Reconciling the Business Case and the Social Justice Case for Diversity: A Model of Human Relations

Abstract

There are two dichotomous rationales for valuing diversity in organizational contexts: the business case and the social justice case. Arguments for the business case for diversity and the social justice case are both supported by valuing philosophies. However, lacking in either of these philosophies is a human relations component that recognizes the role of relationships in achieving the intended goals. In this article, we propose that reconciling the tensions between the business case and the social justice case is contingent upon adopting an organizational strategy that includes a human relations valuing philosophy. The organizational strategy suggested reaffirms a strategic role of human resource development.

Keywords

diversity business case social justice case human relations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

Bell

L. A.

(Eds.). (2016). Teaching for diversity and social justice. Routledge.

Ahmed

(2007). The language of diversity. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 30(2), 235–256. https://doi.org/10.1080/01419870601143927

Alvesson

(1984). Questioning rationality and ideology: On critical organization theory. International Studies of Management and Organization, 14(1), 61–79. https://doi.org/10.1080/00208825.1984.11656383

Amodio

(2015). Prejudiced? me? New Scientist, 227(3030), 26–27. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0262-4079(15)30785-5

Aronson

(2002). Managing the diversity revolution: Best practices for 21st century business. Civil Rights Journal, 6(1), 46.

Banaji

M. R.

Hardin

Rothman

A. J.

(1993). Implicit stereotyping in person judgment. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 65(2), 272–281. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.65.2.272

Bell

M. P.

Berry

D. P.

(2007). Viewing diversity through different lenses: Avoiding a few blind spots. Academy of Management Perspectives, 21(4), 21–25. https://doi.org/10.5465/amp.2007.27895336

Benschop

(2001). Pride, prejudice and performance: Relations between HRM, diversity and performance. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 12(7), 1166–1181. https://doi.org/10.1080/09585190110068377

Bierema

L. L.

(2009). Critiquing human resource development’s dominant masculine rationality and evaluating its impact. Human Resource Development Review, 8(1), 68–96. https://doi.org/10.1177/1534484308330020

10.

Bierema

L. L.

(2010). Resisting HRD’s resistance to diversity. Journal of European Industrial Training, 34(6), 565–576. https://doi.org/10.1108/03090591011061239

11.

Bierema

Callahan

J. L.

(2014). Transforming HRD: A framework for critical HRD practice. Advances in Human Resources, 16(4), 429–444. https://doi.org/10.1177/1523422314543818

12.

Boeckmann

R. J.

Tyler

T. R.

(1997). Commonsense justice and inclusion within the moral community: When do people receive procedural protections from others? Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 3(2/3), 362–380. https://doi.org/10.1037/1076-8971.3.2-3.362

13.

Bogan

C. E.

English

M. J.

(1994). Benchmarking for best practices: Winning through innovative adaptation. McGraw-Hill.

14.

Bohonos

J. W.

Otchere

K. D.

Pak

Y. K.

(2019). Teaching and learning social justice in human resource development graduate programs: Preparation for research and practice. New Horizons in Adult Education and Human Resource Development, 31(4), 18–35. https://doi.org/10.1002/nha3.20262

15.

Brookfield

S. D.

(2014). Foundations of critical theory. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 16(4), 417–428. https://doi.org/10.1177/1523422314543819

16.

Brungardt

(1996). The making of leaders: A review of the research in leadership development and education. Journal of Leadership Studies, 3(3), 81-95.

17.

Byrd

(2007). Educating and developing leaders of racially diverse organizations. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 18(2), 275–279. https://doi.org/10.1002/hrdq.1203

18.

Byrd

M. Y.

(2014). A social justice paradigm for HRD. In Chalofsky

N. E.

Rocco

T. S.

Morris

M. L.

(Eds.), Handbook of human resource development (pp. 281–298). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118839881.ch17

19.

Byrd

M. Y.

(2018a). Diversity branding strategy: Concealing implicit stereotypes and biased behaviors. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 20(3), 299–312. https://doi.org/10.1177/1523422318778006

20.

Byrd

M. Y.

(2018b). Does HRD have a moral duty to respond to matters of social injustice? Human Resource Development International, 21(1), 3–11. https://doi.org/10.1080/13678868.2017.1344419

21.

Carroll

A. B.

(2015). Corporate social responsibility: The centerpiece of competing and complementary frameworks. Organizational Dynamics, 44, 87-96.

22.

Civil Rights Act of 1964 (1964). Public law 88-352, Title VII, sec. 703 (pp. 78). U.S. Statutes at Large.

23.

Clayton

Opotow

(2003). Justice and identity: Changing perspectives on what is fair. Personality & Social Psychology Review, 7(4), 298–310. https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327957PSPR0704_03

24.

