It is now a well-documented fact of survey research that Black survey respondents overreport turning out to vote at higher rates than many of their peers of other racial and ethnic backgrounds. We bring renewed attention to this phenomenon by investigating how the ways in which the race of the interviewer might influence a Back respondent’s propensity to overreport turning out to vote. In this paper, we test two competing mechanisms for African American overreporting and race of interviewer effects: (1) racial group linked fate, and (2) conformity with norms of Black political behavior. We find support that social pressure to conform to group norms of political behavior is behind Black respondent’s overreporting in the presence of a same-race interviewer. These results have significant implications for how we view, analyze, and consider results from such studies.
AbelsonR. P.LoftusE. F.GreenwaldA. (1992). Attempts to improve the accuracy of self-reports of voting. In TanurJ. M. (Ed.), Questions about questions (pp. 138–153). Russell Sage Foundation.
2.
AbramsonP.ClaggettW. (1984). Race-related differences in self-reported and validated turnout. Journal of Politics, 46(3), 719–738.
3.
AbramsonP.ClaggettW. (1986). Race-related differences in self-reported and validated turnout in 1984. Journal of Politics, 48(2), 412–422.
4.
AbramsonP.ClaggettW. (1991). Race-related differences in self-reported and validated turnout in the 1988 presidential election. Journal of Politics, 53(1), 186–197.
5.
AbramsonP.ClaggettW. (1992). The quality of record keeping and racial differences in validated turnout. The Journal of Politics, 54(3), 871–880.
6.
AiC.NortonE. (2003). Interaction terms in logit and probit models. Economics Letters, 80(1), 123–129.
7.
AndersonB.SilverB.AbramsonP. (1988). The effects of race of the interviewer on measures of electoral participation by blacks in SRC national election studies. Public Opinion Quarterly, 52(1), 53–83.
8.
ANES. (2014). User’s guide and codebook for the ANES 2012 time series study. The University of Michigan and Stanford University.
9.
ANES. (2016). User’s guide and codebook for the ANES 2012 time series voter validation supplemental data. The University of Michigan and Stanford University.
10.
AnsolabehereS. (2013). Cooperative congressional election study, 2012: Common content [Computer file]. Release 1: April 15, 2013. Harvard University [Producer]. http://cces.gov.harvard.edu
11.
AnsolabehereS.HershE. (2012). Validation: What big data reveal about survey misreporting and the real electorate. Political Analysis, 20(4), 437–459.
12.
BelliR.MooreS.VanHoewykS. (2006). An experimental comparison of question forms used to reduce vote overreporting. Electoral Studies, 25(4), 751–759.
13.
BelliR.TraugottM.BeckmannM. (2001). What leads to voting over reports? Contrasts of over reporters to validated voters and admitted nonvoters in the American National Election Studies. Journal of Official Statistics, 17(4), 479–498.
14.
BelliR.TraugottM.YoungM.McGonagleK. (1999). Reducing vote overreporting in surveys: Social desirability, memory failure, and source monitoring. Public Opinion Quarterly, 63(1), 90–108.
15.
BernsteinR.ChadhaA.MontjoyR. (2001). Overreporting voting: Why it happens and why it matters. Public Opinion Quarterly, 65(1), 22–44.
16.
CasselC. (2003). Overreporting and Electoral Participation Research. American Politics Research, 31(1), 81–92.
17.
ChongD. (1991). Collective action and the civil rights movement. University of Chicago Press.
18.
CialdiniR.RenoR.KallgrenC. (1990). A focus theory of normative construct: Recycling the concept of norms to reduce littering in public places. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 58(6), 1015–1026.
DawsonM. (1994). Behind the mule: Race and class in African-American politics. Princeton University Press.
21.
DawsonM. (2003). Black visions: The roots of contemporary African-American political ideologies. University of Chicago Press.
22.
DeufelB.KedarO. (2010). Race and turnout in U.S. elections: Exposing hidden effects. Public Opinion Quarterly, 74(2), 286–318.
23.
DuffD.HanmerM. J.ParkW.WhiteI. K. (2007). Good excuses: Understanding who votes with an improved turnout question. Public Opinion Quarterly, 71(1), 67–90.
24.
EnamoradoT.ImaiK. (2020). Validating self-reported turnout by linking public opinion surveys with administrative records. Public Opinion Quarterly, 80(2), 723–748.
25.
GayC. (2006). Seeing difference: The effect of economic disparity on black attitudes toward Latinos. American Journal of Political Science, 50(4), 982–997.
