Comparison of Time Delay during In-Flight and Ground Simulation

Abstract

An in-flight experiment was performed to investigate the effects of time delay on manual flight control and flying qualities. The experiment was conducted using the USAF/FDL variable-stability NT-33A aircraft. Pure time delay was added equally to the pitch and roll flight control system. Evaluation tasks were presented on a head-up display (HUD). Instrument meteorological conditions (IMC) were simulated which limited the visual cues available to the pilot to the 20 degree foveal scene provided by the HUD. The in-flight time delay data were generated with full fidelity, unlimited range of motion cues. Using the same cockpit and a digital aerodynamic simulation, the in-flight experiment was completely replicated as a fixed-based ground simulation. Thus, the effects of extreme conditions in motion cuing (i.e., full motion versus no-motion) were examined for constant visual cuing.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bailey

R.E.

Knotts

L.H.

Horowitz

S.J.

Malone

H.L.

(1987). Effect of time delay on manual flight control and flying qualities during in-flight and ground-based simulation. Proceedings of the AIAA Flight Simulation Technologies Conference (pp. 30–38). Washington, D.C.: AIAA.

Bailey

R.E.

Knotts

L.H.

Levison

W.H.

(1987). An investigation of time delay during in-flight and ground-based simulation. Buffalo, NY: Calspan Corporation, Final Report Number 7205–16.

Hall

G.W.

Huber

R.W.

(1970). System description and performance data for the USAF/Calspan Variable Stability T-33 Airplane. Wright Patterson Air Force Base, OH: Flight Dynamics Laboratory, Technical Report AFFDL-TR-70-71.

Levison

W.H.

Papazion

(1987). The effects of time delay and simulation mode on closed loop pilot/vehicle performance: model analysis and manned simulation results. Proceedings of the AIAA Flight Simulation Technologies Conference (pp. 39–49). Washington, D.C., AIAA.

Miller

G.K.

Riley

D.R.

(1976). The effect of visual-motion time delays on pilot performance in a pursuit tracking task. Proceedings of the AIAA Visual and Motion Simulation Conference. Washington, D.C., AIAA.