Asbestos as Difficult Heritage: The Need for a Multi-Voiced Heritage Policy

Abstract

Asbestos can be present in a wide variety of heritage objects that are maintained in museums and heritage collections. Current research focuses on health risks, safety measures, and asbestos consolidation. However, there are additional challenges that remain understudied. Asbestos itself needs to be tackled as heritage, asking whether it is heritage, and if—in that case—the removal of asbestos affects the values and significance of an object. The collection of the former Belgian Asbestos and Rubber Factory (Belgium) is used in this contribution to illustrate why the heritage values of asbestos need to be considered, how asbestos challenges museums and heritage institutions, and why it needs to be theorized as difficult heritage. Subsequently, a methodology to value asbestos-containing heritage objects in a multi-voiced way is elaborated.

Keywords

museum subject focus collections assessment case study inclusion research and topics hazards facilities difficult heritage

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

“Asbestalarm in Deurne.” 1993. Stadskrant, June 25, 1993, 11.

A.V.W. 1993. “Deurnese buurtbewoners bang voor sloping asbestfabriek.” Gazet van Antwerpen, September 2, 1993, 35.

Belgisch Staatsblad. 2001. “Koninklijk Besluit van 23 oktober 2001 tot beperking van het op de markt brengen, de vervaardiging en het gebruik van bepaalde gevaarlijke stoffen en preparaten.” https://etaamb.openjustice.be/nl/koninklijk-besluit-van-23-oktober-2001_n2001022848.html (accessed May 7, 2024).

Belgisch Staatsblad. 1998. “Koninklijk Besluit van 3 februari 1998 tot beperking van het op de markt brengen, de vervaardiging en het gebruik van bepaalde gevaarlijke stoffen en preparaten.” https://etaamb.openjustice.be/nl/koninklijk-besluit-van-03-februari-1998_n1998022104.html (accessed May 7, 2024).

“Beslissende dagen voor Willebroeks asbeststort.” 1986. Gazet van Antwerpen, Februari 3, 1986, 10.

“Beurs van Antwerpen.” 1982. Gazet van Antwerpen, November 25, 1982, 21.

Blancquaert

Doris.

2023. Interview with Walter Verbruggen. October 19, 2023.

Blancquaert Doris. “Database ‘Articles and Mentions on Asbestos in Gazet van Antwerpen, 1900-2001’.” Last modified October 25, 2024.

“Codex over het Welzijn op het werk. Boek VI.- Chemische, kankerverwekkende, mutagene en reprotoxische agentia en agentie met hormoonontregelende eigenschappen. Titel 3. - Asbest.” Federale Overheidsdienst Werkgelegenheid, Arbeid en Sociaal Overleg. Last modified October 6, 2024. https://werk.belgie.be/sites/default/files/content/documents/Welzijn%20op%20het%20werk/Regelgeving/Codex_over_het_welzijn_op_het_werk.pdf (accessed August 27, 2024).

10.

Conte

Lisa

Schrager

Kerith Koss

. 2023. “Reconsidering Dust in Approaches to the Preservation of 9/11 Artifacts.” In Prioritizing People in Ethical Decision-Making and Caring for Cultural Heritage Collections, edited by Owczarek

, 168–83. London: Routledge.

11.

Council of Europe. 2005. Framework Convention on the Value of Cultural Heritage for Society. Council of Europe Treaty Series, No. 199. Adopted in Faro, October 27.

12.

Dalewicz-Kitto

Suzanne

Marston

Holly

. 2016. “Asbestos in the Collection of the Royal Armouries and the Conservation of a First World War German Gasmask.” Arms & Armour 13 (2): 177–89.

13.

De Kezel

Evelien

. 2013. Asbest, gezondheid en veiligheid. Antwerp: Jurisquare.

14.

Decré

Hanne

. 2023. “Gevaar verdoezeld: rechtbank oordeelt dat asbestmaker Eternit opzettelijk fout maakte en zo kanker veroorzaakte bij Eric Jonckheere.” VRT NWS, https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2023/12/04/eternit-proces-uitspraak/ (accessed May 15, 2024).

15.

“Delen en Co met kapitaalverhoging naar de beurs.” 1989. Gazet van Antwerpen, October 6, 1989, 15.

16.

Deucher

M. Virginia

Moore

Tamura L.

Hemlin

Steve

. 2000. “Access Denied: Asbestos Contamination as Catalyst and Hindrance to Collection Retrieval and Preservation.” Journal of the American Institute for Conservation 39 (1): 75–84.

17.

De Vos

Johan

. 2022. Christiane Thijs, een biografie. Gent: ETWIE.

18.

ETWIE. 2019. “Asbestos in Heritage.” https://etwie.be/nl/kennisbank/nieuws/asbestos-in-heritage (accessed May 6, 2024).

19.

ETWIE. “Asbest in collecties (2020-2022).” https://etwie.be/nl/kennisbank/projecten/asbest-in-collecties-2020-2022 (accessed December 27, 2023).

