Abstract
Edwin Sutherland’s concept of white-collar crime remains incredibly influential in contemporary criminological research and thought. Sutherland’s work was critical of several of the most influential industries in the United States, highlighting both their criminal and unethical conduct. Today, the video game industry has garnered tremendous influence over society and until recently, has seemed to escape criminological critique (other than for that of the potential negative effects of violent games) and white-collar crime theoretical inquiry. This study aims to change that, as we analyze the video game industry for its involvement in many traditional (and some more contemporary) forms of white-collar crime. More specifically, we discuss overpromising, broken games, and price gouging.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams
E.
(2016 , January 14). The DLC problem and why companies need to re-think their strategy . Gameskinny.com .
2.
Alexander
A.
(2015 , June 12). Price gouging in full effect as steam summer sale begins . Words About Games . Retrieved from https://wordsaboutgames.net/2015/06/12/price-gouging-in-full-effect-as-steam-summer-sale-begins/
3.
Bennett
C.
(2019 , October 29). Fortnite v11.10 early patch notes-fortnitemares, bug fixes, more . Fortnite Intel . Retrieved from https://fortniteintel.com/fortnite-v11-10-early-patch-notes-fortnitemares-bug-fixes-more/27104/
4.
Bonthuys
D.
(2018 , February 16). Will cyberpunk 2077 have loot boxes? Nope, says CD projekt red . Critical Hit Gaming . Retrieved from https://www.criticalhit.net/gaming/will-cyberpunk-2077-loot-boxes-nope-says-cd-projekt-red/
5.
Braithwaite
J.
(1985 ). White collar crime . Annual Review of Sociology , 11 (1 ), 1 -25 .
6.
Brumfiel
G.
(2017 , May 31). Total failure: The world’s worst video game . NPR . Retrieved from https://www.npr.org/2017/05/31/530235165/total-failure-the-worlds-worst-video-game
7.
Charlebois
S.
Schwab
A.
Henn
R.
Huck
C. W.
(2016 ). Food fraud: An exploratory study for measuring consumer perception towards mislabeled food products and influence on self-authentication intentions . Trends in Food Science & Technology , 50 , 211 -218 .
8.
Clinard
M. B.
Yeager
P. C.
(1980 ). Corporate crime . NY : Free Press .
9.
Crecente
B.
(2016 , November 30). No man’s sky creators cleared of false advertising allegations . Polygon . Retrieved from https://www.polygon.com/2016/11/30/13791782/no-mans-sky-false-advertising-results
10.
Dutton
F.
(2012 , April 18). Apple sued over in-app microtransactions . Eurogamer . Retrieved from https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-04-17-apple-sued-over-in-app-microtransactions
11.
Emons
W.
(1989 ). On the limitation of warranty duration . The Journal of Industrial Economics , 37 (3 ), 287 -301 .
12.
Freedman
A. E.
(2019 , August 9). What are loot boxes? Gaming’s big controversy explained . Tom’s Guide . Retrieved from https://www.tomsguide.com/us/what-are-loot-boxes-microtransactions,news-26161.html
13.
Geis
G.
Meier
R. F.
Salinger
L. M.
(1995 ). Introduction . In
Geis
G.
Meier
R. F.
Salinger
L. M.
(Eds.), White-collar crime: Classic and contemporary views (3rd ed , pp. 1 -19 ). New York : Free Press .
14.
Gibson
A.
(2018 , October 22). 8 times you had to pay to see a game’s true ending . Twinfinite . Retrieved from https://twinfinite.net/gallery/8-times-you-had-to-pay-to-see-a-games-true-ending/
15.
Gilbert
B.
(2017 , November 22). A state politician in Hawaii says the new ‘star wars’ game encourages kids to gamble and Hhe wants ot ban sales to anyone under 21 . Business Insider . Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/ea-star-wars-hawaii-gambling-2017-11
16.
Gilbert
B.
(2018 a, March 16). The latest major ‘star wars’ game finally dropped its most controversial aspect-but it may be too late . Business Insider . Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/star-wars-battlefront-2-drops-loot-boxes-2018-3
17.
Gilbert
B.
(2018 b, April 17). ‘We got it wrong’: EA exec apoogizes for ‘star wars’ loot box fiasco, promises to ‘be better’ . Business Insider . Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/star-wars-battlefront-2-ea-apologizes-for-loot-box-fiasco-2018-4
18.
Gilbert
B.
(2019 , June 23). The video game industry is facing government scrutiny over loot boxes, and the most powerful leaders in gaming are divided over what to do . Business Insider . Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/video-game-industry-loot-box-legislation-2019-6.
