This article explores the controversial 1996 success of three African American incumbents (Sanford Bishop and Cynthia McKinney of Georgia and Corrine Brown of Florida) who lost their majority-Black southern congressional districts to Supreme Court decisions. Using aggregate electoral data and Gary King's solution to the ecological inference problem, we gauge (a) the extent of bias against Black candidates, (b) the extent of backlash against Black voters, and (c) the extent to which incumbency explains away the Georgia victories. The findings are compatible with neither a full attack on racial redistricting nor a defense of it. Southern Whites do not exhibit either consistent bias against Black candidates or backlash against Black voters, but racial polarization is nonetheless evident and dispersed in a geographically systematic manner. Barriers against Black representation are still strong, but they are not the electoral barriers that civil rights activists assume when they embrace majority-minority districts.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allport, G. W.
(1979). The nature of prejudice (25th anniversary ed.). Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. (Original work published 1954)
2.
Alt, J. E.
(1993). Persistence and change in southern voter registration patterns, 1972-1990. Paper presented at the Workshop on Race, Ethnicity, Representation and Governance, given by the Center for American Political Studies of Harvard University Government Department, Cambridge, MA.
3.
Applebome, P.
(1994, September 18). The 1994 campaign: Georgia district ruling is test for racial politics. New York Times, late edition final, p. B8.
4.
Baxter, T.
(1996, August 1). Georgia campaign `96: Primaries offer some indications state voting patterns changing. Atlanta Journal and Constitution, p. 2C.
5.
Berard, S. P.
(1998, October). Racial context and White attitudes in the South: Reexamining racial threat. Paper presented at the meeting of the Southern Political Science Association, Atlanta, GA.
6.
Blalock, H. M., Jr.
(1967). Toward a theory of minority-group relations. New York: John Wiley.
7.
Bositis, D. A. (1997). The future of majority-minority districts and Black and Hispanic legislative representation. Unpublished typescript in possession of authors.
8.
Brady, D. W.
, & Volden, C. (1998). Revolving gridlock: Politics and policy from Carter to Clinton. Boulder, CO: Westview.
9.
Branton, R. P.
, & Jones, B. S. (1999, March). Multiculturalism, diversity, and prejudice. Paper presented at the meeting of the Western Political Science Association, Seattle, WA.
10.
Bullock, C. S., III
. (1996, November 13). Incumbency, not race, wins in the South. Newsday, Nassau and Suffolk edition, p. A41.
11.
Bullock, C. S., III
, & Dunn, R. E. (1997, August). The demise of racial redistricting and the future of Black representation. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington, DC.
12.
Bullock, C. S., III
, & Dunn, R. E. (in press). The demise of racial redistricting and the future of Black representation. Emory Law Journal.
13.
Bullock, C. S., III
, Gaddie, R. K., & Kuzenski, J. C. (1995). The candidacy of David Duke as a stimulus to minority voting. In J. C. Kuzenski, C. S. Bullock, III, & R. K. Gaddie (Eds.), David Duke and the politics of race in the South (pp. 99-114). Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press.
14.
Burnham, W. D.
(1996). Realignment lives: The 1994 earthquake and its implications. In C. Campbell & B. A. Rockman (Eds.), The Clinton presidency: First appraisals (pp. 363-395). Chatham, NJ: Chatham House.
15.
Cameron, C.
, Epstein, D., & O'Halloran, S. (1996). Do majority-minority districts maximize substantive Black representation in Congress?American Political Science Review, 90(4), 794-813.
16.
Campbell, A. L.
, & Palmquist, B. (1998, September). Exit polls as a source of political data. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Political Science Association, Boston, MA.
17.
Carsey, T. M.
(1995). The contextual effect of race on White voter behavior: The 1989 New York City mayoral election. Journal of Politics, 57(1), 221-228.
18.
Charen, M.
(1996, November 14). Election signals more racial harmony. Detroit News, p. A11.
19.
Cho, W. T.
(1998). Iff the assumption fits...: A comment on the King ecological inference solution. Political Analysis, 7(1), 143-163.
20.
Corbello, M. C.
(1998). Searching for evidence of “racial threat” in Louisiana. American Review of Politics, 19(2), 163-174.
21.
Corey, J. W.
(1998, October). Majority-minority districts and campaign finance: An equal playing field? Paper presented at the meeting of the Southern Political Science Association, Atlanta, GA.
