It has been assumed that the mental health effects of repeated trauma should be incrementally greater than simple additive effects of separate trauma. However, repeated disasters afflicting the same population are uncommon. This study investigated psychiatric disorders following differential exposures to repeated disasters.
Methods
Mental health effects of exposure to repeated disasters of 547 individuals exposed to either flooding, tornadoes, dioxin contamination, and/or radioactive well water were assessed. Structured diagnostic interviews assessed prevalence of psychiatric disorders before and after each of the disasters. A multiple logistic regression model was used to test the association of post-disaster disorders after each flood with the total number of flood exposures, controlling for lifetime pre-disaster disorders.
Results
Approximately one-fifth to one-third of the disaster-exposed groups had a psychiatric disorder following exposure to disaster, but disaster-related posttraumatic stress disorder and incident psychiatric disorders were nonexistent or rare in both post-disaster periods. Most identified post-disaster psychopathology consisted of alcohol use that predated the disasters.
Conclusions
Findings suggest that alcohol use disorder may be more representative of a risk factor for, rather than an outcome of, flood exposure. This possibility is supported by the high lifetime pre-flood prevalence of alcohol use disorders in flood plain populations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
MastenASNarayanAJ. Child development in the context of disaster, war, and terrorism: pathways of risk and resilience. Annu Rev Psychol.2012; 63: 227–257.
2.
SeeryMDHolmanEASilverRC. Whatever does not kill us: cumulative lifetime adversity, vulnerability, and resilience. J Pers Soc Psychol.2010; 99: 1025–1041.
3.
KeinanGShriraAShmotkinD.The association between cumulative adversity and mental health: considering dose and primary focus of adversity. Qual Life Res.2012; 21: 1149–1158.
4.
TurnerRJLloydDA. Lifetime traumas and mental health: the significance of cumulative adversity. J Health Soc Behav.1995; 36: 360–376.
5.
Armed Forces Health Surveillance Center.Associations between repeated deployments to Iraq (OIF/OND) and Afghanistan (OEF) and post-deployment illnesses and injuries, active component, U.S. Armed Forces, 2003-2010. Part II. Mental disorders, by gender, age group, military occupation, and "dwell times" prior to repeat (second through fifth) deployments. MSMR.2011; 18: 2–11.
6.
KlineAFalca-DodsonMSussnerB. Effects of repeated deployment to Iraq and Afghanistan on the health of New Jersey Army National Guard troops: implications for military readiness. Am J Public Health.2010; 100: 276–283.
7.
BreslauNChilcoatHDKesslerRC. Previous exposure to trauma and PTSD effects of subsequent trauma: results from the Detroit Area Survey of Trauma. Am J Psychiatry.1999; 156: 902–907.
8.
BroussardRMyersR.School nurse resilience: experiences after multiple natural disasters. J School Nurs.2010; 26: 203–211.
9.
NorthCS. An exploration of causality in the development and timing of disaster-related PTSD. In: Widom CS, ed. Psychopathology and violence. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2012: 219–230.
10.
NorthCS. Approaching disaster mental health research after the 9/11 World Trade Center terrorist attacks. Psychiatr Clin North Am.2004; 27: 589–602.
11.
NorthCSSurisAMDavisM. Toward validation of the diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder. Am J Psychiatry.2009; 166: 34–41.
12.
NorthCS. Disaster mental health epidemiology: methodological review and interpretation of research findings. Psychiatry.2016; 79: 130–146.
13.
StoughLM. The effects of disaster on the mental health of individuals with disabilities. In: NenaYGaleaSNomsFH eds. Mental health and disasters. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press; 2009: 264–276.
14.
RobinsLNFishbachRLSmithEM. Impact of disaster on previously assessed mental health. In: ShoreJH ed. Disaster stress studies: new methods and findings. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association; 1986: 22–48.
15.
StoughLMMayhornCB.Population segments with disabilities. Int J Mass Emergand Disasters.2013; 31: 384–402.
16.
HasinDSKeyesKMHatzenbuehlerML. Alcohol consumption and posttraumatic stress after exposure to terrorism: effects of proximity, loss, and psychiatric history. Am J Publ Health.2007; 97: 2268–2275.
17.
HarvilleEWXiongXSmithBW. Combined effects of Hurricane Katrina and Hurricane Gustav on the mental health of mothers of small children. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs.2011; 18: 288–296.
18.
MarshallEMFrazierPFrankfurtS. Trajectories of posttraumatic growth and depreciation after two major earthquakes. Psychol Trauma.2015; 7: 112–121.
