Scholars have recently highlighted a critical, but previously neglected, facet of racially discriminatory public policies—such policies may be motivated by either economic or psychological forces. That is, racially discriminatory policy may be the result of self-interest and competition in the face of scarcity or prejudices and affects based on group identities. We test if these motivations were behind the passage of an important, openly discriminatory public policy: California's Alien Land Law of 1920. We find that neither motivation alone accounts for the initiative vote that passed this law; both played a role. Our analysis also illustrates how racially discriminatory policies in the early 20th century fit into the ordinary politics of the day.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllswangJohn M.2000. The Initiative and Referendum in California, 1898–1998. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
2.
AlvarezR. MichaelBedollaLisa Garcia. 2004. “The Revolution against Affirmative Action in California: Racism, Economics and Proposition 209.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly4:1–17.
3.
BaileyThomas A.1932. “California, Japan, and the Alien Land Legislation of 1913.” Pacific Historical Review1:36–59.
4.
BettelheimBrunoJanowitzMorris. [1950] 1964. Social Change and Prejudice. New York: Macmillan Co.
5.
BuellRaymond Leslie. 1922. “Development of the Anti-Japanese Agitation in the United States.” Political Science Quarterly37:605–38.
6.
BuellRaymond Leslie. 1923a. “Development of the Anti-Japanese Agitation in the United States II.” Political Science Quarterly38:57–81.
7.
BuellRaymond Leslie. 1923b. “Some Legal Aspects of the Japanese Question.” American Journal of International Law17:29–49.
CarseyThomas M.1995. “The Contextual Effects of Race on White Voter Behavior: The 1989 New York City Mayoral Election.” Journal of Politics57:221–8.
10.
ChangRobert S.1999. Disoriented: Asian Americans, Law, and the Nation-State. New York: NYU Press.
11.
ChoWendy K. TamGainesBrian J.. 2000. “Racial Roll Calls at the Turn of the Century.” Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington, DC.
12.
DanielsRoger. 1962. The Politics of Prejudice. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
13.
DanielsRoger. 1988. Asian America: Chinese and Japanese in the United States since 1850. Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press.
14.
Department of Commerce. 1913. Thirteenth Census of the United States Taken in the Year 1910. Volume II. Washington, DC: United States Government Printing Office.
15.
FeldmanStanleyStennerKaren. 1997. “Perceived Threat and Authoritarianism.” Political Psychology18:741–70.
16.
FugitaStephen S.O'BrienDavid J.. 1991. Japanese American Ethnicity: The Persistence of Community. Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press.
17.
GainesBrian J.LewkowiczMichael. 2003. “Three Dimensions of Voting: A Decomposition of California Turnout Levels Over Time, Across Space, and Down the Ballot.” University of Illinois. Typescript.
18.
GilesMichael W.GatlinDouglas S.CataldoEverett F.. 1976. “Racial and Class Prejudice: Their Relative Effects on Protest Against School Desegregation.” American Sociological Review41:280–8.
19.
GilesMichael W.CataldoEverettGatlinDouglas. 1975. “White Flight and Percent Black: The Tipping Point Re-examined.” Social Science Quarterly56:85–92.
20.
GreenDonald P.StrolovitchDara Z.WongJanelle S.. 1998. “Defended Neighborhoods, Integration, and Racially Motivated Crime.” American Journal of Sociology104:372–403.
21.
GyoryAndrew. 1998. Closing the Gate: Race, Politics, and the Chinese Exclusion Act. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
22.
GyoryAndrew. 2000. “A Reply to Stanford Lyman.” New Politics29:51–9.
23.
HallettMary E.1972. “A Governor-General's Views on Oriental Immigration to British Columbia, 1904–1911.” BC Studies14:51–72.
24.
HarmanHarry H.1976. Modern Factor Analysis. 3rd ed.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
25.
HichbornFranklin. 1909. Story of the Session of the California Legislature of 1909. San Francisco, CA: Press of the James H. Barry Company.
26.
HichbornFranklin. 1911. Story of the Session of the California Legislature of 1911. San Francisco, CA: Press of the James H. Barry Company.
27.
HichbornFranklin. 1913. Story of the Session of the California Legislature of 1913. San Francisco, CA: Press of the James H. Barry Company.
28.
HiggsRobert. 1978. “Landless by Law: Japanese Immigrants in California Agriculture to 1941.” Journal of Economic History38:205–25.
29.
IchihashiYamato. 1915. Japanese Immigration: Its Status in California. San Francisco, CA: The Marshall Press.
30.
JordanFrank C.1904–20. Statement of the Vote of California at the General Election (various years). Sacramento, CA: Secretary of State/ Superintendent of State Printing.
31.
KeyV.O.Jr. [1949] 1984. Southern Politics in State and Nation. Knoxville, TN: University of Tennessee Press.
32.
KinderDonald R.MendelbergTali. 1995. “Cracks in American Apartheid: The Political Impact of Prejudice among Desegregated Whites.” Journal of Politics57:402–24.
33.
LymanStanford. 2000a. “The ‘Chinese Question’ and American Labor Historians.” New Politics28:113–48.
34.
LymanStanford. 2000b. “Engels Was Right! Organized Labor's Opposition to Chinese in the U.S.” New Politics29:60–7.
35.
McGovneyDudley O.1947. “The Anti-Japanese Land Laws of California and Ten Other States.” California Law Review35:7–90.
36.
MillerStuart Creighton. 1969. The Unwelcome Immigrant: The American Image of the Chinese, 1785–1882. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
37.
OlinSpencer C.Jr.1966. “European Immigrant and Oriental Alien: Acceptance and Rejection by the California Legislature of 1913.” Pacific Historical Review35:303–15.
38.
OliverJ. EricMendelbergTali. 2000. “Reconsidering the Environmental Determinants of Racial Attitudes.” American Journal of Political Science44:574–89.
39.
ParsonsStanley B.BeachWilliam W.DubinMichael J.. 1986. United States Congressional Districts and Data, 1843–1883. New York: Greenwood Press.
40.
RoyPatricia E.1989. White Man's Province: British Columbia Politicians and Chinese and Japanese Immigrants. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.
41.
SalesS.1973. “Threat as a Factor in Authoritarianism: An Analysis of Archival Data.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology28:44–57.
42.
SnidermanPaul M.PeriPierangeloRuiJde FigueiredoP.Jr.PiazzaThomas. 2000. The Outsider: Prejudice and Politics in Italy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
SuzukiMasao. 2000. “Important or Impotent? Taking Another Look at the 1920 California Alien Land Law.” San Francisco, CA: PPIC Working Paper.
45.
TajfelHenri. 1981. Human Groups and Social Categories: Studies in Social Psychology. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
46.
YuHenry. 2002. “Book Review: Closing the Gate.” Law and History Review20:418.
47.
VossD. StephenMillerPenny. 2001. “Following a False Trail: The Hunt for White Backlash in Kentucky's 1996 Desegregation Vote.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly1:62–80.