22.
Davidson, C.
, & Grofman, B. (Eds.). (1994). Quiet revolution in the South: The impact of the Voting Rights Act 1965-1990. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
23.
Democratic Leadership Council
. (1996, December 3). Good news on race and redistricting. The DLC Update. Available at time of submission at http://www.dlcppi.org/fax/961203.htm
24.
Diversity wins. (1996, July 11). USA Today, final edition, p. 10A.
25.
Epstein, D.
, & O'Halloran, S. (1999). A social science approach to race, redistricting, and representation. American Political Science Review, 93(1), 187-191.
26.
Fiorina, M.
(1977). Congress: Keystone of the Washington establishment. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
27.
Fletcher, M. A.
(1996, November 23). New tolerance in the South or old power of incumbency? Blacks won in five redrawn mostly White districts. Washington Post, final edition, p. A01.
28.
Freedman, D. A.
, Klein, S. P., Sacks, J., Smyth, C.A., & Everett, C. G. (1991). Ecological regression and voting rights. Evaluation Review, 15(6), 673-711.
29.
Gaddie, R. K.
, & Bullock, C. S., III. (1997). Voter turnout and candidate participation: Effects of affirmative action districting. In R. P. Steed, L. W. Moreland, & T. A. Baker (Eds.), Southern parties and elections: Studies in regional political change (pp. 37-51). Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.
30.
Garrett, R. T.
(1996, November 24). Minorities don't need race-based districts. Courier-Journal (Louisville, KY), Sunday Metro, p. 1D.
31.
Gay, C.
(1996, April). Race and political context: The impact of Black congressional representation on the voting behavior of White and Black constituents. Paper presented at the 54th meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago.
32.
Gelman, A.
, & King, G. (1990). Estimating the incumbency advantage without bias. American Journal of Political Science, 34(4), 1142-1164.
33.
Giles, M. W.
, & Buckner, M. A. (1993). David Duke and Black threat: An old hypothesis revisited. Journal of Politics, 55(3), 702-713.
34.
Giles, M. W.
, & Buckner, M. A. (1996). Comment: Racial threat redux. Journal of Politics, 58(4), 1171-1180.
35.
Giles, M. W.
, & Hertz, K. (1994). Racial threat and partisan identification. American Political Science Review, 88(2), 317-326.
36.
Glaser, J. M.
(1994). Back to the Black Belt: Racial environment and White racial attitudes in the South. Journal of Politics, 56(1), 21-42.
37.
Green, D. P.
, & Palmquist, B. (1990). Of artifacts and partisan instability. American Journal of Political Science, 34(3), 872-902.
38.
Green, D. P.
, & Palmquist, B. (1994). How stable is party identification?Political Behavior, 16(4), 437-466.
39.
Green, D. P.
, Palmquist, B., & Schickler, E. (1998). Macropartisanship: A replication and critique. American Political Science Review, 92(4), 883-899.
40.
Grofman, B.
, Griffin, R., & Glazer, A. (1992). The effect of Black population on electing Democrats and liberals to the House of Representatives. Legislative Studies Quarterly, 17(3), 365-379.
41.
Grofman, B.
, & Handley, L. (1989). Minority population proportion and Black and Hispanic congressional success in the 1970s and 1980s. American Politics Quarterly, 17, 436-445.
42.
Grofman, B.
, & Handley, L. (1995). 1990s issues in voting rights. Mississippi Law Journal, 65(2), 205-270.
43.
Grofman, B.
, & Handley, L. (1998). Estimating the impact of voting-rights-related districting on Democratic strength in the U.S. House of Representatives. In B. Grofman (Ed.), Race and redistricting in the 1990s (pp. 51-66). New York: Agathon.
44.
Handley, L.
, Grofman, B., & Arden, W. (1998). Electing minority-preferred candidates to legislative office: The relationship between minority percentages in districts and the election of minority-preferred candidates. In B. Grofman (Ed.), Race and redistricting in the 1990s (pp. 13-38). New York: Agathon.
45.
Helton, C.
(1996, November 7). Georgia analysis: McKinney, Bishop show Blacks can win in majority-White districts. Atlanta Journal and Constitution, p. 3C.
46.
Huckfeldt, R.
, & Kohfeld, C. W. (1989). Race and the decline of class in American politics. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
47.
Jacobson, G. C.