19.
SmithEMRobinsLNPrzybeckTR. Psychosocial consequences of a disaster. In: ShoreJH.Disaster stress studies: new methods and findings. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association; 1986: 49–76.
20.
LarsonLW. Destructive water: water-caused natural disasters-their abatement and control. Presented at the International Association of Hydrological Sciences Conference; June 24-28, 1996; Anaheim, CA.
RobinsLNHeizerJECroughanJ. NIMH Diagnostic Interview Schedule: version III.Rockville, MD: National institute of Mental Health; 1981.
23.
RobinsLNHeizerJECroughanJ. National Institute of Mental Health Diagnostic Interview Schedule. Its history, characteristics, and validity. Arch Gen Psychiatry.1981; 38: 381–389.
24.
RobinsLNSmithEM. The Diagnostic Interview Schedule/Dis aster Supplement. St. Louis, MO: Washington University; 1983.
25.
RobinsLNHeizerJECottierL. NIMH Diagnostic Interview Schedule, Version Ill-Revised. St. Louis, MO: Washington University; 1989.
26.
BoscarinoJAAdamsREGaleaS.Alcohol use in New York after the terrorist attacks: a study of the effects of psychological trauma on drinkingbehavior. Addict Behav.2006; 31: 606–621.
27.
KhantzianEJ. The self-medication hypothesis of substance use disorders: a reconsideration and recent applications. Harv Rev Psychiatry.1997; 4: 231–244.
28.
PfefferbaumBDoughtyDE. Increased alcohol use in a treatment sample of Oklahoma City bombing victims. Psychiatry.2001; 64: 296–303.
29.
NorthCSTivisLMcMillenJC. Psychiatric disorders in rescue workers after the Oklahoma City bombing. Am J Psychiatry.2002; 159: 857–859.
30.
NorthCSNixonSJShariatS. Psychiatric disorders among survivors of the Oklahoma City bombing. JAMA.1999; 282: 755–762.
31.
NorthCSAdinoffBPollioDE. Alcohol use disorders and drinking among survivors of the 9/11 attacks on the World Trade Center in New York City. Compr Psychiatry.2013; 54: 962–969.
32.
NorthCSRingwaltCLDownsD. Postdisaster course of alcohol use disorders in systematically studied survivors of 10 disasters. Arch Gen Psychiatry.2011; 68: 173–180.
33.
NorthCSKawasakiASpitznagelEL. The course of PTSD, major depression, substance abuse, and somatization after a natural disaster. J Nerv Ment Dis.2004; 192: 823–829.
34.
RobinsLNRegierDA. Psychiatric disorders in America: the Epidemiologic Catchment Area study. New York, NY: The Free Press; 1991.
35.
FloryKHankinBLKloosB. Alcohol and cigarette use and misuse among Hurricane Katrina survivors: psychosocial risk and protective factors. Subst Use Misuse.2009; 44: 1711–1724.
36.
JosephSYuleWWilliamsR. Increased substance use in survivors of the Herald of Free Enterprise disaster. Br J Med Psychol.1993, 66(pt 2):185–191.
37.
SmithDWChristiansenEHVincentR. Population effects of the bombing of Oklahoma City. J Okla State MedAss.1999; 92: 193–198.
38.
VlahovDGaleaSResnickH. Increased use of cigarettes, alcohol, and marijuana among Manhattan, New York, residents after the September 11th terrorist attacks. Am J Epidemiol.2002; 155: 988–996.
39.
VlahovDGaleaSAhernJ. Sustained increased consumption of cigarettes, alcohol, andmarijuana among Manhattan residents after September 11, 2001. Am J Publ Health.2004; 94: 253–254.
40.
BoscarinoJAKirchnerHLHoffmanSN. PTSD and alcohol use after the World Trade Center attacks: a longitudinal study. J Trauma Stress.2011; 24: 515–525.
41.
SimsASimsD.The phenomenology of posttraumatic stress disorder. A symptomatic study of 70 victims of psychological trauma. Psychopathol.1998; 31: 96–112.
42.
NordløkkenAPapeHWentzel-LarsenT. Changes in alcohol consumption after a natural disaster: a study of Norwegian survivors after the 2004 Southeast Asia tsunami. BMC Public Health.2013; 13: 58.
43.
FullertonCSHerberman MashHB, BenevidesKN, . Distress of routine activities and perceived safety associated with post-traumatic stress, depression, and alcohol use: 2002 Washington, DC, sniper attacks. Disaster Med Public Health Prep.2015; 9: 509–515.
