Ethics and Science in the Participatory Era: A Vignette-Based Delphi Study

Abstract

Participatory researchers rely on relationship-based ethical considerations to address ethical challenges, but little is known about how these considerations shape day-to-day decision-making. We presented vignettes describing ethical dilemmas to health researchers with varying degrees of experience in participatory research in an online modified-Delphi panel. Panelists rated potential solutions to dilemmas and provided rationales for choosing solutions in text boxes and discussion boards. Panelists agreed on a preferred solution for three of five vignettes. Panelists indicated that ethical research decision-making should be inclusive of diverse perspectives. Panelists prioritized scientific goals above participatory ones and viewed tenets of scientific validity as value-free. Panelists indicated that participatory research ethics would be difficult to codify, but that vignette-based learning could support didactic objectives.

Keywords

participatory research research ethics vignette research modified-Delphi panel

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atzmüller

Steiner

P. M.

(2015). Experimental vignette studies in survey research. Methodology, 6, 128-138.

Banks

Armstrong

Carter

Graham

Hayward

Henry

. . . McNulty

(2013). Everyday ethics in community-based participatory research. Contemporary Social Science, 8, 263-277.

Barter

Renold

(1999). The use of vignettes in qualitative research. Social Research Update, 25(9), 1-6.

Beaton

Hudson

Milne

Port

R. V.

Russell

Smith

. . . Bartholomew

(2016). Engaging Maori in biobanking and genomic research: A model for biobanks to guide culturally informed governance, operational, and community engagement activities. Genetics in Medicine, 19, 345-351.

Braveman

(2006). Health disparities and health equity: Concepts and measurement. Annual Review of Public Health, 27, 167-194.

Bromley

Mikesell

Jones

Khodyakov

(2015). From subject to participant: Ethics and the evolving role of community in health research. American Journal of Public Health, 105, 900-908.

Brugge

Cole

(2003). A case study of community-based participatory research ethics: The Health Public Housing Initiative. Science and Engineering Ethics, 9, 485-501.

Callahan

Jennings

(2002). Ethics and public health: Forging a strong relationship. American Journal of Public Health, 92, 169-176.

Cargo

Mercer

S. L.

(2008). The value and challenges of participatory research: Strengthening its practice. Annual Review of Public Health, 29, 325-350.

10.

Chantler

Otewa

Onyango

Okoth

Odhiambo

Parker

. . . Geissler

P. W.

(2013). Ethical challenges that arise at the community interface of health research: Village reporters’ experiences in Western Kenya. Developing World Bioethics, 13, 30-37. doi:10.1111/dewb.12023

11.

Claassen

C. A.

Pearson

J. L.

Khodyakov

Satow

P. M.

Gebbia

Reidenberg

D. J.

. . . Insel

T. R.

(2014). Reducing the burden of suicide in the U.S.: The aspirational research goals of the national action alliance for suicide prevention research prioritization task force. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 47, 309-314.

12.

Cohn

(2008). Making objective facts from intimate relations: The case of neuroscience and its entanglements with volunteers. History of the Human Sciences, 21(4), 86-103.

13.

Cook

B. R.

Kesby

Fazey

Spray

(2013). The persistence of “normal” catchment management despite the participatory turn: Exploring the power effects of competing frames of reference. Social Studies of Science, 43, 754-779.

14.

Cordner

Ciplet

Brown

Morell-Frosch

(2012). Reflexive research ethics for environmental health and justice: Academics and movement-building. Social Movement Studies, 11, 161-176.

15.

Cornwall

Jewkes

(1995). What is participatory research? Social Science & Medicine, 41, 1667-1676.

16.

Dalal

S. R.

Khodyakov

Srinivasan

Straus

S. G.

Adams

(2011). Expertlens: A system for eliciting opinions from a large pool of non-collocated experts with diverse knowledge. Technological Forecasting & Social Change, 78, 1426-1444.

17.

Domecq

J. P.

Prutsky

Elraiyah

Wang

Nabhan

Shippee

. . . Murad

(2014). Patient engagement in research: A systematic review. BMC Health Services Research, 14, 89.

18.

Fitch

Bernstein

S. J.

Aguilar

M. D.

Burnand

Lacalle

J. R.

Lazaro

. . . Kahan

J. P.

(2001). The RAND/UCLA appropriateness method user’s manual. Santa Monica, CA: RAND

19.

