A shortage of long-term care workers: Effects on clients with dementia

Abstract

Although advocates promote caregiving services to families in need, the formal care system is directly dependent upon the availability of workers willing to provide this type of care. If there is a worker shortage, are clients with cognitive impairment more adversely affected than other clients? This article reports the findings from a study conducted in one state during a worker shortage. A worker bias was found against servicing Alzheimer clients in their homes that was not evident in day care facilities or nursing homes with Alzheimer units. Policy is sues are raised and recommendations made concerning worker's wages and benefits, work life, job design, and the structure of the long term care industry.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Austin CD : Yes, but who will deliver the care? The Gerontologist, 1990;39(1):134-135

2. Austin, ibid

3. Wilner MA : Who will care? A study of employee shortages in Massachusetts nursing and rest homes. Final Report, Dedham, MA, Massachusetts Federation of Nursing Homes, 1987

4. Office of Technology Assessment, U.S. Congress : Confused minds, burdened families: Finding help for people with Alzheimer's and other dementias. OTA-BA-403, Washington, DC, U.S. Government Printing Office, (July) 1990

5. Raia PA : The Alzheimer's disease partnership project: An experiment in community organization for improved long term care. Am J Alz Care and Rel Disorders and Research, September/October 1989:30-35

6. Representative studies addressing the availability and high turnover of paraprofessional workers include: Baum S and Berman HJ: Nurses aide turnover and the work environment. Presented at the annual scientific meeting of the Gerontological Society of America, Chicago, Illinois, November 1986; Baum S and Berman HJ: Predictors of nurse aide turnover. Presented at the annual scientific meeting of the Gerontological Society of America, Washington DC, November 1987; Liebman J: Rate setting for home care services in Massachusetts. Boston, MA, Dept. of Health Policy and Mgmt, Harvard School of Public Health, 1986; Mahoney DF, Pearlman DN, Callahan JJ: Crisis in long term care: The impact of the Mass. worker shortage on caring for persons with dementia. Working Paper No. 37, Waltham, MA, Policy Center On Aging, Heller School, Brandeis University, 1987; Task Force Report: Problems on the supply side: The homemaker shortage in Mass. Boston, MA, Mass. Council for Homemaker-Home Health Aide Services (March) 1987; Wilner, ibid; Camberg LC, Lischko AM, and Brandenburg JA: Staffing in government and other nonprofit nursing homes in Mass. West Roxbury, MA: Vets Admin, 1988; Feldman P. Sapienza A, Kane N: Who cares for them? Workers in the home care industry. Westport, CT, Greenwood Press, 1990

7. Office of Technology Assessment, U.S. Congress : Losing a million minds: Confronting the tragedy of Alzheimer's disease and other dementias. OTA-BA-323, Washington, DC, U.S. Government Printing Office (April) 1987

8. Feldman P , Sapienza A : Quality of work life in the home care industry. Boston, MA, Harvard College, 1987

9. Kane RL , Saslow MG , Brundage T : Using ADLs to establish eligibility for long term care among the cognitively impaired. The Gerontologist, 1991;31(1):60-66

10.

10. Spector WD : Cognitive impairment and disruptive behaviors among community-based elderly persons: Implications for targeting longterm care. The Gerontologist, 1991;31(1):51-59

11.

11. Hospital News: Special units may improve care of Alzheimer's victims, July 1987:24-24

12.

12. Mahoney et al., ibid.

13.

13. Camberg et al., ibid.

14.

14. Phillips C : Staff turnover in nursing homes for the aged: A review and research proposal. Int J Nursing Studies, 1987;24(1):45-57