An evidence-based selection process for organ transplantation may be a valuable approach to improve posttransplant outcomes. This paper reviews state-of-the-art psychosocial and behavioral selection criteria and assesses their validity in view of predicting outcomes after transplantation. Psychosocial factors addressed are psychiatric disorders, mental retardation, irreversible cognitive dysfunction, and lack of social support. Behavioral selection criteria discussed are alcoholism, smoking, drug abuse, and obesity. This review reveals that the evidence concerning these selection criteria is scarce. There is a definite need for more longitudinal research to strengthen the scientific basis of the psychosocial and behavioral dimension of transplantation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CostanzoMRAugustineSBourgeR. Selection and treatment of candidates for heart transplantation: A statement for health professionals from the Committee on Heart Failure and Cardiac Transplantation of the Council on Clinical Cardiology, American Heart Association. Circulation.1995;92:3593–3612.
2.
ImagawaDKStrangeSMShakedA. Liver transplantation at UCLA: Report of clinical activities. Clin Transpl.1991;5:127–134.
3.
RosenHRShackletonCRMartinP. Indications for and timing of liver transplantation. Med Clin North Am.1996; 80:1069–1102.
4.
BronstherOFungJJIzakisAVan ThielDStarzlTE. Priorization and organ distribution for liver transplantation. JAMA.1994;271:140–143.
5.
Torre-AmioneGKapadiaSShortD3rdYoungJB. Evolving concepts regarding selection of patients for cardiac transplantation: Assessing risks and benefits. Chest.1996;109:223–232.
6.
KaoWWinkelECostanzoMR. Candidate evaluation and selection for heart transplantation. Curr Opin Cardiol.1995;10:159–168.
7.
FrigerioMGrondaEGMangiavacchiM. Restrictive criteria for heart transplantation candidacy maximize survival of patients with advanced heart failure. J Heart Lung Transplant.1997;16:160–168.
8.
FrantzRPOlsonLJ. Recipient selection and management before cardiac transplantation. Am J Med Sci.1997;314:139–152.
9.
O'ConnellJBBourgeRCCostanzo-NordinMR. Cardiac transplantation: Recipient selection, donor procurement, and medical follow-up. A statement for health professionals from the Committee on Cardiac Transplantation of the Council on Clinical Cardiology, American Heart Association. Circulation.1992;86:1061–1079.
10.
MudgeGHGoldsteinSAddonizioLJ. 24th Bethesda conference: Cardiac transplantation. Task Force 3: Recipient guidelines/priorization. J Am Coll Cardiol.1993;22(1):21–31.
11.
BriggsJD. Patient selection for renal transplantation. Nephrol Dial Transplant.1995;10(suppl):10–13.
12.
FigueroaJE. Selection of patients for kidney transplantation. Med Clin North Am.1992;76:1188–1195.
13.
RamosELKasiskeBLAlexanderSR. The evaluation of candidates for renal transplantation: The current practice of U.S. transplant centers. Transplantation.1994;57:490–497.
14.
MillerLW. Candidate selection for heart transplantation. Cardiol Clin.1995;13:93–100.
15.
MillerLWKuboSHYoungJBStevensonLWLohECostanzoMR. Report of the consensus conference on candidate selection for Heart Transplantation-1993. J Heart Lung Transplant.1995;14:562–571.
16.
CostanzoMR. Selection and treatment of candidates for heart transplantation. Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg.1996;8:113–125.
17.
GradyKL. When to transplant: Recipient selection for heart transplantation. J Cardiovasc Nurs.1996;10(2):58–70.
18.
LuxonBA. Liver transplantation: Who should be referred and when?Postgrad Med.1997;102:103–113.
19.
LuceyMRBrownKAEversonGT. Minimal criteria for placement of adults on the liver transplant waiting list: A report of a national conference organized by the American Society of Transplant Physicians and the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases. Liver Transplant Surg.1997;3:628–637.
KasiskeBL. The evaluation of prospective renal transplant recipients and living donors. Surg Clin North Am.1998; 78(1):27–39.
22.
OlbrischMELevensonJL. Psychosocial evaluation of heart transplant candidates: An international survey of process, criteria, and outcomes. J Heart Lung Transplant.1991;10:948–955.
