Filtering Out My Face: Rethinking Critical Narrative Analysis

Abstract

Based on an 18-month narrative study of female middle managers at a large community college in the mid-Atlantic region of the United States, we examine current critical narrative analysis practices, emphasizing the structural nature of inequity and oppression. We illustrate how critical approaches to structural narrative analysis have missed intersectional aspects of the structures we analyze. We conclude that by explicitly analyzing for both intersectionality and critical resistance, researchers have an opportunity to deepen and nuance critical narrative analysis in such a way that acknowledges the complexity of individual experiences and disproportionate structural constraints that affect people of color.

Keywords

narrative inquiry intersectionality critical resistance higher education narrative analysis structural analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acker

(2006). Inequality regimes: Gender class and race in organizations. Gender & Society, 20(4), 441–464.

ACE (2017). American Council on Education: American College President Study 2017. http://www.aceacps.org/

Archer

(1996). Social integration and system integration: Developing the distinction. Sociology, 30(4), 679–699.

Bilge

(2013). Intersectionality undone: Saving intersectionality from feminist intersectionality studies. Du Bois Review, 10(2), 405–424.

Boggs

G. R.

(2012). Next steps: Looking to the future. New Directions for Community Colleges, 2012(159), 97–107.

Boje

(2001). Narrative methods for organizational and communication research. Sage.

Brown

C. G.

(2012). Anti-oppression through a postmodern lens: Dismantling the master’s conceptual tools in discursive social work practice. Critical Social Work, 13(1), 34–65.

Bryman

(2007). Effective leadership in higher education: Summary of findings. Leadership Foundation for Higher Education. https://www.advance-he.ac.uk/knowledge-hub/effective-leadership-higher-education-summary-findings

Cann

(2016, October 25). Beyond our lifetimes: Prospects for workplace gender equality slip to 2186 [Press release]. https://www.weforum.org/press/2016/10/beyond-our-lifetimes-prospects-for-workplace-gender-equality-slip-to-2186/

10.

Carbado

(2013). Colorblind intersectionality. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 38(4), 811–845.

11.

Catalyst. (2017, March 1). Pyramid: Women in S&P 500 companies [Chart]. https://www.catalyst.org/research/women-in-sp-500-companies/

12.

Chadwick

(2017). Thinking intersectionally with/through narrative methodologies. Agenda, 31(1), 5–16.

13.

Childers

(2012). Against simplicity against ethics: Analytics of disruption as quasi-methodology. Qualitative Inquiry, 18(9), 752–761.

14.

Clemons

K. M.

(2019). Black feminist thought and qualitative research in education. Virginia State University.

15.

Collins

P. H.

(1990). Black feminist thought. Routledge.

16.

Columbia Law School. (2017, June 8). Kimberlé Crenshaw on intersectionality, more than two decades later. https://www.law.columbia.edu/news/archive/kimberle-crenshaw-intersectionality-more-two-decades-later

17.

Combahee River Collective. (1979). Why did they die? A document of Black feminism. Radical America, 13(6), 40–47.

18.

Combahee River Collective. (1986). The Combahee river Collective statement: Black feminist organizing in the seventies and eighties. Kitchen Table: Women of Color Press.

19.

Cooper

A. J.

(1988). A voice from the south. Oxford University Press. (Original work published 1892)

20.

Crenshaw

K. W.

(1989). Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A Black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine feminist theory and antiracist politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum, 1989(1), 139–167.

21.

Dan

Pollitt

(2015). NPM can work: An optimistic review of the impact of new public management reforms in Central and Eastern Europe. Public Management Review, 17(9), 1305–1332.

22.

Dennis

(2013). Not so obvious? The structural elements of caring: An example for critical qualitative studies. Counterpoints, 354, 407–435.

23.

Derrida

Caputo

J. D.

(1997). Deconstruction in a nutshell: A conversation with Jacques Derrida. Fordham University Press.

24.

Fairclough

(1989). Language and power. Longman.

25.

Fraser

(2004). Doing narrative research: Analysing personal stories line by line. Qualitative Social Work, 3(2), 179–201.

26.

Fraser

MacDougall

(2017). Doing narrative feminist research: Intersections and challenges. Qualitative Social Work, 16(2), 240–254.

27.

Giddens

(1976). New rules of sociological method. Hutchinson.

28.

Giddens

(1990). Central problems in social theory: Action structure and contradiction in social analysis. University of California Press.

29.

Houle

(2009). Making strange. Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies, 30(1), 172–193.

30.

Jackson

J. F. L.

O’Callaghan

E. M.

(2009). What do we know about glass ceiling effects? A taxonomy and critical review to inform higher education research. Research in Higher Education, 50(5), 460–482.

31.

King

J. E.

Gomez

G. G.

(2008). On the pathway to the presidency: Characteristics of higher education’s senior leadership. Retrieved from College and University Professional Association for Human Resources website: http://www.cupahr.org/knowledgecenter/files/PathwayPresidency.pdf

32.

Martin

A. B.

(2014). An exploratory examination of the factors contributing to the increasing presence of women presidents in Maryland community colleges [Doctoral dissertation]. Digital Repository at the University of Maryland. https://drum.lib.umd.edu/bitstream/handle/1903/15157/Martin_umd_0117E_14929pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

33.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2016, May). Characteristics of postsecondary faculty. Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov

34.

Preston

Floyd

(2016). Supporting the role of associate dean in universities: An alternative approach to management development. Higher Education Quarterly, 70(3), 264–280.

35.

Preston

Price

(2012). “I see it as a phase: I don’t see it as the future”: Academics as managers in a United Kingdom university. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 34(4), 409–419.

36.

Prins

(2006). Narrative accounts of origin: A blind spot in the intersectional approach? European Journal of Women’s Studies, 13(3), 277–290.

37.

Soutou-Manning

(2014). Critical narrative analysis: The interplay of critical discourse and narrative analyses. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 27(2), 159–180.

38.

Rainey

(2020). “The Cavalry Isn’t Coming”: Exploring the Experiences of Female Middle Managers in Higher Education [Doctoral dissertation, George Mason University].

39.

Townsend

B. K.

Twombly

S. B.

(2007). Accidental equity: The status of women in the community college. Equity & Excellence in Education, 40(3), 208–217.

40.

VanDerLinden

K. E.

(2005). Learning to play the game: Professional development and mentoring. Community College Journal of Research & Practice, 29(9/10), 729–743.

41.

Webster

Mertova

(2007). Using narrative inquiry as a research method. Routledge.

42.

Tarc

A. M.

(2005). Education as humanism of the other. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 37(6), 833–849.

43.

The White House Project. (2009). The White House Project report: Benchmarking women’s leadership. https://www.in.gov/icw/files/benchmark_wom_leadership.pdf

44.

Wodak

(2001). What CDA is about: A summary of its history important concepts and its developments. In Wodak

Meyer

(Eds.), Methods of critical discourse analysis (pp. 1–13). Sage.

45.

Wolf-Wendel

Ward

(2006). Academic life and motherhood: Variations by institutional type. Higher Education, 52(3), 487–521.

46.

Wolgemuth

(2014). Analyzing for critical resistance in narrative research. Qualitative Research, 14(5), 586–602.