Rational Adaptation: Contextual Effects in Medical Decision Making

Abstract

Research and practice in medical decision making value consistency with standardized intervention, potentially neglecting the impact of various environmental features such as workload or the constraints of local work practice. This study presents both qualitative and quantitative analyses of emergency physicians’ decision-making processes in their natural work setting to examine the impact of contextual features. We study contextual effects on two separable decision-making processes identified in quantified observational data: goal enactment and goal establishment. Whereas goal enactment responds to hospital differences and patient difficulty as main effects, goal establishment responds to their interaction. Our emphasis on goal establishment expands the scope of a medical decision-making literature focused on diagnosis, and extends to other professions and the more general conceptualization of expertise. From a theoretical perspective, we emphasize the importance of accounting for contextual variability within the bounds of expert behavior. Practically, we provide real-world examples of context effects that bear on the standardization of care, cost differences between hospitals, and the conceptualization of quality medical care.

Keywords

medical decision making naturalistic observation situated cognition emergency medicine expert reasoning

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arora

Sevdalis

Nestel

Woloshynowych

Darzi

Kneebone

. (2010). The impact of stress on surgical performance: A systematic review of the literature. Surgery, 147(3), 318–330.doi:10.1016/j.surg.2009.10.007

Atkins

Ersser

S. J

. (2008). Clinical reasoning and patient-centered care. In Higgs

Jones

Loftus

Christensen

(Eds.), Clinical reasoning in the health professions (pp. 68–77). Elsevier.

Benner

. (1982). From novice to expert. The American Journal of Nursing, 82(3), 402–407.

Bliese

P. D

. (2002). Multilevel random coefficient modeling in organizational research: Examples using SAS and S-PLUS. In Drazgow

Schmitt

(Eds.), Measuring and analyzing behavior in organizations: Advances in measurement and data analysis (pp. 401–445). Jossey-Bass, Inc.

Boulton

Cole

. (2016). Adaptive flexibility: Examining the role of expertise in the decision making of authorized firearms officers during armed confrontation. Journal of Cognitive Engineering and Decision Making, 10(3), 291–308.

Brooks

L. R.

Norman

G. R.

Allen

S. W

. (1991). Role of specific similarity in a medical diagnostic task. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 120(3), 278–287.doi:10.1037/0096-3445.120.3.278

Carayon

Alyousef

Xie

. (2012). Human factors and ergonomics in health care. In Salvendi

(Ed.), Handbook of human factors and ergonomics (4th ed.). John Wiley & Sons.

Croker

Loftus

Higgs

. (2008). Multidisciplinary clinical decision making. In Higgs

Jones

Loftus

Christensen

(Eds.), Clinical reasoning in the health professions (pp. 291–298). Elsevier.

Croskerry

. (2013). From mindless to mindful practice — cognitive bias and clinical decision making. New England Journal of Medicine, 368(26), 2445–2448.doi:10.1056/NEJMp1303712

10.

Cummings

E. M

. (1980). Caregiver stability and day care. Developmental Psychology, 16(1), 31–37.doi:10.1037/0012-1649.16.1.31

11.

Currey

Botti

. (2003). Naturalistic decision making: A model to overcome methodological challenges in the study of critical care nurses' decision making about patients' hemodynamic status. American Journal of Critical Care, 12(3), 206–211.doi:10.4037/ajcc2003.12.3.206

12.

Donner-Banzhoff

Seidel

Sikeler

A. M.

Bösner

Vogelmeier

Westram

Feufel

Gaissmaier

Wegwarth

Gigerenzer

. (2017). The phenomenology of the diagnostic process: A primary care-based survey. Medical Decision Making : An International Journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making, 37(1), 27–34.doi:10.1177/0272989X16653401

13.

Dreyfus

H. L.

Dreyfus

S. E

. (2005). Expertise in real world contexts. Organization Studies, 26(5), 779–792.

14.

Elstein

A. S

. (2009). Thinking about diagnostic thinking: A 30-year perspective. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 14(S1), 7–18.doi:10.1007/s10459-009-9184-0

15.