23.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.4th ed.Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association; 1994.
24.
ChackoRCHarperRGGottoJYoungJ. Psychiatric interview and psychometric predictors of cardiac transplant survival. Am J Psychiatry.1996;153:1607–1612.
25.
KuhnWFMyersBBrennanAF. Psychopathology in heart transplant candidates. J Heart Transplant.1988;7:223–226.
26.
FreemanAM3rdFolksDGSokolRSFahsJJ. Cardiac transplantation: Clinical correlates of psychiatric outcome. Psychosomatics.1988;29(1):47–54.
27.
JonesBMChangVPEsmoreD. Psychological adjustment after cardiac transplantation. Med J Aust.1988; 149:118–122.
28.
MaricleRAHosenpudJDNormanDJ. Depression in patients being evaluated for heart transplantation. Gen Hosp Psychiatry.1989;11:418–424.
29.
TrzepaczPTBrennerRPVan ThielDH. A psychiatric study of 247 liver transplantation candidates. Psychosomatics.1989;30:147–153.
30.
MaiFM. Psychiatric aspects of heart transplantation. Br J Psychiatry.1993;163:285–292.
31.
ParisWMuchmoreJPribilAZuhdiNCooperDK. Study of the relative incidences of psychosocial factors before and after heart transplantation and the influence of posttransplantation psychosocial factors on heart transplantation outcome. J Heart Lung Transplant.1994;13:424–432.
32.
DeshieldsTLMcDonoughEMMannenRKMillerLW. Psychological and cognitive status before and after heart transplantation. Gen Hosp Psychiatry.1996;18(suppl):62S–69S.
33.
EatonWW. Progress in the epidemiology of anxiety disorders. Epidemiol Rev.1995;17(1):32–38.
34.
KatzRStephenJShawBFMatthewANewmanFRosenbluthM. The East York Health Needs Study. I: Prevalence of DSM-III-R psychiatric disorder in a sample of Canadian women. Br J Psychiatry.1995;166:100–106.
BurvillPW. Recent progress in the epidemiology of major depression. Epidemiol Rev.1995;17(1):21–31.
37.
KesslerRCNelsonCBMcGonagleKALiuJSwartzMBlazerDG. Comorbidity of DSM-III-R major depressive disorder in the general population: Results from the US National Comorbidity Survey. Br J Psychiatry.1996;168(suppl):17–30.
38.
WeissmanMMBlandRCCaninoGJ. Cross-national epidemiology of major depression and bipolar disorder. JAMA.1996;276:293–299.
39.
ZhengDMaceraCACroftJBGilesWHDavisDScottWK. Major depression and all-cause mortality among white adults in the United States. Ann Epidemiol.1997;7:213–218.
40.
SilversteinB. Gender differences in the prevalence of clinical depression: The role played by depression associated with somatic symptoms. Am J Psychiatry.1999;156:480–482.
41.
ShapiroPAWilliamsDLForayATGelmanISWukichNSciaccaR. Psychosocial evaluation and prediction of compliance problems and morbidity after heart transplantation. Transplantation.1995;60:1462–1466.
42.
DewMASimmonsRGRothLH. Psychosocial predictors of vulnerability to distress in the year following heart transplantation. Psychol Med.1994;24:929–945.
43.
DewMARothLHThompsonMEKormosRLGriffithBP. Medical compliance and its predictors in the first year after heart transplantation. J Heart Lung Transplant.1996;15:631–645.
44.
BunzelBWollenekG. Heart transplantation: Are there psychosocial predictors for clinical success of surgery?Thorac Cardiovasc Surg.1994;42:103–107.
45.
SaloveyPBirnbaumD. Influence of mood on health relevant cognitions. J Pers Soc Psychol.1989;57:539–551.
46.
FranksPCampbellTLShieldsCG. Social relationships and health: The relative roles of family functioning and social support. Soc Sci Med.1992;34:779–788.
47.
RiceDP. The economic impact of schizophrenia. J Clin Psychiatry.1999;60(suppl):4–6.
48.
DiMartiniATwillmanR. Organ transplantation and paranoid schizophrenia. Psychosomatics.1994;35:159–161.
49.
