Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Background:

In China, workplace violence (WPV) toward health-care professionals has been a major concern, but no meta-analysis on this topic has been published. This study is a meta-analysis of the pooled prevalence of WPV against health-care professionals in China and its associated risk factors.

Method:

English- (PubMed, PsycINFO, and Embase) and Chinese-language (Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure, WanFang, and SinoMed) databases were systematically searched. Data on the prevalence of WPV and the subtypes of violence experienced by health-care professionals in China were extracted and pooled using random-effects models.

Findings:

A total of 47 studies covering 81,771 health-care professionals were included in the analyses. The overall prevalence of WPV from 44 studies with available data was 62.4% (95% confidence interval [CI] = [59.4%, 65.5%]). The estimated prevalence of physical violence, psychological violence, verbal abuse, threats, and sexual harassment were 13.7% (95% CI [12.2%, 15.1%]), 50.8% (95% CI [46.2%, 55.5%]), 61.2% (95% CI [55.1%, 67.4%]), 39.4% (95% CI [33.4%, 45.4%]), and 6.3% (95% CI [5.3%, 7.4%]), respectively. Males were more likely to experience WPV than females.

Interpretation:

WPV against health-care professionals appears to be a significant issue in China. Relevant policies and procedures related to WPV should be developed. Staff should be provided with adequate training, education, and support to implement violence management policies to ensure safety at the workplace.

Keywords

workplace violence health-care professionals meta-analysis China

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abed

Morris

Sobers-Grannum

(2016). Workplace violence against medical staff in healthcare facilities in Barbados. Occupational Medicine, 66, 580–583.

Abou-ElWafa

H. S.

El-Gilany

A. H.

Abd-El-Raouf

S. E.

Abd-Elmouty

S. M.

El-Sayed Rel

(2015). Workplace violence against emergency versus non-emergency nurses in Mansoura university hospitals, Egypt. Journal Interpersonal Violence, 30, 857–872.

ALBashtawy

(2013). Workplace violence against nurses in emergency departments in Jordan. International Nursing Review, 60, 550–555.

C. X.

(2006, 2 20). The survey on the medical dispute in Shijiazhuang: Have “angels in white” become “wolfs in white”? [in Chinese]. China Economic Weekly. Retrieved from http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2006-2002/2020/content_4203595.htm

Barling

Dupré

K. E.

Kelloway

E. K.

(2009). Predicting workplace aggression and violence. Annual Review of Psychology, 60, 671–692.

Barling

Kelloway

E. K.

Iverson

R. D.

(2003). Accidental outcomes: Attitudinal consequences of workplace injuries. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 8, 74–85.

Beech

Leather

(2006). Workplace violence in the health care sector: A review of staff training and integration of training evaluation models. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 11, 27–43.

Begg

C. B.

Mazumdar

(1994). Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Biometrics, 50, 1088–1101.

Blumenthal

Hsiao

(2005). Privatization and its discontents—The evolving Chinese health care system. New England Journal of Medicine, 353, 1165–1170.

10.

Butcher

(2001). Are paediatricians at risk of violence in the workplace? Lancet, 357, 285.

11.

Cao

X. L.

Zhong

B. L.

Xiang

Y. T.

Ungvari

G. S.

Lai

K. Y.

Chiu

H. F.

Caine

E. D.

(2015). Prevalence of suicidal ideation and suicide attempts in the general population of China: A meta-analysis. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 49, 296–308.

12.

Chappell

Di Martino

(2006). Violence at work (3rd ed.). Geneva, Switzerland: International Labour Organization.

13.

Chen

C. X.

(2014). The descriptive study of violence against nurses in joint-stock hospitals [in Chinese]. Chinese Medical Innovation, 11, 79–82.

14.

Chen

Q. C.

C. L.

L. C.

(2012). Investigation on workplace violence in two general hospitals in Wenzhou city [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Disease Control, 16, 945–947.

15.

Chen

Lin

Ruan

(2016). Workplace violence and its effect on burnout and turnover attempt among Chinese medical staff [in Chinese]. Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health, 71, 330–337.

16.

Chen

(2009). Launch of the health-care reform plan in China. Lancet, 373, 1322–1324.

17.

Chen

Z. H.

(2011). An epidemiological study of hospital workplace violence in Guangzhou city [in Chinese] (PhD thesis). Southern Medical University, Guangzhou, China.

18.

