault-judge-recall
70.
Lewis
R.
Marine
S.
Kenney
K.
(2016 ). “I get together with my friends and try to change it.” Young feminist students resist “laddism”, “Rape culture” and “everyday sexism” . Journal of Gender Studies , 11 , 1 -17 .
71.
McGlynn
C.
Downes
J.
Westmarland
N.
(2017 ). Seeking justice for survivors of sexual violence: Recognition, voice and consequences . In
Zinsstag
E.
Keenan
M.
(Eds.), Sexual violence and restorative justice: Legal, social and therapeutic dimensions (pp. 1 -11 ). Routledge .
72.
Mendelberg
T.
(1997 ). Executing Hortons: Racial crime in the 1988 presidential campaign . The Public Opinion Quarterly , 61 , 134 -157 .
73.
Merlan
A.
(2016 ). After the Brock Turner case, would recalling judge Aaron Persky really achieve anything? Jezebel . Retrieved from http://jezebel.com/after-the-brock-turner-case-would-recalling-judge-aaro-1782299942
74.
Miller
M.
(2016 , June 6 ). “A steep price to pay for 20 minutes of action: Dad defends Stanford sex offender .” The Washington Post . Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/06/06/a-steep-price-to-pay-for-20-minutes-of-action-dad-defends-stanford-sex-offender/?utm_term=.76cdad874afb
75.
Pallotta
F.
(2016 , June 6 ). Why Ashleigh Banfield read Stanford rape victim’s letter on CNN . CNN . Retrieved from http://money.cnn.com/2016/06/06/media/ashleigh-banfield-cnn-stanford-letter/
76.
Pattis
N.
(2016 , June 15 ). Bonds of civil society dissolving in name of righteousness . New Haven Register . Retrieved from http://www.nhregister.com/opinion/20160615/norm-pattis-bonds-of-civil-society-dissolving-in-name-of-righteousness
77.
Pauly
M.
(2016 , June 9 ). Read Joe Biden’s open letter to the Stanford survivor of sexual assault . Mother Jones . Retrieved from http://www.motherjones.com/media/2016/06/read-joe-bidens-open-letter-stanford-suvivor-sexual-assault
78.People v. Brock Allen Turner . (2016 , June 10 ). People v. Brock Allen Turner (1/9) . Los Angeles Times . Retrieved from http://documents.latimes.com/people-v-brock-allen-turner-19/
79.Pew Charitable Trusts . (2016 , October 21 ). The public strongly supports cost-effective alternatives to incarceration: Polling and surveys on the criminal justice system and reform efforts . Retrieved from http://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/collections/2016/10/the-public-strongly-supports-cost-effective-alternatives-to-incarceration
80.
Pfaff
J.
(2017 ). Locked in: The true causes of mass incarceration and how to achieve real reform . New York, NY : Basic Books .
81.
Phipps
A.
Ringrose
J.
Renold
E.
Jackson
C.
(2017 ). Rape culture, lad culture and everyday sexism: Researching, conceptualizing and politicizing new mediations of gender and sexual violence . Journal of Gender Studies , 27 , 1 -7 .
82.
Powell
A.
(2015 ). Seeking rape justice: Formal and informal responses to sexual violence through technosocial counter-publics (1st ed.). Theoretical Criminology , 19 , 571 -588 .
83.
Powell
A.
Henry
N.
Flynn
A.
(Eds.). (2015 ). Rape justice: Beyond the criminal law . Hampshire, UK : Palgrave Macmillan .
84.
Pratt
J.
(2006 ). Penal populism . London, England : Routledge .
85.
Phillips
N. D.
(2016 ). Beyond Blurred Lines: Rape Culture in Popular Media . Lanham, Maryland : Rowman & Littlefield Publishers .
86.
Richie
B.
(2012 ). Arrested justice: Black women, violence, and America’s prison nation . New York : New York University Press .
87.
Rocha
V.
Mejia
B.
(2016 , June 10 ). Stanford swimmer convicted of sex assault lied about never partying, documents show . Los Angeles Times . Retrieved from http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-stanford-rape-case-documents-release-20160610-snap-htmlstory.html
88.
Salinger
T.
(2016 ). Out of Order: Push to oust judge for Stanford rape wrist-slap . New York Daily News, p. 17 .
89.
Sanchez
R.
(2016 , June 11 ). Stanford rape case: Inside the court documents . CNN . Retrieved from http://www.cnn.com/2016/06/10/us/stanford-rape-case-court-documents/
90.
Sered
D.
(2017 ). Accounting for violence: How to increase safety and break our failed reliance on mass incarceration . Common Justice, Vera Institute of Justice. Retrieved from https://www.vera.org/publications/accounting-for-violence
91.
Shibley
R.
(2016 ). Twisting Title IX . New York, NY : Encounter Books .
92.
Sills
S.
Pickens
C.
Beach
K.
Jones
L.
Calder-Dawe
O.
Benton-Greig
P.
Gavey
N.
(2016 ). Rape culture and social media: Young critics and a feminist counterpublic . Feminist Media Studies , 16 (6 ), 1 -17 .
93.
Smith
S. G.
Chen
J.
Basile
K. C.
Gilbert
L. K.
Merrick
M. T.
Patel
N.
Jain
A.
(2017 ). The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey (NISVS): 2010-2012 State Report . Atlanta, GA : National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention .
94.
Stack
L.
(2016 , June 6 ). Light sentence for Brock Turner in Stanford rape case draws outrage . The New York Times . Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/07/us/outrage-in-stanford-rape-case-over-dueling-statements-of-victim-and-attackers-father.html?_r=0
95.
Temkin
J.
Krahé
B.
(2008 ). Sexual assault and the justice gap: A question of attitude . Portland, OR : Hart .
96.
Thuma
E.
(2015 ). Lessons in self-defense: Gender violence, racial criminalization, and anticarceral feminism . WSQ: Women’s Studies Quarterly , 43 (3 ), 52 -71 .
97.Title IX . (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.knowyourix.org/college-resources/title-ix/
98.
Wade
L.
(2017 ). American hookup: The new culture of sex on campus . New York, NY : W.W. Norton .
99.White House . (2017 ). The second report of the White House task force to protect students from sexual assault . Retreived from https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/images/Documents/1.4.17.VAW%20Event.TF%20Report.PDF
100.
Woolf
N.
(2016 , June 24 ). Stanford sexual assault: Public defenders support judge in open letter . The Guardian . Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jun/24/stanford-sexual-assault-public-defenders-support-judge
101.
Zaleski
K. L.
Gundersen
K. K.
Baes
J.
Estupinian
E.
Vergara
A.
(2016 ). Exploring rape culture in social media forums . Computers in Human Behavior , 63 , 922 -927 .