This article explores diversity within top leadership positions in state governments, specifically, the role that position selection method plays in promoting the inclusion of racial and ethnic minorities into positions of power. We hypothesize that minorities will be more likely to serve in appointed positions as governors consider diversity in making appointments and less likely to serve in elected positions due to the additional hurdles for candidates of color. Using an original data set of state executive leaders from 2001 to 2017 from all 50 states, we find evidence that institutional design influences levels of diversity among state executive leaders. Racial and ethnic minorities are more likely to be appointed than elected to state executive leadership positions. In addition, we find that Democratic governors are more likely than Republican governors to appoint minorities. Ultimately, this evidence is important for understanding how institutional design can have consequences for descriptive representation, specifically for groups that have been historically excluded from political life.
AlexanderAmy C.2011. “Mayoral Election and the Demand and Supply of Women Mayors.” Journal of Women, Politics & Policy32 (2): 114–35.
2.
AlozieNicholas O.1988. “Black Representation on State Judiciaries.” Social Science Quarterly69 (4): 979–86.
3.
BerinskyAdam J.HutchingsVincent L.MendelbergTaliShakerLeeValentinoNicholas A. 2011. “Sex and Race: Are Black Candidates More Likely to Be Disadvantaged by Sex Scandals?” Political Behavior33 (2): 179–202.
4.
BerkmanMichael B.2005. Ten Thousand Democracies: Politics and Public Opinion in America’s School Districts. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
BradburyMark D.KelloughJ. Edward. 2007. “Representative Bureaucracy: Exploring the Potential for Active Representation in Local Government.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory18 (4): 697–714.
8.
BrantonRegina P.2009. “The Importance of Race and Ethnicity in Congressional Primary Elections.” Political Research Quarterly62 (3): 459–73.
9.
BrattonKathleen A.SpillRorie L. 2002. “Existing Diversity and Judicial Selection: The Role of the Appointment Method in Establishing Gender Diversity in State Supreme Courts.” Social Science Quarterly83 (2): 504–18.
10.
BroockmanDavid E.2013. “Black Politicians Are More Intrinsically Motivated to Advance Blacks’ Interests: A field Experiment Manipulating Political Incentives.” American Journal of Political Science57 (3): 521–36.
11.
BrownNadia E.2014. Sisters in the Statehouse: Black Women and Legislative Decision Making. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12.
BullockCharles S.IIIDunnRichard E. 1999. “The Demise of Racial Districting and the Future of Black Representation.” Emory Law Journal48:1209.
13.
BullockCharles S.IIIRozellMark J. 2017. The New Politics of the Old South: An Introduction to Southern Politics. Lanham, MA: Rowman & Littlefield.
14.
ButlerDaniel M.BroockmanDavid E. 2011. “Do Politicians Racially Discriminate against Constituents? A field Experiment on State Legislators.” American Journal of Political Science55 (3): 463–77.
15.
Edward G.CarminesStimsonJames A.1989. Issue Evolution: Race and the Transformation of American Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
16.
CarrollSusan J.SanbonmatsuKira. 2013. More Women Can Run: Gender and Pathways to the State Legislatures. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
17.
CasellasJason P.2009. “Coalitions in the House? The Election of Minorities to State Legislatures and Congress.” Political Research Quarterly62 (1): 120–31.
18.
ChinJean Lau. 2010. “Introduction to the Special Issue on Diversity and Leadership.” American Psychologist65 (3): 150–56.
Crowder-MeyerMelodyCoopermanRosalyn. 2018. “Can’t Buy Them Love: How Party Culture among Donors Contributes to the Party Gap in Women’s Representation.” The Journal of Politics80 (4): 1211–24.
22.
DavidsonChandlerKorbelGeorge. 1981. “At-large Elections and Minority-Group Representation: A Re-examination of Historical and Contemporary Evidence.” The Journal of Politics43 (4): 982–1005.
23.
DawsonMichael C.1995. Behind the Mule: Race and Class in African-American Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
24.
ElazarDaniel J. 1994. The American Mosaic: The Impact of Space, Time, and Culture on American Politics. Westview Press.
25.
EsterlingKevin M.AndersenSeth S. 1999. “Diversity and the Judicial Merit Selection Process: A Statistical Report.” Research on Judicial Selection2: 2–39.
26.
FoxRichard L.LawlessJennifer L. 2004. “Entering the Arena? Gender and the Decision to Run for Office.” American Journal of Political Science48 (2): 264–80.
27.
FoxRichard L.LawlessJennifer L. 2005. “To Run or Not to Run for Office: Explaining Nascent Political Ambition.” American Journal of Political Science49 (3): 642–59.
28.
