Do Disproportionate Minority Contact (DMC) Mandate Reforms Change Decision-Making? Decomposing Disparities in the Juvenile Justice System

Abstract

To reduce disproportionate minority contact (DMC) in their juvenile justice systems, policy makers must alter decision-making processes through policy interventions. Effective DMC reforms should ideally diminish the influence of race on processing outcomes and give more weight to objective differences in cases such as charge severity or a youth’s prior adjudications. This study evaluates the impacts of DMC interventions on secure detention and placement decisions. It introduces the Gelbach decomposition approach to estimate unexplained racial differences in processing outcomes. The method also illuminates the relative importance of case factors in reducing or aggravating explainable group differences over time. Findings suggest DMC reforms can moderate the effect of race on processing outcomes. When detailed, decomposition estimates show a greater emphasis on prior contact for detention and legal factors and prior history for placement following reform. DMC interventions may then help diminish unwarranted processing distinctions, and decomposition methods can inform these policy debates.

Keywords

racial disparity disproportionate minority contact juvenile justice reform evaluation decomposition

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bishop

Leiber

Johnson

(2010). Contexts of decision making in the juvenile justice system: An organizational approach to understanding minority overrepresentation. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 8, 213–233.

Blinder

A. S.

(1973). Wage discrimination: Reduced form and structural estimates. The Journal of Human Resources, 8, 436.

Breaux

Jannetta

(2014, 8 11). Could risk assessment contribute to racial disparity in the justice system? Retrieved April 10, 2018 from https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/could-risk-assessment-contribute-racial-disparity-justice-system

Burruss

G. W.

Kempf-Leonard

(2002). The questionable advantage of defense counsel in juvenile court. Justice Quarterly, 19, 37–68.

Cabaniss

Frabutt

Kendrick

Arbuckle

(2007). Reducing disproportionate minority contact in the juvenile justice system: Promising practices. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 12, 393–401.

Coleman

(2010). A disproportionate minority contact (DMC) chronology: 1988 to date. Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

Davis

Sorensen

J. R.

(2013). Disproportionate minority confinement of juveniles: A national examination of Black–White disparity in placements, 1997–2006. Crime & Delinquency, 59, 115–139.

Donnelly

E. A.

(2017a). Racial disparity reform: Racial inequality and policy responses in US national politics. Journal of Crime and Justice, 40, 462–477.

Donnelly

E. A.

(2017b). The disproportionate minority contact mandate: An examination of its impacts on juvenile justice processing outcomes (1997–2011). Criminal Justice Policy Review, 28, 347–369.

10.

Feld

B. C.

(1991). Justice by geography: Urban, suburban, and rural variations in Juvenile Justice Administration. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1973-), 82, 156.

11.

Feyerherm

(1995). The DMC initiative: The convergence of policy and research themes. In Kempf-Leonard

Pope

Feyerherm

(Eds.), Minorities in juvenile justice (pp 127–144). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

12.

Feyerherm

Snyder

Villarruel

(2006). Identification and monitoring. In Disproportionate minority contact technical assistance manual (3rd ed., pp. 1–37). Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

13.

Fix

R. L.

Cyperski

M. A.

Burkhart

B. R.

(2017). Disproportionate minority contact: Comparisons across juveniles adjudicated for sexual and non-sexual offenses. Sexual Abuse, 29, 291–308.

14.

Gelbach

J. B.

(2014). B1X2: Stata module to account for changes when X2 is added to a base model with X1. Retrieved April 10, 2018 from https://econpapers.repec.org/software/bocbocode/s457814.htm

15.

Gelbach

J. B.

(2016). When do covariates matter? And which ones, and how much? Journal of Labor Economics, 34, 509–543.

16.

Griffin

(2008). Doing something about DMC (Pennsylvania progress) (pp. 1–8). Pittsburgh, PA: National Coalition for Juvenile Justice.

17.

Griffith

Jirard

Ricketts

(2012). Pennsylvania juvenile justice disproportionate minority contact (DMC) monitoring, reduction, and prevention efforts. Shippensburg, PA: Juvenile Court Judges’ Commission/Center for Juvenile Justice Training and Research.

