Many rationalizations have been proposed for the euthanasia of persons with severe handicaps. Those that are most convincing appeal to the alleged good to handicapped individuals of being allowed to die. This article examines two common rationalizations and presents arguments to refute them. The article calk for parents, professionals, and friends of persons with severe handicaps to be clear and vocal in refuting euthanasia and its rationales.
AffleckG. (1980). Physicians' attitudes towards discretionary medical treatment of Down's Syndrome infants. Mental Retardation, 18, 79–81.
2.
AlexanderL. (1949). Medical science under dictatorship. New England Journal of Medicine, 241, 39–47.
3.
AllenD.AllenV. (1979). Ethical issues in mental retardation. Nashville: Abingdon.
4.
Australian College of Pediatrics. (1983). Non-intervention in children with major handicaps: Legal and ethical issues. Australian Pediatric Journal, 19, 217–222.
5.
BardB.FletcherJ. (1968, April). The right to die. Atlantic Monthly, pp. 59–64.
6.
BlattB. (1970). Exodus from pandemonium: Human abuse and a reformation of public policy. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
7.
BlattB. (1981). In and out of mental retardation: Essays on educability, disability and human policy. Baltimore: University Park Press.
8.
BlattB.KaplanF. (1966). Christmas in Purgatory: A photographic essay on mental retardation. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
9.
BogdanR.TaylorS. (1982). Inside out: The social meaning of mental retardation. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
10.
BuberM. (1947). Between man and man. London: Collins.
11.
DiamondE. F. (1977). The deformed child's right to life. In HoranD. J.MallD. (Eds.), Death, dying and euthanasia (pp. 127–138). Washington, DC: University Publications of America.
12.
DiamondJ. (1982). Perspectives on decisions for nontreatment of damaged newborns. In SawinD.HawkinsR.WalkerL.PenticuffJ.. (Eds.), Exceptional infant: Psychosocial risks in infant-environment transactions (pp. 204–207). New York: Brunner/Mazel.
13.
DouderaA. E.PetersJ. D. (Eds.). (1982). Legal and ethical aspects of treating critically and terminally ill patients. Ann Arbor, MI: AUPHA Press.
14.
FletcherJ. (1972). Indicators of humanhood: A tentative profile of man. Hastings Center Report, 2, 1–4.
15.
FletcherJ. (1973). Ethics and euthanasia. In WilliamsR. H. (Ed.), To live and to die: When, why and how (pp. 113–122). New York: Springer-Verlag.
16.
FletcherJ. (1974). Four indicators of humanhood - The enquiry matures. Hastings Center Report, 4, 4–7.
17.
FletcherJ. C. (1975). Abortion, euthanasia, and care of defective newborns. The New England Journal of Medicine, 292, 75–78.
18.
FriedlanderB. (1982). Pain-filled fruit of the tree of knowledge: Problems and paradoxes in the sanctity of life. In SawinD.HawkinsR.WalkerL.PenticuffJ.. (Eds.) Exceptional infant: Psychosocial risks in infantenvironment transactions (pp. 190–196). New York: Brunner/Mazel.
19.
GuessD.DussaultB.BrownF.MulliganM.OreloveF.ComegysA.RuesJ. (1984). Legal, economic, psychological and moral considerations on the practice of withholding medical treatment from infants with congenital defects. Seattle, WA: The Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps.
20.
GustafsonJ. (1973). Mongolism, parental desires, and the right to life. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 16, 529–557.
21.
HoranD. (1977). Euthanasia as a form of medical management. In HoranD. J.MallD. (Eds.), Death, dying and euthanasia (pp. 196–227). Washington, DC: University Publications of America.
22.
HoranD.DelahoydeM. (Eds.). (1982). Infanticide and the handicapped newborn. Provo, UT: Brigham Young Press.
23.
HoranD.MallD. (1977). Death, dying and euthanasia. Washington, DC: University Publications of America.
24.
JakobovitzI. (1977). Some recent Jewish views on euthanasia. In HoranD. J.MallD. (Eds.), Death, dying and euthanasia (pp. 344–347). Washington, DC: University Publications of America.
25.
JonsenA.PhibbsR.TooleyW.GarlandM. (1975). Critical issues in newborn intensive care: A conference report and policy proposal. Pediatrics, 55, 756–768.
26.
KamisarY. (1958). Some non-religious views against proposed mercy-killing legislation. Minnesota Law Review, 42, 969–1042.
27.
KramerM. (1976). Ethical issues in neonatal intensive care: An economic perspective. In JonsenA.GarlandM. (eds.), Ethics of new born intensive care (pp. 75–93). Berkeley: University of California, Institute of Governmental Studies.
28.
