Principals and superintendents operating in high-choice environments are often faced with enrollment challenges as they compete for students. This case study examines the experience of a principal at Crossroads Elementary—a high-performing, culturally responsive, and innovative traditional public school that struggles to retain many of its older students. Despite outperforming most elementary schools in New York City and seemingly doing “everything right,” most of their older students transferred to charter school networks as they approach middle school. We discuss implications in terms of equity, ethics, community engagement, and planning in high-choice districts.
BickmoreD. L. (2020). Traditional principals’ reaction to a charter school opening. NASSP Bulletin, 104(4), 270–291.
2.
BuckleyJ.Sattin-BajajC. (2011). Are ELL students underrepresented in charter schools? Demographic trends in New York City, 2006–2008. Journal of School Choice, 5(1), 40–65.
3.
BuckleyJ.SchneiderM. (2006). Are charter school parents more satisfied with schools? Evidence from Washington, DC. Peabody Journal of Education, 81(1), 57–78.
4.
CastilloE. (2020). A neoliberal grammar of schooling? How a progressive Charter school moved toward market values. American Journal of Education, 126(4), 519–547.
5.
ChenK. K.MoskopM. (2020). School choice’s idealized premises and unfulfilled promises: How school markets simulate options, encourage decoupling and deception, and deepen disadvantages. Sociology Compass, 14(3), Article e12766.
6.
DiMartinoC.JessenS. B. (2018). Selling school: The marketing of public education. Teachers College Press.
7.
FuscoM. (2017). Burnout factories: The challenge of retaining great teachers in charter schools. Phi Delta Kappan, 98(8), 26–30.
8.
HernándezL. E. (2016). Race and racelessness in CMO marketing: Exploring charter management organizations’ racial construction and its implications. Peabody Journal of Education, 91(1), 47–63.
9.
HittD. H.TuckerP. D. (2016). Systematic review of key leader practices found to influence student achievement: A unified framework. Review of Educational Research, 86(2), 531–569.
JabbarH. (2016). Selling schools: Marketing and recruitment strategies in New Orleans. Peabody Journal of Education, 91(1), 4–23.
12.
KhalifaM. (2012). A re-new-ed paradigm in successful urban school leadership: Principal as community leader. Educational Administration Quarterly, 48(3), 424–467.
13.
KotokS.KnightD. S.JabbarH.RiveraL. E.RinconesR. (2019). On becoming a district of choice: Implications for equity along the United States–Mexico border. Educational Administration Quarterly, 55(4), 615–656.
14.
KotokS.DiMartinoC.DeMatthewsD. E. (2021). Principals and district leaders navigating the marketplace: Lessons from Texas, New York, and Pennsylvania. Journal of School Leadership, 31(5), 373–395.
15.
LeeM.LouisK. S. (2019). Mapping a strong school culture and linking it to sustainable school improvement. Teaching and Teacher Education, 81, 84–96.
16.
McGheeC.AndersonG. (2019). Gentrification, market regimes, and the new entrepreneurial principal: Enacting integration or displacement?Leadership and Policy in Schools, 18(2), 180–194.
17.
McWilliamsJ. A. (2017). The neighborhood school stigma: School choice, stratification, and shame. Policy Futures in Education, 15(2), 221–238.
18.
McWilliamsJ. A. (2019). Compete or close: Traditional neighborhood schools under pressure. Harvard Education Press
19.
MungalA. S. (2016). Teach for America, Relay Graduate School, and the charter school networks: The making of a parallel education structure. Education Policy Analysis Archives/Archivos Analíticos de Políticas Educativas, 24, 1–30.
PottertonA. U. (2019). Leaders’ experiences in Arizona’s mature education market. Journal of Educational Administration, 57(1), 21–35.
22.
RielV. (2020). Building expectations and keeping customers happy: How charter school leaders recruit and retain families. The Sociological Quarterly. Advance online publication.
23.
ScottJ. (2009). The politics of venture philanthropy in charter school policy and advocacy. Educational Policy, 23(1), 106–136.
24.
TrujilloT.ScottJ.RiveraM. (2017). Follow the yellow brick road: Teach for America and the making of educational leaders. American Journal of Education, 123(3), 353–391.
