In 1995, New York State Education Commissioner Richard Mills and the Board of Regents changed the state’s testing policy in favor of a challenging, high-stakes testing accountability system. The case describes Mill’s leadership over the next six years in the face of significant opposition from parents, alternative schools, vocational educators, and bilingual advocates. The case portrays Mills’ effectiveness as an apologist of the policy to the public and his ability to survive politically. It documents his justification of placing stakes on students as the means to persuade state institutions, including the governor and the legislature, to provide greater financial support for education.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Banner, R.
(1999, September 8). Critics say graduation exams hurt vocational students [Electronic version]. The New York Times.
2.
Corcoran, D.
(1999, August 4). Requiring standard tests for graduation: Two views [Electronic version]. The New York Times.
3.
Dao, J.
(1995, August 10). Vermont official is picked as State Education Chief for New York. The New York Times, p. B1.
4.
Education Week (1998, March 25).
5.
Fieldnotes
, Legislative hearing on Regents Requirements, June 6, 1999, Albany, New York.
6.
Fuhrman, S.
(1999). The new accountability (RB-27). Philadelphia, PA: Consortium for Policy Research in Education.
7.
Gehring, J.
(2000, February 2). `High-stakes’ exams seen as test for voc. education. Education Week.
8.
Goertz, M.
, Floden, R., & O’Day, J. (1996). Studies of education reform: Vol. 2. Case Studies (p. 82). Washington DC: U.S. Dept. of Education.
9.
Hale-Spencer, M.
(1998, March 12). Students interrogate unflappable commish. The Altamont Enterprise.
10.
Hartocollis, A.
(1999, January 29). Statewide tests draw some local outcries: Schools fighting new Regents exam. The New York Times, p. A-15.
11.
Hartocollis, A.
(1999, April 1). The man behind the exams: New York’s Education Chief pushes agenda of change. The New York Times.
12.
Hartocollis, A.
(1999, August 19). High schools chief is said to retire under pressure [Electronic version]. The New York Times.
13.
Hartocollis, A.
(1999, September 9). Students face new standards in city schools [Electronic version]. The New York Times.
14.
Hartocollis, A.
(2000, March 11). Officials struggle to explain increase in high school dropout rate. The New York Times.
15.
Hendrie, C.
(1997, June 11). Harder tests spur debate on NY diploma [Electronic version]. Education Week.
16.
Heubert, J.
, & Hauser, R. (Eds.). (1998). High stakes: Testing for tracking, promotion, and graduation. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press.
17.
Holland, J.
(1999, September 7). Mills blunt about school system overhaul. The Daily Gazette.
18.
Holloway, L.
(2000, January 27). Education Commissioner rejects substitutes for Regents English Exam [Electronic version]. The New York Times.
19.
Jenkins Holt, K.
(1998, December 1). Testing his ideas for N.Y. schools: State Commissioner Richard P. Mills raises the bar for students. The Journal News.
20.
Keller, B.
(2000, February 2). N.Y. Chief deals blow to alternative-assessment plans. Education Week, p. 13.
21.
Mills, R.
(1996, May). Report to the State Board of Regents. New York State Education Department, p. 1.
22.
Mills, R.
(1997, May). Report to the State Board of Regents. New York State Education Department.
23.
Moore, M.H.
(1981). Realms of obligation and virture. In J. Fleishman, L. Liebman, & M. Moore (Eds.), Public duties: The moral obligations of government officials (pp. 3-31). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
24.
Navigating the changing seas of N.Y. education
. (1999, February 28). The Democrat and Chronicle.
25.
New York State Education Department
. (1997) SED - update: State Education Department’s proposal for raising high school graduation requirements. Albany, NY: State Education Department.
26.
New York Times (1997, June 18).
27.
Richardson, L.
(1996 April 28). State Education Chief: A zealot for higher standards for all. The New York Times, p. A33.
28.
Simon, P.
, & Palazzetti, A. (1996, May 4). Official blasts disparity in school funding. The Buffalo News, p. B-12.
29.
Stout, D.
(1995, August 10). Plain-spoken innovator: Richard Paul Mills. The New York Times, p. B4.
30.
Terdiman, A.
(1996, February). Education without excuses. Empire State Report, p. 39.
31.
Wirt, F.
& Kirst, M. (1997). The state political process: The political dynamics of American education (pp. 219-245). Berkeley, CA: McCutchan Publishing.
