Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Unprovenienced archaeological collections present a unique set of opportunities and challenges for museums. These collections are often from stolen, illegally excavated and/or illicitly transported sources, but can also be the result of improper recording, housing, and handling. Recent trends have relegated unprovenienced archaeological museum collections to storage, neither researched nor exhibited, because of their questionable source and perceived liabilities. The educational value of these types of collections warrants a closer look at the potential benefits and detriments of unprovenienced archaeological collections. This paper discusses the nature of unprovenienced archaeological collections in museums. It recognizes the challenges of researching unprovenienced archaeological collections and presents a framework through which these collections may be recontextualized. Demonstrating the type of information that can be learned about unprovenienced archaeological collections, this paper notes the issues faced in the publication and exhibition of these collections in museums.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ambrose

Tim

, and Paine

Crispin

. 1993. Museum Basics. London: ICOM in conjunction with Routledge.

Anonymous. 1998. Society for American Archaeology: Principles of Archaeological Ethics. International Journal of Cultural Property 7(1): 231–233.

Brodie

Neil

, Doole

Jennifer

, and Watson

Peter

. 2000. Stealing History: The Illicit Trade in Cultural Malertal. Cambridge [U.K.]: McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research.

Buchli

Victor

. 2002. “Introduction.” In The Malertal Cultere Reader, ed. Victor Buchli, 1–22. Oxford: Berg.

Buck

Rebecca A.

, and Gilmore

Jean Allman

. 1998. The New Museum Registealion Methods. Washington, DC: American Association of Museums.

Bunker

Emma C.

2005. “The Acquisition and Ownership of Antiquities in Today's Age of Transition.” In Who Owns the Past? Cultural Policy, Cultural Property, and the Law, ed. Gibbon

Kate Fitz

, 311–317. New Jersey: Rutgers University Press.

Carnell

Clarisse

and Buck

Rebecca

. 1998. “Acquisitions and Accessioning.“ In The New Museum Registration Methods, ed. Buck

Rebecca A.

and Gilmore

Jean Allman

, 157–165. Washington, DC: American Association of Museums.

Coggins

Clemency Chase

. 2005. “Observations of a Combatant.“ In Who Owns the Past? Cultural Policy, Cultural Property, and the Law, ed. Gibbon

Kate Fitz

, 231–237. New Jersey: Rutgers University Press.

DeAngelis

Ildiko P.

2006. “How Much Provenance is Enough? Post-Schultz Guidelines for Art Museum Acquisition of Archaeological Materials and Ancient Art.“ In Art and Cultural Herttage: Law, Policy and Practice, ed. Hoffman

Barbara T.

, 398–408. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

10.

des Portes

Elisabeth

. 1998. Museums and Ethics: Long History, New Development. lnternalional Joirnal of Celteral Property 7(1): 141–148.

11.

Elliot

Robert

, Butler

Darrel

, Earl

Elizabeth

, Finley

Gregg

, Godwin

Kim

, Hughes

Gary

, Lewis

Milford

, and Thomas

Gerald

. 1985. Towards a Material History Methodology. Material History Belletin 22(Fall): 31–40.

12.

Fleming

E. McClung

. 1974. Artifact Study: A Proposed Model. Winterthur Portfolio 9: 153–173.

13.

Ford

Richard I.

1984. “Ethics and the Museum Archaeologist.” In Ethics and Value in Archaeology, ed. Green

Ernestene

, 133–142. New York: The Free Press.

14.

Furst

Hans Jorg

. 1989. “Material Culture Research and the Curation Process.“ In Museum Studies in Material Culture, ed. Pearce

Susan M.

, 98–111. Leicester: University of Leicester.

15.

Glassie

Henry H.

1999. Material Culture. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

16.

Joukowsky

Martha

. 1980 A Complete Manual of Field Archaeology Tools and Teshniques of Field Work for Archaeologists. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.

17.

Martin

John

. 2004. “All Legal and Ethical? Museums and the International Market in Fossils.” In Museums and the future of collecting, ed. Knell

Simon J.

, 155–178. Aldershot, Hampshire, Great Britain: Ashgate.

18.

Merryman

John Henry

, and Elsen

Albert Edward

. 1987. Law, Ethics, and the Visual Arts. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

19.

Muscarella

Oscar White

. 2000. The Lie Besame Great. The Forgery of Ancient Near Eastern Cultures. Studies in the Art and Archaeology of Antiquity, vol. 1. Groningen: Styx Publications.

20.

National Park Service. 1996. National Park Service Museum Handbook, Part I. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.

21.

Pearce

Susan M.

1992. Museums, Objects, and Collections: A Cultural Study. Leicester: Leicester University Press.

22.

Pearce

Susan M.

1990. Archaeological Curatorship. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Press.

23.

Pearce

Susan M.

1986. Thinking about Things: Approaches to the Study of Artifacts. Museums Journal 82(2): 198–201.

24.

Renfrew

Colin

and Bahn

Paul G.

1996. Archaeology theories, methods, and practice. London: Thames and Hudson.

25.

Schiffer

Michael B.

and Miller

Andrea R.

1999. The material life of human beings: Artifacts, behavior, and communication. London: Routledge.

26.

Schlereth

Thomas J.

1985. “Material Culture and Cultural Research.” In Material Culture: A Research Guide, ed. Schlereth

Thomas J.

, 1–34. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.

27.

Stone

Sheila M.

1992. “Documenting Collections.“ In Manual of curatorship a guide to museum practice, ed. Thompson

John M. A.

, 213–228. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann.

28.

Wiseman

James

. 1984. Scholarship and Provenience in the Study of Artifacts. Journal of Field Archaeology 11(1): 67–77.

Studying the Skeletons in the Closet Unprovenienced Archeological Collections in Museums

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References