Cohen

M. A.

(2010). The narrow application of Rawls in business ethics: A political conception of both stakeholder theory and the morality of markets. Journal of Business Ethics, 97(4), 563–579. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-010-0525-y

25.

Coleman

P. T.

Coon

Kim

Chung

Bass

Regan

Anderson

(2017). Promoting constructive multicultural attractors: Fostering unity and fairness from diversity and conflict. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 53(2), 180–211. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886317702133

26.

Cooley

(2016). Human relations theory of organizations. In Farazmand

(Ed.), Global encyclopedia of public administration, public policy, and governance. Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-31816-5_2998-1

27.

Cox

Jr. (2001). Creating the multicultural organization: A strategy for capturing the power of diversity. John Wiley & Sons.

28.

Cox

T. H.

Blake

(1991). Managing cultural diversity: Implications for organizational competitiveness. Academy of Management Perspectives, 5(3), 45–56. https://doi.org/10.5465/ame.1991.4274465

29.

Dalla

C. J.

(1998). The ethical imperative: Why moral leadership is good business. Perseus Books.

30.

Day

N. E.

Glick

B. J.

(2000). Teaching diversity: A study of organizational needs and diversity curriculum in higher education. Journal of Management Education, 24(3), 338–352. https://doi.org/10.1177/105256290002400305

31.

Deetz

(2005). Critical theory. In Mumby

D. K.

May

(Eds.), Engaging organizational communication theory & research: Multiple perspectives (pp. 85–111). Sage.

32.

Deutsch

(1975). Equity, equality, and need: What determines which value will be used as the basis of distributive justice? Journal of Social Issues, 31(3), 137–149. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-4560.1975.tb01000.x

33.

Deutsch

(2006). Framework for thinking about oppression and its change. Social Justice Research, 19(1), 7–41. https://doi-org.ezproxy.lib.ou.edu/10.1007/s11211-006-9998-3

34.

Edelman

L. B.

Fuller

S. R.

Mara‐Drita

(2001). Diversity rhetoric and the managerialization of law. American Journal of Sociology, 106(6), 1589–1641. https://doi.org/10.1086/321303

35.

Elliott

Turnbull

(2005). Critical thinking in human resource development: An introduction. In Elliott

Turnbull

(Eds.), Critical thinking in human resource development (pp. 15-22). Routledge.

36.

Ely

R. J.

Thomas

D. A.

(2020). Getting serious about diversity. Harvard Business Review, 98(6), 114–122.

37.

Erwee

(2003). Integrating diversity management initiatives with strategic human resource management. In Wiesner

Millett

(Eds.), Human resource management: Contemporary challenges and future directions (pp. 57–71). John Wiley.

38.

Fehr

(2011). What is in it for me? The benefits of diversity in scientific communities. In Grasswick

(Ed.), Feminist epistemology and philosophy of science (pp. 133–155). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-6835-5_7

39.

Fenwick

T. J.

(2004). Toward a critical HRD in theory and practice. Adult Education Quarterly, 54(3), 193–209. https://doi.org/10.1177/0741713604263051

40.

Foster

(1993). Difference and equality: A critical assessment of the concept of diversity. Wisconsin Law Review, 93(1), 105–161.

41.

Freeman

R. E.

(1999). Divergent stakeholder theory. Academy of Management Review, 24(2), 233–236. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1999.1893932

42.

Freeman

R. E.

(2010). Managing for stakeholders: Trade-offs or value creation. Journal of Business Ethics, 96(1), 7–9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-011-0935-5

43.

Friedman

(1970). The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. The New York Times Magazine.

44.

Garavan

T. N.

(1991). Strategic human resource development. Journal of European Industrial Training, 15(1), 17–30. https://doi.org/10.1108/eum0000000000219

45.

Gedro

Collins

J. C.

Rocco

T. S.

(2014). The “critical” turn: An important imperative for human resource development. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 16(4), 529–535. https://doi.org/10.1177/1523422314543847

46.

Gilligan

(1982). A different voice: Psychological theory and women's development. Harvard University Press.

47.

Hansmann

Kraakman

(2000). The end of history for corporate law. Georgetown Law Journal, 89(2), 439–468.

48.

Heidegger

Macquarrie

Robinson

(1962). Being and time. Harper Press.

49.

Herring

(2009). Does diversity pay? Race, gender, and the business case for diversity. American Sociological Review, 74(2), 208–224. https://doi.org/10.1177/000312240907400203

50.

Hite

L. M.

McDonald

K. S.

(2010). Perspectives on HRD and diversity education. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 12(3), 283–294. https://doi.org/10.1177/1523422310374974

51.