18.

Hanes

(2012). Disproportionate minority contact (OJJDP In Focus) (pp. 1–4). Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

19.

Hou

(2014). A general approach to effect decomposition: General approach to effect decomposition. Social Science Quarterly, 95, 894–904.

20.

Hoytt

E. H.

Schiraldi

Smith

B. V.

Ziedenberg

(2002). Reducing racial disparities in juvenile detention. Pathways to Juvenile Detention Reform 8 (Vol. 8). Baltimore, MD: Annie E. Casey Foundation. Retrieved April 5, 2018 from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED467685

21.

Hsia

Hamparian

(1998). Disproportionate minority confinement: 1997 update (Juvenile Justice Bulletin) (pp. 1–12). Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

22.

Huizinga

Thornberry

T. P.

Knight

Lovegrove

Loeber

Farrington

(2007). Disproportionate minority contact in the juvenile justice system: A study of differential minority arrest/referral to court in three cities. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.

23.

Hurst

Zawicki

(2003). Minorities in Pennsylvania’s juvenile justice system (Pennsylvania Juvenile Justice Statistical Bulletin) . Pittsburgh, PA: National Center for Juvenile Justice.

24.

Kempf

(1992). The role of race in juvenile justice processing in Pennsylvania (pp. 1–192). Shippensburg, PA: Juvenile Court Judges’ Commission/Center for Juvenile Justice Training and Research.

25.

Kurlychek

M. C.

Hurst

(1998). Reducing disproportionate minority confinement: A data driven approach (Pennsylvania Progress Series) . Harrisburg, PA: National Coalition for Juvenile Justice.

26.

Leiber

Bishop

Chamlin

M. B.

(2011). Juvenile justice decision-making before and after the implementation of the disproportionate minority contact (DMC) mandate. Justice Quarterly, 28, 460–492.

27.

Leiber

Peck

(2015). Race, gender, crime severity, and decision making in the juvenile justice system. Crime & Delinquency, 61, 771–797.

28.

Leiber

Rodriguez

(2011). The implementation of the disproportionate minority contact mandate: A failure or success? Race and Justice, 1, 103–124.

29.

MacDonald

Arkes

Nicosia

Pacula

R. L.

(2014). Decomposing racial disparities in prison and drug treatment commitments for criminal offenders in California. The Journal of Legal Studies, 43, 155–187.

30.

MacDonald

J. M.

Chesney-Lind

(2001). Gender bias and juvenile justice revisited: A multiyear analysis. Crime & Delinquency, 47, 173–195.

31.

Mackinnon

D. P.

Dwyer

J. H.

(1993). Estimating mediated effects in prevention studies. Evaluation Review, 17, 144–158.

32.

Maggard

S. R.

(2015). Assessing the impact of the Juvenile Detention Alternatives Initiative (JDAI): Predictors of secure detention and length of stay before and after JDAI. Justice Quarterly, 32, 571–597.

33.

Majumdar

(2017). Decomposing disproportionate minority contact in juvenile justice. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 0, 1–18.

34.

Mallett

C. A.

(2018). Disproportionate minority contact in juvenile justice: Today’s, and yesterdays, problems. Criminal Justice Studies, 0, 1–19.

35.

Mallett

C. A.

Stoddard-Dare

(2010). Predicting secure detention placement for African-American juvenile offenders: Addressing the disproportionate minority confinement problem. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 8, 91–103.

36.

Mooradian

J. K.

(2012). Breaking the lock: Addressing ‘disproportionate minority confinement’ in the United States using a human rights approach. Journal of Social Work, 12, 37–50.

37.

Moore

L. D.

Padavic

(2011). Risk assessment tools and racial/ethnic disparities in the juvenile justice system: Risk assessment tools and racial/ethnic disparities. Sociology Compass, 5, 850–858.

38.

National Center for Juvenile Justice. (2018). National juvenile court data archive. Retrieved April 10, 2018 from https://www.ojjdp.gov/ojstatbb/njcda/asp/by_state.asp?state=Pennsylvania

39.

