Smoke-Free Policy Implementation: Theoretical and Practical Considerations

Abstract

Secondhand smoke exposure is a major public health issue, increasing the risk of cardiovascular and respiratory diseases and cancer. Although best practices for adopting smoke-free policy are well understood, there is limited research on the effective implementation of smoke-free policy. This article presents theoretical and practical considerations for smoke-free policy implementation in three Kentucky communities guided by the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) Framework. Although both Danville and Lexington-Fayette County, Kentucky have comprehensive smoke-free policies, Danville had more effective implementation, as well as better outcomes. Further study is needed to understand the critical elements of smoke-free policy implementation and their association with population outcomes. The IAD is a promising model to guide the study of both policy adoption and implementation.

Keywords

smoke-free policy policy implementation Institutional Analysis and Development Framework

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Americans for Nonsmokers’ Rights Foundation. (2012). 100% smokefree definitions. Retrieved from http://www.no-smoke.org/document.php?id=758.

Americans for Nonsmokers’ Rights Foundation. (2013). Overview list—How many smokefree laws? Retrieved from http://www.no-smoke.org/pdf/mediaordlist.pdf.

Anderson

J. E.

(1979) Public policymaking, 2nd ed. New York, NY: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.

Berman, P. (1978). The study of macro and micro implementation of social policy (The Rand Paper Series # P6071, pp. 1–42).

Cameron

Brennan

Durkin

Borland

Travers

M. J.

Hyland

Wakefield

M. A.

(2010) Secondhand smoke exposure (PM2.5) in outdoor dining areas and its correlates. Tobacco Control 19(1): 19–23.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2008). Evaluation toolkit for smoke-free policies. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/basic_information/secondhand_smoke/evaluation_toolkit/pdfs/evaluation_toolkit.pdf.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2013). Behavioral risk factor surveillance system. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/brfss/.

deLeon

(2002) What ever happened to policy implementation? An alternative approach. Journal of Public Administration Research 12(4): 467–492.

Eriksen

Chaloupka

(2007) The economic impact of clean indoor air laws. A Cancer Journal for Clinicians 57: 367–378.

10.

Fallin, A. (2011). Implementation effectiveness of campus tobacco-free policies (Doctoral Dissertations Paper 167). University of Kentucky, Lexington.

11.

Gotz

N. K.

van Tongeren

Wareing

Wallace

L. M.

Semple

Maccalman

(2008) Changes in air quality and second-hand smoke exposure in hospitality sector businesses after introduction of the English Smoke-free legislation. Journal of Public Health (Oxf) 30(4): 421–428.

12.

Greathouse

Hahn

Okoli

Warnick

Riker

(2005) Passing a smoke-free law in a pro-tobacco culture: A multiple streams approach. Policy, Politics and Nursing Practice 6(3): 211–220.

13.

Hahn

E. J.

(2010) Smokefree legislation: A review of health and economic outcomes research. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 39(6 Suppl. 1): S66–S76.

14.

Hahn, E. J. (2013). Smoke-free ordinance and regulation data base. Retrieved from www.kcsp.uky.edu.

15.

Hahn

E. J.

Rayens

M. K.

(2010) Local health department tobacco cessation survey 2000–2010, Lexington: University of Kentucky College of Nursing.

16.

Hahn

E. J.

Rayens

M. K.

Adkins

Simpson

Frazier

Mannino

D. M.

(2014) Fewer hospitalizations for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in communities with smoke-free public policies. American Journal of Public Health 104(6): 1059–1065.

17.

Hahn

E. J.

Rayens

M. K.

Butler

K. M.

Zhang

Durbin

Steinke

(2008) Smoke-free laws and adult smoking prevalence. Preventive Medicine 47(2): 206–209.

18.

Hahn

E. J.

Rayens

M. K.

Okoli

C. T.

Love

Kim

(2004) Tobacco use prevention and cessation policies in manufacturing facilities in the tobacco-growing state of Kentucky. American Journal of Health Promotion 18(3): 225–231.

19.

Hahn

E. J.

Rayens

York

Okoli

Zhang

Dignan

Al-Delaimy

W. K.

(2006) Effects of a smoke-free law on hair nicotine and respiratory symptoms in restaurant and bar workers. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 48(9): 906–913.

20.

Harachi

T. W.

Abbott

R. D.

Catalano

R. F.

Haggerty

K. P.

Fleming

C. B.

(1999) Opening the black box: Using process evaluation measures to assess implementation and theory building. American Journal of Community Psychology 27(5): 711–731.

21.