MahadevaSLynchSDaviesMH. Liver transplantation in an undiagnosed schizophrenic. J Royal Soc Med.1997;90:563.
50.
WiebbeJSChristensenAJ. Health beliefs, personality and adherence in hemodialysis patients: An interactional perspective. Ann Behav Med.1997;19(1):30–35.
51.
RuscherSMde WitRMazmanianD. Psychiatric patients' attitudes about medication and factors affecting noncompliance. Psychiatr Serv.1997;48(1):82–85.
52.
YatesWRLaBrecqueDRPfabD. Personality disorder as a contraindication for liver transplantation in alcoholic cirrhosis. Psychosomatics.1998;39:501–511.
53.
BryantSBReamsC. How to assess a patient's support system and personal abilities prior to liver transplantation. Hepatogastroenterology.1998;45:1395–1397.
54.
LenzenwegerMFLorangerAWKorfineLNeffC. Detecting personality disorders in a nonclinical population: Application of a 2-stage procedure for case identification. Arch Gen Psychiatry.1997;54:345–351.
55.
BodlundOGrannMOttosonHSvanborgC. Validation of the self-report questionnaire DIP-Q in diagnosing DSM-IV personality disorders: A comparison of three psychiatric samples. Acta Psychiatr Scand.1998;97:433–439.
56.
FriersonRLLippmannSB. Heart transplant candidates rejected on psychiatric indications. Psychosomatics.1987; 28:347–355.
57.
DidlakeRHDreyfusKKermanRHVan BurenCTKahanBD. Patient non-compliance: A major cause of late graft failure in cyclosporine-treated renal transplants. Transplant Proc.1988;10(suppl):63–69.
58.
DunnJGoldenDVan BurenCTLewisRMLawenJKahanBD. Causes of graft loss beyond two years in the cyclosporin era. Transplantation.1990;49:349–353.
59.
De GeestSBorgermansLGemoetsH. Incidence, determinants and consequences of subclinical noncompliance with immunosuppressive therapy in renal transplant recipients. Transplantation.1995;59:340–347.
60.
De GeestSAbrahamIMoonsP. Late acute rejections and subclinical non-compliance with cyclosporine-therapy in heart transplant patients. J Heart Lung Transplant.1998;17:854–863.
61.
BenedettiEAsolatiMDunnT. Kidney transplantation in recipients with mental retardation: Clinical results in a single-center experience. Am J Kidney Dis.1998;31:509–512.
62.
SurmanOS. Psychiatric aspects of organ transplantation. Am J Psychiatry.1989;146:972–982.
63.
TrzepaczPTLevensonJLTringaliRA. Psychopharmacology and neuropsychiatric syndromes in organ transplantation. Gen Hosp Psychiatry.1991;13:233–245.
64.
SurmanOSDienstagJLCosimiABChaunceySRussellPS. Psychosomatic aspects of liver transplantation. Psychother Psychosom.1987;48(1–4):26–31.
65.
TrzepaczPTMaueFRCoffmanGVan ThielDH. Neuropsychiatric assessment of liver transplantation candidates: Delirium and other psychiatric disorders. Int J Psychiatry Med.1986–87;16(2):101–111.
66.
TrzepaczPTBrennerRPCoffmanGVan ThielDH. Delirium in liver transplantation candidates: Discriminant analysis of multiple test variables. Biol Psychiatry.1988;24(1):3–14.
67.
TrzepaczPTDiMartiniA. Survival of 247 liver transplant candidates: Relationship to pretransplant psychiatric variables and presence of delirium. Gen Hosp Psychiatry.1992;14:380–386.
68.
WeddingtonWW. The mortality of delirium: An underappreciated problem?Psychosomatics.1982;23:1232–1235.
69.
InouyeSKRushingJTForemanMDPalmerRMPompeiP. Does delirium contribute to poor hospital outcomes: A three-site epidemiologic study. J Gen Intern Med.1998;13:234–242.
70.
BlancoRDe GirolamiVJenkinsRLKhettryU. Neuropathology of liver transplantation. Clin Neuropathol.1995;14:109–117.
71.