Chen

Z. H.

Wang

S. Y.

Y. C.

Jin

C. X.

(2004). Analysis on the epidemiological features and risk factors of hospital workplace violence in Guangzhou [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Epidemiology, 25, 3–5.

19.

Di Martino

(2002). Workplace violence in the health sector. Country case studies Brazil, Bulgaria, Lebanon, Portugal, South Africa, Thailand and an additional Australian study. Ginebra, Switzerland: Organización Internacional del Trabajo.

20.

Egger

Davey Smith

Schneider

Minder

(1997). Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. British Medical Journal, 315, 629–634.

21.

Fallahi-Khoshknab

Oskouie

Najafi

Ghazanfari

Tamizi

Afshani

(2016). Physical violence against health care workers: A nationwide study from Iran. Iranian Journal of Nursing and Midwifery Research, 21, 232–238.

22.

Fasanya

B. K.

Dada

E. A.

(2016). Workplace violence and safety issues in long-term medical care facilities: Nurses’ perspectives. Safety Health Work, 7, 97–101.

23.

Ferri

Silvestri

Artoni

Di Lorenzo

(2016). Workplace violence in different settings and among various health professionals in an Italian general hospital: A cross-sectional study. Psychology Research and Behavior Management, 9, 263–275.

24.

Fisekovic

M. B.

Trajkovic

G. Z.

Bjegovic-Mikanovic

V. M.

Terzic-Supic

Z. J.

(2015). Does workplace violence exist in primary health care? Evidence from Serbia. European Journal of Public Health, 25, 693–698.

25.

Gao

(2008). A study of the current status and correlative factors on the nurses [in Chinese] (Master thesis). Fuzhou: Fujian Medical University.

26.

Gillespie

G. L.

Fisher

B. S.

Gates

D. M.

(2015). Workplace violence in healthcare settings. Work, 51, 3–4.

27.

Gong

Han

Chen

Dib

H. H.

Yang

Zhuang

… Lu

(2014). Prevalence of anxiety and depressive symptoms and related risk factors among physicians in China: A cross-sectional study. PLoS One, 9, e103242.

28.

Guo

Huang

Zhou

X. L.

J. Y.

(2015). The investigation on coping capacity of nursing staff to medical workplace violence [in Chinese]. Chinese Nursing Management, 15, 688–691.

29.

Hershcovis

M. S.

Turner

Barling

Arnold

K. A.

Dupre

K. E.

Inness

… Sivanathan

(2007). Predicting workplace aggression: A meta-analysis. The Journal of Applied Psychology, 92, 228–238.

30.

Hesketh

Wei

X. Z.

(1997). Health in China. From Mao to market reform. British Medical Journal, 314, 1543–1545.

31.

Higgins

J. P.

Green

(2011). Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions (Vol. 4). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

32.

Higgins

J. P.

Thompson

S. G.

Deeks

J. J.

Altman

D. G.

(2003). Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. British Medical Journal, 327, 557–560.

33.

Jackson

Ashley

(2005). Physical and psychological violence in Jamaica’s health sector. Pan American Journal of Public Health, 18, 114–121.

34.

Jafree

S. R.

(2017). Workplace violence against women nurses working in two public sector hospitals of Lahore, Pakistan. Nursing Outlook, 65, 420–427. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.outlook.2017.01.008

35.

Jiang

(2011, 10 11). In some Chinese hospitals, violence is out of control and it’s doctors who are at risk. Time. Retrieved from http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2096630,2096600.html

36.

Jiang

S. S.

Jiang

Z. H.

(2015). Influence of workplace violence on ethical decision-making of nurses [in Chinese]. Journal of Nursing Administration, 15, 132–134.

37.

Jiao

Ning

Gao

Cui

Sun

… Hao

(2015). Workplace violence against nurses in Chinese hospitals: A cross-sectional survey. British Medical Journal Open, 5, e006719.

38.

Jie

(2012). New generations of Chinese doctors face crisis. Lancet, 379, 1878.

39.

Jing

Otten

Sullivan

Lovell-Simons

Granek-Catarivas

Fritzsche

(2013). Improving the doctor-patient relationship in China: The role of Balint groups. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 46, 417–427.

40.

Kar

S. P.

(2017). Addressing underlying causes of violence against doctors in India. Lancet, 389, 1979–1980.

41.

Kou

C. G.

Ning

Wang

Jing

Y. Y.

,& Zhang

F. L.

(2006). Epidemiological analysis of workplace violence in hospital [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Public Health, 22, 964–965.