FoxRichard L.OxleyZoe M. 2003. “Gender Stereotyping in State Executive Elections: Candidate Selection and Success.” The Journal of Politics65 (3): 833–50.
29.
FrederickKristofer A.JeffriesJudson L. 2009. “A study in African American candidates for high-profile statewide office.” Journal of Black Studies39 (5):689–718.
30.
GayClaudine. 2001. “The Effect of Black Congressional Representation on Political Participation.” American Political Science Review95 (3): 589–602.
31.
GoelzhauserGreg. 2011. “Diversifying State Supreme Courts.” Law & Society Review45 (3): 761–81.
32.
GrahamBarbara Luck. 1990. “Do Judicial Selection Systems Matter? A Study of Black Representation on State Courts.” American Politics Quarterly18 (3): 316–36.
33.
GriffinJohn D.KeaneMichael. 2006. “Descriptive Representation and the Composition of African American Turnout.” American Journal of Political Science50 (4): 998–1012.
34.
GrofmanBernardHandleyLisa. 1989. “Black Representation: Making Sense of Electoral Geography at Different Levels of Government.” Legislative Studies Quarterly14 (2): 265–79.
35.
GroseChristian R.2011. Congress in Black and White: Race and Representation in Washington and at Home. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
36.
HajnalZoltan L.2006. Changing White Attitudes toward Black Political Leadership. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
37.
HenningsValerie M.UrbatschR. 2016. “Gender, Partisanship, and Candidate-Selection Mechanisms.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly16 (3): 290–312.
38.
HolmanMirya R.SchneiderMonica C. 2018. “Gender, Race, and Political Ambition: How Intersectionality and Frames Influence Interest in Political Office.” Politics, Groups, and Identities6 (2): 264–80.
39.
HolmesLisa M.EmreyJolly A. 2006. “Court Diversification: Staffing the State Courts of Last Resort through Interim Appointments.” Justice System Journal27 (1): 1–13.
40.
ImaiKosukeKhannaKabir. 2016. “Improving Ecological Inference by Predicting Individual Ethnicity from Voter Registration Records.” Political Analysis24 (2): 263–72.
41.
JeffriesJudson L.1999. “U.S. Senator Edward W. Brooke and Governor L. Douglas Wilder Tell Political Scientists How Blacks Can Win High-Profile Statewide Office.” PS: Political Science & Politics32 (3): 583–88.
42.
JeffriesJudson L.WavroMatthew A. 2011. “Can African Americans Win High-Profile Statewide Offices in the South? A Study in Southern Inhospitality.” Journal of African American Studies15 (4): 415–32.
43.
JohnsonGbemendeOppenheimerBruce I.SelinJennifer L. 2012. “The House as a Stepping Stone to the Senate: Why Do so Few African American House Members Run?” American Journal of Political Science56 (2): 387–99.
44.
KahnKim Fridkin. 1995. “Characteristics of Press Coverage in Senate and Gubernatorial Elections: Information Available to Voters.” Legislative Studies Quarterly20 (1): 23–35.
45.
KarnigAlbert K.WelchSusan. 1982. “Electoral Structure and Black Representation on City Councils.” Social Science Quarterly63 (1): 99.
KrauseGeorge A.LewisDavid E.DouglasJames W. 2006. “Political Appointments, Civil Service Systems, and Bureaucratic Competence: Organizational Balancing and Executive Branch Revenue Forecasts in the American States.” American Journal of Political Science50 (3): 770–87.
50.
LawlessJennifer L.FoxRichard L. 2010. It Still Takes a Candidate: Why Women Don’t Run for Office. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
LewisDavid E.2007. “Testing Pendleton’s Premise: Do Political Appointees Make Worse Bureaucrats?” The Journal of Politics69 (4): 1073–88.
53.
LewisDavid E.2012. “The Contemporary Presidency: The Personnel Process in the Modern Presidency.” Presidential Studies Quarterly42 (3): 577–96.
54.
MansbridgeJane. 1999. “Should Blacks Represent Blacks and Women Represent Women? A Contingent ‘Yes.’” The Journal of Politics61 (3): 628–57.
55.
MarschallMelissa J.RuhilAnirudh V. S.ShahParu R. 2010. “The New Racial Calculus: Electoral Institutions and Black Representation in Local Legislatures.” American Journal of Political Science54 (1): 107–24.
56.
MartinElainePyleBarry. 2002. “Gender and Racial Diversification of State Supreme Courts.” Women & Politics24 (2): 35–52.
57.
McDermottMonika L.1998. “Race and Gender Cues in Low-Information Elections.” Political Research Quarterly51 (4): 895–918.
58.
