What a diagnosis of brain stem death (the term used in the United Kingdom) or brain death (the term used in the United States) means to the family members of potential organ donors is an important issue to explore as biomedicine moves to expand the range of end-of-life technologies that, potentially, blur the demarcation between life and death.
Objective
To provide some insights into how a diagnosis of brain stem death or brain death may be perceived by family members approached about organ donation.
Methods
A review of the literature regarding organ donation was carried out.
Results
Although most publications do not focus specifically on the concept of brain death, those that do so made a valuable contribution, offering potential theoretical frameworks to aid our understanding of what the diagnosis of death by brain-based criteria means to family members of potential organ donors. The diagnosis of brain death is intricately linked to the issue of organ donation and may influence family members' decision making. Also, the perception that death has occurred differs from one person to another.
Conclusions
A sustained increase in the number of organs available for transplantation may never be achieved until the concepts of brain death, brain stem death, and now Non—Heart-beating death (1) are debated more widely within society; (2) a greater degree of consensus is reached within health care; and (3) bereaved family members approached to donate the organs of their deceased relative have a better understanding of what these diagnoses mean.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
MooresBClarkeGLewisBRMallickNP. Public attitudes toward kidney Transplantation. Br Med J.1976;1(6010):629–631.
2.
ProttasJM. Encouraging altruism: Public attitudes and the marketing of organ donation. Milbank Mem Fund Q Health Soc.1983;61(2):278–306.
3.
Gallup Poll surveys views on organ donation.Nephrol News Issues.1993;7(5):16,19.
4.
SannerM. A Comparison of public attitudes toward autopsy, organ donation, and anatomic dissection: A Swedish survey. JAMA.1994;271(4):284–288.
5.
SannerM. Attitudes toward organ donation and transplantation: A model for understanding reactions to medical procedures after death. Soc Sci Med.1994;38(8):1141–1152.
6.
SannerMA. Exchanging spare parts or becoming a new person? People's attitudes toward receiving and donating organs. Soc Sci Med.2001;52(10):1491–1499.
7.
SannerM. People's attitudes and reactions to organ donation. Mortality.2006;11(2):133–150.
8.
BattenHLProttasJM. Kind strangers: The families of organ donors. Health Aff (Millwood).1987;6(2):35–47.
9.
MurrayTH. Gifts of the body and the needs of strangers. Hastings Cent Rep.1987;17(2):38–38.
10.
PelletierM. The organ donor family members' perception of stressful situations during the organ donation experience. J Adv Nurs.1992;17(1):90–97.
11.
PelletierM. The needs of family members of organ and tissue donors. Heart Lung.1993;22(2):151–157.
12.
PelletierM. Emotions experienced and coping strategies used by family members or organ donation. Can J Nurs Res.1993;25(2):63–73.
13.
PearsonIYBazeleyPSpencer-PlaneTChapmanJRRobertsonP. A survey of families of brain dead patients: Their experiences, attitudes to organ donation and transplantation. Anaesth Intensive Care.1995;23(1):88–95.
14.
SqueM. The Experiences of Donor Relatives, and Nurses' Attitudes, Knowledge and Behaviour Regarding Cadaveric Donotransplantation [dissertation]. Southampton, United Kingdom: University of Southampton; 1996.
15.
SqueMPayneS. Dissonant loss: The experience of donor relatives. Soc Sci Med.1996;43(9):1359–1370.
16.
VerbleMWorthJ. Dealing with the fear of mutilation in the donation discussion. J Transpl Coord.1999;9(1):54–56.
17.
VerbleMWorthJ. Fears and concerns expressed by families in the donation discussion. Prog Transplant.2000;10(1):48–53.
18.
SqueMLongTPayneS. Organ and tissue donation: Exploring the needs of families.http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/11140/. Accessed February 24, 2008.
19.
Sque M, Long T, Payne S. Organ donation: Key factors influencing families' decision-making. Transplant Proc.2005;37(2):543–546.
20.
SqueMLongTPayneS. Why relatives do not donate organs for transplant: “sacrifice” or “gift of life.”J Adv Nurs.2008;61(2):134–144.
21.
