This study meta-analyzed rates of criminal justice decisions in 21 studies of prosecution of child abuse. Rates of referral to prosecution, filing charges, and incarceration varied considerably. Rates of carrying cases forward without dismissal were consistently 72% or greater. For cases carried forward, plea rates averaged 82% and conviction rates 94%. Compared to national data, child abuse was less likely to lead to filing charges and incarceration than most other felonies but more likely to be carried forward without dismissal. Diversion, guilty plea, and trial and conviction rates were about the same for child abuse and all violent crimes. Thus, prosecuting child abuse is generally neither feckless nor reckless. Rates can be misleading and cannot be the sole measure of prosecution success.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
†Boland, B., & Brady, E. (1985). The prosecution of felony arrests, 1980 (NCJ-97684). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS).
2.
†Boland, B., Brady, E., Tyson, H., & Bassler, J. (1983). The prosecution of felony arrests, 1979 (NCJ-86482). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
3.
†Boland, B., Conly, C. H., Mahanna, P., Warner, L., & Sones, R. (1990). The prosecution of felony arrests, 1987 (NCJ-124140). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
4.
†Boland, B., Conly, C. H., Warner, L., Sones, R., & Martin, W. (1989). The prosecution of felony arrests, 1986 (NCJ-113248). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
5.
†Boland, B., Logan, W., Sones, R., & Martin, W. (1988). The prosecution of felony arrests, 1982 (NCJ-106990). Washing-ton, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
6.
†Boland, B., Mahanna, P., & Sones, R. (1992). The prosecution of felony arrests, 1988 (NCJ-130914). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
7.
†Boland, B., & Sones, R. (1986). The prosecution of felony arrests, 1981 (NCJ-101380). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
8.
*Bradshaw, T. L., & Marks, A. E. (1990). Beyond a reasonable doubt: Factors that influence the legal disposition of child sexual abuse cases. Crime & Delinquency, 36(2), 276-285.
9.
*Brewer, K. D., Rowe, D. M., & Brewer, D. D. (1997). Factors related to prosecution of child sexual abuse cases. Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 6(1), 91-111.
10.
†Brossi, K. B. (1979). A cross-city comparison of felony case processing (LEAA Contract No. J-LEAA-016-76). Washing-ton, DC: Department of Justice.
11.
Cashmore, J., & Horsky, M. (1988). The prosecution of child sexual assault. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 21, 241-252.
12.
Champion, D. J. (1988). Child sexual abusers and sentencing severity. Federal Probation, 52, 53-57.
13.
*Chapman, J. R., & Smith, B. (1987). Response of social ser-vice and criminal justice agencies to child sexual abuse complaints. Response, 10(3), 7-13.
14.
*Cheit, R. E., & Goldschmidt, E. (1997). Child molesters in the criminal justice system: A comprehensive case-flow analysis of the Rhode Island docket (1985-1993). New England Journal on Criminal and Civil Confinement, 23(2), 267-301.
15.
*Conte, J. R., & Berliner, L. (1981). Prosecution of the offender in cases of sexual assault against children. Victimology: An International Journal, 6(1-4), 102-109.
16.
Cooper, H., & Hedges, L. V. (Eds.). (1994). The handbook of research synthesis. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
17.
Cross, T. P., DeVos, E. D., & Whitcomb, D. (1994). Prosecution of child sexual abuse: Which cases are accepted? Child Abuse and Neglect, 18(8), 663-677.
18.
*Cross, T. P., Whitcomb, D., & DeVos, E. D. (1995). Criminal justice outcomes of prosecution of child sexual abuse: A case flow analysis. Child Abuse and Neglect, 19(12), 1431-1442.
19.
Cross, T. P., Martell, D., McDonald, E., & Ahl, M. (1999). The criminal justice system and child placement in child sexual abuse cases. Child Maltreatment, 4, 32-44.
20.
*Cullen, B. J., Smith, P. H., Funk, J. B., & Haaf, R. A. (2000). A matched cohort comparison of a criminal justice system's response to child sexual abuse: A profile of perpetrators. Child Abuse and Neglect, 24(4), 569-577.
21.
Davidson, H. A. (1997). Courts and child maltreatment. In M. E. Helfer, R. S. Kempe, & R. D. Krugman (Eds.), The battered child (5th ed., pp. 482-499). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
22.
*Davis, N. S., & Wells, S. J. (1996). Justice system processing of child abuse and neglect cases. Final report. Washington, DC: American Bar Association and National Institute of Justice.
23.
*DeFrancis, V. (1969). Protecting the child victim of sex crimes committed by adults. Englewood, CO: The American Humane Association, Children's Division.
24.
*DeJong, A. R., & Rose, M. (1991). Legal proof of child sexual abuse in the absence of physical evidence. Pediatrics, 88(3), 506-511.
25.
*Dolan, K. J. (1985). Evaluation of outcomes for reported cases of child sexual abuse in Texas. Victimology: An International Journal, 9(3-4), 383-397.
26.
Dziech, B. W., & Schudson, C. B. (1989). On trial: America's courts and their treatment of sexually abused children. Boston: Beacon.
27.
*Faller, K. C., & Henry, J. (2000). Child sexual abuse: A case study in community collaboration. Child Abuse and Neglect, 24, 1215-1225.
28.
Fridell, L. A. (1991). Intrafamilial child sexual abuse treatment: Prosecution following expulsion. Child Abuse and Neglect, 15, 587-592.
