A Comparison of Work Domain and Task Analysis for Identifying Information Requirements: A Case Study of Rural Intersection Decision Support Systems

Abstract

Minnesota drivers are over-represented in accidents at rural intersections and many crashes are attributable to drivers accepting unsafe gaps. In this context, intersection decision support (IDS) systems are promising technologies for supporting driver decision-making. A significant activity during IDS development is to determine the information requirements to display to drivers. To be effective, an IDS system must present information that helps drivers successfully negotiate intersections. This paper compares two methods for identifying information requirements: work domain analysis (WDA) and hierarchical task analysis (HTA). Results showed that 58% of the requirements were identified by WDA, 7% by HTA, and 35% by both methods. An analysis of driver errors at intersections during the HTA activity identified that drivers can perceive gaps at intersections in different ways. This important nuance was not captured in the WDA. Therefore, both WDA and HTA are effective methods for identifying information requirements. Discussion focuses on the importance of both WDA and HTA in IDS system development.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Burns

Hajdukiewicz

(2004). Ecological interface design. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.

American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (1997). Highway safety design and operations guide. Washington, DC: AASHTO.

Caird

J. K.

Hancock

P. A.

(1994). The perception of arrival time for different oncoming vehicles at an intersection. Ecological Psychology, 6(2), 83–109.

Caird

J. K.

Hancock

P. A.

(2002). Contributing factors to left turn and gap acceptance crashes. In Dewar

R.E.

Olson

, Human factors in traffic safety (pp. 613–652). Tucson, AZ: Lawyers & Judges Publishing.

Chovan

J. D.

Tijerina

Everson

J. H.

Pierowicz

J. A.

Hendricks

D. L.

(1994a). Examination of intersection left turn across path crashes and potential IVHS countermeasures (Rep. No. DOT HS 808 154). Cambridge, MA: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

Chovan

J. D.

Tijerina

Pierowicz

J. A.

Hendricks

D. L.

(1994b). Examination of non-signalized intersection, straight crossing path crashes and potential IVHS countermeasures (Rep. No. DOT HS 808 152). Cambridge, MA: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

Creaser

J. I.

Rakauskas

M. E.

Ward

N. J.

Laberge

J. C.

Donath

(in press). Concept evaluation of intersection decision support (IDS) system interfaces to support drivers' gap acceptance decisions at rural stop-controlled intersections. Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour.

Jamieson

G. A.

Miller

C. M.

W. H.

Vicente

K. J.

(in press). Integrating task- and work domain-based work analyses in ecological interface design: A process control case study. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man & Cybernetics.

Kirwan

Ainsworth

(1992). A guide to task analysis. Taylor and Francis: Bristol, PA.

10.

Laberge

J. C.

Creaser

J. I.

Rakauskas

M. E.

Ward

N. J.

(2006). Design of an intersection decision support (IDS) interface to reduce crashes at rural stop-controlled intersections. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 14, 39–56.

11.

Lee

Stoner

Wiese

Hoffman

McGehee

Brucker

(2003). Grounding driver attention to enhance vehicle safety. Final report. Iowa City, IA: University of Iowa.

12.

Preston

Storm

(2003). Review of Minnesota's rural crash data. Eagan, MN: CH2M HILL.

13.

Preusser

D. F.

Willliams

A. F.

Ferguson

S. A.

Ulmer

R. G.

Weinstein

H. B.

(1998). Fatal crash risk for older drivers at intersections. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 30(2), 151–159.

14.

Scialfa

C. T.

Kline

D. W.

Lyman

B. J.

Kosnik

(1987). Age differences in judgements of automobile velocity and distance. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 31, 645–650.

15.

Staplin

Lyles

R. W.

(1991). Age differences in motion perception and specific traffic maneuver problems. Transportation Research Record, 1325, 23–33.

16.

Staplin

Lococo

McKnight

A. J.

NcKnight

A. S.

Odenheimer

(1998). Intersection negotiation problems of older drivers, Volume II: Background synthesis on age and intersection driving difficulties (Rep. No. DOT HS 808 850). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

17.

Stoner

H. A.

Wiese

E. E.

Lee

J. D.

(2003). Applying ecological interface design to the driving domain: The results of an abstraction hierarchy analysis. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 47th Annual Meeting, 444–448.

18.

Vicente

K. J.

(1999). Cognitive work analysis: Towards safe, productive, and healthy computer-based work. Erlbaum: Mahwah, NJ.

19.

Vicente

K. J.

(2002). Ecological interface design: Progress and challenges. Human Factors, 44(1), 62–78.