HaddowG. Donor and nondonor families' accounts of communication and relations with health care professionals. Prog Transplant.2004;14(1):41–48.
22.
HaddowG. The phenomenology of death, embodiment and organ transplants. Soc Health Illness.2005;27(1):92–113.
23.
LongTSqueMPayneS. Information sharing: Its impact on donor and nondonor families experiences in the hospital. Prog Transplant.2006;16(2):144–149.
24.
RadeckiCMJaccardJ. Psychological aspects of organ donation: A critical review and synthesis of individual and next-of-kin donation decisions. Health Psychol.1997;16(2):183–195.
25.
BurroughsTEHongBAKappelDFFreedmanBK. The stability of family decisions to consent or refuse organ donation. Would you do it again?Psychosom Med.1998;60(2):156–162.
26.
MartinezJMLopezJSMartinAMartinMJScandroglioBMartinJM. Organ donation and family decision-making within the Spanish donation system. Soc Sci Med.2001;53:405–421.
27.
SiminoffLAArnoldRMCaplanAL. Asking for altruism when death occurs: Who asks for organ donation and why?Transplant Proc.1996;28(6):3632–3638.
28.
GortmakerSLBeasleyCSheehyE. Improving the request process to increase family consent for organ donation. J Transpl Coord.1998;8(4):210–217.
29.
DeJongWFranzHGWolfeSM. Requesting organ donation: An interview study of donor and nondonor families. Am J Crit Care.1998;7(1):13–23.
30.
FranzHGDeJongWWolfeSMNathanHPayneDReitsmaWBeasleyC. Explaining brain death: A critical feature of the donation process. J Transpl Coord.1997;7(1):14–21.
31.
SiminoffLA. American attitudes and beliefs about brain death. In: YoungnerSJArnoldRMSchapiroR, eds. The Definition of Death: Contemporary Controversies.Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press; 1999:183–193.
32.
SiminoffLAGordonNHewlettJArnoldRM. Factors influencing families' consent for donation of solid organs for transplantation. JAMA.2001;286(1):71–77.
33.
SiminoffLAMercerMBArnoldRM. Families understanding of brain death. Prog Transplant.2003;13(3):218–224.
34.
SiminoffLABurantCYoungnerSJ. Death and organ procurement: Public beliefs and attitudes. Soc Sci Med.2004;59(11):2325–2334.
35.
ArnoldJDZimmermanTFMartinDC. Public attitudes and the diagnosis of death. JAMA.1968;206(9):1949–1954.
36.
HessingDJElffersDF. Attitudes toward death, fear of being declared dead too soon and donation of organs after death. Omega J Death Dying.1986;17(2):115–124.
37.
DuboisJMSchmidtT. Does the public support organ donation using higher brain–death criteria. J Clin Ethics.2003;14(1–2):26–36.
38.
ProttasJMBattenHL. Heath professionals and hospital administrators in organ procurement: Attitudes, reservations, and their resolutions. Am J Public Health.1988;78(6):642–645.
39.
WakefordREStepneyR. Obstacles to organ donation. Br J Surg.1989;76(5):435–439.
40.
NewBSolomonMDingwallRMcHaleJ. A Question of Give and Take: Improving the Supply of Organs for Transplantation.London, England: Kings Fund Institute; 1994. Research Report S.
41.
BarberKFalveySHamiltonCCollettDRudgeC. Potential for organ donation in the United Kingdom: Audit of intensive care records. BMJ.2006. http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/332/7550/1124. Accessed February 24, 2008.
42.
ReberAS. The Penguin Dictionary of Psychology.London, United Kingdom: Penguin Books; 1985.
43.
LongTSqueM. Conflict rationalization: How family members cope with a diagnosis of brain stem death. Soc Sci Med. In press.
44.
BellMDD. Emergency medicine, organ donation and the Human Tissue Act. J Emerg Med.2006;23:824–827.
45.
KootstraGDaemenHCOomenAP. Categories of non-heart-beating donors. Transplant Proc.1995;27(5):2893–2894.
46.
MatesanzR. Cadaveric organ donation: Comparison of legislation in various countries of Europe. Nephrol Dial Transplant.1998;13(7):1632–1635.