29.
*Goodman, G. S., Taub, E. P., Jones, D. P. H., England, P., Port, L. K., Rudy, L., et al. (1992). Testifying in criminal court: Emotional effects on child sexual assault victims (Serial No. 229). Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 57(5).
30.
*Gray, E. (1993). Unequal justice: The prosecution of child sexual abuse. New York: Free Press.
31.
Harshbarger, S. (1987, March). Prosecution is an appropriate response in child sexual abuse cases. Journal of Inter-personal Violence, 2, 108-112.
32.
†Hart, T. C., & Reaves, B. A. (1999). Felony defendants in large urban counties, 1996 (NCJ-176981). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
33.
Levesque, R. J. R. (1995). Prosecuting sex crimes against children: Time for “outrageous” proposals? Law & Psychology Review, 19, 59-91.
34.
Light, R., & Pillemer, D. (1984). Summing up: The science of reviewing research. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
35.
Lipsey, M. W., & Wilson, D. B. (2001). Practical meta-analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
36.
*MacMurray, B. K. (1989). Criminal determination for child sexual abuse: Prosecutor case-screening judgments. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 4(2), 233-244.
37.
Martell, D. (2002). Child placement and criminal prosecution: A study of the relationship between criminal justice and protective service interventions in cases of child abuse. Dissertation Abstracts International, 62(12), 4334A. (Publication No. AAT 3035629)
38.
*Martone, M., Jaudes, P. K., & Cavins, M. K. (1996). Criminal prosecution of child sexual abuse cases. Child Abuse and Neglect, 20(5), 457-464.
39.
McEwen, T. (1995). National Assessment Program: 1994 survey results (NCJ-150856). Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
40.
McGregor, R. P. (1990). The prosecution of child molesters. In R. L. Goldman & R. M. Gargiulo (Eds.), Children at risk: An interdisciplinary approach to child abuse and neglect. Austin, TX: Pro-Ed.
41.
*Mennerich, A., Martell, D., Cross, T. P., & White, A. (2002). Case and system predictors of prosecution of child abuse. Manuscript submitted for publication.
42.
Myers, J. E. B. (1994). Adjudication of child sexual abuse cases. The Future of Children, 4(2), 84-102.
43.
Nardulli, P. F., Eisenstein, J., & Flemming, R. B. (1988). The tenor of justice. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
44.
National Children's Alliance. (2001). [Number of NCA member agencies]. Unpublished raw data.
45.
Newberger, E. H. (1987, March). Prosecution: A problematic approach to child abuse. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 2, 112-117.
46.
Ostrom, B. J., & Hanson, R. A. (2000). Efficiency, timeliness, and quality: A new perspective from nine state trial courts (NCJ-181942). Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
47.
Peters, J. M., Dinsmore, J., & Toth, P. (1989). Why prosecute child abuse? South Dakota Law Review, 34, 649-659.
48.
†Reaves, B. A. (1998). Felony defendants in large urban counties, 1994 (NCJ-164616). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
49.
†Reaves, B. A. (2001). Felony defendants in large urban counties, 1998 (NCJ-187232). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
50.
†Reaves, B. A., & Smith, P. Z. (1995). Felony defendants in large urban counties 1992 (NCJ-148826). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, BJS.
51.
*Rogers, C. M. (1982). Child sexual abuse and the courts: Preliminary findings. Social Work and Child Sexual Abuse, 1(1), 145-153.
52.
Sheppard, D. I., & Zangrillo, P. A. (1996, Winter). Coordinating investigations of child abuse. Public Welfare, 54(1), 21-31.
53.
*Smith, B. E., & Goretsky-Elstein, S. (1993). The prosecution of child sexual and physical abuse cases. Washington, DC: American Bar Association.
54.
Stevens, G., & Fischer, D. G. (1992). Review and monitoring of child sexual abuse cases in selected sites in Saskatchewan: Studies on the sexual abuse of children in Canada. Ottawa: Canada Department of Justice.
55.
*Stroud, D. D.. Martens S., & Barker, J. (2000). Criminal investigation of child sexual abuse: A comparison of cases referred to the prosecutor to those not referred. Child Abuse and Neglect, 24, 689-700.
56.
*Tjaden, P. G., & Thoennes, N. (1992). Predictors of legal intervention in child maltreatment cases. Child Abuse and Neglect, 16, 807-821.
57.
Trocme, N., MacLaurin, B., Fallon, B., Daciuk, J., Billingsley, D., Tourigny, M., et al. (2001). Canadian incidence study of reported child abuse and neglect: Final report. Ottawa, Canada: Minister of Public Works and Government Services Canada.
58.
Van Dam, C. V., Halliday, L., & Bates, C. (1985). The occurrence of sexual abuse in a small community. Canadian Journal of Community Mental Health, 4(1), 105-111.
59.
Whitcomb, D. (1992). When the victim is a child (2nd ed.) (Contract No. OJP-86-C-009). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, National Institute of Justice.
60.
Whitcomb, D., & Hardin, M. (1996). Coordinating criminal and juvenile court proceedings in child maltreatment cases (NCJ-161835 Grant No.92-IJ-CX-K034). Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
61.
Wilber, N. R. (1987). Dilemmas of addressing child sexual abuse: The implementation of Chapter 288 in Middlesex County. Dissertation Abstracts International, 48(7), 1889A. (Publication No. AAT 8722710)
62.
Wright, L. (1995). Remembering Satan. New York: Vintage.