19.
Gilbert
B.
(2020 , September 16). The standard price for video games is increasing to $70 for the playstation 5 and next-gen Xbox consoles, ending 15 years of $60 games . Business Insider . Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/video-game-price-increase-60-70-nba-2k-xbox-ps5-2020-7#:∼:text=%22%2469.99%20may%20be%20the%20new,Piscatella%20said%20of%20the%20announcement.&text=That%20last%20change%20came%20with,increased%20to%20%2460%20from%20%2450
20.
Good
O. S.
(2018 , March 21). Star wars battlefront 2 unlocks every hero in update overhauling progression . Polygon . Retrieved from https://www.polygon.com/2018/3/21/17147396/battlefront-2-update-progression-loot-crates-heroes-unlocks
21.
Greene
J. A.
Padula
W. V.
(2017 ). Targeting unconscionable prescription-drug prices-MD’s anti-price-gouging law . New England Journal of Medicine , 377 (2 ), 101 -103 .
22.
Gurwin
G.
(2017 , September 12). Nintendo expands SNES classic edition stock to halt price gouging . Digital Trends . Retrieved from https://www.digitaltrends.com/gaming/nintendo-snes-classic-edition-scalper-warning/
23.
Hamari
J.
(2015 ). Why do people buy virtual goods? Attitude toward virtual good purchases versus game enjoyment . International Journal of Information Management , 35 (3 ), 299 -308 .
24.
Hawthorne
F.
(2005 ). Inside the FDA: The business and politics behind the drugs we take and the food we eat . Hoboken, NJ : John Wiley & Sons .
25.
Haynes
J.
(2012 , May 12). Socom: Confrontation review . IGN . Retrieved from https://www.ign.com/articles/2008/10/31/socom-confrontation-review
26.
Hurlbut
D.
Rogas
K.
Oren
S.
(2004 ). Protecting the market from “hockey stick” pricing: How the public utility commission of texas is dealing with potential price gouging . The Electricity Journal , 17 (3 ), 26 -33 .
27.
Kain
E.
(2012 , November 14). Why day-one DLC isn’t just bad for gamers, it’s bad for business . Forbes . Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2012/11/14/why-day-one-dlc-isnt-just-bad-for-gamers-its-bad-for-business/#10f7721c1316
28.
Kelion
L.
(2014 , November 27). Ubisoft apologises for assassin’s creed unity bugs . BBC News . Retrieved from https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-30226586
29.
Lagioia
S.
(2018 , December 27). 15 nintentdo sequels worse than the original (and 15 that saved the franchise) . The Gamer . Retrieved from https://www.thegamer.com/nintendo-sequels-least-best/
30.
Lin
H.
Sun
C.-T.
(2011 ). Cash trade in free-to-play online games . Games and Culture , 6 (3 ), 270 -287 .
31.
Loveridge
S.
(2016 , March 10). 11 Video-game trailers that looked nothing like the actual game . Digital Spy . Retrieved from https://www.digitalspy.com/videogames/a809830/11-videogame-trailers-that-looked-nothing-like-the-actual-game
32.
MacDonald
K.
(2015 , September 30). Why you pay what you pay for video games . Kotaku . Retrieved from https://www.kotaku.co.uk/2015/09/30/why-you-pay-what-you-pay-for-video-games
33.
MacDonald
K.
(2018 , July 20). No man’s Sky developer sean Murray: ‘It was as bad as things can get’ . The guardian . Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/games/2018/jul/20/no-mans-sky-next-hello-games-sean-murray-harassment-interview
34.
Marchand
A.
Hennig-Thurau
T.
(2013 ). Value creation in the video game industry: Industry economics, consumer benefits, and research opportunities . Journal of Interactive Marketing , 27 (3 ), 141 -157 .
35.
Marsh
C.
(2018 , August 27). So they’re good: Five terrible video games that people loved anyway . The Guardian . Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/games/2018/aug/27/so-bad-theyre-good-five-terrible-video-games-that-people-loved-anyway
36.
Marshall
C
(2019 ). It may not be possible to save fallout 76 . Polygon . Retrieved from https://www.polygon.com/2019/2/7/18214008/fallout-76-updates-patch-fix-future
37.
Neely
E. L.
(in press). Come for the game, stay for the cash grab: The ethics of loot boxes, microtransactions, and freemium games . Games and Culture .
38.
Newton
P. N.
Green
M. D.
Fernández
F. M.
Day
N. P.
White
N. J.
(2006 ). Counterfeit anti-infective drugs . The Lancet Infectious Diseases , 6 (9 ), 602 -613 .