(1996). The 1994 House elections in perspective. In P. A. Klinkner (Ed.), Midterm: The elections of 1994 in context (pp. 1-20). Boulder, CO: Westview.
48.
Janofsky, M.
(1996, June 14). Political briefing: The states and the issues. New York Times, p. A20.
49.
Key, V. O.
(1949). Southern politics in state and nation. New York: Knopf.
50.
Kinder, D. R.
, & Sanders, L. M. (1996). Divided by color: Racial politics and democratic ideals. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
51.
King, G.
(1995). Replication, replication. PS: Political Science and Politics, 28(3), 444-452.
52.
King, G.
(1997). A solution to the ecological inference problem: Reconstructing individual behavior from aggregate data. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
53.
Lehrer, J.
(1996, December 9). Politics of race (transcript No. 5716). Newshour.
54.
Loury, G. C.
(1995). One by one from the inside out: Essays and reviews on race and responsibility in America. New York: Free Press.
55.
Lublin, D.
(1997a). The election of African Americans and Latinos to the U.S. House of Representatives, 1972-1994. American Politics Quarterly, 25(3), 269-286.
56.
Lublin, D.
(1997b). The paradox of representation: Racial gerrymandering and minority interests in Congress. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
57.
Lublin, D.
(1999). Racial redistricting and African-American representation: A critique of “Do majority-minority districts maximize substantive black representation in Congress?”American Political Science Review, 93(1), 183-186.
58.
Lublin, D.
, & Voss, D. S. (1997, August). Boll-weevil blues: The partisan impact of voting rights law in the 1990s. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington, DC, and the Stanford Law Review Symposium on Law and Politics.
59.
Lublin, D.
, & Voss, D. S. (1998). The partisan impact of voting rights law. Stanford Law Review, 50(1), 765-777.
60.
Lublin, D.
, & Voss, D. S. (2000). Racial redistricting and realignment in southern state legislatures. American Journal of Political Science, 44, 792-810.
61.
Mansbridge, J.
(1986). Why we lost the ERA. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
62.
Massey, D. S.
, & Denton, N. A. (1993). American apartheid: Segregation and the making of the underclass. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
63.
Metz, D. H.
, & Tate, K. (1995). The color of mayoral campaigns. In P. E. Peterson (Ed.), Classifying by race (pp. 262-277). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
64.
Miller, N.
, & Brewer, M. B. (1984). The social psychology of desegregation: An introduction. In N. Miller & M. B. Brewer (Eds.), Groups in contact: The psychology of desegregation (pp. 1-8). Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
65.
Morris, R. S.
(1997). Behind the Oval Office: Winning the presidency in the nineties. New York: Random House.
66.
Nichols, J.
(1996, November 11). Georgia's Cinderella story: Soccer moms meet welfare moms in the redistricted campaign of Cynthia McKinney. The Nation.
67.
Orey, B. D.
(1998). The race in black and white: The 1995 Louisiana gubernatorial election. Southeastern Political Review, 26, 909-922.
68.
Overby, L. M.
, & Cosgrove, K. M. (1996). Unintended consequences? Racial redistricting and the representation of minority interests. Journal of Politics, 58(2), 540-550.
69.
Page, C.
(1996, December 1). Results are deceptive in redrawn Black districts. Houston Chronicle, 2 Star edition, p. 3.
70.
Palmquist, B. (1993). Ecological inference, aggregate data analysis of U.S. elections, and the Socialist Party of America. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.
71.
Palmquist, B.
(1994, September 1-4). Respecification approaches to ecological inference: A comparison of control variables and the quadratic model. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Political Science Association, New York.
72.
Palmquist, B. L.
, & Voss, D. S. (1996, April). Racial polarization and turnout in Louisiana: New insights from aggregate data analysis. Paper presented at the 54th meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago.
73.
Palmquist, B. L.
, & Voss, D. S. (1997, April 10-12). Racial polarization in the southern electorate: Republican votes for Duke in Louisiana. Paper presented at the 55th annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago.
74.
Petrocik, J. R.
, & Desposato, S. W. (1998). The partisan consequences of majority-minority redistricting in the South, 1992 and 1994. Journal of Politics, 60(3), 613-633.
75.
Race factor not always primary. (1996, July 16). Tampa Tribune, final edition, p. 6.
76.
Rankin, B.
(1997, June 20). Georgia's congressional districts upheld; Justice Department's clout curbed. Atlanta Journal and Constitution, p. 14A.