Goering

Holland

Fryer-Edwards

(2008). Genetic research practices with marginalized communities. Hastings Center Report, 38(2), 43-53.

20.

Hasson

Keeney

McKenna

(2000). Research guidelines for the Delphi survey technique. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 32, 1008-1015. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2648.2000.t01-1-01567.x

21.

Hebert

J. R.

Brandt

H. M.

Armstead

C. A.

Adams

S. A.

Steck

S. E.

(2009). Interdisciplinary, translational, and community-based participatory research: Finding a common language to improve cancer research. Cancer Epidemiology and Prevention Biomarkers, 18, 1213-1217.

22.

Hughes

Huby

(2002). The application of vignettes in social and nursing research. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 37, 382-386.

23.

Jagosh

Bush

P. L.

Salsberg

Macaulay

A. C.

Greenhalgh

Wong

. . . Pluye

(2015). A realist evaluation of community-based participatory research: Partnership synergy, trust building and related ripple effects. BMC Public Health, 15(1), Article 725.

24.

Khanlou

Peter

(2005). Participatory action research: Considerations for ethical review. Social Science & Medicine, 60, 2333-2340.

25.

Khodyakov

Hempel

Rubenstein

Shekelle

Foy

Salem-Schatz

. . . Dalal

(2011). Conducting online expert panels: A feasibility and experimental replicability study. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 11(1), Article 174.

26.

Khodyakov

Mikesell

Booth

Schraiber

Bromley

(2016). On using ethical principles of community-engaged research in translational science. Translational Research, 171, 52-62.

27.

Khodyakov

Stockdale

Jones

Mango

Jones

Lizaola

(2012). On measuring community participation in research. Health Education & Behavior, 40, 346-354.

28.

Kraemer-Diaz

A. E.

Spears Johnson

C. R.

Arcury

T. A.

(2013). Variation in the interpretation of scientific integrity in community-based participatory health research. Social Science & Medicine, 97, 134-142.

29.

Lau

C. L. L.

(2010). A step forward: Ethics education matters! Journal of Business Ethics, 92, 565-584. doi:10.1007/s10551-009-0173-2

30.

Mah

C. L.

Taylor

Hoang

Cook

(2014). Using vignettes to tap into moral reasoning in public health policy: Practical advice and design principles from a study on food advertising to children. American Journal of Public Health, 104, 1826-1832.

31.

Mallery

Ganachari

Fernandez

Smeeding

Robinson

Moon

. . . Siegel

(2012). Innovative methods in stakeholder engagement: An environmental scan. Rockville, MD: American Institutes for Research, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.

32.

Malone

R. E.

Yerger

V. B.

McGruder

Froelicher

(2006). It’s like Tuskegee in reverse: A case study of ethical tensions in Institutional Review Board review of community-based participatory research. American Journal of Public Health, 96, 1914-1919.

33.

McCarron

M. C. E.

Stewart

D. W.

(2011). A Canadian perspective on using vignettes to teach ethics in psychology. Canadian Psychology/psychologie Canadienne, 52, 185-191. doi:10.1037/a0024504

34.

Mikesell

Bromley

Khodyakov

(2013). Ethical community-engaged research: A literature review. American Journal of Public Health, 103(12), e7-e14.

35.

Minkler

(2010). Linking science and policy through community-based participatory research to study and address health disparities. American Journal of Public Health, 100(Suppl. 1), S81-S87.

36.

Minkler

Wallerstein

(Eds.). (2008). Community-based participatory research for health: From process to outcomes (2nd ed.). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

37.

Monahan

Stewart

D. E.

Oliver

Clarke-Jones

Rees

Milne

. . . Stein

(2003). The role of lay panelists on grant review panels: Involving consumers in research and development agenda setting for the NHS: Developing an evidence-based approach. Chronic Diseases in Canada, 24(2-3), 70-74.

38.

Mooney

G. H.

(1983). Equity in health care: Confronting the confusion. Effective Health Care, 1(4), 179-185.

39.

National Institutes of Health. (2015). Communities and research. Retrieved from https://ncats.nih.gov/ctsa/community

40.

National priorities for research and research agenda . (2012). Patient Centered Outcomes Research Institute. Adopted by PCORI Board of Governors May 21. Retrieved from www.pcori.org/sites/default/files/PCORI-National-Priorities-and-Research-Agenda.pdf

41.

Patton

M. Q.

(2002). Qualitative research and evaluation methods. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.