20.

ETWIE. 2022. “Consolidatie van asbest.” https://etwie.be/nl/kennisbank/nieuws/consolidatie-van-asbest (accessed May 6, 2024).

21.

Fredheim

L. Harald

Khalaf

Manal

. 2016. “The Significance of Values: Heritage Value Typologies Re-examined.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 22 (6): 466–81.

22.

Geological Curators’ Group Blog. 2022. “The Case of the “Asbestos” Dinosaur.” https://geocollnews.wordpress.com/2022/07/27/the-case-of-the-asbestos-dinosaur/ (accessed May 7, 2024).

23.

Gerkin

Patrick M.

Doyon-Martin

Jacquelynn

. 2015.1 “Asbestos: Not Just an Exhibit at the Smithsonian.” Critical Criminology 23: 311–28.

24.

Gordon

David M.

2017. “Precursors to Red Rubber: Violence in the Congo Free State, 1885-1895.” Past & Present 236 (1): 133–8.

25.

Haberstich

David

. 1988. “Conservation and Carcinogens. Removing Asbestos from 28,000 Glass-Plate Stereographs (or How to Move Your Asbestos).” Topics in Photographic Preservation 2: 6–11.

26.

Harkes

Danielle

. 2018. “We Do Asbestos We Can.” Manuscript, Reinwardt Academie Amsterdam.

27.

Harrison

Rodney

. 2013. Heritage. Critical Approaches. London and New York, NY: Routledge.

28.

Hawks

Catharine

Makos

Kathryn

. 2000. “Inherent and Acquired Hazards in Museum Objects.” Cultural Resource Management 23: 31–7.

29.

Holzer

Charlotte

Wetzenkircher

Marina

. 2009. “Asbest im musealen Kontext, Ein bewahrenswerter Bestandteil von Kulturgut.” VRD Beiträge zur erhaltung von Kunst und Kulturgut 1: 104–114.

30.

Ingenium Channel. 2022. “Artifacts and Asbestos: Managing Hazards at Ingenium.” https://ingeniumcanada.org/channel/articles/artifacts-and-asbestos-managing-hazards-at-ingenium (accessed May 7, 2024).

31.

Jonckheere

Eric

. 2017. Asbest. Leugens, chantage en mensenlevens. Berchem: Uitgeverij EPO vzw.

32.

Joy

Jody

. 2009. “Reinvigorating Object Biography: Reproducing the Drama of Object Lives.” World Archaeology 41 (4): 540–56.

33.

Levin

Lester

. 2018. “Properties and Uses of Asbestos.” In Asbestos the Hazardous Fiber, edited by Benarde

Melvin A.

, 27–45. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.

34.

Lima

Benny

Laurijssen

Sven

. 1993. “Bewoners ongerust over afbraak van fabriek vol asbest in Deurne.” Gazet van Antwerpen, September 22, 1993, 17.

35.

William

Logan

Reeves

Keir

, eds. 2008. Places of Pain and Shame: Dealing with ‘Difficult Heritage’. London and New York, NY: Routledge.

36.

Loockx

Peter

Januarius

Joeri

Morren

Donna

. 2022. Asbest in je erfgoedcollectie? Wegwijzer voor erfgoedvrijwilligers. Gent: Histories vzw and ETWIE.

37.

Mcculloch

Jock

Tweedale

Geoffrey

. 2008. Defending the Indefensible. The Global Asbestos Industry and its Fight for Survival. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

38.

McIvor

Arthur

. 2024. “Toxic City: Industrial Residues, the Body and Community Activism as Heritage Practice in Glasgow.” In Toxic Heritage. Legacies, Futures, and Environmental Injustice, edited by Kryder-Reid

May

, 239–55. London and New York, NY: Routledge.

39.

Macdondald

Sharon

. 2010. Difficult Heritage: Negotiating the Nazi Past in Nuremberg and Beyond. London and New York, NY: Routledge.

40.

Marshall

Skye

Riddle

Jacqueline

. 2023. “A Tale of Hazards: Ingenium’s Industrial Collections Move.” Conservar Património 44: 15–29.

41.

McIvor

Arthur

. 2014. “Industrial Heritage and the Oral Legcay of Disaster.” In Displaced Heritage Responses to Disaster, Trauma, and Loss, edited by Convery

Ian

Corsane

Gerard

Davis

Peter

, 243–51. Woodbridge: The Boydell Press.

42.

Museum and Heritage Advisor. 2016. “Managing Natural Collections from Asbestos to Radioactive Minerals and Cannabis to Bird Eggs.” https://advisor.museumsandheritage.com/blogs/managing-natural-collections-what-do-i-need-know/ (accessed May 7, 2024).

43.

Museum of London. 2019. “Welcome to the Hazards in Collections eTool.” Hazards in Collections. https://hazardsincollections.org.uk/ (accessed May 6, 2024).

44.

