From the “landmark” Alston v. NCAA antitrust decision, we examine whether the legally hypothesized fan wage-repugnance effect implies procompetitive benefits in NCAA sports output markets via increased output demand from student-athlete wage restriction. In Alston v. NCAA, the Courts took this benefit as given but failed to recognize the empirically-verified relationship between league talent and fan demand. We assume a legally-hypothesized wage-repugnance line exists and present a theoretical output-demand model functionally dependent upon allocations in a wage-constrained labor-input market. Even given fan repugnance, wage restrictions do not necessarily generate procompetitive benefits. For families of model parameterizations, wage restrictions impose anticompetitive harm.
Alston v. National Collegiate Athletic Association (Alston II), 958 F.3D 1239 (9th Cir. 2021).
2.
BakerT. A.EdelmanM.WatanabeN. M. (2017). Debunking the NCAA’s myth that amateurism conforms with antitrust law: A legal and statistical analysis. Tenn L Rev, 85, 661.
3.
BarabinoB.SalisS. (2019). Moving towards a more accurate level of inspection against fare evasion in proof-of-payment transit systems. Networks and Spatial Economics, 19(4), 1319–1346.
4.
Berry, IIIW. W. (2017). Employee-athletes, antitrust, and the future of college sports. Stan. L. & Pol’y Rev, 28, 245.
5.
BrandesL.FranckE.NüeschS. (2008). Local heroes and superstars: An empirical analysis of star attraction in German soccer. Journal of Sports Economics, 9(3), 266–286.
6.
BratsbergB.RøedK.RaaumO.NaylorR.JanttiM.ErikssonT.OsterbackaE. (2007). Nonlinearities in intergenerational earnings mobility: Consequences for cross-country comparisons. The Economic Journal, 117(519), C72–C92.
7.
BuraimoB.SimmonsR. (2015). Uncertainty of outcome or star quality? Television audience demand for English Premier League football. International Journal of the Economics of Business, 22(3), 449–469.
8.
CroxsonK.James ReadeJ (2014). Information and efficiency: Goal arrival in soccer betting. The Economic Journal, 124(575), 62–91.
9.
Di LeoS.CaramutaP.CurciP.CosmiC (2020). Regression analysis for energy demand projection: An application to TIMES-Basilicata and TIMES-Italy energy models. Energy, 196, 117058.
EhrlichJ. A.GhimireS.SadlerT. R.SandersS. D. (2023). Policy and policy response on the court: A theoretical and empirical examination of the three-Point line extension in basketball. Journal of Sports Economics, 24(2), 159–173.
12.
FanQ.WangT. (2018). Game day effect on stock market: Evidence from four major sports leagues in US. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 20, 9–18.
13.
FeldmanP.RehbeckJ. (2022). Revealing a preference for mixtures: An experimental study of risk. Quantitative Economics, 13(2), 761–786.
14.
HumphreysB. R.JohnsonC. (2020). The effect of superstars on game attendance: Evidence from the NBA. Journal of Sports Economics, 21(2), 152–175.
JinJ. Y.KanagaretnamK.LiuY.LiuN. (2019). Banks’ loan growth, loan quality, and social capital. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 21, 83–102.
17.
KahaneL.LongleyN.SimmonsR. (2013). The effects of coworker heterogeneity on firm-level output: assessing the impacts of cultural and language diversity in the National Hockey League. Review of Economics and Statistics, 95(1), 302–314.
18.
NCAA v. Alston, 141 S. Ct. 2141 (2021).
19.
NgoF.CoynerM.LoughN. (2022). The financial behaviors of chasing athletic prestige: Evidence from the NCAA cost of attendance policy. The Review of Higher Education, 45(3), 307–336.
20.
NollR. G. (2022). Sports economics on trial: Alston v. NCAA. Journal of Sports Economics, 23(6), 826–845.
21.
O’Bannon v. NCAA, 7 F. Supp. 3d 955, 962–63 (N.D. Cal. 2014).
22.
RothA. E.WangS. W. (2020). Popular repugnance contrasts with legal bans on controversial markets. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(33), 19792–19798.
23.
SandersS. (2022). Point shaving in NCAA Men’s Basketball: Behavioral finance, scale, and deterrence. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 34, 100670.
24.
SungH.MillsB. M.MondelloM. (2019). Local broadcast viewership in major league soccer. Journal of Sport Management, 33(2), 106–118.
25.
WuR. (2022). Sports Mood Index, institutional investors, and earnings announcement anomalies. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 35, 100688.