77.
Reeves, K.
(1997). Voting hopes or fears? White voters, Black candidates, and racial politics in America. New York: Oxford University Press.
78.
Robinson, W. S.
(1950). Ecological correlations and the behavior of individuals. American Sociological Review, 15(3), 351-357.
79.
Savage, D. G.
(1996, November 9). Despite redistricting dispute, Black lawmakers win reelection. Los Angeles Times, home edition, p. A10.
80.
Schoenberger, R. A.
, & Segal, D. R. (1971). The ecology of dissent: The southern Wallace vote in 1968. Midwest Journal of Political Science, 15(3), 583-586.
81.
Sigelman, C. K.
, Sigelman, L., Walkosz, B. J., & Nitz, M. (1995). Black candidates, White voters: Understanding racial bias in political perceptions. American Journal of Political Science, 39(1), 243-266.
82.
Sleeper, J.
(1996, December 2). The rainbow coalition. New Republic, p. 24.
83.
Sleeper, J.
(1997). Liberal racism. New York: Viking.
84.
Smart, D. B.
(1996, November 26). Blacks don't need gerrymanders to win. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Five Star Lift edition, p. 13B.
85.
Stanley, H. W.
(1996). The parties, the president, and the 1994 midterm elections. In C. Campbell & B. A. Rockman (Eds.), The Clinton presidency: First appraisals (pp. 188-211). Chatham, NJ: Chatham House.
86.
Sturrock, D. E.
(1997). Out of the phone booths: Republican primaries in the Deep South. In R. P. Steed, L. W. Moreland, & T. A. Baker (Eds.), Southern parties and elections: Studies in regional political change (pp. 95-108). Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.
87.
Swain, C. M.
(1993). Black faces, Black interests. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
88.
Tilove, J.
(1996, July 28). Color lines: The untold story of minority districts. Tampa Tribune, metro edition, p. 1.
89.
Toner, R.
(1996, May 19). Political briefs: The states and the issues. New York Times, late edition final, pp. 1, 20.
90.
Traugott, M. W.
, & Price, V. (1992). Exit polls in the 1989 Virginia gubernatorial race: Where did they go wrong?Public Opinion Quarterly, 56(2), 245-253.
91.
Voss, D.S.
(1996a). Beyond racial threat: Failure of an old hypothesis in the New South. Journal of Politics, 58(4), 1156-1170.
92.
Voss, D. S.
(1996b). Familiarity doesn't breed contempt: A rejoinder to “Comment.”Journal of Politics, 58(4), 1181-1183.
93.
Voss, D. S.
(1998, October). Black incumbents, White districts: An appraisal of the 1996 congressional elections in Georgia and Florida. Paper presented at the 1998 meeting of the Southern Political Science Association, Atlanta, GA.
94.
Voss, D. S.
(1999, July). Racial redistricting and the quest for legislative diversity. Extensions of Remarks: APSA Legislative Studies Section Newsletter, 22, 1114
95.
Voss, D. S. (2000). Familiarity doesn't breed contempt: The political geography of racial polarization. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Department of Government, Cambridge, MA.
96.
Voss, D. S.
, & Lublin, D. (1998). Ecological inference and the comparative method. APSA-CP: Newsletter of the APSA Organized Section in Comparative Politics, 9(1), 25-31.
97.
Voss, D. S.
, & Miller, P. (2001). Following a false trail: The hunt for White backlash in Kentucky's 1996 desegregation vote. State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 1, 63-82.
98.
Voter News Service
. 1997. Voter News Service general election exit polls, 1996. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR #6989).
99.
Voters: Black, White and tan; election surprises: Black victories in majority White districts; soaring Latino power. (1996, December 2). Baltimore Sun, final edition, p. 14A.
100.
Wasserman, I. M.
, & Segal, D. R. (1973). Aggregation effects in the ecological study of presidential voting. American Journal of Political Science, 17(1), 177-181.
101.
Weko, T.
, & Aldrich, J. H. (1998). The presidency and the election campaign: Framing the choice in 1996. In M. Nelson (Ed.), The presidency and the political system (5th ed., pp. 275-296). Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly Press.
102.
Williams, D.
(1996, July 16). Surprise at the polls: Racial-bloc politics? Don't look at White voters. Atlanta Journal and Constitution, journal edition, p. 10A.
