The Lack of Reliability of Clinical Examination in the Diagnosis of Wound Infection: Preliminary Communication

Abstract

The diagnosis of infection in chronic wounds is challenging. Clinicians tend to rely on the classic signs and the symptoms. Quantitative tissue biopsy, the most accurate method, is rarely used because it is expensive, invasive, and difficult to perform. A recently completed clinical trial evaluating collagen/oxidized regenerated cellulose/antimicrobial matrix versus standard of care in venous leg ulcerations was reviewed. Patients with infected venous leg ulcers by clinical examination were excluded. In fact, none of the subjects in the 2 arms of the study had target ulcers that appeared to be infected at any time during the study. Quantitative biopsies of the ulcers were obtained and compared with investigator evaluation. In all, 14 of 49 subjects (28%) had bacterial counts greater than 10⁵ or β-hemolytic streptococcus despite the lack of clinical signs of infection. This analysis suggests that clinical examination is unreliable in the diagnosis of wound infection in venous leg ulcerations.

Keywords

wound infection venous leg ulcer clinical trial

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Robson MC , Heggars JP Bacterial quantification of open wounds. Mil Med. 1969;134:19-24.

Gardner SE , Frantz RA , Doebbeling BN The validity of the clinical signs and symptoms used to identify localized chronic wound infection. Wound Repair Regen. 2001;9:178-186.

Serena TE , Robson MC , Cooper DM , Ignatius J. Lack of reliability of clinical/visual assessment of chronic wound infection: the incidence of biopsy-proven infection in venous leg ulcers. Wounds. 2006;18:197-202.

Bamberg R. , Sullivan PK , Conner-Kerr TA Diagnosis of wound infections: current culturing practices of US wound care professionals. Wounds. 2002;14:314-327.

Schraibman IG The significance of beta-hemolytic streptococci in chronic leg ulcers. Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1990;72:123-124.

Levine NS , Lindberg RB , Mason AD , et al. The quantitative swab culture and smear: a quick method for determining the number of viable aerobic bacteria in open wounds. J Trauma. 1976;16:89-94.

Gardner SE , Frantz R. , Hillis SL , et al. Diagnostic validity of semiquantitative swab cultures. Wounds. 2007;19: 31-38.

Poon VK , Burd A. In vitro cytotoxicity of silver: implication for clinical wound care. Burns. 2004;30:140-147.

Johnson & Johnson Wound Management World Wide. The effects of a variety of silver products and ORC/ Collagen on Fibroblast cell growth in culture. In press.