A clinical case is used to explore the ethical complexities of solid organ donation and transplantation within the Hmong community in the United States. Although many cultures can present various ethical issues, the challenges of the Hmong belief system are unique and distinctly complex. Ways for the medical team to integrate with the Hmong value system to attempt to create an environment of transcultural respect and appreciation are described.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
United Network for Organ Sharing.Data request: Directed donor transplants involving minors, USA, 1988–2006. August 2007. http://www.optn.org/data/request_main.asp. Accessed November 16, 2008.
ClemingsR. Fresno's Hmong leave for new lives. The Fresno Bee. September 10, 2001:A1, A12.
6.
Culhane-PeraKVawterDXiongPBabbittBSolbergM, eds. Healing by Heart: Clinical and Ethical Case Stories of Hmong Families and Western Providers.Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press; 2003.
7.
HelselDMochelMBauerR. Chronic illness and Hmong shamans. J Transcultural Nurs.2005;16:150–154.
8.
PlotnikoffGNumrichCWuCYangDXiongP. Hmong shamanism: Animist spiritual healing in Minnesota. Minnesota Med.2002;85:29–34.
9.
FadimanA. The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures.New York, NY: Farrar, Straus and Giroux;1997.
10.
BarnesLPlotnikoffG. Fadiman and beyond—the dangers of extrapolation. Bioethics Forum.2001;17(1):32–40.
11.
O'ConnorB. Healing Traditions: Alternative Medicine and the Health Professions.Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press; 1995.
12.
ReznikVCooperTMacDonaldDBenadorNLemireJ. Hais cuaj txub kaum txub—to speak of all things: A Hmong cross-cultural case study. J Immigrant Health.2001;3:23–30.
13.
BramstedtK. Is it ethical to prioritize patients for organ allocation according to their values about organ donation?Prog Transplant.2006;16:170–174.
SimmonsRGHickeyKKjellestrandCMSimmonsRL. Family tension in the search for a kidney donor. JAMA.1971;215:909–912.
16.
Hart v Brown, 289 A2d 386 (Conn 1972).
17.
VerbleMBowenGKayNMitoffJShaferTWorthJ. A multiethnic study of the relationship between fears and concerns and refusal rates. Prog Transplant.2002;12:185–190.
18.
FabrePPautOCamboulivesJ. Hémodilution normovolémique profonde chez un enfant témoin de Jéhovah et prélévement multiorganes: Queeles limites?Ann Fr Anesth Reanim.1998;17:198–199.
19.
DanovitchG. Cultural barriers to kidney transplantation: A new frontier. Transplantation.2007;84(4):462–463.
20.
ReadCM. Working with an Aboriginal community liaison worker. Rural Remote Health.2006;6(2):381.
21.
JainN. Evolution and development of a renal recipient transplant co-ordinator for the Asian community. EDTNA ERCA J.1999;25(2):4–6.
22.
WindmillDCJainNInstonNGReadyAR. Impact of a “direct approach” to live kidney donation in the British Indo-Asian community. Transplant Proc.2005;37(2):551–552.
23.
RosellT. An ethics conflict and culture: Should this kidney be used?Pediatr Nurs.2006;32(1):68–70.
24.
NumrichCPlotnikoffGYangDWuCXiongP. Enhanced listening skills: Gifts from the Hmong. J Clin Ethics.2002;13(4):337–343.
