Nuisance Alerts in Operational ATC Environments: Classification and Frequencies

Abstract

Nuisance alerts can cause many problems in operational settings. They are distracting and can lead to desensitization. In Air Traffic Control (ATC), there has been much anecdotal evidence regarding the high rate of nuisance alerts in facilities, but there have been few formal studies to evaluate this problem. In this study, we measured the rate of nuisance alerts in en route and terminal ATC facilities. After calculating the average duration of alerts, the percentage of alerts that receive a controller response, and the timing of responses to these alerts, we estimate that 62% of Conflict Alerts (CAs) and 91% of Minimum Safe Altitude Warnings (MSAWs) in en route, and 44% of CAs and 61% of MSAWs in terminal are unnecessary. Using human factors principles, we make recommendations for improving the accuracy and utility of ATC alerts.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahlstrom

(2003). An initial survey of National Airspace System auditory alarm issues in terminal Air Traffic Control (DOT/FAA/CT-TN03/10).

Allendoerfer

Friedman-Berg

Pai

(2007). Human factors analysis of safety alerts in air traffic control (DOT/FAA/TC-07/22).

Altmann

E. M.

Trafton

J. G.

(2002). Memory for goals: An activation-based model. Cognitive Science, 26, 39–83.

Breznitz

(1983). Cry wolf: The Psychology of False Alarms. Hillsdale, NJ.

Cardosi

Boole

P. W.

(1991). Analysis of pilot response time to time-critical Air Traffic Control calls (NTIS No. DOT/FAA/RD-91/20).

Federal Aviation Administration. (2006). Adjustable volume for the TRACON, Case File No. ATO0T-STARS-1021. Internal system configuration management communications between a field site and the FAA Standard Terminal Automation Replacement System (STARS) program, initiated February 1, 2006.

Getty

D. J.

Swets

J. A.

Pickett

R. M.

Gonthier

(1995). System operator response to warnings of danger: A laboratory investigation of the effects of the predictive value of a warning on human response time. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 1, 19–33.

Jones

D. M.

(1999). The 1997 BPS Broadbent Lecture: The cognitive psychology of auditory distraction. British Journal of Psychology, 90, 167–187.

Meyer

(2001). Effects of warning validity and proximity on responses to warnings. Human Factors, 43, 563–572.

10.

Parasuraman

Hancock

P. A.

(1999). Designing automated warning systems: A signal detection and Bayesian analysis. In Scerbo

M. W.

Mouloua

Automation technology and human performance: Current research and trends (pp. 63–67. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.

11.

Rogers

(1999). Flight test results of the controlled flight into terrain avoidance maneuver in fly-by-wire transports. Report of the Air Line Pilots Association. Airworthiness Performance Evaluation and Certification Committee.

12.

Sanquist

T. F.

Thurman

D. A.

Mahy

H. A.

(2005). The human element in homeland security systems: Application issues and research needs. Proceedings of the HFES 49th Annual Meeting, 913–917.

13.

Sarter

N. B.

(2005). Graded and multimodal interruption cueing in support of preattentive reference and attention management. Proceedings of the HFES 49th Annual Meeting, 478–47.

14.

Stokes

Wickens

(1988). Aviation displays. In Wiener

E. L.

Nagel

D. C.

Human factors in aviation (pp. 387–431).

15.

Watson

Sanderson

Anderson

(2000). Designing auditory displays for team environments. Proceedings of the 5th Australian Aviation Psychology Symposium (AAvPA).

16.

Wickens

C. D.

Dixon

S. R.

(2005). The benefits of imperfect diagnostic automation: A synthesis of the literature (Technical Report AHFD-05-01/MAAD-05-1).

17.

Xiao

Seagull

F. J.

Nieves-Khouw

Barczak

Perkins

(2004). Organizational historical analysis of the failure to respond to alarm problem. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics. Part A: Systems and Humans, 34, 772–778.