Preliminary Evaluation of Lowering Tympanic Temperature for the Symptomatic Treatment of Multiple Sclerosis

Abstract

Objective : Two pilot studies were designed to assess the effects of acute cooling in the laboratory (experiment one) and daily home cooling (experiment two) on objective indices of MS impairment and disability.

Methods: Experiment one was a single group, repeated measures design in which nine MS outpatients with a history of heat lability were tested for immediate effects of lowering tympanic temperature in the laboratory. Subjects were tested under three experimental conditions separated by about one week: cooling with each of two cooling garments (the Life Support Systems, Inc., Mark VII MicroClimate System™ and the Steele Vest™ Body Cooling System) and no cooling. Experiment two was a prospective, unblinded, parallel group study in which twelve chronic progressive MS outpatients with a history of heat lability entered a six-week cooling protocol. Subjects used a cooling suit at home to lower body temperature two times per day. Five additional MS patients were in a non-cooling control group. In both experiments subjects were evaluated by clinical, neuroperformance, and quality of life indices, and were tested with a reduced battery of indices immediately before and after cooling on their weekly visit to the laboratory.

Results: In experiment one, significant temperature decreases (mean 0.6°C) were achieved with both cooling garments, but no statistically significant change in performance post-cooling was found on any test measure. In experiment two, eight out of twelve subjects reported reduced fatigue and improved ability to ambulate immediately after and up to two to three hours after cooling. There was a significant immediate post-cooling (non-cumulative) improvement on tandem gait and standing balance. Additionally, seven subjects reported long-term improvements in quality of life over the cooling weeks. No statistically significant cumulative effect of cooling was found on objective indices of motor and cognitive function.

Conclusions: The results provided weak subjective support for both acute and cumulative effects of cooling. A placebo effect cannot be ruled out. The study raised important questions regarding development of an appropriate sham cooling procedure, measurement of core temperature changes, and other design issues in evaluating cooling in MS patients.

Keywords

Multiple sclerosis Cooling Symptomatic treatment Cooling garment.

References

Syndulko K. , Jafari M. , Woldanski A. , Baumhefner R. , Tourtellotte W.

Effects of temperature in multiple sclerosis: a review of the literature. Submitted to

J Neuro Rehab 1996.

Matthews WB , Compston A. , Allen IV , Martyn CN McAlpine's multiple sclerosis, 2nd ed. Edinburgh, London, Melbourne , and New York: Churchill Livingstone , 1991.

Simons DJ A note on the effect of heat and cold upon certain symptoms of multiple sclerosis . Bull Neurol Inst NY 1937; 6:385-86.

Bassett SW , Lake BM Use of cold applications in the management of spasticity. Phys Ther Rev 1958;38:333-34.

Boynton BL , Garramone PM , Buca J. Cold baths as adjunct in treatment of patients with multiple sclerosis. Quart Bull Northw Univ Med Sch 1958;33:6.

Geller M. Appearance of signs and symptoms of multiple sclerosis in response to cold . Mt Sinai J Med 1974;41:127-30.

Watson CW Effect of lowering body temperature on the symptoms and signs of multiple sclerosis. New Engl J Med 1959; 261:1253-59.

Tourtellotte WW , Potvin AR , Potvin JH , Syndulko K. Assessment of disability in multiple sclerosis by a trained technician. Acta Neurol'Scand 1981;64 (Suppl 87):82-87.

Syndulko K. , Tourtellotte WW , Baumhefner RW , et al. Neuroperformance evaluation of multiple sclerosis disease progression in a clinical trial: implications for neurological outcomes. J Neuro Rehab 1993;7:153-76.

10.

Brengelmann GL Dilemma of body temperature measurement. In: Shiraki K , Yousef MK (ed.). Man in stressful environments: thermal and work physiology. Sptingfield, IL: Thomas, 1987: 5-22.

11.

Muma BK , Treloar DJ , Wurmlinger K. , et al. Comparison of rectal, axillary, and tympanic membrane temperatures in infants and young children. Ann Emerg Med 1991;20:41-44.

12.

Rao SM , Leo GJ , Bemardin L. , Unverzagt F. Cognitive dysfunction in multiple sclerosis. I. Frequency, patterns, and prediction . Neurology 1991;41:685-91.

13.

Syndulko K. , Jafari M. , Baumhefner R. , Tourtellotte WW Single-subject design for the objective evaluation of a cooling suit in the symptomatic treatment of chronic progressive multiple sclerosis of moderate severity. Ann Neurol 1991;30:278.

14.

Potvin AR , Tourtellotte WW Quantitative examination of neurologic function. Volume 1. Scientific basis and design of instrumented tests. Boca Raton, FL : CRC Press, Inc., 1985.

15.

Potvin AR , Tourtellotte WW Quantitative examination of neurologic function. Volume II. Methodology for test and patient assessments and design of a computer-automated system . Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, Inc. , 1985.

16.

Kondraske GV A PC-based performance measurement laboratory system. J Clin Engr 1990;15:467-78.

17.

Cohen SN , Syndulko K. , Tourtellotte WW , Potvin AR Critical frequency of photic driving in the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis: a comparison to pattern evoked responses. Arch Neurol 1980;37:80-83.

18.

Kurtzke JF Rating neurologic impairment in multiple sclerosis: an expanded disability status scale (EDSS). Neurology 1983;33: 1444-52.

19.

International Federation of Multiple Sclerosis Societies. Symposium on a Minimal Record of Disability for Multiple Sclerosis. Vancouver, Canada, September 11,1,2, 1983. Acta Neurol Scand 1984;101 (Suppl):1-217.

20.

Dupuy HJ , Engel A. , Devine BK , Scanlon J. , Quere CL Selected symptoms of psychological distress. United States Vital and Health Statistics Series 1: Programs and Collection Procedures 1970; 11:1-44.

21.

Beck AT , Ward CH , Mendelson M. , Moch J. , Erbaugh J.

An inventory for measuring depression. Arch Genl

Psychiat 1965;4:561-71.

22.

Krupp L. , LaRocca N. , Muir—Nash J, Steinberg A. The Fatigue Severity Scale. Arch Neurol 1989;46:1121-23.

23.

Crook T. , Salama M. , Gobert J. A computerized test battery for detecting and assessing memory disorders . In: Bes A , Cahn J , Hoyer S , Marc Vergenes JP , Wisniewski HM (eds.). Senile dementias: early detection. London -Paris: John Libbey Eurotext , 1986: 79-85.

24.

Marcus P. Some effects of cooling and heating areas of the head and neck on body temperature measurement at the ear. Aerosp Med 1973;44:397-402.

25.

Shiraki K. , Sagawa S. , Tajima F. , Yokota A. , Hashimoto M. , Brengelmann L. Independence of brain and tympanic temperatures in an unanesthetized human . J Appl Physiol 1988;1988:482-86.

26.

McCaffrey TV , McCook RD , Wurster RD Effect of head skin temperature on tympanic and oral temeprature in man. J Appl Physiol 1975;39:114-18.

27.

Boynton BL , Garramone PM , Buca JT Observations on the effects of cool baths for patients with multiple sclerosis . Phys Ther Rev 1959; 39:297-99.