Holmes

(2015). Has diversity lost its meaning. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/01/magazine/has-diversity-lost-its-meaning.html

52.

Hughes

Byrd

M. Y.

(2015). Managing human resource development programs. Palgrave Macmillan.

53.

Jayne

M. E. A.

Dipboye

R. L.

(2004). Leveraging diversity to improve business performance: Research findings and recommendations for organizations. Human Resource Management, 43(4), 409–424. https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.20033

54.

Johns

Green

Powell

(2012). Diversity in the British NHS: The business versus the “moral” case. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal, 31(8), 768–783. https://doi.org/10.1108/02610151211277626

55.

Jones

(2004). Screwing diversity out of the workers? Reading diversity. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 17(3), 281–291. https://doi.org/10.1108/09534810410538333

56.

Kaiser

C. R.

Major

Jurcevic

Dover

T. L.

Brady

L. M.

Shapiro

J. R.

(2013). Presumed fair: Ironic effects of organizational diversity structures. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 104(3), 504–519. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0030838

57.

Kalev

Dobbin

Kelly

(2006). Best practices or best guesses? Assessing the efficacy of corporate affirmative action and diversity policies. American Sociological Review, 71(4), 589–617. https://doi.org/10.1177/000312240607100404

58.

Kandola

(1995). Managing diversity: New broom or old hat? In Cooper

C. L.

Robertson

I. T.

(Eds.), International review of industrial and organizational psychology (Vol. 10, pp. 131–167). Wiley.

59.

Kandola

Fullerton

(1998). Managing the mosaic: Diversity in action (2nd ed.). Institute of Personnel Development.

60.

Killen

(2018). The origins of morality: Social equality, fairness, and justice. Philosophical Psychology, 31(5), 767–803. https://doi.org/10.1080/09515089.2018.1486612

61.

King

M. L.

Jr (1958). Stride toward freedom: The Montgomery story. Harper & Row.

62.

Konrad

A. M.

(2003). Special issue introduction: Defining the domain of workplace diversity scholarship. Group & Organization Management, 28(1), 4–17. https://doi.org/10.1177/1059601102250013

63.

Kreitz

P. A.

(2008). Best practices for managing organizational diversity. The Journal of Academic Librarianship, 34(2), 101–120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2007.12.001

64.

Lamberton

L. H.

Minor

(2014). Human relations: Strategies for success. McGraw-Hill.

65.

Machan

T. R.

(2009). Stakeholder vs. shareholder theory of the ethics of corporate management. International Journal of Economics and Business Research, 1(1), 12–20. https://doi.org/10.1504/ijebr.2009.022762

66.

Maitland

(2018). Why the business case for diversity is wrong. Georgetown Journal of Law & Public Policy, 16(Special Issue), 731–752.

67.

Mallia

K. L.

(2016). Addressing the elephant in the room.(Or, I dare you to ignore this any longer). Journal of Advertising Education, 20(1–2), 104–110. https://doi.org/10.1177/10980482160201-213

68.

Marques

J. F.

(2010). Colorful window dressing: A critical review on workplace diversity in three major American corporations. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 21(4), 435–446. https://doi.org/10.1002/hrdq.20045

69.

McDonald

D. M.

(2010). The evolution of diversity management in the USA: Social contexts, managerial motives and theoretical approaches. : Institute of Business Research, Daito Bunka UniversityMarch.

70.

Mease

J. J.

Collins

B. L.

(2018). Asset, liability, possibility: Metaphors of human difference and the business case for diversity. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal, 37(7), 664–682. https://doi.org/10.1108/edi-05-2017-0114

71.

Millard

T. L.

(1962). Human relations in a changing society, trends, and principles. Journal of Educational Sociology, 35(5), 228–235. https://doi.org/10.2307/2264569

72.

Miller

F. A.

(1994). Forks in the road: Critical issues on the path to diversity. In Cross

E. Y.

Katz

J. H.

Miller

F. A.

Seashore

E. W.

(Eds.), The promise of diversity: Over 40 voices discuss strategies for eliminating discrimination in organizations (pp. 33–45). Irwin.

73.

Morgan

(2008). Explicit versus implicit stereotypes: What biases do I really hold? Communication Teacher, 22(3), 84–88. https://doi.org/10.1080/17404620802154683

74.

Neuman

J. H

(2004). Injustice, stress, and aggression in organizations. In Griffin

R. W.

O’Leary-Kelly

A. M.

(Eds.), The dark side of organizational behavior (pp. 62–102). Jossey-Bass.

75.

