Pilot Error in Copying Air Traffic Control Clearances

Abstract

A study investigating the accuracy of pilots' copying air traffic control clearances is described. Twentyfour airline pilots listened to 28 taped clearances and copied them down on an answer sheet using shorthand, longhand, or some combination of these according to their preferences. The copied clearances were analyzed by the number of correctly copied elements, the number of omitted elements, and the number of extraneous elements that were not present in the original clearance. Preliminary results indicate a strong influence of habit and familiar operating environment and procedures on the accuracy of copying unfamiliar information. Common errors included victor-airways copied as jet-airways, low altitudes copied as much higher, and slow speeds copied as much higher. The vulnerability of controller-pilot communications to the effects of unfamiliarity is apparent. A detailed analysis of these data may provide for a better understanding of the shortcomings of controller-pilot communication.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Federal Aviation Administration (2000). Air traffic control [7110.65M]. Washington, DC: Author.

Hopkin

V. D.

(1995). Human factor in air traffic control. Bristol, PA: Taylor & Francis.

Loftus

Dark

Williams

(1979). Short-term memory factors in ground controller/pilot communication. Human Factors, 21, 169–181.

Morrow

Clark

H. H.

Lee

Rodvold

(1990). Collaboration in controller-pilot communications. Paper presented at the 1990 Meeting of the Psychonomic Society in New Orleans, LA.

Morrow

Lee

Rodvold

(1993). Analysis of problems in routine controller—pilot communication. The International Journal of Aviation Psychology, 3(4), 285–302.

Prinzo

O. V.

(1996). An analysis of approach control/pilot voice communications. DOT/FAA/AM-96/26. Washington, DC: Federal Aviation Administration.

Prinzo

O. V.

Britton

T. W.

(1993). ATC/pilot voice communications: A survey of the literature. DOT/FAA/AM-93/20. Washington, DC: Federal Aviation Administration.

Prinzo

O. V.

Britton

T. W.

(1994). A taxonomic analysis of terminal air traffic control/pilot communications. In Aerospace Systems Integration Through Technology and Training [SAE/SP94/1051], pp. 71–75. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers.

Prinzo

O. V.

Britton

T. W.

Hendrix

(1995). Development of coding form for approach control/pilot voice communications. DOT/FAA/AM-95/15. Washington, DC: Federal Aviation Administration.