Engestrom

. (1993). Developmental studies of work as a testbench of activity theory: The case of primary care medical practice. In Chaiklin

Lave

(Eds.), Understanding practice: Perspectives on activity and context (pp. 64–103). Cambridge University Press.

16.

Feufel

. (2009). Bounded rationality in the emergency department [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. Wright State University.

17.

Feufel

M. A

. (2018). How to uncover sources of unwarranted practice variation: A case study in emergency medicine. Qualitative Health Research, 28(9), 1486–1498.doi:10.1177/1049732318774322

18.

Feufel

M. A.

Flach

J. M

. (2019). Medical education should teach heuristics rather than train them away. Medical Education, 53(4), 334–344.doi:10.1111/medu.13789

19.

Foy

Hempel

Rubenstein

Suttorp

Seelig

Shanman

Shekelle

P. G

. (2010). Meta-analysis: Effect of interactive communication between collaborating primary care physicians and specialists. Annals of Internal Medicine, 152(4), 247–258.doi:10.7326/0003-4819-152-4-201002160-00010

20.

Gigerenzer

. (2008). Why heuristics work. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3(1), 20–29.doi:10.1111/j.1745-6916.2008.00058.x

21.

Gilboy

Tanabe

Travers

Rosenau

. (2011). Emergency Severity Index (ESI): A triage tool for emergency department care. Implementation Handbook Version 4. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality document #12-0014. Retrieved August 28, 2019, from https://www.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/wysiwyg/professionals/systems/hospital/esi/esihandbk.pdf

22.

Gonzales

. (2010). Medication administration errors and the pediatric population: A systematic search of the literature. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 25(6), 555–565.doi:10.1016/j.pedn.2010.04.002

23.

Greenhalgh

Howick

Maskrey

Evidence Based Medicine Renaissance Group . (2014). Evidence based medicine: A movement in crisis? BMJ, 348, g3725.doi:10.1136/bmj.g3725

24.

Henkel

R. J.

Maryland

P. A

. (2015). The risks and rewards of value-based reimbursement. Frontiers of Health Services Management, 32(2), 3–16.doi:10.1097/01974520-201510000-00002

25.

Sadler

G. G.

Hoffmann

L. C.

Zemlicka

Lyons

Fergueson

Richardson

Cacanindin

Cals

Wilkins

. (2017). A longitudinal field study of Auto-GCAS acceptance and trust: First-year results and implications. Journal of Cognitive Engineering and Decision Making, 11(3), 239–251.doi:10.1177/1555343417701019

26.

Hutchins

. (2014). The cultural ecosystem of human cognition. Philosophical Psychology, 27(1), 34–49.doi:10.1080/09515089.2013.830548

27.

Johnson

Miller

Horowitz

. (2008). Systems-based practice: Improving the safety and quality of patient care by recognizing and improving the systems in which we work. In Henriksen

Battles

Keyes

Grady

(Eds.), Advances in patient safety: New directions and alternative approaches (Vol. 2: culture and redesign). Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.

28.

Klein

. (2007a). Flexecution as a paradigm for replanning, part 1. IEEE Intelligent Systems, 22(5), 79–83.doi:10.1109/MIS.2007.4338498

29.

Klein

. (2007b). Flexecution, part 2: Understanding and supporting flexible execution. IEEE Intelligent Systems, 22(6), 108–112.doi:10.1109/MIS.2007.107

30.

Kliff

Keating

. (2013, May 8). One hospital charges $8,000 – another, $38,000. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/05/08/one-hospital-charges-8000-another-38000/?noredirect=on

31.

Kulatunga-Moruzi

Brooks

L. R.

Norman

G. R

. (2004). Using comprehensive feature lists to bias medical diagnosis. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 30(3), 563–572.doi:10.1037/0278-7393.30.3.563

32.

