Assessment of an Interactive Environment for Developing Human-Computer Interfaces

Abstract

The goal of this research was to empirically evaluate the usefulness of an interactive environment for developing human-computer interfaces. In particular, it focused on a set of interactive tools, called the Author's Interactive Dialogue Environment (AIDE), for human-computer interface implementation. AIDE is used by an interface design specialist, called a dialogue author, to implement an interface by directly manipulating and defining its objects, rather than by the traditional method of writing source code. In a controlled experiment, a group of dialogue author subjects used AIDE 1.0 to implement a predefined interface, and a group of application programmer subjects implemented the identical interface using programming code. Dialogue author subjects performed the task more than three times faster than the application programmer subjects. This study empirically supports, possibly for the first time, the long-standing claim that interactive tools for interface development can improve productivity and reduce frustration in developing interfaces over traditional programming techniques for interface development.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Graphical Input Interaction Technique Workshop Summar

1983. Computer Graphics, 17 1 (January) 5–30.

Hartson

H. R.

Hix

Human-Computer Interface Development: Concepts and Systems for Its Management 1986. In revision for ACM Computing Surveys, ms. 134 pp.

Hartson

H. R.

Johnson Hix

Ehrich

R. W.

1984 A Human-Computer Dialogue Management System. In Proceedings of INTERACT 1984, First IFIP Conference on Human-Computer Interaction. London (September) 57–61.

Hayes

1985. Executable Interface Definitions using Form Based Interface Abstractions. In Advances in Human Computer Interaction, Volume 1, Hartson

Rex H.

, ed., Ablex Publishing Co., 161–190.

Hix

Hartson

H. R.

An Interactive Environment for Dialogue Development: Its Design, Use, and Evaluation – or – Is AIDE Useful? In Proc. of CHI 1986 Conferenc on Human Factors in Computing Systems, Boston, MA (April 1986).

( Johnson

D. Hix.

1985. The Structure and Developmen of Human-Computer Interfaces. PhD Dissertation, De partment of Computer Science. Virginia Polytechnl Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA.

Kamran

Feldman

M. B.

1983. Graphics Programming Independent of Interaction Techniques and Style Computer Graphics, 171 (January), 58–66.

Kasik

D. J.

1982. A User Interface Management Systen Computer Graphics, 16 3, 99–106.

Olsen

D. R.

Jr.

1983. Automatic Generation of Interactiv Systems. Computer Graphics, 171 (January), 53–57.

10.

Wasserman

A. I.

1982. The User Software Engineering Methodology: An Overview. In Information System Design Methodologies. Verrijn-Stuart

A. A.

, ed. North Holland, 591–628.