39.
Newton
P. N.
White
N. J.
Rozendaal
J. A.
Green
M. D.
(2002 ). Murder by fake drugs . British Medical Journal , 324 (7341 ), 800 .
40.
Orland
K.
(2018 ). The game beat: Observations and lessons from two decades writing about games . Morrisville, NC : Lulu Press .
41.
Orland
K.
(2019 , January 28). Fortnite puts an end to random loot box purchases . Ars Technica . Retrieved from https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2019/01/fortnite-puts-an-end-to-random-loot-boxes-purchases/
42.
Paur
J.
(2015 ). 7 times epic video game box Art wildly overpromised . Geek Tyrant . Retrieved from https://geektyrant.com/news/7-times-epic-video-game-box-art-wildly-overpromised
43.
Perks
M. E.
(in press). How does games critique impact game design decisions? A case study of monetization and loot boxes . Games and Culture .
44.
Plunkett
L.
(2019 , October 31). Australia allows some fallout 76 refunds after consumers were “misle” . Kotaku . Retrieved from https://kotaku.com/australia-allows-some-fallout-76-refunds-after-consumer-1839517936
45.
Reisinger
D
(2007 , August 7). Price cuts and video games . CNET . Retrieved from https://www.cnet.com/news/price-cuts-and-video-games/
46.
Rivera
J.
(2019 , July 22). The video game industry can’t go on like this . Kotaku . Retrieved from https://kotaku.com/the-video-game-industry-cant-go-on-like-this-1836606033
47.
Ruppert
L.
(2018 , May 11). Destiny 2 expansion accused of false advertising by players . Comicbook.com . Retrieved from https://comicbook.com/gaming/2018/05/09/destiny-2-expansion-accused-of-false-advertising-by-players/
48.
Schreier
J.
(2014 , March 11). The man who promised too much . Kotaku . Retrieved from https://kotaku.com/the-man-who-promised-too-much-1537352493
49.
Schreier
J.
(2019 , May 21). U.S. Senator says his anti-loot box bill has the video game industry worried . Kotaku . Retrieved from https://kotaku.com/u-s-senator-says-his-anti-loot-box-bill-has-the-video-1834905639
50.
Sherr
I.
(2019 , June 15). Makers held back the hype: The gaming industry is learning to manage expectations at E3 2019, video game . CNET . Retrieved from https://www.cnet.com/news/at-e3-2019-video-game-makers-held-back-the-hype/
51.
Shover
N.
Hochstetler
A.
(2006 ). Choosing white-collar crime . New York : Cambridge University Press .
52.
Smith
N.
(2020 , May 12). The giants of the video game industry have thrived in the pandemic. Can the success continue? . The Washington Post . Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/video-games/2020/05/12/video-game-industry-coronavirus/
53.
Sutherland
E. H.
(1940 ). White-collar criminality . American Sociological Review , 5 (1 ), 1 -12 .
54.
Sutherland
E. H.
(1945 ). Is “White collar crime” crime? . American Sociological Review , 10 (2 ), 132 -139 .
55.
Tappan
P. W.
(1947 ). Who is the Criminal? American Sociological Review , 12 (1 ), 96 -102 .
56.
Tassi
P.
(2018 , November 27). Bethesda’s silence of the state of fallout 76’ at launch is deafening . Forbes . Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2018/11/27/bethesdas-silence-of-the-state-of-fallout-76-at-launch-is-deafening/#2a5db2fb61e7
57.
Webb
K.
(2018 , September 17). Regulators from more than a dozen countries are looking to crack down on ‘loot boxes,’ A controversial video gaming practice that could be too much like gambling . Business Insider . Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/loot-boxes-european-regulation-2018-9
58.
Webster
A
(2013 , September 13). How Atari box art turned 8-bit games into virtual wonderlands . The Verge . Retrieved from https://www.theverge.com/2013/9/19/4716444/how-atari-box-art-turned-8-bit-games-into-virtual-wonderlands
59.
Wells
N.
(2015 , August 3). The shocking truth about mobile gaming . CNBC . Retrieved from https://www.cnbc.com/2015/08/03/the-shocking-truth-about-mobile-gaming.html
60.
Wolf
M. J. P.
(2008 ). Introduction . In
Wolf
M. J. P.
(Ed.), The video game explosion: A history of PONG to playstation and beyond (pp. xiii -xvi). Westport, CT : Greenwood Publishing Group .
61.
Zwolinski
M.
(2008 ). The ethics of price gouging . Business Ethics Quarterly , 18 (3 ), 347 -378 .