26.
GerberA.GreenD.LarimerC. (2008). Social pressure and voter turnout: Evidence from a large-scale field experiment. American Political Science Review, 102(1), 33–48.
27.
GerberA. S.GreenG.LarimerC. W. (2010). An experiment testing the relative effectiveness of encouraging voter participation by inducing feelings of pride or shame. American Political Science Review, 102(1), 33–48.
28.
GillespieA.BrownN. E. (2019). #BlackGirlMagic demystified: Black women as voters, partisans, and political actors. Phylon, 56(2), 37–58.
29.
HanmerM. J.BanksA. J.WhiteI. K. (2014). Experiments to reduce the over-reporting of voting: A pipeline to the truth. Political Analysis, 22(1), 130–141.
30.
HanmerM. J.KalkanK. (2013). Behind the curve: Clarifying the best approach to calculating predicted probabilities and marginal effects from limited dependent variable models. American Journal of Political Science, 57(1), 263–277.
31.
HillK. Q.HurleyP. A. (1984). Nonvoters in voters’ clothing: The impact of voting behavior misreporting on voting behavior research. Social Science Quarterly, 65(1), 199–206.
32.
HolbrookA.KrosnickJ. A. (2010). Social desirability bias in voter turnout reports: Tests using the item count technique. Public Opinion Quarterly, 74(1), 37–67.
33.
HurwitzJ.PeffleyM.MondakJ. (2015). Linked fate and outgroup perceptions: Blacks, Latinos, and the US criminal justice system. Political Research Quarterly, 68(2), 505–520.
34.
JacksonJ. (1965). Social stratification, social norms, and roles. In SteinerI.FishbenM. (Eds.), Current studies in social psychology (pp. 301–308). Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
35.
KatoshJ. P.TraugottM. W. (1981). The consequences of validated and self reported voting measures. Public Opinion Quarterly, 45(4), 519–535.
36.
LairdC.WambleJ.McConnaughyC. M.WhiteI. K. (2016). Bound by blackness: Understanding the maintenance of Black democratic party loyalty. Manuscript in preparation.
37.
LeighleyJ.VedlitzA. (1999). Race, ethnicity, and participation: Competing models and contrasting explanations. Journal of Politics, 61(4), 1092–1114.
38.
Lewis-BeckM. S.JacobyW. G.NorpothH.WeisberH. (2008). The American voter revisited. University of Michigan Press.
39.
PresserS.TraugottM.TraugottS. A. (1990, November). Vote ‘over’ reporting in surveys: The records or the respondents? [Conference session]. International Conference on Measurement Errors, Tucson, AZ, United States. https://electionstudies.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/nes010157.pdf
40.
SigelmanL. (1982). The nonvoting voter in voting research. American Journal of Political Science, 26(1), 47–56.
41.
SilverB. D.AndersonB. A.AbramsonP. R. (1986). Who overreports voting?American Political Science Review, 80(2), 613–624.
42.
SimienE. (2005). Race, gender, and linked fate. Journal of Black Studies, 35(5), 529–550.
43.
StarkeyB. (2012). Uncle Tom and Justice Clarence Thomas: Is the abuse defensible?Georgetown Journal of Law and Modern Critical Race Perspectives, 4(2), 101–148.
44.
StoutC. T.KretschmerK.RuppannerL. (2017). Gender linked fate, race/ethnicity, and the marriage gap in American politics. Political Research Quarterly, 70(3), 509–522.
45.
TateK. (1991). Black political participation in the 1984 and 1988 presidential elections. American Political Science Review, 85(4), 1159–1176.
46.
TateK. (1993). From protest to politics: The new black voters in American elections. Harvard University Press.
47.
TeslerM. (2012). The spillover of racialization into health care: How President Obama polarized public opinion by race and racial attitudes. American Journal of Political Science, 56(3), 690–704.
48.
TraugottM. W.KatoshJ. P. (1979). Response validity in surveys of voting behavior. Public Opinion Quarterly, 43(3), 359–377.
49.
WhiteI. K. (2007). When race matters and when it doesn’t: Racial group differences in response to racial cues. American Political Science Review, 101(2), 339–354.
50.
WhiteI. K.LairdC.AllenT. (2014). Selling out?: The politics of navigating conflicts between racial group interest and self-interest. American Political Science Review, 108(4), 783–800.
51.
WhiteI. L.LairdC. (2020). Steadfast democrats: How social forces shape Black political behavior. Princeton University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
