Asynchronous Multimodal Communications about Shared Images: A Comparison between Microsoft's Powerpoint and CWS'S Pointntalk for Creating and using Directional Instructions

Abstract

Ten West Point cadets between the ages of 18 and 24 were tested in their ability to build a complex structure using directions provided by either PointnTalk, a purpose built asynchronous multimodal communications tool developed by Collaborative Work Systems (CWS), Inc., or the well known Microsoft program PowerPoint. Cadets then used the opposite system, PointnTalk or PowerPoint respectively, to create their own presentation of an instructional dialogue directing someone how to complete the same complex structure. The results showed that PointnTalk instructions took longer to administer, but that the tool proved to be better at communicating higher level processes and produced superior performance in successful task completion of the participant built instructions. Results support multimodal communication theories and natural language communication strategies for effective asynchronous communication.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

J. R.

Bower

G. H.

(1973). Human associative memory. Washington, DC: Winston.

Bower

J. I.

(2004) The Impact of Asynchronous Multimedia Communications on Understanding and Recall. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 48th Annual Meeting. New Orleans, Louisiana.

Chalfonte

B. L.

Fish

R. S.

Kraut

R. E.

(1991). Expressive richness: A comparison of speech and text as media for revision. In Robertson

S. P.

Olson

G.M.

Olson

J.S.

(Eds.). Reaching through technology: Proceedings of the Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. New Orleans, Louisiana, 21–26.

Chapman

R. J.

(2002). Multimodal, Asynchronously Shared Slide Shows as a Design Strategy for Engineering Distributed Work in the National Airspace System. Doctorial Dissertation, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH.

Daly-Jones

Monk

Frohlich

D.M.

Geelhoed

Loughran

(1997) Multimodal messages: The pen and voice opportunity. Interacting with Computers 9, 1–25.

Ferris

T. K.

Sarter

(2008). Cross-modal links among vision, audition, and touch in complex environments. Human Factors Vol 50(1) 17–26.

Faraday

P. M.

Sutcliffe

A. G.

(1997). Designing effective multimedia presentations. Proceedings of CHI 1997, 272–279.

Neuwirth

C. M.

Chandhok

Charney

Wojahn

Kim

(1994). Distributed collaborative writing: A comparison of spoken and written modalities for reviewing and revising documents. Human Factors in Computing Systems. April 24–28, 51–57.

Paivio

(1986). Mental representations: a dual coding approach. Oxford. England: Oxford University Press.

10.

Wasinger

(2006). Multimodal interaction with mobile devices: fusing a broad spectrum of modality combinations. IOS Press.

11.

Wickens

C. D.

(1992). Engineering Psychology and Human Performance, 2nd ed. Harper Collins, New York.