MillerSusan M.2012. “Administering Representation: The Role of Elected Administrators in Translating Citizens’ Preferences into Public Policy.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory23 (4): 865–97.
PattersonBradley H.PfiffnerJames P. 2001. “The White House Office of Presidential Personnel.” Presidential Studies Quarterly31 (3): 415–38.
63.
PhilpotTasha S.WaltonHanesJr.2007. “One of Our Own: Black Female Candidates and the Voters Who Support Them.” American Journal of Political Science51 (1): 49–62.
64.
PickerillJ. MitchellBowlingCynthia J. 2014. “Polarized Parties, Politics, and Policies: Fragmented Federalism in 2013–2014.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism44 (3): 369–98.
65.
PitkinHanna Fenichel. 1967. The Concept of Representation. Berkeley: University of California Press.
66.
ReevesKeith. 1997. Voting Hopes or Fears? White Voters, Black Candidates & Racial Politics in America. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
67.
SanbonmatsuKira. 2015. “Electing Women of Color: The Role of Campaign Trainings.” Journal of Women, Politics & Policy36 (2): 137–60.
68.
SeldenSally Coleman. 1997. The Promise of Representative Bureaucracy: Diversity and Responsiveness in a Government Agency. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe.
69.
SetzlerMarkYanusAlixandra B. 2018. “Why Did Women Vote for Donald Trump?” PS: Political Science & Politics51 (3): 523–27.
70.
ShahParu. 2015. “Stepping Up: Black Political Ambition and Success.” Politics, Groups, and Identities3 (2): 278–94.
71.
ShahParuScottJamilGonzalez JuenkeEric. 2019. “Women of Color Candidates: Examining Emergence and Success in State Legislative Elections.” Politics, Groups, and Identities7 (2): 429–43.
72.
SidesJohnTeslerMichaelVavreckLynn. 2018. Identity Crisis: The 2016 Presidential Campaign and the Battle for the Meaning of America. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
73.
SigelmanCarol K.SigelmanLeeWalkoszBarbara J.NitzMichael. 1995. “Black Candidates, White Voters: Understanding Racial Bias in Political Perceptions.” American Journal of Political Science39 (1): 243–65.
74.
SigelmanLeeWelchSusan. 1984. “Race, Gender, and Opinion toward Black and Female Presidential Candidates.” Public Opinion Quarterly48 (2): 467–75.
75.
SonensheinRaphael J.1990. “Can Black Candidates win Statewide Elections?” Political Science Quarterly105 (2): 219–41.
TaebelDelbert. 1978. “Minority Representation on City Councils: The Impact of Structure on Blacks and Hispanics.” Social Science Quarterly59 (1): 142–52.
79.
TateKatherine. 2001. “The Political Representation of Blacks in Congress: Does Race Matter?” Legislative Studies Quarterly26 (4): 623–38.
80.
TerkildsenNayda. 1993. “When White Voters Evaluate Black Candidates: The Processing Implications of Candidate Skin Color, Prejudice, and Self-monitoring.” American Journal of Political Science37 (4): 1032–53.
81.
TheriaultSean M.2008. Party Polarization in Congress. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
82.
ThomsenDanielle M.SwersMichele L. 2017. “Which Women Can Run? Gender, Partisanship, and Candidate Donor Networks.” Political Research Quarterly70 (2): 449–63.
TokeshiMatthew. Forthcoming. “Why Are African American Governors and US Senators so Rare? Exploring White Voters’ Responses to African American Statewide Candidates.” Political Behavior.
VisalvanichNeil. 2017. “When Does Race Matter? Exploring White Responses to Minority Congressional Candidates.” Politics, Groups, and Identities5 (4): 618–41.
WekoThomas J.1995. The Politicizing Presidency: The White House Personnel Office, 1948-1994. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.
89.
WelchSusan. 1990. “The Impact of At-large Elections on the Representation of Blacks and Hispanics.” The Journal of Politics52 (4): 1050–76.
90.
WhitbyKenny J.KrauseGeorge A. 2001. “Race, Issue Heterogeneity and Public Policy: The Republican Revolution in the 104th US Congress and the Representation of African-American Policy Interests.” British Journal of Political Science31 (3): 555–72.
91.
WilliamsLinda F.1990. “White/Black Perceptions of the Electability of Black Political Candidates.” National Political Science Review2 (1): 45–64.
92.
WoodsonBenjamin. 2017. “The Two Opposing Effects of Judicial Elections on Legitimacy Perceptions.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly17 (1): 24–46.
93.
ZingherJoshua N.2014. “An Analysis of the Changing Social Bases of America’s Political Parties: 1952–2008.” Electoral Studies35:272–82.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