Nellis

Richardson

(2010). Getting beyond failure: Promising approaches for reducing DMC. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 8, 266–276.

40.

Oaxaca

(1973). Male–female wage differentials in urban labor markets. International Economic Review, 14, 693–709.

41.

Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention. (2014). Disproportionate minority contact (DMC) Literature Review: A Product of the Model Programs Guide. Washington DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention. Retrieved April 5, 2018 from: https://www.ojjdp.gov/mpg/litreviews/Disproportionate_Minority_Contact.pdf

42.

Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention. (2018). State compliance with JJDP act core requirements. Retrieved August 26, 2014 from http://www.ojjdp.gov/compliance/compliancedata.html

43.

Paternoster

Brame

Mazerolle

Piquero

(1998). Using the correct statistical test for the equality of regression coefficients. Criminology, 36, 859–866.

44.

Peck

J. H.

(2016). The importance of evaluation and monitoring within the disproportionate minority contact (DMC) mandate: Future directions in juvenile justice research. Race and Justice, 8, 305–329. doi:10.1177/2153368716675923.

45.

Pennsylvania Juvenile Court Judges’ Commission. (2015). Pennsylvania juvenile delinquency benchbook. Harrisburg, PA: Pennsylvania Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Commission.

46.

Piquero

(2008). Disproportionate minority contact. The Future of Children, 18, 59–79.

47.

Pope

Feyerherm

(1990). Minority status and juvenile justice processing: An assessment of the research literature, Part I and II. Criminal Justice Abstracts, 22, 327–385; 527–542.

48.

Pope

Feyerherm

(1993). Minorities and the juvenile justice system. Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

49.

Pope

Lovell

Hsia

(2002). Disproportionate minority confinement: A review of the research literature from 1989 through 2001 (Juvenile Justice Bulletin). Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

50.

Puzzanchera

Knoll

Adams

Sickmund

(2012). Allegheny County juvenile detention screening study. Pittsburgh, PA: National Center for Juvenile Justice.

51.

Puzzanchera

Sladky

Kang

(2017). Easy access to juvenile populations: Population profiles. Retrieved April 9, 2018 from https://www.ojjdp.gov/ojstatbb/ezapop/asp/profile_display.asp

52.

Schwartz

(2013). Pennsylvania and MacArthur’s models for change: The story of a successful public–private partnership. Philadelphia, PA: Juvenile Law Center.

53.

Shannon

S. K. S.

Hauer

(2018). A life table approach to estimating disproportionate minority contact in the juvenile justice system. Justice Quarterly, 35, 330–355.

54.

Shoenberg

(2012). Reducing racial and ethnic disparities in Pennsylvania (Innovation Brief). Chicago, IL: John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation’s Models for Change.

55.

Steinhart

(2008). Berks County, Pennsylvania juvenile detention risk assessment instrument test. Reading, PA: Berks County Juvenile Probation Office.

56.

The Right to Counsel, 42 Pa. Cons. Stat. § 6337 (2012).

57.

Tracy

P. E.

(2005). Race, ethnicity, and juvenile justice: Is there bias in post-arrest decision-making? In Hawkins

D. F.

Kempf

K. L.

(Eds.), Our children, their children: Confronting racial and ethnic differences in American juvenile justice (pp. 300–350). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

58.

Vergara

A. T.

Kathuria

Woodmass

Janke

Wells

S. J.

(2016). Effectiveness of culturally appropriate adaptations to juvenile justice services. Journal of Juvenile Justice, 5, 85–103.

59.

Waiver of Counsel, 237 Pa. Code Rule 152 (2018). Retrieved April 15, 2018 from https://www.pacode.com/secure/data/237/chapter1/s152.html

60.

Ward

G. K.

(2012). The Black child-savers: Racial democracy and juvenile justice. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

61.

Yiengprugsawan

Lim

L. L.

Carmichael

G. A.

Sidorenko

Sleigh

A. C.

(2007). Measuring and decomposing inequity in self-reported morbidity and self-assessed health in Thailand. International Journal for Equity in Health, 6, 23.