Noon

(2007). The fatal flaws of diversity and the business case for ethnic minorities. Work, Employment & Society, 21(4), 773–784. https://doi.org/10.1177/0950017007082886

76.

O’Leary

B. J.

Weathington

B. L.

(2006). Beyond the business case for diversity in organizations. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 18(4), 283–292.

77.

Olson

Reed

Schweinle

(2009). Human relations: Assessing the affect of cultural awareness curriculum on preservice teachers. Journal of Inquiry and Action in Education, 2(2), 120–139.

78.

Opotow

(1990). Moral exclusion and injustice: An introduction. Journal of Social Issues, 46(1), 1-20.

79.

Pasztor

S. K.

(2019). Exploring the framing of diversity rhetoric in “top-rated in diversity” organizations. International Journal of Business Communication, 56(4), 455–475. https://doi.org/10.1177/2329488416664175

80.

Patton

L. D.

Shahjahan

R. A.

Osei-Kofi

(2010). Introduction to the emergent approaches to diversity and social justice in higher education. Equity & Excellence in Education, 43(3), 265–278. https://doi.org/10.1080/10665684.2010.496692

81.

Phillips

R. A.

(1997). Stakeholder theory and a principle of fairness. Business Ethics Quarterly, 7(1), 51–66. https://doi.org/10.2307/3857232

82.

Pittinsky

T. L.

Montoya

R. M.

(2016). Empathic joy in positive intergroup relations. Journal of Social Issues, 72(3), 511–523. https://doi.org/10.1111/josi.12179

83.

Ratts

M. J.

Singh

A. A.

Nassar-McMillan

Butler

S. K.

McCullough

J. R.

(2016). Multicultural and social justice counseling competencies: Guidelines for the counseling profession. Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development, 44(1), 28–48. https://doi.org/10.1002/jmcd.12035

84.

Rhee

R. J.

(2018). A legal theory of shareholder primacy. Minnesota Law Review, 102, 1951-2017.

85.

Riccò

(2012). Utilizing a new human relations framework to leverage workforce diversity. In Scott

C. L.

Byrd

M. Y.

(Eds.), Handbook of research on workforce diversity in a global society: Technologies and concepts (pp. 440–462). IGI Global.

86.

Richard

O. C.

(2000). Racial diversity, business strategy, and firm performance: A resource-based view. Academy of Management Journal, 43(2), 164–177. https://doi.org/10.5465/1556374

87.

Roberson

Q. M.

(2006). Disentangling the meanings of diversity and inclusion in organizations. Group & Organization Management, 31(2), 212–236. https://doi.org/10.1177/1059601104273064

88.

Roberson

Q. M.

Park

H. J.

(2007). Examining the link between diversity and firm performance: The effects of diversity reputation and leader racial diversity. Group & Organization Management, 32(5), 548–568. https://doi.org/10.1177/1059601106291124

89.

Robinson

Dechant

(1997). Building a business case for diversity. Academy of Management Executive, 11(3), 21–31. https://doi.org/10.5465/ame.1997.9709231661

90.

Ross-Gordon

J. M.

Brooks

A. K.

(2004). Diversity in human resource development and continuing professional education: What does it mean for the workforce, clients, and professionals? Advances in Developing Human Resources, 6(1), 69–85. https://doi.org/10.1177/1523422303260418

91.

Sagut

J. C.

(2008). Justice as responsible human relations. Philippiniana Sacra, 42(127), 67–82.

92.

Sambrook

S. A.

(2014). Critical HRD. In Chalofsky

N. E.

Rocco

T. S.

Morris

M. L.

(Eds.), Handbook of human resource development (pp. 145–163). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118839881.ch9

93.

Schwartz

M. S.

(2017). Business ethics: An ethical decision-making approach. John Wiley & Sons.

94.

Scott

K. A.

Heathcote

J. M.

Gruman

J. A.

(2011). The diverse organization: Finding gold at the end of the rainbow. Human Resource Management, 50(6), 735–755. https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.20459

95.

Sharma

(2016). Managing diversity and equality in the workplace. Cogent Business & Management, 3(1), 1212682. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311975.2016.1212682

96.

Smith

(2010). Application on human relations theory in primary schools. GRIN. http://www.grin.com/en/e-book/178597/application- on-human-relation-theory in primary- schools

97.

Sparkman

T. E.

(2019). Exploring the boundaries of diversity and inclusion in human resource development. Human Resource Development Review, 18(2), 173–195. https://doi.org/10.1177/1534484319837030

98.

Sparrow

P. R.

Hodgkinson

G. P.

(2006). What is strategic competence and does it matter? Exposition of the concept and a research agenda. CAHRS Working Paper #06-16). Cornell University, School of Industrial and Labor Relations. http://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/cahrswp/458

99.

