Effects and Safety of Different Silver Preparation in Burns Treatment: A Bayesian Network Meta-analysis

Abstract

Silver formulation has been used for external use of burn wounds for several decades, mainly including silver sulfadiazine (SSD), nanosilver dressing (NSD), and silver ion dressing (SID). At present, there is no simultaneous comparison of the effects of silver formulation on burn wounds. The databases were retrieved in an orderly manner from the dates of their establishment to May 2020, including PubMed, the Cochrane Library, Web of Science, and Clinical Trials. Then a network meta-analysis was conducted using R and RevMan 5.1 software. A total of 13 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) involving 945 patients with burns were included. A pairwise meta-analysis of the results was presented: the wound healing time in the SID or NSD treatment group was less than that in the SSD group; and in relieving the pain there was a statistical difference between the SSD, SID, or NSD groups. Network meta-analysis of the results was presented: the wound healing time and relieving the pain in the SID or NSD treatment group were less than that in the SSD group, but there was no statistical difference between the SID and NSD groups. The possibility of NSD in the wound healing time being the best treatment was 75.2%, followed by SID (36.6%), and finally SSD (1.1%); and the possibility of NSD being the best relieving the pain was 83.5%; followed by SID (60.0%), and finally SSD (16.3%). According to the evidence, treatment for burns with NSD can improve the wound healing time and relieve the pain of wounds.