42.

Kowalenko

Walters

B. L.

Khare

R. K.

Compton

(2005). Workplace violence: A survey of emergency physicians in the state of Michigan. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 46, 142–147.

43.

Krug

E. G.

Dahlberg

L. L.

Mercy

J. A.

Zwi

A. B.

Lozano

(2002). The world report on violence and health. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization.

44.

Lancet . (2010). Chinese doctors are under threat. Lancet, 376, 657.

45.

Lancet . (2012). Ending violence against doctors in China. Lancet, 379, 1764.

46.

Lancet . (2014). Violence against doctors: Why China? Why now? What next? Lancet Infectious Diseases, 383, 1013.

47.

LeBlanc

M. M.

Kelloway

E. K.

(2002). Predictors and outcomes of workplace violence and aggression. The Journal of Applied Psychology, 87, 444–453.

48.

Cao

X. L.

Zhong

B. L.

Ungvari

G. S.

Chiu

H. F.

Lai

K. Y.

… Xiang

Y. T.

(2016). Smoking in male patients with schizophrenia in China: A meta-analysis. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 162, 146–153.

49.

Lian

J. J.

(2014). Investigation and analysis on the current situation of workplace violence against nurses in General Hospital of Fuzhou [in Chinese]. Fujian Medical Journal, 36, 132–134.

50.

Liao

Y. L.

Gao

Wan

G. L.

Liu

T. Y.

Tang

H. Q.

(2010). A survey and analysis of the status of nursing violence in different medical areas in Gubei region Guangxi [in Chinese]. Chinese Nursing Research, 24, 1997–1999.

51.

Lin

W. Q.

Yuan

L. X.

Zhang

S. C.

Jing

M. J.

Zhang

H. S.

… Wang

P. X.

(2015). Workplace violence and job performance among community healthcare workers in China: The mediator role of quality of life. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 12, 14872–14886.

52.

Liu

Zhao

Jiao

Wang

Peters

D. H.

Qiao

… Wu

(2015). Extent, nature, and risk factors of workplace violence in public tertiary hospitals in China: A cross-sectional survey. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 12, 6801–6817.

53.

Liu

Wang

Kong

Cheng

K. K.

(2011). China’s primary health-care reform. Lancet, 377, 2064–2066.

54.

Long

Huang

Liang

Chen

Xie

… Su

(2014). The prevalence of schizophrenia in mainland China: Evidence from epidemiological surveys. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 130, 244–256.

55.

Luo

(2010). Study on sub-health condition and its influencing factors among nurses of the class III hospital in Xinjiang Urumqi city [in Chinese] (Master thesis). Urumchi: Xinjiang Medical University.

56.

X. C

. (2007). Investigation and analysis of hospital violence among five Grade A hospitals of Changchun (Master thesis). Changchun: Jilin University.

57.

Magin

Adams

Ireland

Joy

Heaney

Darab

(2006). The response of general practitioners to the threat of violence in their practices: Results from a qualitative study. Family Practice, 23, 273–278.

58.

Mantzouranis

Fafliora

Bampalis

V. G.

Christopoulou

(2015). Assessment and analysis of workplace violence in a Greek Tertiary Hospital. Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health, 70, 256–264.

59.

Meng

H. Y.

Wang

H. F.

Lin

Zhao

X. P.

Zhao

(2013). Survey of workplace violence among nurses in general hospitals of Suzhou city [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Modern Nursing, 19, 254–258.

60.

Minter

(2012, 3 29). Violent crimes in China’s hospitals spread happiness. Bloomberg. Retrieved from http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-2003-2029/violent-crimes-in-china-s-hospitals-spread-happiness.html

61.

National Bureau of Statistics of China. (2017). China statistical yearbook. Retrieved from http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/ndsj/2017/indexch.htm

62.

(2012, 5 7). Hospital violence sign of doctor-patient strife. Shanghai Daily. Retrieved from http://www.china.org.cn/opinion/2012-2005/2007/content_25321732.htm

63.

Nowrouzi-Kia

. (2017). The impact of workplace violence on health care workers’ quality of life. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, 59, 675. Jones and Bartlett Learning.

64.

Qin

F. Q.

Wei

Luo

W. J.

(2016). Ability to cope with occupational violence of medical staff in public mental hospitals in Guangxi [in Chinese]. Journal of Nursing, 32, 43–46.

65.