Steel

Bolduc

(2020). A closer look at the business case for diversity: The tangled web of equity and epistemic benefits. Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 50(5), 418–443. https://doi.org/10.1177/0048393120911130

100.

Steinberg

S. R.

Kincheloe

J. L.

(2010). Power, emancipation, and complexity: Employing critical theory. Power and Education, 2(2), 140–151. https://doi.org/10.2304/power.2010.2.2.140

101.

Storberg-Walker

(2014). What type of leaders are we? Understanding and enhancing critical human resource development identity in the United States. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 16(4), 499–514. https://doi.org/10.1177/1523422314544296

102.

Sue

D. W.

Capodilupo

C. M.

Torino

G. C.

Bucceri

J. M.

Holder

A. M. B.

Nadal

K. L.

Esquilin

(2007). Racial microaggressions in everyday life: Implications for clinical practice. American Psychologist, 62(4), 271–286. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.62.4.271

103.

Syna

H. D.

(2016). Social divisions, intergroup conflict and diversity. Reflections about social conflict and diversity: The case of Israeli organizations. In Braedel-Kühner

C. B.

Müller

(Eds.), Re-thinking diversity (pp. 55–82). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-658-11502-9_4

104.

Tajfel

H. E.

(1978). Differentiation between social groups: Studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations. Academic Press.

105.

Tajfel

Wilkes

A. L.

(1963). Classification and quantitative judgement. British Journal of Psychology, 54(2), 101–114. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8295.1963.tb00865.x

106.

Thomas

R. R.

Jr. (1991). Beyond race and gender: Unleashing the power of your total work force by managing diversity. AMACOM.

107.

Thompson

(2016). Anti-discriminatory practice: Equality, diversity and social justice. Macmillan International Higher Education.

108.

Tomlinson

Schwabenland

(2010). Reconciling competing discourses of diversity? The UK non-profit sector between social justice and the business case. Organization, 17(1), 101–121. https://doi.org/10.1177/1350508409350237

109.

Torraco

R. J.

Swanson

R. A.

(1995). The strategic roles of human resource development. Human Resource Planning, 18(4), 10–21.

110.

Toubiana

(2014). Business pedagogy for social justice? An exploratory investigation of business faculty perspectives of social justice in business education. Management Learning, 45(1), 81–102. https://doi.org/10.1177/1350507612454097

111.

United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) (2020). Title VII of the civil rights act of 1964. https://www.eeoc.gov/statutes/title-vii-civil-rights-act-1964

112.

United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) (2021). Charge statistics (Charges filed with EEOC) FY 1997 through FY 2020. https://www.eeoc.gov/statistics/charge-statistics-charges-filed-eeoc-fy-1997-through-fy-2020

113.

United States Government Accountability Office (2013).Diversity management trends and practices in the financial services industry and agencies after the recent financial crisis. https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-13-238.pdf

114.

van Dijk

van Engen

Paauwe

(2012). Reframing the business case for diversity: A values and virtues perspective. Journal of Business Ethics, 111(1), 73–84. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-012-1434-z

115.

Wang

(2019). Moral leadership and unethical pro-organizational behavior: A moderated mediation model. Frontiers in Psychology, 10, 1-16. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02640.

116.

Weisinger

J. Y.

Borges-Méndez

Milofsky

(2016). Diversity in the nonprofit and voluntary sector. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 45(1_suppl), 3S–27S. https://doi.org/10.1177/0899764015613568

117.

Werner

J. M.

(2014). Connecting the dots or ships passing in the night. In Roth

G. L.

Poell

R. F.

Rocco

T. S.

(Eds.), The Routledge companion to human resource development (pp. 89–98). Routledge.

118.

Wiggins-Romesburg

C. A.

Githens

R. P.

(2018). The psychology of diversity resistance and integration. Human Resource Development Review, 17(2), 179–198. https://doi.org/10.1177/1534484318765843

119.

Winkle-Wagner

Locks

(2014). Diversity and inclusion on campus: Supporting racially and ethnically underrepresented students. In Higher education core concept series. Routledge.

120.

Young

I. M.

(1990). Justice and the politics of difference. Princeton.

121.

Young

I. M.

(2006). Responsibility and global justice: A social connection model. Social Philosophy and Policy, 23(1), 102–130. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0265052506060043

122.

Zanoni

Janssens

Benschop

Nkomo

(2010). Guest editorial: Unpacking diversity, grasping inequality: Rethinking difference through critical perspectives. Organization, 17(1), 9–29. https://doi.org/10.1177/1350508409350344