Neirinck

Pieter

. 2019. “Asbest is ook erfgoed.” Faro Tijdschrift 12 (3): 6–11.

45.

Norfolk Museums Shine a Light Project. 2020. “Hazards: Asbestos(sed).” https://shinealightproject.wordpress.com/2020/12/14/hazards-asbestossed/ (accessed May 7, 2024).

46.

Odegaard

Nancy

Sadongei

Alyce

, eds. 2005. Old Poisons, New Problems. A Museum Resource for Managing Contaminated Cultural Materials. Walnut Creek: AltaMira Press.

47.

“Onrust rond afbraak asbestfabriek luwt.” 1993. Gazet van Antwerpen, September 16, 1993, 35.

48.

OVAM. “Asbestveilig Vlaanderen in 2040.” https://overheid.vlaanderen.be/asbestveilig-vlaanderen-in-2040 (accessed December 27, 2023).

49.

Peeters

Ludo

. 2012. “Manufacture Belge de l’amiante et du caoutchouc te Deurne.” Tijdschrift Turninum 1: 1–5.

50.

Ruers

Robert Frank

. 2012. Macht en tegenmacht in de Nederlandse asbestregulering. Boom: Boom Juridische Uitgevers.

51.

Simon

Nina

. 2010. The Participatory Museum. Santa Cruz: Museum 2.0.

52.

Smith

Laurajane

. 2006. Uses of Heritage. London and New York, NY: Routledge.

53.

Samuels

Joshua.

2015. “Difficult Heritage.” In Heritage Keywords. Rhetoric and Redescription in Cultural Heritage, edited by Samuels

K. L.

Rico

, 111–28. Boulder, CO: University Press of Colorado, 2015.

54.

Stassijns

Jan.

2024. “Jarig VolXmuseum ziet toekomst somber in nu collectie beschimmelt en gebouwen wegrotten: “Nood aan investeringen”.” Het Nieuwsblad, Februari 19, 2024. https://www.nieuwsblad.be/cnt/dmf20240219_96148657.

55.

Strong

Della T.

Turnbull

Rose E.

Markwitz

Andreas

. 2018. “Managing Hazardous Materials in New Zealand’s National Petrology Reference Collection.” New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics 61 (4): 562–9.

56.

The Synergist. “Hazard or Artifact?” https://synergist.aiha.org/20210607-hazard-or-artifact (accessed May 7, 2024).

57.

Thives

P. Liseane

Ghisi

Enedir

Júnior

Juarez J.Thives

Vieira

Abel Silva

. 2022. “Is Asbestos Still a Problem in the World? A Current Review.” Journal of Environmental Management 319: 1–11.

58.

Tweedale

Geoffrey

. 2000. Magic Mineral to Killer Dust: Turner & Newall and the Asbestos Hazard. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

59.

Van den

Borre

Patrick Deboosere

Laura

. 2014. “Asbestos in Belgium: An Underestimated Health Risk.” International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health 20 (2): 134–40.

60.

Van den

Borre

Patrick Deboosere

Laura

2016. “The Asbestos Industry in Belgium (1945-2001).” Published online ahead of print January 2016: 1–30. http://interfacedemography.be/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/IDWP2016-2.pdf.

61.

Van den Borre

Laura

Deboosere

Patrick

. 2017. “Understanding a Man-Made Epidemic: The Relation between Historical Asbestos Consumption and Mesothelioma Mortality in Belgium.” TSEG-The Low Countries Journal of Social and Economic History 14 (4): 116–38.

62.

Vandromme

Bram

. 2020. Asbest. Niet wachten tot het stof gaat liggen. Brugge: Die Keure.

63.

Van Horrsen

Jessica

. 2016. A Town Called Asbestos. Environmental Contamination, Health, and Resilience in a Resource Community. British Columbia: UBC Press.

64.

VolXmuseum. “Meer dan een verhaal.” https://www.volxmuseum.be/collectie.php (accessed May 6, 2024).

65.

Wain

Alison

. 1992. “Hazardous Materials in Museum Collections.” AICCM Bulletin 18 (1–2): 3–28.

66.

Wollentz

Gustav

May

Sarah

Holtorf

Cornelius

Högberg

Anders

. 2020. “Toxic Heritage: Uncertain and Unsafe.” In Heritage Futures. Comparative Approaches to Natural and Cultural Heritage Practices, edited by Harrisson

Rodney

DeSilvey

Caitlin

Holtorf

Cornelius

Macdonald

Sharon

Bartolini

Nadia

Breithoff

Esther

Fredheimm

Harald

, et al., 294–313. London: UCL Press.

67.

Ziterasbestin.be. “Zit er asbest in jouw erfgoed?” https://ziterasbestin.be/ziterasbestin/ (accessed December 27, 2023).

68.

Ziterasbestin.be. “Collectie ‘Manufacture Belge d’amiante et de caoutchouc de Deurne’.” https://ziterasbestin.be/ziterasbestin/databank/object/?id=202 (accessed May 6, 2024).