Pattern of Physical Injury Associated with Intimate Partner Violence in Women Presenting to the Emergency Department: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Restricted accessReview articleFirst published online April, 2010
Pattern of Physical Injury Associated with Intimate Partner Violence in Women Presenting to the Emergency Department: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Objective: To examine patterns of physical injury associated with intimate partner violence (IPV) among women presenting to emergency room departments. Data sources: Systematic searches of Medline, EMBASE, and CINAHL electronic databases from their earliest entries up to February, 2008. Reference lists from the studies included from the electronic database search were reviewed for published and unpublished studies. The authors contacted study authors regarding published and unpublished information. Review methods: After titles and abstracts were initially screened by a single reviewer, two reviewers screened the remaining full-text articles for inclusion into the review. Studies were included if they pertained in whole or in part to women who presented to an emergency department because of IPV and reported the location or type of injuries. Studies without comparison groups of non-IPV women and case series/case reports were excluded. The authors performed a meta-analysis of the available data using the random effects model. Results: The authors identified 262 potentially relevant titles and abstracts, of which 7 articles were included in the review. The association between head, neck, or facial injuries and IPV was higher among studies that excluded women with verifiable injuries such as witnessed falls or motor vehicle collisions (pooled odds ratio (OR) 24 (95% CI [15, 38]). Thoracic, abdominal, or pelvic injuries were nonspecific for IPV (pooled OR 1.07 (95% CI [0.89, 1.29]). Injuries in the upper extremities were suggestive of non-IPV etiology (pooled OR 0.51 (95% CI [0.41, 0.54]), as were lower extremity injuries (pooled OR 0.15 (95% CI [0.04, 0.56]). Conclusions: Among women presenting to emergency room departments, unwitnessed head, neck, or facial injuries are significant markers for IPV. Conversely, extremity injuries are less likely to have been the consequence of IPV.
American Medical Association. (2000). Opinion 2.02: Abuse of spouses, children, elderly persons, and others at risk . Retrieved February20, 2010, http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/physician-resources/medical-ethics/code-medical-ethics/opinion202.shtml
2.
Astbury, J., Atkinson, J., Duke, J., Easteal, P., Kurrie, S.W., Tait, P., & Turner, J. ( 2000). The impact of domestic violence on individuals. The Medical Journal of Australia, 173, 427-431.
3.
AuCoin, K. ( 2005). Family violence in Canada: A statistical profile. Statistics Canada, 89.
4.
Bhandari, M., Dosanjh, S., Tornetta, P., & Matthews, D., on behalf of the Violence Against Women Health Research Collaborative. (2006). Musculoskeletal manifestations of physical abuse after intimate partner violence. Journal of Trauma, 61, 1473-1479.
5.
Bhandari, M., Sprague, S., Tornetta, P., 3rd., D’Aurora, V., Schemitsch, E., Shearer, H., & ... Dosanjh , S. (2008). (Mis)perceptions about intimate partner violence in women apresenting for orthopaedic care: A survey of Canadian orthopedic surgeons. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 90, 1590-1597.
6.
Campbell, J., Jones, A.S., Dienemann, J., Kub, J., Schollenberger, J., O’Campo, P., & Wynne, C. ( 2002). Intimate partner violence and physical health consequences . Archives of Internal Medicine, 162, 1157-1163.
7.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. ( 2008). Adverse health conditions and health risk behaviors associated with intimate partner violence-United States, 2005. MMWR Morbidity Mortal Weekly Report, 57, 113-117.
8.
Coker, A.L., Davis, K.E., Arias, I., Desai, S., Sanderson, M., Brandt, H.M., & Smith, P.H. ( 2002). Physical and mental effects of intimate partner violence for men and women. American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 23, 260-268.
9.
Davis, J.W., Kaups, K.L., Campbell, S.D., & Parks, S.N. ( 2000). Domestic violence and the trauma surgeon: Results of a study on knowledge and education. Journal of American College of Surgeons, 191, 347-353.
10.
Davis, J.W., Parks, S.N., Kaups, K.L., Bennink, L.D., & Bilello, J.F. ( 2003). Victims of domestic violence on the trauma service: Unrecognized and underreported. Journal of Trauma, 54, 352-355.
11.
Downs, S.H., & Black, N. ( 1998). The feasibility of creating a check-list for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 52, 377-384.
12.
Guth, A.A., & Pachter, L. ( 2000). Domestic violence and the trauma surgeon. American Journal of Surgery, 179, 134-140.
13.
Halpern, L., Perciaccante, V., Hayes, C., Susarla, S., & Dodson, T. ( 2006). A protocol to diagnose intimate partner violence in the emergency department. Journal of Trauma, 60, 1101-1105.
14.
Halpern, L.R., Susarla, S.M., & Dodson, T.B. ( 2005). Injury location and screening questionnaires as markers for intimate partner violence. Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 63, 1255-1261.
15.
MacMillan, H.L., & Wathen, C.N., & The Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care. (2001). Prevention and treatment of violence against women: Systematic review & recommendations. CTFPHC Technical Report #01-4. London, ON: Canadian Task Force.
16.
MacMillan, H.L., Wathen, C.N., Jamieson, E., Boyle, M., McNutt, L.A., & Worster, A. ... McMaster Violence Against Women Research Group. ( 2006). Approaches to screening for intimate partner violence in health care settings: A randomized trial. Journal of the American Medical Association, 296, 530-536.
17.
McCloskey, L.A., Williams, C.M., Lichter, E., Gerber, M., Ganz, M.L., & Sege, R. ( 2007). Abused women disclose partner interference with health care: An unrecognized form of battering. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 22, 1067-1072.