Qin

Wang

S. Y

. (2005). An epidemiological survey on hospital workplace violence in Enshi Tujia and Miao Autonomous Prefecture [in Chinese]. Chinese Hospital Management, 25, 58–59.

66.

Schat

A. C.

Kelloway

E. K.

(2003). Reducing the adverse consequences of workplace aggression and violence: The buffering effects of organizational support. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 8, 110–122.

67.

Schat

A. C.

Kelloway

E. K

. (2005). Workplace aggression. In Baring

Kelloway

E. K.

Frone

(Eds.), Handbook of work stress (pp. 189–218). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

68.

Shi

Sun

Gao

Liu

W. H.

… Fan

L. H.

(2017). Analysis of status and risk factors of workplace violence among nurses in country hospitals [in Chinese]. Journal of Nursing Research, 31, 592–594.

69.

Sibbald

(2017). Workplace violence is not part of a doctor’s job. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 189, E184.

70.

T. Z.

Ding

M. C

. (2015). The current situation and prevention strategies of Taiyuan general hospitals’ nurses suffer from “the medical violence” [in Chinese]. Chinese Health Law, 23, 89–94.

71.

Sun

Zhang

Sun

Jiao

Xing

… Yin

(2017). Workplace violence against health care workers in North Chinese Hospitals: A cross-sectional survey. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 14, 1–10.

72.

Sun

Wang

Fan

L. H.

Cao

D. P

. (2014). Epidemiological characteristics and variance analysis of workplace violence in public hospitals [in Chinese]. Practical Preventive Medicine, 21, 478–480.

73.

Tian

G. Y.

Zhu

R. Y.

Q. Y

. (2013). Discussion on the related factors and countermeasures of violence suffered by medical personnel [in Chinese]. Chinese Medicine Economics, 114–116.

74.

von Elm

Altman

D. G.

Egger

Pocock

S. J.

Gotzsche

P. C.

Vandenbroucke

J. P.

(2007). The Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement: Guidelines for reporting observational studies. PLoS Medicine, 4, e296.

75.

Wang

P. X.

Wang

M. Z.

G. X.

Wang

Z. M.

Lan

Y. J.

Jiang

J. D.

… Liu

S. M.

(2006). Study on the relationship between workplace violence and work ability among health care professionals in Shangqiu City [in Chinese]. Journal of Hygiene Research, 35, 472–475.

76.

Wang

W. Q.

Xie

Cheng

S. Z.

Zhang

M. X.

L. J.

… Yu

(2011). Investigation and analysis of workplace violence against for nurse [in Chinese]. Nursing Practice and Research, 8, 104–107.

77.

Wang

Jin

Z. R.

Zhao

B. L.

Shi

Y. B.

C. X.

Liu

(2015). Survey on workplace violence and job burnout among nurses [in Chinese]. Journal of Nursing Science, 30, 15–17.

78.

Wang

X. F.

Zhu

C. X.

Pan

H. Y.

Zhu

X. Y.

Y. M.

Chen

W. J.

(2016). Survey and analysis on present situation and coping style of nurses suffering from workplace violence in primary hospitals [in Chinese]. Nursing and Rehabilitation, 15, 320–324.

79.

World Health Organization. (2002). Joint programme on workplace violence in the health sector. Framework guidelines addressing workplace violence in the health sector. Geneva, Switzerland: International Labour Office.

80.

World Health Organization. (2003). Joint programme on workplace violence in the health sector. Workplace violence in the health sector country case studies research instruments—Survey Questionnaire. Geneva, Switzerland: International Labour Office.

81.

Winsper

Ganapathy

Marwaha

Large

Birchwood

Singh

S. P.

(2013). A systematic review and meta-regression analysis of aggression during the first episode of psychosis. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 128, 413–421.

82.

Q. Q.

(2016). Analysis of influencing factors and status on workplace violence of Nurses working in general hospitals of Pingyang County [in Chinese]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine Management, 24, 18–20.

83.

Lin

Chai

Zhang

Zhu

(2014). A study on workplace violence and its effect on quality of life among medical professionals in China. Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health, 69, 81–88.

84.

Zhu

Lin

Chai

Wang

(2012). Workplace violence and influencing factors among medical professionals in China. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 55, 1000–1008.

85.

Xiao

Xiong

Sha

D. R.

Qiu

X. R.

(2015). Investigation on the current situation of workplace among nurses in Changsha city [in Chinese]. Medical Information, 28, 111–111.

86.