42.

Petersen

(2013). From bioethics to a sociology of bio-knowledge. Social Science & Medicine, 98, 264-270.

43.

Pickersgill

(2012). The co-production of science, ethics, and emotion. Science, Technology & Human Values, 37, 579-603.

44.

Precision medicine initiative: Privacy and trust principles . (2015). Retrieved from https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/finalpmiprivacyandtrustprinciples.pdf

45.

Principles of Community Engagement. (2011, June). Clinical and translational science awards consortium (Publication No 11-7782, 2nd ed.). Community Engagement Key Function Committee Task Force on the Principles of Community Engagement, National Institute of Health, NIH.

46.

Roberts

L. W.

Warner

T. D.

Hammond

K. A. G.

Brody

J. L.

Kaminsky

Roberts

B. B.

(2005). Teaching medical students to discern ethical problems in human clinical research studies. Academic Medicine, 80, 925-930.

47.

Rubenstein

Khodyakov

Hempel

Danz

Salem-Schatz

Foy

. . . Shekelle

(2014). How can we recognize continuous quality improvement? International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 26, 6-15.

48.

Ryan

G. W.

Bernard

H. R.

(2003). Techniques to identify themes. Field Methods, 15, 85-109.

49.

Schmittdiel

J. A.

Grumbach

Selby

J. V.

(2010). System-based participatory research in health care: An approach for sustainable translational research and quality improvement. The Annals of Family Medicine, 8, 256-259.

50.

Schoenberg

N. E.

Ravdal

(2000). Using vignettes in awareness and attitudinal research. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 3, 63-74.

51.

Shore

(2007). Re-conceptualizing the Belmont report. Journal of Community Practice, 14(4), 5-26.

52.

Shore

Wong

K. A.

Seifer

S. D.

Grignon

Northington Gamble

(2008). Introduction to special issue: Advancing the ethics of community-based participatory research. Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics, 3(2), 1-4.

53.

Skinner

H. G.

Calancie

M. B.

Garcia

DeMarco

Patterson

. . . Schisler

J. C.

(2015). Using community-based participatory research principles to develop more understandable recruitment and informed consent documents in genomic research. PLoS ONE, 10(5), e0125466.

54.

Smith

S. A.

Blumenthal

D. S.

(2013). Translating research to practice. In Blumenthal

D. S.

DiClemente

R. L.

Braithwaite

S. A.

Smith

S. A.

(Eds.), Community-based participatory health research: Issues, methods, and translation to practice (pp. 181-94). New York, NY: Springer.

55.

Sofaer

Eyal

(2010). The diverse ethics of translational research. The American Journal of Bioethics, 10(8), 19-30.

56.

Stellefson

Paige

S. R.

Alber

J. M.

Barry

A. E.

James

(2015). Proposing ethical practice standards for community-engaged research in health education. American Journal of Health Education, 46(2), 61-66.

57.

Sugarman

(2016). Ethics and regulatory challenges and opportunities in patient-centered comparative effectiveness research. Academic Medicine, 91, 455-457.

58.

Svendsen

M. N.

Koch

(2008). Between neutrality and engagement: A case study of recruitment to pharmacogenomic research in Denmark. Biosocieties, 3, 399-418.

59.

Tallon

Chard

Dieppe

(2000). Relation between agendas of the research community and the research consumer. The Lancet, 355, 2037-2040.

60.

Wainwright

S. P.

Williams

Michael

Farsides

Cribb

(2006). Ethical boundary-work in the embryonic stem cell laboratory. Sociology of Health & Illness, 28, 732-748.

61.

Westfall

J. M.

Mold

Fagnan

(2007). Practice-based research—“Blue highways” on the NIH roadmap. Journal of the American Medical Association, 297, 403-406.

62.

Wilson

Kenny

Dickson-Swift

(2017). Ethical challenges of community based participatory research: Exploring researchers’ experience. International Journal of Social Research Methodology. Advance online publication. doi:10.1080/13645579.2017.1296714

63.

Wynne

(2006). Public engagement as a means of restoring public trust in science—Hitting the notes, but missing the music? Community Genetics, 9, 211-220.

64.

Yonas

M. A.

Jaime

M. C.

Barone

Valenti

Documét

Ryan

C. M.

. . . Miller

(2016). Community partnered research ethics training in practice: A collaborative approach to certification. Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics, 11, 97-105.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.05 MB