18.
McLeer, S.V., Anwar, R.A.H., Herman, S., & Maquiling, K. ( 1989). Education is not enough: A systems failure in protecting battered women. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 18, 651-653.
19.
Muelleman, R.L., Lenaghan, P.A., & Pakieser, R.A. (1996). Battered women: injury locations and types. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 28, 486-492.
20.
Nicolaidis, C. ( 2007). Partner interference with health care: Do we want one more piece of a complex puzzle? Journal of General Internal Medicine, 22, 1216-1217.
21.
Ochs, H.A., Neuenschwander, M.C., & Dodson, T.B. ( 1996). Are head, neck and facial injuries markers of domestic violence? Journal of the American Dental Association, 127, 757-761.
22.
Perciaccante, V.J., Ochs, H.A., & Dodson, T.B. ( 1999). Head, neck, and facial injuries as markers of domestic violence in women. Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery , 57, 760-762; discussion 762-763.
23.
Perciaccante, V.J., Carey, J.W., & Dodson, T.B. ( 2008). Markers for Intimate Partner Violence in the Emergency Department Setting. Unpublished manuscript, 1-19.
24.
Petridou, E., Browne, A., Lichter, E., Dedoukou, X., Alexe, D., & Dessypris, N. ( 2002). What distinguishes unintentional injuries from injuries due to intimate partner violence: A study in Greek ambulatory care settings . Injury Prevention, 8, 197-201.
25.
Ramsay, J., Richardson, J., Carter, Y., & Feder, G. ( 2001). Appraisal of evidence about screening women for domestic violence. Royal London and Bart’s Medical School. Retrieved February20, 2010, http://www.library.nhs.uk/screening/ViewResource.aspx?resID=60992
26.
Ramsay, J., Richardson, J., Carter, Y.H., Davidson, L.L., & Feder, G. ( 2002). Should health professionals screen women for domestic violence? Systematic review. British Medical Journal, 325, 314.
27.
Randall, T. ( 1990). Domestic violence intervention calls for more than treating injuries. Journal of the American Medical Association, 264, 939-940.
28.
Reisenhofer, S., & Seibold, C. ( 2007). Emergency Department care of women experiencing intimate partner violence: Are we doing all we can? Contemporary Nurse , 24, 3-14.
29.
Richardson, J., Coid, J., Petruckevitch, A., Chung, W., Moorey, S., & Feder, G. ( 2002). Identifying domestic violence: Cross-sectional study in primary care. British Medical Journal, 324, 274-277.
30.
Roelens, K., Verstraelen, H., Van Egmond, K., & Temmerman, M. ( 2006). A knowledge, attitudes, and practice survey among obstetrician-gynaecologists on intimate partner violence in Flanders, Belgium. BMC Public Health, 6, 238.
31.
Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. ( 2008). Objectives of training and specialty training: Requirements in emergency medicine. Retrieved February 20, 2010, http://rcpsc.medical.org/residency/certification/objectives/emergmed_e.pdf
32.
Sackett, D.L., Haynes, R.B., Guyatt, G.H., & Tugwell, P. ( 1991). Clinical epidemiology: A basic science for clinical medicine (2nd ed.). Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
33.
Schunemann, H. J., Jaeschke, R., Cook, D. J., Bria, W. F., El-Solh, A. A., & Ernst, A. . . . ATS Documents Development and Implementation Committee. (2006). An official ATS statement: Grading the quality of evidence and strength of recommendations in ATS guidelines and recommendations. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 174, 605-614.
Spangaro, J., Zwi, A.B., & Poulos, R. ( 2009). The elusive search for definitive evidence on routine screening for intimate partner violence. Trauma, Violence & Abuse, 10, 55-68.
36.
Spedding, R.L., McWilliams, M., McNicholl, B.P., & Dearden, C.H. ( 1999). Markers for domestic violence in women. Journal of Accident and Emergency Medicine, 16, 400-402.
37.
Sugg, N.K., Thompson, R.S., Thompson, D.C., Maiuro, R., & Rivara, F.P. ( 1999). Domestic violence and primary care: Attitudes, practices, and beliefs. Journal of Family Medicine, 8, 301-306.
38.
Taket, A., Wathen, C.N., & Macmillan, H. ( 2004). Should health professionals screen all women for domestic violence? PLoS Medicine, 1, 7-10.
39.
Tjaden, P., & Thoennes, N. ( 2000). Full report of the prevalence, incidence, and consequences of violence against women. Washington, DC: Department of Justice (US). (Publication No. NCJ 183781).
40.
U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. (2004 a). Screening for family and intimate partner violence: Recommendation Statement. Annals of Internal Medicine, 140, 382-386.
41.
U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. (2004 b). Screening for family and intimate partner violence: Summary of recommendations. Retrieved February20, 2010, http://www.ahrq.gov/clinic/uspstf/uspsfamv.htm
42.
Wadman, M.C., & Muelleman, R.L. (1999). Domestic violence homicides: ED use before victimization. American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 17, 689-691.
43.
Wijma, B., Schei, B., Swahnberg, K., Hilden, M., Offerdal, K., Pikarinen, U., & ... Halmesmäki, E. (2003). Emotional, physical, and sexual abuse in patients visiting gynaecology clinics: A Nordic cross-sectional study. Lancet, 361, 2107-2113.
44.
World Health Organization. (2005). Violence against women by intimate partners. In WHO multi-country study on women’s health and domestic violence against women: Summary report of initial results on prevalence, health outcomes and women’s responses. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization.
45.
Yam, M. ( 2000). Seen but not heard: Battered women’s perceptions of the ED experience. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 26, 464-470.