ButtAKKhanAAAlamAShahSWShafqatFNaqviAB. Predicting hospital mortality in cirrhotic patients: Comparison of Child-Pugh and Acute Physiology, Age and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE III) scoring systems. Am J Gastroenterol.1998;93:2469–2475.
72.
EckhoffDEPirschJDD'AlessandroAM. Pretransplant status and patient survival following liver transplantation. Transplantation.1995;60:920–925.
73.
DonovanJPShaferDFShawBWJrSorrellMF. Cerebral oedema and increased intracranial pressure in chronic liver disease. Lancet.1998;351:719–721.
74.
NaidooDPBramdevACooperK. Autopsy prevalence of Wernicke's encephalopathy in alcohol-related disease. S Afr Med J.1996;86:1110–1112.
75.
BurnDJBatesD. Neurology and the kidney. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry.1998;65:810–821.
76.
LevyEMViscoliCMHorowitzRI. The effect of acute renal failure on mortality: A cohort analysis. JAMA.1996; 275:1489–1494.
77.
RietherAMSmithSLLewisonBJCotsonisGAEpsteinCM. Quality-of-life changes and psychiatric and neurocognitive outcome after heart and liver transplantation. Transplantation.1992;54:444–450.
78.
SarasonBRSarasonIGPierceGR. Differentiating the cognitive and behavioral aspects of social support. In: SarasonBR, ed. Social Support: An Interactional View.New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons Inc; 1990:267–296.
79.
LazaroLMarcosTValdesM. Affective disorders, social support, and health status in geriatric patients in a general hospital. Gen Hosp Psychiatry.1995;17:299–304.
80.
GrassiLMalacarnePMaestriARamelliE. Depression, psychosocial variables and occurrence of life events among patients with cancer. J Affect Disord.1997;44(1):21–30.
81.
AaronsonLS. Perceived and received support: Effects on health behavior during pregnancy. Nurs Res.1989;38(1):4–9.
82.
LevyRL. Social support and compliance: Update. J Hypertens Suppl.1985;3(1):45–49.
83.
FrazierPADavis-AliSHDahlKE. Correlates of noncompliance among renal transplant recipients. Clin Transplant.1994;8:550–557.
84.
BeresfordTP. Predictive factors for alcoholic relapse in the selection of alcohol-dependent persons for hepatic transplant. Liver Transplant Surg.1997;3:280–291.
85.
KeeffeEB. Assessment of the alcoholic patient for liver transplantation: Comorbidity, outcome, and recidivism. Liver Transplant Surg.1996;2(suppl):12–20.
86.
YatesWRMartinMLaBrecqueDHillebrandDVoigtMPfabD. A model to examine the validity of the 6-month abstinence criterion for liver transplantation. Alcohol Clin Exp Res.1998;22:513–517.
87.
ScharschmidtBF. Human liver transplantation: Analysis of data on 540 patients from four centers. Hepatology.1984;4(suppl):95S–101S.
88.
KumarSStauberREGavalerJS. Orthotopic liver transplantation for alcoholic liver disease. Hepatology.1990;11:159–164.
89.
BirdGLO'GradyJGHarveyFACalneRYWilliamsR. Liver transplantation in patients with alcoholic cirrhosis: Selection criteria and rates of survival and relapse. BMJ.1990;301(6742):15–17.
90.
LuceyMRMerionRMHenleyKS. Selection for and outcome of liver transplantation in alcoholic liver disease. Gastroenterology.1992;102:1736–1741.
91.
GishRGLeeAHKeeffeEBRomeHConcepcionWEsquivelCO. Liver transplantation for patients with alcoholism and end-stage liver disease. Am J Gastroenterol.1993;88:1337–1342.
92.
StefaniniGFBiselliMGraziGL. Orthotopic liver transplantation for alcoholic liver disease: Rates of survival, complications and relapse. Hepatogastroenterology.1997; 44:1356–1359.
93.
FosterPFFabregaFKarademirSSankaryHNMitalDWilliamsJW. Prediction of abstinence from ethanol in alcoholic recipients following liver transplantation. Hepatology.1997;25:1469–1477.
94.
De MariaNColantoniAVan ThielDH. Liver transplantation for alcoholic liver disease. Hepatogastroenterology.1998;45:1364–1368.