LorberJ. (1973). Early results of selective treatment of Spina Bifida Cystica. British Medical Journal, 4, 210–204.
29.
LorberJ. (1978, September 14). Selection - the best policy available. The Nursing Mirror, 147, 14–17.
30.
LouisellD. (1973). Euthanasia and biathanasia: On dying and killing. Catholic University Law Review, 22, 723–745.
31.
McCormickR. (1974). To save or let die: The dilemma of modern medicine. Journal of the American Medical Association, 229, 172–176.
32.
MurrayT. (1984). At last, final rules on Baby Doe. Hastings Center Report, 14, 17.
33.
National Institute on Mental Retardation. (1981). Orientation manual on mental retardation. Toronto: National Institute on Mental Retardation.
34.
O'RourkeK. (1977). Christian affirmation of life. In. HoranD. J.MallD. (eds.), Death, dying and euthanasia (pp. 362–367). Washington, DC: University Publications of America.
35.
PanzaJ. (1984, November). Quality of life. Newsletter of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, p. 2. Pope Pius XII. (1977). The prolongation of life: An address of Pope Pius XII to an international congress of anesthesiologists. In HoranD. J.MallD. (Eds.), Death, dying and euthanasia (pp. 282–292). Washington, DC: University Publications of America.
36.
President's Committee for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1983). Deciding to forego life sustaining treatment. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
37.
RamseyP. (1972). Ethics at the edge of life: Medical and legal intersection. New Haven: Yale University Press.
38.
RestakR. (1975). Genetic counseling for defective parents: The danger of knowing too much. Psychology Today, 9, 21–23, 92–93.
39.
RickhamP. (1969). The ethics of surgery in newborn infants. Clinical Pediatrics, 8, 251–254.
40.
RiveraG. (1972). Willowbrook: A report on how it is and why it doesn't have to be that way. New York: Vintage Books.
41.
RobertsonJ. (1975). Involuntary euthanasia of defective newborns: A legal analysis. Stanford Law Review, 27, 213–269.
42.
RobertsonJ. (1982). Legal aspects of withholding medical treatment from handicapped children. In DouderaA. E.PetersJ. D. (Eds.), Legal and ethical aspects of treating critically and terminally ill patients. Ann Arbor, MI: AUPHA Press.
43.
RyndersJ. (1982). Research on promoting learning in children with Down Syndrome. In PueschelS.RyndersJ. (Eds.), Down Syndrome: Advances in biomedicine and the behavioral sciences (pp. 389–451). Cambridge, MA: The Ware Press.
44.
St. MartinT. (1975). Euthanasia: The three-in-one issue. Baylor Law Review, 27, 62–67.
45.
ShawA. (1977). Dilemmas of “informed consent” in children. In HoranD. J.MallD. (Eds.), Death, dying and euthanasia (pp. 75–90). Washington, DC: University Publications of America.
46.
ShawA.RandolfJ.ManardB. (1977). Ethical issues in pediatric surgery: A national survey of pediatricians and pediatric surgeons. Pediatrics, 60, 588–599.
47.
SlackA. (1984). Killing and allowing to die in medical practice. Journal of Medical Ethics, 2, 82–87.
48.
TooleyM. (1972). Abortion and infanticide. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 2, 7–65.
49.
VanierJ. (1971). Eruption to hope. Toronto: Griffin House.
50.
WalmsleyS. A. (1978). A life and death issue. Mental Retardation, 16, 387–389.
51.
WeirR. (1977). Ethical issues in death and dying. New York: Columbia University Press.
52.
WeirR. (1984). Selective nontreatment of handicapped newborns: Moral dilemmas in neonatal medicine. Don Mills, Ontario: Oxford University Press.
53.
WerthamF. (1966). A sign for Cain. New York: Macmillan.
54.
WhyteheadL.ChidwickP. F. (1977). Considerations concerning the transit from life to death. Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada: Task Force on Human Life, General Synod of the Anglican Church of Canada.
55.
WillG. F. (1982). The rights of retarded people at birth. Paper presented to the Maryland Association for Retarded Citizens. The MARC, 11, 4.
56.
WolfensbergerW. (1972). The principle of normalization in human services. Toronto: National Institute on Mental Retardation.
57.
WolfensbergerW. (1975). The origin and nature of our institutional models. Syracuse, NY: Human Policy Press.
58.
WolfensbergerW. (1981). The extermination of handicapped people in World War II Germany. Mental Retardation, 19, 1–7.
59.
WolfensbergerW. (1984). Voluntary associations on behalf of societally devalued and/or handicapped people. Toronto: National Institute on Mental Retardation.
60.
ZacharyR. B. (1977). Life with spina bifida. British Medical Journal, 2, 1460–1462.