Xing

Jiao

Qiao

Hao

… Wu

(2015). Physical violence against general practitioners and nurses in Chinese township hospitals: A cross-sectional survey. PLoS One, 10, e0142954.

87.

Z. Q.

(2009). The impact of workplace violence on the student nurse [in Chinese]. China Medical Herald, 6, 116–118.

88.

Yan

J. H.

Lin

H. Q.

Wang

Liu

X. M.

Han

X. F.

Wang

X. C

. (2012). A survey on coping style in nursing staff suffering from workplace violence in hospital settings [in Chinese]. Chinese PLA Journal of Nursing, 29, 16–19.

89.

Yan

J. H.

Zhang

M. F.

Song

Y. L.

Yang

G. Q.

Chen

Z. J.

Zhang

X. Y.

(2009). Study on the correlation between workplace violence in hospital settings and work-related stress of nursing staff [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Modern Nursing, 15, 420–422.

90.

Yang

X. D.

Jiang

Y. F.

Huang

L. S.

Wang

X. B.

Zhao

. (2009). The prevalence and influential factors of workplace violence against nurses in general hospitals [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Nursing, 44, 877–881.

91.

Yang

X. D.

Zhu

Wang

L. M.

Shen

F. H

. (2016). Analysis of violent events in two hospitals in a city of Hebei province [in Chinese]. World’s Medical Information Digest, 203–219.

92.

Yang

Liu

Y. H.

Zhang

H. F.

Liu

J. Y.

Liu

H. N.

Liu

H. W.

(2015). Prevalence and influence factors of workplace violence among nurses in 3A grade hospitals [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Public Health, 31, 1155–1159.

93.

Yao

Wang

Yao

. (2014). General self-efficacy and the effect of hospital workplace violence on doctors’ stress and job satisfaction in China. International Journal of Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health, 27, 389–399.

94.

Yip

W. C.

Hsiao

Meng

Chen

Sun

(2010). Realignment of incentives for health-care providers in China. Lancet, 375, 1120–1130.

95.

L. Q.

Jiang

S. F.

Tang

X. X.

Zhang

Dong

X. F.

(2006). Analysis of prevalence of workplace violence among staff in two hospitals of Tangshan city [in Chinese]. Modern Preventive Medicine, 33, 147–148, 152.

96.

L. Q.

Tang

X. X.

Jiang

S. F.

(2007). Investigation on the causes of workplace violence in Tangshan city [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Hospital Administration, 23, 787–790.

97.

L. Q.

Tang

X. X.

J. H.

Wang

S. Y.

M. Y

. (2013). The study of workplace violence in hospitals of different levels in Tangshan city [in Chinese]. Modern Preventive Medicine, 40, 1670–1673, 1677.

98.

L. Q.

Zhang

T. Z.

Tang

X. X.

J. H.

Chen

Shi

(2010). Comparison of workplace violence between Stata-owned and private hospitals [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Public Health, 26, 1510–1511.

99.

Sui

S. J.

(2015). The prevalence and predictors of workplace violence against nurses in Harbin [in Chinese]. Journal of Nursing Science, 30, 1–5.

100.

Zhang

Wang

Xie

Zhou

Yang

Zhang

(2017). Workplace violence against nurses: A cross-sectional study. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 72, 8–14.

101.

Zhao

Liu

Jiao

Hao

… Qiao

(2015). Coping with workplace violence in healthcare settings: Social support and strategies. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 12, 14429–14444.

102.

Zhao

Wang

F. M.

Zhou

C. Y.

Peng

B. S.

,… Fan

L. H.

(2016). Investigation and analysis of present situation of workplace violence at tertiary hospitals and county hospitals in Heilongjiang province [in Chinese]. Medicine and Society, 29, 35–37.

103.

Zhu

Yang

L. F.

Lou

X. P.

Zhao

X. Y.

Wang

. (2011). Survey on the status of workplace violence in general hospitals in Zhengzhou [in Chinese]. Chinese Health Service Management, 334–336.

104.

Zou

X. J.

Zheng

Zhu

J. F

. (2016). A survey of workplace violence in general hospitals of Xi’an city [in Chinese]. Chinese Nursing Research, 30, 3300–3302.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.06 MB

Prevalence of Workplace Violence Against Health-Care Professionals in China: A Comprehensive Meta-Analysis of Observational Surveys

Abstract

Background:

Method:

Findings:

Interpretation:

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References

Supplementary Material