YatesWRLaBrecqueDRPfabD. The reliability of alcoholism history in patients with alcohol-related cirrhosis. Alcohol Alcohol.1998;33:488–494.
97.
StarzlTEVan ThielDTzakisAG. Orthotopic liver transplantation for alcoholic cirrhosis. JAMA.1988;260: 2542–2544.
98.
WiesnerRHLombarderoMLakeJREverhartJDetreKM. Liver transplantation for end-stage alcoholic liver disease: An assessment of outcomes. Liver Transplant Surg.1997;3:231–239.
99.
Van ThielDHBonetHGavalerJWrightHI. Effect of alcohol use on allograft rejection rates after liver transplantation for alcoholic liver disease. Alcohol Clin Exp Res.1995;19:1151–1155.
100.
Lucey. Liver transplantation in the alcoholic patient. In: MaddreyWCSorrellMF, eds. Transplantation of the Liver.2nd ed.Norwalk, Conn: Appleton & Lange; 1995:461–475.
101.
MerikangasKRGelernterCS. Comorbidity for alcoholism and depression. Psychiatr Clin North Am.1990;13:613–632.
102.
RegierDAFarmerMERaeDS. Comorbidity of mental disorders with alcohol and other drug abuse: Results from the Epidemiologic Catchment Area (ECA) study. JAMA.1990;264:2511–2518.
103.
GrantBFHarfordTC. Comorbidity between DSM-IV alcohol use disorders and major depression: Results of a national survey. Drug Alcohol Depend.1995;39:197–206.
104.
SchuckitMATippJESmithTL. An evaluation of type A and B alcoholics. Addiction.1995;90:1189–1203.
105.
CharnessME. Brain lesions in alcoholics. Alcohol Clin Exp Res.1993;17(1):2–11.
106.
NägeleHKalmarPRödigerWStubbeHM. Smoking after heart transplantation: An underestimated hazard?Eur J Cardiothorac Surg.1997;12(1):70–74.
107.
CurtilARobinJTroncFNinetJBoissonnatPChampsaurG. Malignant neoplasms following cardiac transplantation. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg.1997;12(1):101–106.
108.
GoldsteinDJAustinJHMZuechN. Carcinoma of the lung after heart transplantation. Transplantation.1996; 62:772–775.
109.
KasiskeBLGuijarroCMassyZAWiederkehrMRMaJZ. Cardiovascular disease after renal transplantation. J Am Soc Nephrol.1996;7:158–165.
110.
HojoMMorimotoTMaluccioM. Cyclosporine induces cancer progression by a cell-autonomous mechanism. Nature.1999;397:530–534.
111.
CosioFGAlamirAYimS. Patient survival after renal transplantation: I. The impact of dialysis pre-transplant. Kidney Int.1998;53:767–772.
112.
StevensJCallenderCOSimonJDillardPYeagerCL. Renal transplantation in heroin addicts. Surg Gynecol Obstet.1983;156:651–655.
113.
RossGJrWeinsteinSDuttonSWhittierFC. Renal transplantation in the end stage renal disease of drug abuse. J Urol.1983;129(1):14–15.
114.
BrayGA. Complications of obesity. Ann Intern Med.1985;103(6pt2):1052–1062.
115.
KeeffeEBGettysCEsquivelCO. Liver transplantation in patients with severe obesity. Transplantation.1994;57:309–311.
116.
ModlinCSFlechnerSMGoormasticM. Should obese patients lose weight before receiving a kidney transplant?Transplantation.1997;64:599–604.
117.
GradyKLCostanzoMRFisherSKochD. Preoperative obesity is associated with decreased survival after heart transplantation. J Heart Lung Transplant.1996;15:863–871.
118.
HalmeLEklundBKyllönenLSalmelaK. Is obesity still a risk factor in renal transplantation?Transplant Int.1997;10:284–288.
119.
SmalleyKJKnerrANKendrickZVColliverJAOwenOE. Reassessment of body mass indices. Am J Clin Nutr.1990;52:405–408.
120.
ColliverJAFrankSFrankA. Similarity of obesity indices in clinical studies of obese adults: A factor analytic study. Am J Clin Nutr.1983;38:640–647.