Hopkins

D. P.

Razi

Leeks

K. D.

Priya Kalra

Chattopadhyay

S. K.

Soler

R. E.

(2010) Smokefree policies to reduce tobacco use a systematic review. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 38(2 Suppl.): S275–S289.

22.

Hyland

Travers

M. J.

Dresler

Higbee

Cummings

K. M.

(2008) A 32-country comparison of tobacco smoke derived particle levels in indoor public places. Tobacco Control 17(3): 159–165.

23.

Institute of Medicine (2009) Secondhand smoke exposure and cardiovascular effects: Making sense of the evidence, Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.

24.

Kentucky Center for Smoke-free Policy. (2013). Tobacco use and policy fact sheets by county. Retrieved from http://www.mc.uky.edu/tobaccopolicy/KCSP/UseAndPolicyFactSheets2011.HTM.

25.

Lee

Hahn

Robertson

Lee

Vogel

Travers

(2009) Strength of smoke-free laws and indoor air quality. Nicotine & Tobacco Research 11(4): 381–386.

26.

Martinez

(2009) Barriers and challenges of implementing tobacco control policies in hospitals: Applying the institutional analysis and development framework to the catalan network of smoke-free hospitals. Policy Politics and Nursing Practice 10(3): 224–232.

27.

Matland

R. E.

(1995) Synthesizing the implementation literature: The ambiguity-conflict model of policy implementation. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory: J-PART 5(2): 145–174.

28.

Meier

K. J.

(1993) Politics and the bureaucracy: Policymaking in the fourth branch of government, New York, NY: Harcourt-Brace.

29.

Nagler

R. H.

Viswanath

(2013) Implementation and research priorities for FCTC Articles 13 and 16: Tobacco advertising, promotion and sponorship and sales to and by minors. Nicotine & Tobacco Research 15(4): 832–846.

30.

Ostrom

(2005) Understanding institutional diversity, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

31.

O’Toole

L. J.

Jr. (2000) Research on policy implementation: Assessment and prospects. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 10(2): 263–288.

32.

Rayens

M. K.

Burkhart

P. V.

Zhang

Lee

Moser

D. K.

Mannino

Hahn

E. J.

(2008) Reduction in asthma-related emergency department visits after implementation of a smoke-free law. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology 122(3): 537–541.e533.

33.

Sabatier

P. A.

Mazmanian

(1979) The conditions of effective implementation: A guide to accomplishing policy objectives. Policy Analysis 5(4): 481–504.

34.

Skeer

Land

M. L.

Cheng

D. M.

Siegel

M. B.

(2004) Smoking in Boston bars before and after a 100% smoke-free regulation: An assessment of early compliance. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice 10(6): 501–507.

35.

Stillman

Hartman

Graubard

Gilpin

Murray

Gibson

(2003) Evaluation of the American Stop Smoking Intervention Study (ASSIST): A report of outcomes. Journal of the National Cancer Institute 95(22): 1681–1691.

36.

Stillman

Yang

Figueiredo

Hernandez-Avila

Samet

(2006) Building capacity for tobacco control research and policy. Tobacco Control 15: i18–i23.

37.

Tan

C. E.

Glantz

S. A.

(2012) Association between smoke-free legislation and hospitalizations for cardiac, cerebrovascular, and respiratory diseases: A meta-analysis. Circulation 126: 2177–2183.

38.

Thornley

Dirks

K. N.

Edwards

Woodward

Marshall

(2013) Indoor air pollution levels were halved as a result of a national tobacco ban in a New Zealand prison. Nicotine & Tobacco Research 15(2): 343–347.

39.

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (2006) The health consequences of involuntary exposure to tobacco smoke: A report of the surgeon general, Atlanta, GA: Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Chronic Disease and Prevention and Promotion, Office of Smoking and Health.

40.

Van Meter

D. S.

Van Horn

C. E.

(1975) The policy implementation process: A conceptual framework. Administration & Society 6(4): 445–488.

41.

Weber

M. D.

Bagwell

D. A.

Fielding

J. E.

Glantz

S. A.

(2003) Long term compliance with California’s Smoke-Free Workplace Law among bars and restaurants in Los Angeles county. Tobacco Control 12(3): 269–273.

42.

World Health Organization. (2014a). Framework convention on tobacco control. Retrieved from http://www.who.int/fctc/en/.

43.

World Health Organization. (2014b). Tobacco Free Initiative (TFI): Smoke-free policies. Retrieved from http://www.who.int/tobacco/training/success_stories/smokefree_policies/en/.

44.

Yamin

Bitton

Bates

(2010) E-cigarettes: A rapidly growing Internet phenomenon. Annals of Internal Medicine 153(9): 607–609.