Analysis of Subjective Body Discomfort Ratings during Simulated Prolonged Driving Tasks: What Measures are most Effective?

Abstract

Subjective discomfort ratings are a common assessment technique in human factors and ergonomics, and there exist a number of different methods for analyzing ratings (e.g., mean, median, maximum rating, etc.). The objective of this research was to evaluate multiple methods for analyzing body discomfort ratings. Perceived discomfort of eight participants was measured across ten body parts (buttock, left buttock, right buttock, lower back, upper back, neck, shoulder, eye, thigh and whole body) during 2-hour simulated driving tasks at 3 backrest angles (105°, 120°, 135°). Discomfort ratings were collected every 15 minutes using a modified Borg CR-scale. The time weighted discomfort (TWD) average of was found to be more sensitive to backrest angle changes than other measures considered. In addition, factor analysis revealed different methods provided different groupings of body parts, and the method selected for analyzing subjective discomfort ratings should be selected based on the objective of the study.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bishu

R. R.

Hallbeck

M. S.

Riley

M. W.

(1991). Seating comfort and its relationship to spinal profile: A pilot study. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 8(1), 89–101.

Borg

(2007). On perceived Exertion and its Measurement. Doctoral dissertation, Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Sweden.

Borg

(2002). A comparison of AME and CR100 for scaling perceived exertion. Acta Psychologica, 109, 157–175.

Borg

(1962). Physical performance and perceived exertion. Studia Psychologica et Paedagogica, Series altera, Investigationes X1. Lund, Sweden: Gleerup.

Borg

(2001). A new generation of scaling methods: Level-anchored ratio scaling. Psychologica, 28, 15–45.

Design & Emotion Society. (2008). Tools to measure SENSORY characteristics. Retrieved February 20, 2008, from World Wide Web: http://www.designandemotion.org/society/knowledge_base/tools_methods.html?showcase=1category=4.

England

M. A.

Wakely

(2006). Color atlas of the brain and spinal cord: An introduction to normal neuroanatomy. Philadelphia, PA: Mosby Elsevier. pp. 223.

Falou

W. E.

Duchene

Grabisch

Hewson

Langeron

Lino

(2003). Evaluation of driver discomfort during long-duration car driving. Applied Ergonomics, 34(3), 249–255.

Helander

(2003). Forget about ergonomics in chair design? Focus on aesthetics and comfort! Ergonomics 46 (13–14), 1306–1319.

10.

Helander

Zhang

(1997). Field studies of comfort and discomfort in sitting. Ergonomics 40 (9), 895–915.

11.

Hughes

L. E.

Babski-Reeves

Nussbaum

Maury

Smith-Jackson

(2004). Effects of time pressure and mental workload on physiological risk factors for upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders while typing. M. Sc. Thesis. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia.

12.

Johnson

R. A.

Wichern

D. W.

(2007). Applied multivariate statistical analysis. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson Prentice Hall. Chapter 9 and Chapter 10, pp. 481–574.

13.

Kourinka

Jonsson

Kilbom

Vinterberg

Biering-Sorensen

Andersson

Jorgensen

(1987). Standardised Nordic questionnaires for the analysis of musculoskeletal symptoms, Applied Ergonomics, 18(3), 233–237.

14.

Kyung

Nussbaum

M. A.

Babski-Reeves

(2007). Driver sitting comfort and discomfort (part 1): Use of subjective ratings in discriminating car sets and correspondence among ratings. Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 38 (5–6), 516–525.

15.

Looze

M. P. D.

Kuijt-Evers

L. F. M.

Dieen

J. V.

(2003). Sitting comfort and discomfort and the relationships with objective measures. Ergonomics, 46(10), 985–997.

16.

Mansfield

N. J.

MacMull

S. J.

Singla

Rimell

A. N.

(2007). Relative influence of sitting duration and vibration magnitude on sitting discomfort in a car seat. 42nd United Kingdom Conference on Human Responses to Vibration. ISVR, University of Southampton, Southampton, England, September 10–12, 2007.

17.

Lim

Choi

H. S.

Chung

M. K.

(2005). Evaluation of driver's discomfort and postural change using dynamic body pressure distribution. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 35(12), 1085–1096.

18.

Schifferstein

Hekkert

(2008). Product experience. San Diego, CA: Elsevier, pp. 459.

19.

Smith

R. D.

Andrews

D. M.

Wawrow

P. T.

(2006). Development and evaluation of the automotive seating discomfort questionnaire (ASDQ). International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 36(2), 141–149.

20.

Zenk

Mergl

Hartung

Bubb

(2007). Predicting overall seating discomfort based on body area ratings. SAE World Congress & Exhibition, April 2007, Detroit, MI, USA.

21.

Zhang

Helander

M. G.

Drury

C. G.

(1996). Identifying factors of comfort and discomfort in sitting, Human Factors, 38(3), 377–389.