LaHuis

D. M.

Ferguson

M. W

. (2009). The accuracy of significance tests for slope variance components in multilevel random coefficient models. Organizational Research Methods, 12(3), 418–435.doi:10.1177/1094428107308984

33.

Lippa

K. D.

Feufel

M. A.

Robinson

F. E.

Shalin

V. L

. (2017). Navigating the decision space: Shared medical decision making as distributed cognition. Qualitative Health Research, 27(7), 1035–1048.doi:10.1177/1049732316665347

34.

Martin

Haskard-Zolnierek

DiMatteo

M. R

. (2010). Health behavior change and treatment adherence. Oxford University Press.

35.

Maude

. (2014). Differential diagnosis: The key to reducing diagnosis error, measuring diagnosis and a mechanism to reduce healthcare costs. Diagnosis, 1(1), 107–109.doi:10.1515/dx-2013-0009

36.

Norman

G. R.

Eva

K. W

. (2010). Diagnostic error and clinical reasoning. Medical Education, 44(1), 94–100.doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03507.x

37.

Reyna

V. F.

Lloyd

F. J

. (2006). Physician decision making and cardiac risk: Effects of knowledge, risk perception, risk tolerance, and fuzzy processing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 12(3), 179–195.doi:10.1037/1076-898X.12.3.179

38.

Roter

Hall

. (2006). Doctors talking with patients - patients talking with doctors. Praeger.

39.

Shalin

V. L.

Bertram

D. A

. (1996). Functions of expertise in a medical intensive care unit. Journal of Experimental & Theoretical Artificial Intelligence, 8(3-4), 209–227.doi:10.1080/095281396147302

40.

Shalin

V. L.

Geddes

N. D.

Bertram

D. L.

Szczepkowski

DuBois

. (1997). Expertise in dynamic, physical task domains. In Feltovich

Ford

Hoffman

(Eds.), Expertise in context: Human and machine. AAAI Press.

41.

Singh

. (2018, December 3). Kids with concussions can phase in exercise, screen time Sooner than before. NPR. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/12/03/672002830/kids-with-concussions-can-phase-in-exercise-screen-time-sooner-than-before

42.

Smith

Higgs

Ellis

. (2008). Factors influencing clinical decision making. In Higgs

Jones

Loftus

Christensen

(Eds.), Clinical reasoning in the health professions (3rd ed., pp. 89–100). Elsevier.

43.

Timmermans

Mauck

. (2005). The promises and pitfalls of evidence-based medicine. Health Affairs, 24(1), 18–28.doi:10.1377/hlthaff.24.1.18

44.

Todd

P. M.

Gigerenzer

. (2007). Environments that make us smart. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 16(3), 167–171.doi:10.1111/j.1467-8721.2007.00497.x

45.

van der Veen

van den Bemt

P. M. L. A

Wouters

Bates

D. W

Twisk

J. W. R

de Gier

J. J

Taxis

Duyvendak

Luttikhuis

K. O

Ros

J. J. W

Vasbinder

E. C

Atrafi

Brasse

Mangelaars

BCMA Study Group . (2018). Association between workarounds and medication administration errors in bar-code-assisted medication administration in hospitals. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 25(4), 385–392.doi:10.1093/jamia/ocx077

46.

Walsh

Beatty

P. C. W

. (2002). Human factors error and patient monitoring. Physiological Measurement, 23(3), R111–R132.doi:10.1088/0967-3334/23/3/201

47.

Ward

Gore

Hutton

Conway

G. E.

Hoffman

R. R

. (2018). Adaptive skill as the condition sine qua non of expertise. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 7(1), 35–50.doi:10.1016/j.jarmac.2018.01.009

48.

Ward

Hutton

Hoffman

Gore

Anderson

Leggatt

. (2016). Developing skilled adaptive performance: A scoping study: Final technical report. BAE Systems.

49.

Weiss

D. J.

Shanteau

. (2014). Who's the best? A relativistic view of expertise. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 28(4), 447–457.doi:10.1002/acp.3015

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.36 MB

0.12 MB

0.00 MB